Results for “LAMINAR BOUNDARY LAYER SEPARATION” — Page 4

NASA NTRS1981

Experimental investigation of the flow on the suction side of a thin Delta wing

Surface oil flow patterns were photographed and pressure distribution measurements were carried out on a sharp edged delta wing of aspect ratio lambda = 1.0 in order to determine the influence of Reynolds number and of vortex breakdown on the flow on the suction side of the wing. The formation of the secondary vortex occurs due to separation of a laminar boundary layer in the front part of the wing and due to separation of a turbulent boundary layer in the rear part of the wing. In the case of turbulent separation, the secondary separation line is closer to the wing leading edge than in the laminar case. The position of the transition depends on the Reynolds number and on the angle of incidence. The breakdown of a vortex above the wing leads to a kink in the secondary separation line.

Hummel, D.↗

NASA NTRS1990

On the Lagrangian description of unsteady boundary-layer separation. I - General theory

Although unsteady, high-Reynolds number, laminar boundary layers have conventionally been studied in terms of Eulerian coordinates, a Lagrangian approach may have significant analytical and computational advantages. In Lagrangian coordinates the classical boundary layer equations decouple into a momentum equation for the motion parallel to the boundary, and a hyperbolic continuity equation (essentially a conserved Jacobian) for the motion normal to the boundary. The momentum equations, plus the energy equation if the flow is compressible, can be solved independently of the continuity equation. Unsteady separation occurs when the continuity equation becomes singular as a result of touching characteristics, the condition for which can be expressed in terms of the solution of the momentum equations. The solutions to the momentum and energy equations remain regular. Asymptotic structures for a number of unsteady 3-D separating flows follow and depend on the symmetry properties of the flow. In the absence of any symmetry, the singularity structure just prior to separation is found to be quasi 2-D with a displacement thickness in the form of a crescent shaped ridge. Physically the singularities can be understood in terms of the behavior of a fluid element inside the boundary layer which contracts in a direction parallel to the boundary and expands normal to it, thus forcing the fluid above it to be ejected from the boundary layer.

Van Dommelen, Leon L.↗

NASA NTRS1989

Analysis of low Reynolds number separation bubbles using semiempirical methods

The formation and growth of transitional separation bubbles can significantly affect boundary-layer development on airfoils operating at low chord Reynolds numbers. Of primary concern is the change in boundary-layer thickness between laminar separation and turbulent reattachment. This can be estimated using semiempirical methods, such as the one devised by Horton (1968), which are based on solutions to the integral forms of the boundary-layer equations. The applicability of these methods at low Reynolds numbers was investigated using hot-wire measurements of bubbles formed on an NACA 66(3)-018 airfoil at chord Reynolds numbers of 50,000-200,000. The momentum thickness growth between separation and transition was found to be similar to that predicted for a laminar half-jet and appears to be influenced by the momentum thickness Reynolds number at separation. This parameter also was found to have a noticeable effect on the Reynolds number based on the length of a bubble's laminar portion.

Schmidt, Gordon S.↗

NASA NTRS1979

Low speed airfoil design and analysis

A low speed airfoil design and analysis program was developed which contains several unique features. In the design mode, the velocity distribution is not specified for one but many different angles of attack. Several iteration options are included which allow the trailing edge angle to be specified while other parameters are iterated. For airfoil analysis, a panel method is available which uses third-order panels having parabolic vorticity distributions. The flow condition is satisfied at the end points of the panels. Both sharp and blunt trailing edges can be analyzed. The integral boundary layer method with its laminar separation bubble analog, empirical transition criterion, and precise turbulent boundary layer equations compares very favorably with other methods, both integral and finite difference. Comparisons with experiment for several airfoils over a very wide Reynolds number range are discussed. Applications to high lift airfoil design are also demonstrated.

Eppler, R.↗

NASA NTRS1989

On the Lagrangian description of unsteady boundary layer separation. Part 1: General theory

Although unsteady, high-Reynolds number, laminar boundary layers have conventionally been studied in terms of Eulerian coordinates, a Lagrangian approach may have significant analytical and computational advantages. In Lagrangian coordinates the classical boundary layer equations decouple into a momentum equation for the motion parallel to the boundary, and a hyperbolic continuity equation (essentially a conserved Jacobian) for the motion normal to the boundary. The momentum equations, plus the energy equation if the flow is compressible, can be solved independently of the continuity equation. Unsteady separation occurs when the continuity equation becomes singular as a result of touching characteristics, the condition for which can be expressed in terms of the solution of the momentum equations. The solutions to the momentum and energy equations remain regular. Asymptotic structures for a number of unsteady 3-D separating flows follow and depend on the symmetry properties of the flow. In the absence of any symmetry, the singularity structure just prior to separation is found to be quasi 2-D with a displacement thickness in the form of a crescent shaped ridge. Physically the singularities can be understood in terms of the behavior of a fluid element inside the boundary layer which contracts in a direction parallel to the boundary and expands normal to it, thus forcing the fluid above it to be ejected from the boundary layer.

