Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Substrate surface energy”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 73 records · Page 4
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2025

Predicting Pulsed-Laser Deposition SrTiO 3 Homoepitaxy Growth Dynamics Using High-Speed Reflection High-Energy Electron Diffraction

Pulsed-laser deposition (PLD) is a powerful technique for growing complex oxides with controlled stoichiometry. To understand growth dynamics therein, it is common to leverage in situ spectroscopies, such as reflection high-energy electron diffraction (RHEED), to monitor surface crystallinity. Most commercial systems rely on video-rate cameras operating at 60-120 Hz that lack sufficient temporal resolution to capture growth dynamics at practical deposition frequencies. Here, a high-speed platform to record in situ dynamics via RHEED at >500 Hz is implemented. An open-source analysis package is designed to fit diffraction spots to 2D Gaussians, allowing single-pulse surface reconstruction kinetics extraction. Using homoepitaxially deposited (001)-oriented SrTiO 3 as a model system, we demonstrate how high-speed RHEED can provide real-time insight into growth processes obscured by slower acquisition systems. By fitting the single-pulse intensity to a set of exponential functions, we observe changes in the characteristic decay time and mechanism correlated to the substrate step width and surface termination. We observe distinct surface effects, with diffraction intensity decaying on lower-energy TiO 2 -terminated surfaces and stabilizing on SrO- or mixed-terminated surfaces. Similarly, using an exponential model, the extracted characteristic time of adatom deposition decreases with increased density of bonding sites associated with mixed termination and narrower step widths. Ultimately, this work shows how increasing RHEED temporal resolution can uncover new insights into growth processes, with practical implications for the design and control of PLD processes. This experimental platform provides new capabilities to enable data-driven machine learning analysis and autonomous control systems to enhance the complexity and fecundity of PLD.

(SrO)↗
DOE OSTI2020

Toward non-Si electronics: From remote epitaxy to layer splitting of 2D materials for mixed dimensional heterostructures

The current electronics has been mainly dominated by Si-based devices due to their mature processing system and exceptional cost-effectiveness. However, next generation electronics needs novel functionalities that cannot be realized by Si because of intrinsic limitation of Si. Accordingly, demand for non-Si electronics has been getting substantially high. Unfortunately, current methodology requires extremely high cost for non-Si materials, which impedes the progress in developing the non-Si based electronics. Here, I will discuss about our group’s efforts to address this issue. Our team recently conceived a new crystalline growth, termed as “remote epitaxy”, which can copy/paste crystalline information from substrates remotely through graphene, thus generating single-crystalline films on graphene. As interfacial binding energy is attenuated by inserting graphene at interface, the single-crystalline films can be easily exfoliated from the slippery graphene surface. Also, the graphene-coated substrates can be, in principle, reused infinitely to produce single-crystalline films. Thus, the remote epitaxy can produce non-Si semiconductor films with unprecedented cost efficiency while allowing additional flexible device functionality required for current ubiquitous electronics. Next, I will discuss about a layer splitting technique which can be a potential solution to overcome the problem in obtaining large-scale and monolayer 2D materials. A 2D material-based heterostructure has been intensively studied because of its unique device functionalities and novel physics. However, it is extremely challenging to secure large-scale and monolayer 2D materials because of following issues: 1) poor scalability for laboratory fabrication processes of 2D heterostructures and 2) lack of well-defined control parameters for kinetics of 2D materials and predictable number of layers of 2D materials. To resolve this issue, we conceived a new approach called “layer-resolved splitting” which obtains multiple monolayer from multilayer 2D materials by controlling interfacial toughness contrast. As this method is versatile and universal, we can, in principle, apply to all 2D materials. We succeeded in having large-scale, monolayer 2D materials through our approach and, thereby 2D heterostructures were demonstrated for functional devices. Lastly, I would like to discuss opportunities of mixed-dimensional heterostructure demonstrated by remote epitaxy and layer-resolved splitting. As they produce freestanding 3D bulk films and 2D atomic layers, a new type of 3D/2D heterostructures can be realized where a new physics and new device architecture are revealed. Therefore, I believe that a new opportunity will be discovered through the mixed-dimensional heterostructures.

