Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “baseline graphite characterization”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

64 records · Page 4

AGR-1 Irradiated Compact 6-1-1 PIE Report: Evaluation of As-Irradiated Fuel Performance Using Leach Burn Leach, IMGA, Materialography, and X-ray Tomography

The AGR-1 irradiation test train consisted of six independently monitored capsules. All capsules contained twelve compacts in three stacks of four compacts each [Pope 2010]. Compact 6-1-1 was located in capsule 6, at the top of the test train. The compact was in stack 1 (one of the two stacks closest to the core) in position 1 (at the bottom of the 4 compact stack). Compact 6-1-1 was identified in the fabrication data package as LEU01-46T-Z32 [Hunn et al. 2006]. Details of the compact fabrication and measured properties can be found in that data package. The compact lot was made using TRISO-coated particles designated as AGR-1 Baseline fuel. These particles contained 19.7% enriched mixed uranium oxideuranium carbide (UCO) kernels with a O/U atomic ratio of ~1.36 and a C/U atomic ratio of ~0.33 [Pope 2010]. Details of the coated particle fabrication and measured properties can be found in the data package for the AGR-1 Baseline particles [Hunn and Lowden 2006]. The compact was irradiated at the INL Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) to an average calculated burn-up of 15.1% fissions per initial metal atom (FIMA) and an average calculated fast fluence of 3.0 x 10 25 n/m 2 [Sterbentz 2011] at a calculated volume averaged and time averaged temperature of approximately 1111°C [Hawkes 2012]. Capsules were disassembled and preliminary compact and graphite holder inspection was performed [Demkowicz et al. 2011]. Compact 6-1-1 was shipped to ORNL and post-irradiation examination (PIE) was performed according to examination plan PLN-3624 [Demkowicz 2010-2]. All the examination plan objectives listed below were completed except item 6, which was deleted due to limited funding. 1. Determine the inventory of fission products retained in the compact matrix, but not contained by the SiC and determine the number of exposed kernels or particles with defective SiC layers using the deconsolidation-leach-burn-leach method. 2. Gamma count all particles to quantify 137Cs inventory for comparison with calculated values and gamma spectrometric measurements made on the whole compact. Also, attempt to quantify the inventory of any other fission products for which gamma emissions are observed. 3. Characterize each particle based on the 137 Cs/ 144 Ce ratio to identify particles with low Cs retention that may be the result of a failed SiC coating. 4. Gamma count a subset of particles to determine the 110m Ag inventory for comparison with calculated values and gamma spectrometric measurements made on the whole compact. Also, attempt to quantify the inventory of other fission products observed. 5. Microscopically inspect selected particles to determine the condition of the kernels and coatings. This could include kernel migration, coating microstructures and defects, fission product attack of the SiC layer, and fission product migration in the coating layers. 6. Perform high temperature fission product release tests on a subset of particles in order to calibrate the collection efficiency of the Core Conduction Cooldown Test Facility (CCCTF) deposition cup for selected fission products. Gamma count particles before and after the heating test to quantify the released fission product fractions. 7. Archive remaining particles for later use. Compact 6-1-1 LBL began with compact deconsolidation in the Building 3525 hot cell, followed by two nitric acid leaches of the particles and matrix residue using a Soxhlet extraction apparatus. The matrix residue was then burned and the ash was leached twice with boiling nitric acid. The deconsolidated particles underwent an IMGA analysis to determine gamma-emitting isotope inventories for individual particles; the most conspicuous elements with reduced inventories, indicating fission product release, were silver and europium. During the IMGA analysis, particles with low silver were identified and a subset of these was set aside for materialography and x-ray. After the completion of the IMGA study, about 10% of the particles (421) were set aside as an archive and the remainder burned back and leached twice in the Soxhlet apparatus. Figure 1 shows a flow chart detailing the PIE of Compact 6-1-1.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Lamb wave characterization of the effects of long-term thermal-mechanical aging on composite stiffness

Lamb waves offer a promising method of evaluating damage in composite materials. The Lamb wave velocity is directly related to the material parameters, so an effective tool exists to monitor damage in composites by measuring the velocity of these waves. The Lamb Wave Imager (LWI) uses a pulse/receive technique that excites an antisymmetric Lamb mode and measures the time-of-flight over a wide frequency range. Given the material density and plate thickness, the bending and out-of-plane shear stiffnesses are calculated from a reconstruction of the dispersion curve. In this study, the time-of-flight as well as the elastic stiffnesses D11, D22, A44, and A55 for composite samples which have undergone combined thermal and mechanical aging are obtained. The samples examined include a baseline specimen with 0 cycles, specimens which have been aged 2350 and 3530 cycles at high strain levels, and one specimen aged 3530 cycles at low strain levels.

