Tomographic assessment of peening for metallurgical bonding in cold spray
It is widely asserted that peening densifies cold spray coatings and improves particle–particle and particle–substrate bonding, yet systematic studies analyzing the evolution of bonding due to peening particle strikes are scarce. We explore peening at the level of individual particle impacts, by creating two-particle Cu-on-Cu stacks using laser-induced particle impact testing. Exploring impact velocities that range from the onset of bonding at the “critical velocity”, V cr , to its peak near 1.4⋅V cr , we perform full 3D tomography of the particle stacks to characterize the bonding state at the particle-substrate interface. Direct labeling of non-bonded patches and the total particle-substrate interface permits quantification and comparison of bonding in single impacts with bonding after subsequent impacts to reveal the origins of the peening effect. The data reveal a surprising finding: although a second impact directly atop the first particle increases the area of the particle-substrate interface (~40% area increase), there is no improvement in metallurgical bonding. Analysis of these data suggest that not only area expansion (and associated oxide rarefication), but also stress-induced extrusion of metal at that interface needs to occur to achieve metal-on-metal contact to see an enhancement in bonding. Furthermore, our analysis suggests that the subsequent impacting particle needs to have ~70% more kinetic energy to produce additional bonding; this implies that particle and velocity distributions within a spray may be helpful, and that peening may rely on unaligned impacts.