Bae, Sang-Hoon↗
DOE OSTI2025

Achieving Electrode Smoothing by Controlling the Nucleation Phase of Metal Deposition Through Polymer‐Substrate Binding

Polymer additives [like polyethylene oxide (PEO)] are widely used for smooth electrode deposition in aqueous zinc and many other battery systems. However, the precise mechanism by which they regulate morphology and suppress dendrite formation remains unclear. In this study, the knowledge gap is addressed by using in situ electrochemical atomic force microscopy to directly observe the interfacial evolution during Zn electrodeposition and polymer adsorption on Cu substrates in the presence of varying concentrations of ZnSO 4 and PEO. Contrary to previous literature assumptions, which emphasize the binding to the growing Zn crystal surfaces or Zn 2+ ions, the results demonstrate that PEO smooths Zn films by promoting nucleation of (002)-oriented Zn platelets through interactions with the Cu substrate. Density functional theory simulations support this finding by showing that PEO adsorption on Cu modifies the interfacial energy of Zn/Cu/electrolyte interfaces, favoring the stabilization of Zn (002) on the Cu substrate, as well as confines Zn electrodeposition to a narrow near-surface region. In conclusion, these findings elucidate a novel design principle for electrode smoothing, emphasizing the importance of substrate selection paired with polymer additives that exhibit an attractive interaction with the substrate but minimal interaction with growing crystals, offering a mechanistic perspective for improved battery performance.

Electrodeposition↗
DOE OSTI2026

Atomic‐Scale Surface Imaging of Bulk Epitaxial CsPbBr 3 Perovskite Single Crystals on Mica Using Light Assisted Scanning Tunneling Microscopy at Low‐Temperature (80 K)

Epitaxial single-crystalline CsPbBr 3 perovskite films on mica, prepared ex situ, are explored using a low-temperature scanning tunneling microscope (STM) by probing the unoccupied electronic states of their surface in ultra-high vacuum (UHV) at 80 K. Light-assisted STM measurements under a broadband illumination with visible light were employed to enhance and stabilize surface conductivity. STM imaging across the surface of macroscopic bulk CsPbBr 3 films reveals large flat terraces characterized by a specific type of surface reconstruction, consisting of parallel rows of U-shaped atomic nanostructures. These structures are spaced by 12 Å and exhibit an internal feature size of 5.1 Å. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations reproduce the experimental observations and reveal a competition between different orthorhombic CsPbBr 3 (110) surface reconstructions: a Cs-rich structure, identified as the most energetically stable, and three alternative Pb–Br-rich reconstructions, which are slightly higher in energy yet remain consistent with the STM data. Additional analyses that explicitly account for the mica substrate exclude the cubic CsPbBr 3 phase and other orthorhombic surface orientations, while showing that variations in the mica surface termination do not alter the preferred CsPbBr 3 (110) reconstruction. In conclusion, this combined approach thereby confirms our assignment and resolves previous STM interpretations of CsPbBr 3 .

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Pulsed laser deposition assisted epitaxial growth of cesium telluride photocathodes for high brightness electron sources

The development of high-brightness electron sources is critical to state-of-the-art electron accelerator applications like X-ray free electron laser (XFEL) and ultra-fast electron microscopy. Cesium telluride is chosen as the electron source material for multiple cutting-edge XFEL facilities worldwide. This manuscript presents the first demonstration of the growth of highly crystalized and epitaxial cesium telluride thin films on 4H-SiC and graphene/4H-SiC substrates with ultrasmooth film surfaces. The ordering of the film was characterized by in situ reflection high energy electron diffraction and multiple X-ray diagnostics. The results of the quantum efficiency performance for epitaxial cesium telluride photocathodes are also reported.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗
DOE OSTI2023

Residual stress of controlled atmosphere plasma spray blended metal deposits measured via in-situ substrate curvature method