Aircraft↗

Study of Tritium Transport in Nuclear-Grade Graphite and Molten Fluoride Salt Systems

High-temperature salts are proposed as coolant in recent reactor technologies including Fluoride Salt-Cooled High Temperature Reactor (FHR) with fluoride salt as primary and secondary loop coolant, Molten Salt Reactors (MSRs) with fuel salt, and high-magnetic-field fusion machines with salt coolant blanket. The baseline coolant is {sup 7}Li{sub 2}BeF{sub 4} (flibe) due to its good thermal-hydraulic and neutronic properties. Tritium produced in flibe due to neutron irradiation makes the issue of tritium transport an area of great interest. In the temperature range of 427- 704 deg. C, tritium readily diffuses through metallic reactor structural materials, which makes tritium control and capture a key technical challenge. It is anticipated that tritium can be captured by graphite, as graphite material showed a high affinity for tritium in the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE) due to the porous and irregular crystallite microstructure. Two types of nuclear grade graphite which used as core components for FHR: matrix graphite, which encapsulates the TRISO (Tri-structural-isotropic) fuel particles in FHR, and high purity, isotropic nuclear grade graphite IG-110 which can be used as moderator and reflector in reactor core for both fission and fusion reactor. The microstructure of matrix graphite and IG-110 is different from that of matrix graphite, due to the raw material and manufacturing processes. There are three phenomena important for predicting tritium transport in graphite-salt systems: tritium species diffusion in molten flibe; tritium species transport at the salt-graphite interface; and tritium species transport in graphite. In this summary microstructure characterization of IG-110 and matrix graphite, characterization of graphite-salt interface as well as techniques for trace tritium detection in graphite are discussed.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

First Keck Nulling Observations of a Young Stellar Object: Probing the Circumstellar Environment of the Herbig Ae Star MWC325

We present the first N-band nulling plus K- and L-band V(sup 2) observations of a young stellar object, MWC 325, taken with the 85 m baseline Keck Interferometer. The Keck nuller was designed for the study of faint dust signatures associated with debris disks, but it also has a unique capability for studying the temperature and density distribution of denser disks found around young stellar objects. Interferometric observations of MWC 325 at K, L, and N encompass a factor of five in spectral range and thus, especially when spectrally dispersed within each band, enable characterization of the structure of the inner disk regions where planets form. Fitting our observations with . geometric models such as a uniform disk or a Gaussian disk show that the apparent size increases 'monotonically with wavelength in the 2-12/Lm wavelength region, confirming the widely held assumption based on radiative transfer models, now with spatially resolved measurements over a broad wavelength range, that disks are extended with a temperature gradient. The effective size is a factor of about 1.4 and 2.2 larger in the L band and N band, respectively, compared to that in the K band. The existing interferometric measurements and the spectral energy distribution can be reproduced by a flat disk or a weakly shadowed nearly flat disk model, with only slight flaring in the outer regions of the disk, consisting of representative "sub-micron" (0.1 micron) and "micron" (2 micron) grains of a 50:50 ratio of silicate and graphite. This is in marked contrast io the disks previously found in other Herbig Ae/Be stars, suggesting a wide variety in the disk properties among Herbig Ae/Be stars.

Ragland, S.↗

First Keck Nulling Observations of a Young Stellar Object: Probing the Circumstellar Environment of the Herbig Ae star MWC 325