Vandommelen, Leon L.↗

NASA NTRS1953

Notes on the Prediction of Shock-induced Boundary-layer Separation

The present status of available information relative to the prediction of shock-induced boundary-layer separation is discussed. Experimental results showing the effects of Reynolds number and Mach number on the separation of both laminar and turbulent boundary layer are given and compared with available methods for predicting separation. The flow phenomena associated with separation caused by forward-facing steps, wedges, and incident shock waves are discussed. Applications of the flat-plate data to problems of separation on spoilers, diffusers, and scoop inlets are indicated for turbulent boundary layers.

Lange, Roy H.↗

NASA NTRS2002

Experimental Investigation of Separated and Transitional Boundary Layers Under Low-Pressure Turbine Airfoil Conditions

Modern low-pressure turbine airfoils are subject to increasingly stronger pressure gradients as designers impose higher loading in an effort to improve efficiency and to reduce part count. The adverse pressure gradients on the suction side of these airfoils can lead to boundary-layer separation, particularly under cruise conditions. Separation bubbles, notably those which fail to reattach, can result in a significant degradation of engine efficiency. Accurate prediction of separation and reattachment is hence crucial to improved turbine design. This requires an improved understanding of the transition flow physics. Transition may begin before or after separation, depending on the Reynolds number and other flow conditions, has a strong influence on subsequent reattachment, and may even eliminate separation. Further complicating the problem are the high free-stream turbulence levels in a real engine environment, the strong pressure gradients along the airfoils, the curvature of the airfoils, and the unsteadiness associated with wake passing from upstream stages. Because of the complicated flow situation, transition in these devices can take many paths that can coexist, vary in importance, and possibly also interact, at different locations and instances in time. The present work was carried out in an attempt to systematically sort out some of these issues. Detailed velocity measurements were made along a flat plate subject to the same nominal dimensionless pressure gradient as the suction side of a modern low-pressure turbine airfoil ('Pak-B'). The Reynolds number based on wetted plate length and nominal exit velocity, Re, was varied from 50;000 to 300; 000, covering cruise to takeoff conditions. Low, 0.2%, and high, 7%, inlet free-stream turbulence intensities were set using passive grids. These turbulence levels correspond to about 0.2% and 2.5% turbulence intensity in the test section when normalized with the exit velocity. The Reynolds number and free-stream turbulence level do not have a significant effect on the location of boundary-layer separation unless they are high enough to induce transition upstream of separation. The location and extent of the transition zone, in contrast, depend strongly on Re and TI. The beginning of reattachment closely follows the onset of transition. Under low free-stream turbulence conditions the boundary layer is laminar at separation and then begins to exhibit fluctuations in a finite frequency band in the shear layer over the separation bubble. These fluctuations are due to instability waves. The fluctuations grow in magnitude, higher harmonics are generated, and finally lead to a breakdown to turbulence. Transition begins in the shear layer, but quickly spreads to the near wall region and causes the boundary layer to reattach. The transition is rapid and the resulting turbulence contains a full range of high and low frequencies. Under high free-stream turbulence conditions, slowly growing low-frequency fluctuations are induced in the pretransitional boundary layer by the free-stream. The separation bubbles are considerably thinner than in the low TI cases, resulting in thinner boundary layers at the end of the test wall. At Re=50,000 and 100,000, the pre-transitional boundary layer separates at about the same location as in the low TI cases. Transition occurs through a bypass mode, begins upstream of the corresponding low-TI location, and proceeds in a manner similar to that of an attached boundary layer. Under high TI at Re=200,000 and 300,000, transition begins before separation. The boundary layer may separate, but if it does the separation bubble is very short and does not significantly affect the downstream development of the boundary layer. A comparison is made to previous work in a simulated cascade.

Hultgren, Lennart S.↗

NASA NTRS1978

Practical calculation of laminar and turbulent bled-off boundary layers

Bleed-off of boundary layer material is shown to be an effective means for reducing drag by conserving the laminar boundary layer and preventing separation of the turbulent boundary layer. The case in which the two effects of bleed-off overlap is examined. Empirical methods are extended to the case of bleed-off. Laminar and turbulent boundary layers are treated simultaneously and the approximation differential equations are solved without an uncertain error. The case without bleed-off is also treated.