The preliminary use of the in-situ curvature measurement technique for analyzing the planar stress evolution of controlled atmosphere plasma spray (CAPS) refractory metal deposits was performed with SNL-NM org. 1834’s CAPS system. A porous refractory metal exemplar of Ta-Nb was sprayed onto Ni-200, Ti-6Al-4V, and Al 7075-T6 substrates using a constant plasma torch parameter setting and deposition toolpath. Residual stresses of the deposits were found to be largely influenced by the substrate coefficient of thermal expansion and were calculated to be 49, 90, and -136 MPa for Ni 200, Ti-6Al-4V, and Al 7075-T6, respectively. The “Evolving stress” of the Ta-Nb deposits, which more accurately describes the mean intrinsic splat quenching stress of the spray material during deposition, was calculated to be 67, 92, and 129 MPa for Ni-200, Ti-6Al-4V, and Al 7075-T6, respectively. Notable difference in curvature measurement for the 1st coating pass for the Al 7075- T6 substrate was observed, with interface micrograph evidence suggesting potential softening and/or melting of the Al 7075-T6 substrate surface during deposition. Substrate temperature measurements prior to Ta-Nb deposition were used to calculate thermal energy absorbed from the hot gas plume by the different substrates and were found to correlate to the substrate’s thermal effusively. These calculated thermal energies were also found to be ~10 to 15% of the calculated energy output from the plasma torch’s nozzle exit for these experimental conditions.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Elastic wave suppression through additively manufactured petal lattice metamaterials

Lattice-core sandwich structure metamaterials are lightweight alternatives to monolithic materials that can present better mechanical, thermal, and energy dampening performance. Manufacturing lattice metamaterials to follow curved surfaces can pose a challenge, as the lattices rely on their geometric orientation to the substrate for their mechanical properties. This work rationally designed a lattice structure where the surface is broken up into “petals” connected to the underlying lattice, which localizes the petals’ impact response. This design opens a pathway for implementation of lattice-core sandwich structures onto complex surface geometries. These petal structures were evaluated for their energy absorption efficiency experimentally by utilizing pressure waves generated with nanosecond lasers and computationally via finite element modeling. The lattice structures exhibited a two-orders-of-magnitude decrease in transmitted pressure compared to their constituent steel at equivalent mass. Furthermore, localizing energy absorption into petal structures provided a 44% reduction in peak load compared to a continuous “single-petal” design.

Sarracino, Alex↗
DOE OSTI2019

Self-assembled Ag(111) nanostructures induced by Fermi surface nesting

Scanning tunneling microscopy measurements on Ag(111)/MoS 2 reveal atomically flat preferred, or “magic,” heights occurring at 6, 10, and 14 atomic layers. We note these results are consistent with Ag growth on a variety of semiconducting substrates and correlate with electronic energy savings in electronic structure calculations of freestanding Ag(111) films. Thus, under certain conditions, Ag will spontaneously form quantized structures independent of the substrate. To explain this, we have found Fermi surface nesting vectors in the bulk Ag band structure which account for these results and the fact Ag that is gapped along the surface normal. This model extends to a range of metallic systems which exhibit electronic confinement, epitaxial growth, and minimal strain. As with Au/MoS 2 , the Ag/MoS 2 system exhibits this behavior at unusually high temperatures so that these principles might be used for control over device features at the nanometer scale under standard fabrication conditions.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2020

Composite Structured Surfaces for Durable Dropwise Condensation

Dropwise condensation of steam on hydrophobic substrates has a 10X higher heat transfer coefficient compared to filmwise condensation. To promote dropwise condensation, low surface energy hydrophobic coatings (polymers) are typically utilized. The low intrinsic thermal conductivity (k < 1 W/(m · K)) of polymers, coupled with high heat transfer coefficient of dropwise condensation (100 kW/(m 2 · K)), necessitates that the coating be thin (< 1µm) in order to avoid reducing the overall heat exchanger conductance. However, thin polymeric films easily degrade. The two opposing requirements result in the need for optimization between the durability (thick coating) and the heat transfer (thin coating). To enable high thermal conductivity in thicker coatings, we develop metal-polymer structured surfaces. By using porous structures as inter-connected heat-conducting backbones that are filled with hydrophobic materials, we enable tuning of the coating effective thermal conductivity and surface energy. Three metal structures were studied; micro/nanowires, inverse opals, and sintered spheres. Heat transfer performance was calculated using three-dimensional finite element method simulations with two distinct boundary conditions; convection at the walls and isothermal walls. Interestingly, the overall conductance shows up to 40% difference depending on the boundary condition used in calculating the composite coating effective thermal conductivity. We use our model to predict the heat transfer performance as a function of metal fraction by volume and by surface area for condensation. By coupling our thermal simulations with a previously verified analytical model for predicting wetting behavior on heterogeneous surfaces, we propose a regime map to predict dropwise-to-filmwise transition. Furthermore, our work not only forms a starting point for the development of durable dropwise condensing surfaces, it identifies important considerations needed for computing effective thermal conductivity of composites.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2024