We present the first N-band nulling plus K- and L-band V(sup 2) observations of a young stellar object, MWC325, taken with the 85 m baseline Keck Interferometer. The Keck nuller was designed for the study of faint dust signatures associated with debris disks, but it also has a unique capability for studying the temperature and density distribution of denser disks found around young stellar objects. Interferometric observations of MWC 325 at K, L and N encompass a factor of five in spectral range and thus, especially when spectrally dispersed within each band, enable characterization of the structure of the inner disk regions where planets form. Fitting our observations with geometric models such as a uniform disk or a Gaussian disk show that the apparent size increases monotonically with wavelength in the 2-12 micrometer wavelength region, confirming the widely held assumption based on radiative transfer models, now with spatially resolved measurements over broad wavelength range, that disks are extended with a temperature gradient. The effective size is a factor of about 1.3 and 2 larger in the Lband and N-band, respectively, compared to that in the K-band. The existing interferometric measurements and the spectral energy distribution can be reproduced by a flat disk or a weakly shadowed nearly flat-disk model, with only slight flaring in the outer regions of the disk, consisting of representative "sub-micron" (0.1 micron) and "micron" (2 micron) grains of a 50:50 ratio of silicate and graphite. This is marked contrast with the disks previously found in other Herbig Ae/Be stars suggesting a wide variety in the disk properties among Herbig Ae/Be stars.

Ragland, S.↗

FIRST KECK NULLING OBSERVATIONS OF A YOUNG STELLAR OBJECT: PROBING THE CIRCUMSTELLAR ENVIRONMENT OF THE HERBIG Ae STAR MWC 325

We present the first N-band nulling plus K- and L-band V{sup 2} observations of a young stellar object, MWC 325, taken with the 85 m baseline Keck Interferometer. The Keck nuller was designed for the study of faint dust signatures associated with debris disks, but it also has a unique capability for studying the temperature and density distribution of denser disks found around young stellar objects. Interferometric observations of MWC 325 at K, L, and N encompass a factor of five in spectral range and thus, especially when spectrally dispersed within each band, enable characterization of the structure of the inner disk regions where planets form. Fitting our observations with geometric models such as a uniform disk or a Gaussian disk show that the apparent size increases monotonically with wavelength in the 2-12 {mu}m wavelength region, confirming the widely held assumption based on radiative transfer models, now with spatially resolved measurements over a broad wavelength range, that disks are extended with a temperature gradient. The effective size is a factor of about 1.4 and 2.2 larger in the L band and N band, respectively, compared to that in the K band. The existing interferometric measurements and the spectral energy distribution can be reproduced by a flat disk or a weakly shadowed nearly flat disk model, with only slight flaring in the outer regions of the disk, consisting of representative 'sub-micron' (0.1 {mu}m) and 'micron' (2 {mu}m) grains of a 50:50 ratio of silicate and graphite. This is in marked contrast to the disks previously found in other Herbig Ae/Be stars, suggesting a wide variety in the disk properties among Herbig Ae/Be stars.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

The Effect of Electrolyte Composition on Lithium Plating During Low Temperature Charging of Li-Ion Cells

In the present work, a number of additives have been investigated for their effect on the charge characteristics of cells containing low temperature, high ester content electrolytes (1.0 M LiPF6 in ethylene carbonate (EC) + ethyl methyl carbonate (EMC) + methyl propionate (MP) 20:20:60 vol % + X additive). These experimental three-electrode cells are composed of graphite anodes, LiNiCoAlO2 cathodes, and a lithium metal reference electrode. Cells were first subjected to electrochemical characterization at various temperatures, consisting of performing Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS), linear micropolarization and Tafel polarization measurement to determine the kinetic parameters for both the anodes and cathodes. Following electrochemical characterization, the cells were subjected to charging at decreasing temperatures using C/5 rates to 4.10V, with a constant potential C/50 current taper. Analysis of the C/20 discharge following the charge at low temperature revealed either the presence or absence of a high voltage plateau during the initial stages of the discharge. This plateau has been linked to the presence of lithium metal on the anode previously and was used as a measure for the extent of lithium plating in the cell. Differential analysis (dV/dQ) was applied as well to more clearly visualize the position of the high voltage plateau and use the peak position (x-axis) in the dV/dQ plot as a gauge for the amount of plating which took place in the cell on the prior charge. Most additives investigated increased the resistance of the anode and decreased the resistance of the cathode, thereby leading to an overall increase in plating observed at low temperature. One additive, LiFSI, was found to be beneficial during low temperature charging, however studies of electrode kinetics from the cell containing LiFSI did not reveal significant improvements compared to the baseline.