Eppler, R.↗

NASA NTRS1974

Boundary layer separation and reattachment

A review of developments in a new model for boundary-layer separation is presented. The separation model encompasses timevarying as well as steady-flow conditions. Engineering criteria in terms of calculable pressure gradients are obtained for both laminar and turbulent boundary-layer separation. These criteria, together with limited information on time-dependent separations, should be of value in predicting flows in turbomachinery. The reattachment of boundary layers is also shown to fit within the separation model.

Sandborn, V. A.↗

NASA NTRS1975

On the calculation of supersonic separating and reattaching flows

A method is developed for solving the laminar and turbulent compressible boundary layer equations for separating and reattaching flows. Results of this method are compared with experimental data for two laminar and three turbulent layer, shock wave interactions. Several Navier-Stokes solutions are obtained for each of the laminar boundary layer, shock wave interactions considered. Comparison of these solutions indicates a first order sensitivity in C sub f to the computational mesh selected in both the viscous and inviscid portions of the flow. Comparison of the present boundary layer solutions with the Navier-Stokes solutions and with data for a given Mach number indicates that as long as the separation bubble is small, the boundary layer approximation yields solutions whose accuracy is comparable to the Navier-Stokes solutions.

Murphy, J. D.↗

NASA NTRS1955

separation, stability, and other properties of compressible laminar boundary layer with pressure gradient and heat transfer

Explore the source record for details and available documents.

Morduchow, Morris↗

NASA NTRS1978

Three-dimensional computational aerodynamics in the 1980's

The future requirements for constructing codes that can be used to compute three-dimensional flows about aerodynamic shapes should be assessed in light of the constraints imposed by future computer architectures and the reality of usable algorithms that can provide practical three-dimensional simulations. On the hardware side, vector processing is inevitable in order to meet the CPU speeds required. To cope with three-dimensional geometries, massive data bases with fetch/store conflicts and transposition problems are inevitable. On the software side, codes must be prepared that: (1) can be adapted to complex geometries, (2) can (at the very least) predict the location of laminar and turbulent boundary layer separation, and (3) will converge rapidly to sufficiently accurate solutions.

Lomax, H.↗

NASA NTRS1984

An evaluation of a parabolized Navier-Stokes (PNS) code for cone-cylinder-flared configurations

A PNS code's capability to predict the onset of laminar and turbulent boundary layer separation, forces, moments, and pressure distributions was investigated. Predictions of incipient separation show good agreement with experimental results. Force and moment calculations were found to agree favorably with experimental data for a wide range of geometries for Mach numbers from 2 to 4 with turbulent boundary layers. Limited comparison of pressure distribution data also showed good agreement. Skin friction and Stanton number calculations are presented to indicate the code's capability to calculate this information and hence, provide a complete data base for attached flow conditions. The sensitivity of these calculations to smoothing and marching parameter variations was examined and found to be acceptable for most design work. The code was found to be suitable to complement or reduce wind tunnel experimentation for the design of this class of configuration with regard to accuracy, cost and usability.

Cottrell, C. J.↗

NASA NTRS1996

Supersonic Laminar Flow Control Research

The objective of this research is to understand supersonic laminar flow stability, transition and active control. Some prediction techniques are developed or modified to analyze laminar flow stability. The effects of distributed heating and cooling as an active boundary layer control technique are studied. The primary tasks of the research apply to the NASA/Ames Proof-of-Concept (PoC) and the Laminar Flow Supersonic Wind Tunnel's (LFSWT's) nozzle design with laminar flow control and are listed as follows: (1) Predictions of supersonic laminar boundary layer stability and transition; (2) Effects of wall heating and cooling on supersonic laminar flow control on a flat plate; (3) Performance evaluation of the PoC and LFSWT nozzle designs with wall heating and cooling applied at different locations and various lengths; (4) Effects of a conducted -vs- pulse wall temperature distribution for the LFSWT; and (5) Application of wall heating and/or cooling to laminar boundary layer and flow separation control of airfoils and investigation of related active control techniques.