Assembling Vertical Block Copolymer Nanopores via Solvent Vapor Annealing on Homopolymer-Functionalized Substrates

Utilizing the self-assembly of block copolymers with large Flory–Huggins interaction parameters (χ) for nanofabrication is a formidable challenge due to the attendant large surface energy differences between the blocks. This work reports a robust protocol for the fabrication of thin films with highly ordered cylindrical nanopore arrays via the self-assembly of an asymmetric poly(styrene-block-4-vinylpyridine) (PS-b-P4VP) diblock copolymer blended with a P4VP homopolymer. The desired vertical domain orientation is achieved at the air–polymer interface by controlled solvent vapor annealing (SVA) using acetone, a solvent with weak selectivity for PS over P4VP, and at the substrate interface by functionalization using a hydroxy-terminated poly(2-vinylpyridine) (P2VP-OH) homopolymer brush. In contrast, the vertical cylinder orientation is unstable during acetone SVA on substrates functionalized using hydroxy-terminated poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA-OH). Although PMMA exhibits more balanced interfacial energies between PS and P4VP than P2VP in the dry state, it is also swollen more selectively by acetone. We hypothesize that the nearly balanced solvent swelling of the three polymers (P2VP, P4VP, and PS) stabilizes the vertical cylinder orientation, while unbalanced swelling (PMMA > P4VP and PS) does not. Here we further characterize pore formation by addition of a P4VP homopolymer and its postassembly extraction using ethanol, revealing a narrow window of pore size tunability. Notably, minimal differences in nanopore morphologies are observed for P4VP volume fractions as high as 0.1, regardless of the P4VP molar mass. However, further increasing the P4VP volume fraction results in domain reorientation or macrophase separation when its molar mass is less than or greater than the P4VP block molar mass, respectively. Using a P4VP homopolymer that is nearly equal in length to the P4VP block enables the fabrication of well-ordered arrays of vertical, through-film nanopores with high aspect ratios (>10), small periods (<23 nm), and diameters less than 10 nm.

77 NANOSCIENCE AND NANOTECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2023

Real-Time Monitoring of Strain Accumulation and Relief during Epitaxy of Ultrathin Co Ferrite Films with Varied Co Content

Ultrathin Co x Fe 3-x O 4 films of high structural quality and with different Co content (x = 0.6–1.2) were prepared by reactive molecular beam epitaxy on MgO(001) substrates. Epitaxy of these ferrite films is extensively monitored by means of time-resolved (operando) X-ray diffraction recorded in out-of-plane geometry to characterize the temporal evolution of the film structure. The Co ferrite films show high crystalline ordering and smooth film interfaces independent of their Co content. All Co x Fe 3-x O 4 films exhibit enhanced compressive out-of-plane strain during the early stages of growth, which partly releases with increasing film thickness. When the Co content of the ferrite films increases, the vertical-layer distances increase, accompanied by slightly increasing film roughnesses. The latter result is supported by surface-sensitive low-energy electron diffraction as well as X-ray reflectivity measurements on the final films. In contrast, the substrate–film interface roughness decreases with increasing Co content, which is confirmed with X-ray reflectivity measurements. In addition, the composition and electronic structure of the ferrite films is characterized by means of hard X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy performed after film growth. The experiments reveal the expected increasing Fe 3+ /Fe 2+ cation ratios for a higher Co content.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Electron beam analysis induces Cl vacancy defects in a NaCl thin film

