Application of the BSRN Data in Validating the GEWEX SRB Data: Quality-Control and Resulting Available Monthly Means
The BSRN data have been used in validation of the satellite-based GEWEX SRB data, and the recent Release 4.0-IP data cover the 34-year period from July 1983 to June 2017. Here we focus on the validation of the shortwave monthly means from 1992 to 2017 against the BSRN Global 1. We first perform the BSRN-recommended quality-control on the original data. We then calculate the monthly-hourly means from which we calculate the monthly means. Twenty-four (24) monthly-hourly means are required to calculate a monthly mean. To guarantee the quality of the monthly mean, we also require that 95% or more hourly means be available in order for a monthly-hourly mean to be calculated. Since the above quality-control significantly reduces the number of available monthly means, we are curious how many monthly means we would get if we relax the quality-control, and how the resulting monthly means would compare with the GEWEX SRB data. In a version we experimented, only constant upper and lower bounds are imposed on various fluxes, and the original data are largely retained. We found that many more monthly means would be available, and the overall bias and RMS would not be significantly different from that of the strict quality-control. With the strict quality-control, if we let Avail (minimum percentage of available hourly means required for a monthly-hourly mean to be computed) change from 3.2% to 95%, the Bias/RMS/N change from -2.77/20.56/9756 to -0.35/13.41/4581, where N is the number of available monthly means, and Bias and RMS are in the unit of W/sq. m. On the other hand, with the lax quality-control, when Avail changes from 3.2% to 95%, the Bias/RMS/N change from -0.82/19.53/9819 to -0.21/14.41/5875. South Pole (SPO) is one of the sites we are particularly interested in. With the strict quality-control, and when Avail changes from 3.2% to 95%, the Bias/RMS/N change from 5.89/15.85/283 to 1.23/5.52/133; with the lax quality-control, the Bias/RMS/N change from 1.17/11.21/284 to 1.88/7.9/177.