Lo, C. F.↗

NASA NTRS1996

Supersonic Laminar Flow Control Research

The objective of this research is to understand supersonic laminar flow stability, transition and active control. Some prediction techniques will be developed or modified to analyze laminar flow stability. The effects of distributed heating and cooling as an active boundary layer control technique will be studied. The primary tasks of the research apply to the NASA/Ames PoC and LFSWT's nozzle design with laminar flow control and are listed as follows: Predictions of supersonic laminar boundary layer stability and transition; Effects of wall heating and cooling on supersonic laminar flow control on a flat plate; Performance evaluation of the PoC and LFSWT nozzle designs with wall heating and cooling applied at different locations and various lengths; Effects of a conducted-vs-pulse wall temperature distribution for the LFSWT; and Application of wall heating and/or cooling to laminar boundary layer and flow separation control of airfoils and investigation of related active control techniques.

Lo, Ching F.↗

NASA NTRS2022

Preliminary Airfoil Design for Low Reynolds Numbers

Advances in the fields of electronics, batteries, and electric motors have enabled broad adoption of small-scale aircraft for various terrestrial applications. Numerous Micro Aerial Vehicles (MAVs) and small Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs), both civil and military, are in use today. Operation at their design flight condition often requires rotors, propellers, or wings to perform at Reynolds numbers significantly below 500,000 [1]. Airfoil performance at low Reynolds numbers is generally characterized by low aerodynamic performance (i.e. the attainable lift-to-drag ratio) compared to performance of airfoils at higher Reynolds numbers. The critical chord-based Reynolds number for conventional airfoils lies around Rec = 100,000 to Rec = 500,000 [2]. Below this critical Reynolds number, laminar separation of the boundary layer is usually the cause for poor performance. Researchers have found that below the critical Reynolds number, flat and cambered plates can outperform smooth airfoils. Circular-arc cambered plates especially have remarkable performance advantages compared to conventional airfoil shapes [3].

airfoil↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Transition Analysis for the Pazy Wing

The Pazy wing, designed as a benchmark for highly flexible wings that experience large deformations, presents intriguing nonlinear phenomena due to its unique geometry with spanwise varying static deformation and low Reynolds number flow conditions. These phenomena include limit cycle oscillation related to laminar separation bubbles, boundary-layer transition, and dynamic stall. The primary focus of this study is to investigate transition behavior on the sagged Pazy wing under static loading by using the shear-stress-transport (SST)-based Langtry-Menter 𝜸 − 𝑹𝒆𝜽𝒕 transition model in the NASA OVERFLOW and FUN3D solvers. Based on the steady-state results obtained via different variants of the Langtry-Menter model, we investigate the likely transition behavior over a range of incidence angles. The predicted flowfield on the sagged Pazy wing is strongly three dimensional and the application of turbulence index as a viable indicator of the transition front in such flows is also explored. The study demonstrates the limitations of the Langtry-Menter model when applied to low Reynolds number flows. We introduce a spanwise periodic configuration to simulate a narrow-span section of the Pazy wing, specifically centered on one of the 14 nearly equidistant ribs spanning the wing. The computational results demonstrate that the spanwise periodic configuration provides a straightforward environment for studying transition characteristics as well as demonstrating systematic grid convergence and successful code-to-code comparisons. The research offers useful insights into the transition characteristics of flexible wings under various loading conditions, contributing to the field of aeroelastic simulations.

CFD Modeling↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Transition Analysis for the Pazy Wing

The Pazy wing, designed as a benchmark for highly flexible wings that experience large deformations, presents intriguing nonlinear phenomena due to its unique geometry with spanwise varying static deformation and low Reynolds number flow conditions. These phenomena include limit cycle oscillation related to laminar separation bubbles, boundary-layer transition, and dynamic stall. The primary focus of this study is to investigate transition behavior on the sagged Pazy wing under static loading by using the shear-stress-transport (SST)-based Langtry-Menter 𝜸 − 𝑹𝒆𝜽𝒕 transition model in the NASA OVERFLOW and FUN3D solvers. Based on the steady-state results obtained via different variants of the Langtry-Menter model, we investigate the likely transition behavior over a range of incidence angles. The predicted flowfield on the sagged Pazy wing is strongly three dimensional and the application of turbulence index as a viable indicator of the transition front in such flows is also explored. The study demonstrates the limitations of the Langtry-Menter model when applied to low Reynolds number flows. We introduce a spanwise periodic configuration to simulate a narrow-span section of the Pazy wing, specifically centered on one of the 14 nearly equidistant ribs spanning the wing. The computational results demonstrate that the spanwise periodic configuration provides a straightforward environment for studying transition characteristics as well as demonstrating systematic grid convergence and successful code-to-code comparisons. The research offers useful insights into the transition characteristics of flexible wings under various loading conditions, contributing to the field of aeroelastic simulations.

CFD Modeling↗