This work reports on the electron-induced modification of NaCl thin film grown on Ag(110). We show using low energy electron diffraction that electron beam bombardment leads to desorption and formation of Cl vacancy defects on NaCl surface. The topographic structure of these defects is studied using scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) showing the Cl defects as depressions on the NaCl surface. Most of the observed defects are mono-atomic vacancies and are located on flat NaCl terraces. Auger electron spectroscopy confirms the effect of electron exposure on NaCl thin films showing Cl atoms desorption from the surface. Using density functional theory taken into account the van der Waals dispersion interactions, we confirm the observed experimental STM measurements with STM simulation. Furthermore, comparing the adsorption of defect free NaCl and defective NaCl monolayer on Ag(110) surfaces, we found an increase of the adhesion energy and the charge transfer between the NaCl film and the substrate due to the Cl vacancy. In details, the adhesion energy increases between the NaCl film and the metallic Ag substrate from 30.4 meV Å –2 for the NaCl film without Cl vacancy and from 39.5 meV Å –2 for NaCl film with a single Cl vacancy. The charge transfer from the NaCl film to the Ag substrate is enhanced when the vacancy is created, from 0.63e – to 1.25e – .

Materials Science↗
DOE OSTI2022

Effective properties of semitransparent radiative cooling materials with spectrally variable properties

Radiative cooling is a promising solid-state, non-vapor-compression technology for passive refrigeration and air conditioning. Although this phenomenon occurs naturally, achieving a significant amount of cooling to make it a technically and economically viable technology requires highly engineered, spectrally selective radiative surfaces. These characteristics make radiative cooling difficult to estimate, particularly when it is integrated with other systems such as photovoltaic panels or building envelopes. The complexity further increases when the substrate also participates in the radiative cooling (along with the radiative coating). Energy estimation is becoming increasingly critical because of the recent focus on the semitransparent radiative coatings that transmit a variety of colors to enhance the aesthetic appeal of the system. In this work, we propose an iterative method to calculate the effective radiative properties, which provides the same net radiative cooling that would be observed using the spectral properties at both the coating and substrate surfaces. Compared to traditional methods that rely on either computationally expensive full spectral analysis or methods for averaging each radiative surface parameter locally, our proposed method focuses on calculating effective properties that provide the same the net cooling effect as a full spectral analysis by accounting the emissivity, absorptivity, and transmissivity collectively, thereby providing an overall estimation error of less than 0.2%. We believe that this study will be beneficial to the engineering communities that employ complex simulation codes and require lumped solar and thermal radiation related parameters.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗
DOE OSTI2023

Light‐Driven Metabolic Pathways in Non‐Photosynthetic Biohybrid Bacteria

Biomanufacturing via microorganisms relies on carbon substrates for molecular feedstocks and a source of energy to carry out enzymatic reactions. This creates metabolic bottlenecks and lowers the efficiency for substrate conversion. Nanoparticle biohybridization with proteins and whole cell surfaces can bypass the need for redox cofactor regeneration for improved secondary metabolite production in a non-specific manner. Here we propose using nanobiohybrid organisms (Nanorgs), intracellular protein-nanoparticle hybrids formed through the spontaneous coupling of core-shell quantum dots (QDs) with histidine-tagged enzymes in non-photosynthetic bacteria, for light-mediated control of bacterial metabolism. Furthermore, this proved to eliminate metabolic constrictions and replace glucose with light as the source of energy in Escherichia coli, with an increase in growth by 1.7-fold in 75 % reduced nutrient media. Metabolomic tracking through carbon isotope labeling confirmed flux shunting through targeted pathways, with accumulation of metabolites downstream of respective targets. Finally, application of Nanorgs with the Ehrlich pathway improved isobutanol titers/yield by 3.9-fold in 75 % less sugar from E. coli strains with no genetic alterations. These results demonstrate the promise of Nanorgs for metabolic engineering and low-cost biomanufacturing.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2021

Hybrid molecular beam epitaxy growth of BaTiO 3 films

The ability to reproducibly synthesize thin films with precise composition and controlled structure is essential for fundamental study and mass production. Here, we demonstrate the hybrid molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) growth of epitaxial, single crystalline BaTiO3 films with different thicknesses on Nb-doped SrTiO3 substrates with atomically smooth surfaces. By combining scanning transmission electron microscopy, temperature-dependent high-resolution x-ray diffraction, reflection high-energy electron diffraction, and atomic force microscopy, we study the effect of growth conditions and the interplay between stoichiometry and epitaxial strain on the resulting structure. Furthermore, we demonstrate a close to bulk-like ferroelectric phase transition in thicker films and highlight the effect of strain on the phase transition temperature. This work establishes the hybrid MBE approach for the growth of heteroepitaxial BaTiO3 films on conducting substrates with scalable thickness and controlled stoichiometry.