Jones, John-Paul↗

An Integrated Supercritical System for Efficient Produced Water Treatment and Power Generation

The main goal of this project was to evaluate the feasibility of an integrated supercritical (SC) water desalination and power generation system for treatment of produced waters from CO 2 sequestration, oil production, and coal-bed methane recovery. This system may offer a transformative approach to generating power from coal or natural gas (NG) and purifying saline water or produced water with high total dissolved solids (TDS) in a zero-liquid discharge plant. The closed-loop steam cycle of conventional power plants was replaced with an open-loop steam cycle that heated the pretreated produced water above the SC point of water (374 °C and 221 bar) to precipitate and separate the salts dissolved in the water. After separation of the precipitated salt, the SC steam required further treatment to reduce the salt content from ~100 mg/L (ppm) to <1 ppm to make it suitable for use in turbines for power generation. A SC membrane distillation unit was used to polish the SC steam, which could be sent through a series of turbines for power generation, and the steam exiting the low-pressure turbine could be condensed by cooling water to produce pure water. Project tasks included a process simulation and a techno-economic evaluation of the integrated system; design and assembly of SC salt precipitation and membrane distillation systems; development and characterization of advanced carbon membranes for SC membrane distillation; and pretreatment, desalination, and purification of different produced water samples with salt concentrations of 30,000–200,000 ppm to a high-purity (<1 ppm) level. Process simulations were performed for 550 MW SC coal-fired or NG baseline cases and various scenarios for the proposed integrated SC system using produced water as the water source and coal or NG as the fuel source. Simulation results indicated that the net plant efficiency loss of the proposed SC cogeneration process would be in the range of <1% to ~4%, in which NG and lower TDS produced water cases would have higher efficiencies. The proposed process for coal-fired cases could provide all water needs for the power generation process and generate additional pure water for beneficial use. A techno-economic analysis was performed to estimate the cost of produced water treatment (dollars /kgal of treated water) by conventional treatment processes compared with the proposed cogeneration process. The cost estimation for the proposed cogeneration system included the cost of pretreatment, the cost of power loss to integrate the water desalination process into the power generation system, and the cost of plant modification or retrofitting. The cost of produced water treatment was calculated by assuming three different scenarios in which converting a baseline power plant to the proposed cogeneration plant would increase the cost of the boiler and feed water system by 10%, 50%, and 100%. Results indicated that the cost of produced water treatment, even with a 100% cost increase, was in the range of $8.6–11.6 dollars per kgal, which is about half of the treatment cost by conventional methods. The cost of produced water treatment by the proposed cogeneration system could be further reduced or a considerable income could be generated if the values of saltwater and freshwater products are considered. Overall, the techno-economic analysis results indicated that the proposed integrated SC system could potentially treat produced water at a cost significantly lower than the cost of produced water treatment by conventional technologies. To evaluate the feasibility of the proposed treatment system at a laboratory scale, a SC salt precipitation and membrane distillation system was designed and fabricated to treat a simulated brine or pretreated produced water by precipitating salts and further polishing the SC steam containing ~100 ppm salts to a high-purity steam. Through baseline tests with NaCl solutions, with concentrations ranging from 30,000 to 200,000 ppm, it was demonstrated that concentrated feed solutions could be treated by precipitating salt at SC conditions to a TDS level of 130 ppm. Produced water samples were collected from a potential CO 2 sequestration site, a coal-bed methane site, and an oilfield in Illinois. Representative samples were characterized for various water quality parameters, including pH; turbidity; conductivity; and concentrations of selected anions, cations, alkalinity, dissolved organic carbon, total suspended solids, TDS, and total petroleum hydrocarbons. The produced water samples were first treated by conventional pretreatment methods to remove residual oil, dissolved organic matter, and scale-forming species. Pretreatment methods included coagulation, sedimentation, filtration, activated carbon adsorption, and ion-exchange adsorption. Pretreated produced waters were treated at SC conditions in which salts were precipitated. Analysis of treated samples revealed that the concentration of Na (the main cation) in produced waters was reduced dramatically from 14,000–47,400 ppm in the feed to 21–80 ppm in treated waters. Concentrations of other main cations (Ca, Mg, Sr, K) also decreased significantly from initial values of ~1,000–22,000 ppm to ~1 ppm or less. However, a significant increase in the concentrations of Fe, Ni, Cu, and Co was observed, mainly caused by leaching of these elements from the system (vessels, filters, tubing), which is manufactured from alloys containing Fe, Ni, Cu, and Co. To polish the SC steam containing a salt content of ~100 ppm to a high-purity level of <1 ppm, a SC membrane distillation treatment using carbon membranes was employed. Different types of self-standing or supported carbon membranes were developed from graphite, graphene, carbon nanotubes, carbon nanofibers, and pyrolytic carbon. Screening tests revealed that only a limited number of developed carbon membranes were suitable for the purification of steam at SC conditions. Membranes that were either fragile and lacked mechanical strength or had large pores and showed limited salt rejection (<20%) were found to be unsuitable for the purification of SC steam. Promising carbon membranes that were successfully tested for purifying SC steam included two graphite membranes (i.e., AF-5, a porous graphite material, and FGS, a flexible graphite sheet) and a carbon nanotube membrane grown on a Hastelloy substrate and then further modified using a proprietary method (i.e., membrane C). The AF-5 membrane exhibited a stable water flux of ~50 kg/m 2 ∙h and ~40% salt rejection. The FGS membrane had a high salt rejection of 95%–98% but a lower water flux of ~15 kg/m 2 ∙h. Membrane C showed an extremely high flux of 200-800 kg/m 2 ∙h, which is one order of magnitude higher than the water flux of conventional membranes. Membrane C also exhibited 87%–93% salt rejection. Overall, a two-stage or multistage polishing treatment by these membranes could lower the salt content of the SC steam from initial values of ~100–200 ppm to the steam quality of <1 ppm or to parts per billion levels required for the power cycle.