Materials Science↗
DOE OSTI2025

Effect of sintering temperature on adhesion of spray-on piezoelectric transducers

Conventionally sol-gel spray-on transducers require a high-temperature (> 700 ◦C) sintering process; however, this process can affect the microstructure of the substrate material. For mechanical elbows and valves utilized for fluid transport in the energy sector, the components are designed to have a specific microstructure, and deviations from these specifications can create weak points in the system. For this reason it is important to investigate how the temperature of the deposition process affects the substrate. This paper investigates the effect of high-temperature and low-temperature (< 150 ◦C) processing conditions on the surface composition of the substrate. Furthermore, the resultant transducers from high- and low-temperature fabrication processes are compared to determine if a low-temperature processing method is feasible. For these studies a sol-gel spray-on process is employed to deposit piezoelectric ceramics onto a stainless-steel 316L substrate. Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy is utilized to determine the composition of the substrate surface before and after transducer deposition. Results indicate that the high-temperature processing conditions may alter the surface composition of the metal due to a diffusion of the metal into the ceramic, which results in a metal surface that is bonded to the ceramic. Furthermore, it is shown that low-temperature processing of spray-on transducers is a viable method for transducer fabrication where the resultant transducers meet the industry minimum requirement of 30 dB signalto-noise ratio. In parallel simulation calculations, finite-element method (FEM) studies were performed to model the adhesive strength of the low-temperature processed transducer to the substrate surface. Comparisons between the simulations and experiments suggest that the bond strength is much greater than the commercial gel bonds and closer to hardened epoxy glue bonds. These results indicate that spray-on transducers fabricated under lowtemperature processing conditions are a viable solution for leave-in-place monitoring of structures.

M. Sinding, Kyle↗
DOE OSTI2022

Solar mirrors and methods of making solar mirrors having improved properties

An article for reflecting solar energy includes a coating stack having solar reflecting films and metal oxide films, the coating stack applied on a major surface of a glass substrate, and a protective overcoat comprising a first and a second surface, wherein the first surface of the protective overcoat is disposed toward the solar reflective films and metal oxide films; and a polymer encapsulant over outer wall surfaces of the coating stack, the second surface of the protective overcoat and over peripheral edges of the coated article, the encapsulant having a base layer, a top layer and metallic corrosion-inhibitive material in the base layer.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2025

Flux-Closure Domain Structures in Ferroelectric K 0.5 Na 0.5 NbO 3 Thin Films

Topological domain structures in ferroelectric materials have garnered increasing attention due to their intriguing physical properties and promising applications. While most existing topological structures in ferroelectric perovskite oxides originate from tetragonal or rhombohedral bulk phases, much less is understood about their counterparts in orthorhombic ferroelectrics. Here, in this work, we employ ferroelectric K 0.5 Na 0.5 NbO 3 (KNN) thin films as a model system and leverage phase-field simulations to theoretically predict the static structures and dynamic behaviors of three types of flux-closure domain configurations: in-plane (Type-I), out-of-plane (Type-II), and superdomain (Type-III) flux-closure structures. We systematically investigate the effects of finite size, misfit strains, and electrical boundary conditions on the formation and switching of these topological structures. For the Type-I structure, size reduction or small misfit strain facilitates a transition of the flux-closure pattern to polar vortices. Type-II structures emerge under open-circuit electrical boundary conditions of the film, forming at the junctions of specific domain walls with the film surface or the film–substrate interface. The formation mechanisms of these two flux-closure structures are rationalized from an energy perspective. We demonstrated switching capabilities of Type-II and Type-III structures by obtaining polarization–electric field hysteresis loops. Our simulations also reveal a reversible electric-field-induced transition between the orthorhombic and rhombohedral ferroelectric phases with a checkerboard domain pattern, during which the integrity of the flux-closure structure is preserved. These findings provide theoretical insights and practical guidance for identifying and manipulating topological structures in low-symmetry ferroelectrics, paving the way for developing energy-efficient microelectronic devices based on topological structures.

P-E loop↗