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

Fabrication of Advanced Nanocarbon-Metal Composites for Improved Energy Efficiency

We fabricated nanocarbon metal composites (NCMC) of Al alloys with a process called “electrocharging assisted process” (EAP). This method consists of the application of a high current to a mixture of liquid metal and carbon particles. We investigated aluminum alloys (6061 and 1350) and used activated carbon and graphite powder as the source of carbon. The high current induces the formation of carbon chains and ribbons in the liquid metal. Upon solidification of the metal an epitaxial relation between the carbon nanostructures and the metal lattice is produced. The purpose of the project was to find the parameters during the reaction that would give rise to a high density of nanoribbons extending throughout the metal such that the electrical conductivity and the mechanical strength of the composite increased and that the method could be extended to large scale manufacturing. For this purpose, we designed two reactors for the incorporation of nanocarbon ribbons in aluminum metal. The first reactor was designed to have more control of the region with the high current density. However, there were problems with getting good mixing of the carbon in small volumes. A second reactor was designed with a stirrer that allowed for better mixing of the carbon by the introduction of argon gas through the shaft of the stirrer. NCMC were fabricated with a series of parameters to understand the role of current, time of applied current, type and shape of the cathode electrode and stirring speed of the mixture. We analyzed the composites by Raman scattering to gain information on the crystallite size of the nanocarbon, XRD to obtain the crystal structure of the composite, SEM and TEM to characterize the grain size of the aluminum grains and the quality of the crystal structure. We also measured the electrical conductivity and mechanical properties of selected samples. The nanocomposites showed increase in crystallite size of the nanocarbon with a linear dependence of the crystallite size on the duration of the applied current. There is a minimum current density necessary for the crystallite size to increase compared to the ~ 10 nm size of the activated carbon source used in the fabrication. The electrical conductivity of the nanocomposites increased with crystallite size of the nanocarbon and with the concentration of converted carbon. The maximum increase in electrical conductivity was 5.7% above the baseline for samples with ~ 4 wt % nanocarbon with crystallite size larger than 30 nm. These samples presented a hardness ~ 8% higher than the baseline samples with no carbon.

24 POWER TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION↗

Synthesis and Characterization of Mixed-Conducting Corrosion Resistant Oxide Supports

An extensive search and evaluation of electrochemically stable catalyst supports (including metal oxides like RuO2-SiO2, RuO2-TiO2, and ITO was perfomed during the 4 years of the project. The suports were also catalyzed by deposition of Pt and tested for its performance and electrochemical stability in RDE and fuel cell experiments. For testing the electrochemical stability and fuel cell performance of the catalysts and supports, we have employed the protocols in use at the Department of Energy and Nissan Technological Center North America (NTCNA). The use of such procedures allows a precise and reproducible estimation of the performance and stability of the materials and permits comparisons among laboratories and DOE funded projects. RuO2-SiO2 catalyst supports showed no loss in surface area during start-stop stability tests that were performed by cycling the electrode potential between 0 V to 1.8 V for 1000 cycles. Catalyzed support (40% Pt/RuO2-SiO2; 1:1 mole ratio) were tested in a PEFC, resulting in a current density of 750 mA/cm2 at 0.6 Volts, and a maximum power density of 570 mW/cm2. Measurements were conducted at 80 ºC with 75% relative humidity of the inlet gases (H2/O2); Pt loadings were 0.4 mg/cm2 at the cathode and 0.2 mg/cm2 at the anode. Start-stop stability tests for support and catalyzed support performed in RDE and PEFC set-ups have confirmed RuO2-TiO2 support stability. The beginning of life performance was exactly equal to end of life performance (in an MEA that has been subjected to severe start-stop cycling for 10,000 start/stop cycles between 1 V to 1.5 V). This result was in sharp contrast to baseline Pt/C catalyst that showed significant performance deterioration after accelerated stability tests. The Pt/TRO showed minimal loss in performance upon exposure to start-stop cycles. The loss in cell voltage at 1 A/cm2 at 100% RH was almost 700 mV for Pt/C whereas it was only ca. 15 mV for Pt/TRO. 40% RH data (of inlet gases) revealed a similar trend in terms of stability – exceptional stability for Pt/TRO as opposed to very poor stability for Pt/HSAC. These observations were attributed to the much higher stability of the TRO support compared to Carbon. The carbon dioxide concentration in the cathode exit stream during the accelerated degradation test with Pt/TRO (start-stop protocol) was extremely low (between 3 to 10 ppm of CO2). In contrast, the CO2 emission levels from a conventional Pt/C catalyst were found to be approx. 200 ppm. This observation was a clear indicator that the main source of carbon being oxidized to carbon dioxide in an MEA was the carbon catalyst support, and not the gas diffusion layer or the graphite flow fields. Indium tin oxide (ITO) was also evaluated as a catalyst support for PEFCs. Pt/ITO was very stable under start-up/shutdown accelerated degradation protocol (RDE tests in perchloric acid). The ECSA change was less than 4% over 10,000 cycles. The load cycling accelerated protocol (from 0.6 to 0.95 V vs. RHE) resulted in a loss of approximately 34% of the initial ECSA after 10,000 cycles. However, fuel cell testing resulted in a very low performing catalyst. XPS spectroscopy was employed to investigate the changes in the catalysts occuring during fuel cell operation. It was observed a shift of In 3d5/2 and In 3d3/2 peaks towards higher binding energies. This can be explained by the formation of hydroxides or oxy-hydroxides in the surface of the catalyst. O1s spectrum for Pt/ITO catalyst after being operated in the fuel cell, also confirmed the formation of significant amounts of surface hydroxides (12 to 16%). The presence of surface hydroxides in the catalyst increased the electrode resistivity affecting fuel cell performance. NTCNA performed a detailed analysis of transport phenomena (reactants and products to/from the Pt active sites) in both commercial catalyst and Pt/RTO (in order to have a better understanding at the basic level). The proton resistance (Rionomer) in Pt/C and Pt/RTO cathode catalyst layers were 150 and 12 mΩ-cm2, respectively. Pt/RTO catalyst layer has about an order or magnitude lower proton transfer resistance than Pt/C catalyst layer. Since the ionomer/support ratio that was used in formulating the ink for both catalysts was the same (0.9), it is expected that the volumetric coverage of ionomer of both catalysts will be significantly different due to the disparity in the surface areas (Pt/C had ~ 800 m2/g, while Pt/RTO had ~ 50 m2/g). The differences in the ionomer volumetric coverage and the ionomer film thickness may explain the significantly higher proton conductivity in the Pt/RTO catalyst layer when compared to Pt/HSAC. It is therefore very important to optimize the ionomer loadings when synthesizing new catalyst supports (and never rely on values for carbon-based commercial catalysts). Finally, NTCNA has elaborated a cost model for non-carbon support materials considering their durability benefits. Material costs for production of Pt/ RuO2-TiO2 electrodes were compared to Pt/C. RuO2-TiO2 support was more expensive than carbon but the total material cost was still dominated by platinum cost. Though ruthenium is considered a precious metal, its cost is far less than platinum. It should also be noted that ruthenium only makes up 38% of the mass of the support, while the rest is inexpensive TiO2. After considering the durability advantages of Pt/RTO, cost model showed that even with almost double the Pt loading (0.35 vs 0.18 mgPt/cm2), Pt/RTO ($22.7/kWnet) is only slightly more expensive than Pt/C ($21.9/kWnet).

08 HYDROGEN↗