Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “multigroup approximation”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 73 records · Page 4

HTTR criticality calculations with SCALE6: Studies of various geometric and unit-cell options in modeling

The fuel element of the High Temperature Engineering Test Reactor (HTTR) presents a doubly heterogeneous geometry, where tiny TRISO fuel particles dispersed in a graphite matrix form the fuel region of a cylindrical fuel rod, and a number of fuel rods together with moderator or reflector then constitute the lattice design of the core. In this study, a series of full-core HTTR criticality calculations were performed with the SCALE6 code system using various geometric and unit-cell options in order to systematically investigate their effects on neutronic analysis. Two geometric descriptions (ARRAY or HOLE) in SCALE6 can be used to construct a complicated and repeated model. The result shows that eliminating the use of HOLE in the HTTR geometric model can save the computation time by a factor of 4. Four unit-cell treatments for resonance self-shielding corrections in SCALE6 were tested to create problem-specific multigroup cross sections for the HTTR core model. Based on the same ENDF/B-VII cross-section library, their results were evaluated by comparing with continuous-energy calculations. The comparison indicates that the INFHOMMEDIUM result overestimates the system multiplication factor (k{sub eff}) by 55 mk, whereas the LATTICECELL and MULTIREGION treatments predict the k{sub eff} values with similar biases of approximately 10 mk overestimation. The DOUBLEHET result shows a more satisfactory agreement, about 4.2 mk underestimation in the k{sub eff} value. In addition, using cell-weighted cross sections instead of an explicit modeling of TRISO particles in fuel region can further reduce the computation time by a factor of 5 without sacrificing accuracy. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

An Atomic Mix Closure for Stochastic Media Transport Problems

The accurate modeling of stochastic media in radiation transport calculations remains on ongoing research challenge. The Levermore-Pomraning (LP) closure for the statistical transport equation is simple and inexpensive, but it is often inaccurate. More accurate closures have been proposed, but they can be prohibitively expensive. In this work we present a relatively inexpensive closure that we have observed to be more accurate than LP in almost all cases studied. Obtaining solutions to stochastic transport problems can be quite difficult. Transport calculations on an ensemble of explicit realizations generated by Monte Carlo sampling can be prohibitively expensive. Atomic mix or LP calculations are relatively inexpensive, but they can be inaccurate. The present work illustrates an approach that is less expensive than Monte Carlo sampling yet more accurate than atomic mix or LP approximations. We still need to analyze the reasons why the atomic mix closures derived for thicker problems lead to source iteration instabilities. It is not clear if the closure itself induces an ill-posed problem or if it is merely the iterative process that is problematic. We hope to examine alternative source terms to drive the subsidiary calculations. We also want to extend the work to multigroup and multidimensional problems. (authors)

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Efficient Computation of Doppler-Broadened Elastic Scattering Kernel Moments Using Ladder-Operator Formulation

Anefficient routine for computing Legendre moments of the Doppler-broadened elastic scattering kernel, including resonance scattering effects, has been implemented in the ISOXML module of Griffin. Isotropic scattering in the center-of-mass system and the ideal gas model for target motion are assumed. A ladder-operator formulation is introduced to compute all Legendre moments from order 0 to N simultaneously, enabling near-linear scaling of computational cost with respect to the maximum Legendre order. A physics-based strategy for constructing outgoing energy grids has also been developed, in which a tailored base grid is combined with adaptive refinement to maintain accuracy while limiting the number of outgoing energy points. For energies between resonances, a constant cross-section model is employed to further reduce computational cost. In addition, a quantitative criterion is derived to determine isotope-wise cut-off incident energies based on a prescribed up-scattering probability coverage. For 238U, up to incident energies of approximately 75, 230, and 661 eV at 294, 900, and 2500 K (corresponding to a 2% up-scattering probability threshold), computation of P0 kernels requires 1–8 s and computation of P0–P5 kernels requires 0.4–4 min using a single thread, while maintaining 1–3% relative error in up-scattering probability. These results demonstrate that the proposed formulation enables accurate and computationally practical Doppler-broadened kernel generation for online multigroup cross-section production in Griffin.

Doppler-broadening↗

Validation of Scale 6.2 criticality calculations using KENO V.A and KENO-VI - 14603

SCALE 6.2 provides enhancements for criticality calculations relative to SCALE 6.1, especially with updated nuclear data libraries, resonance self-shielding options for multigroup (MG) calculations, and problem-dependent temperature treatments for continuous-energy (CE) calculations. Benchmark experiments from the International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project that are available in the Oak Ridge National Laboratory Verified, Archived, Library of Inputs and Data (VALID) were applied in this validation effort to examine the impact of the SCALE 6.2 enhancements. Over 300 cases are drawn from the VALID library for testing KENO V.a, and a more limited set of approximately 50 configurations is used for validation of KENO-VI. A total of 401 unique critical experiments are used in this validation effort. In some cases, the KENO V.a models were converted to KENO-VI models so that the performance of both codes could be assessed for the same systems. Validation results for the SCALE 6.2 ENDF/B-VII.1 nuclear data libraries are presented, including MG neutron data in 56- and 252-group structures as well as CE data. The performance of all three multipurpose neutron libraries in calculating k{sub eff} is examined with critical experiment models covering a wide range of fuels, moderators, reflectors, absorbers, and neutron spectra. The SCALE 6.2 ENDF/B-VII.1 coupled neutron-photon library, primarily developed for shielding applications with 200 neutron groups and 47 gamma groups, provides additional energy resolution for fast systems relative to the MG neutron libraries which were developed to produce low biases for thermal neutron systems. The applicability of this library to criticality calculations for fast neutron spectrum systems is not investigated here but will be addressed in the final SCALE 6.2 validation report. The results of these calculations demonstrate that SCALE 6.2 generally provides lower biases than SCALE 6.1 and that the two versions of KENO provide equivalent results on the same suite of problems. SCALE 6.2 also includes an updated neutron cross-section covariance library based on the ENDF/B-VII.1 covariance data. The effect of these updated covariances on the uncertainty in k{sub eff} due to cross section uncertainties is also presented for some cases. A more thorough investigation of the updated covariance data is presented in a companion paper. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Demonstration of Full Core Reactor Depletion with MPACT

MPACT is a three-dimensional (3-D) whole core transport code capable of generating sub-pin level power distributions. This feature is accomplished by obtaining the integral transport solutions to the heterogeneous reactor problem in which the actual detailed geometrical configuration of fuel components such as the pellet and cladding is modelled explicitly.. The cross section data needed for the neutron transport calculation are obtained directly from a multigroup microscopic cross section library similar to those used in lattice physics codes. Hence MPACT involves neither a priori homogenization nor group condensation for the core spatial solution. The integral transport solution is obtained by means of the method of characteristics (MOC) that employs discrete ray tracing. Since the direct application of the 3-D MOC capability in MPACT to 3-D core configuration requires considerable amounts of memory and computing time for practical reactor applications, an alternative approximate 3-D solution method was implemented in MPACT based on a 2D-1D approach which employs planar MOC solutions in the framework of the 3-D coarse mesh finite difference (CMFD) formulation. The axial coupling is resolved by one-dimensional (1-D) diffusion solutions and the planar and axial problems are coupled through the transverse leakage. The use of a lower order 1-D solution in the axial direction is justified by the fact that most heterogeneity in the core occurs in the radial direction rather than the axial. However, it is possible to use one of the higher order methods in MPACT such as the 1-D SN kernel if improved solution accuracy is desired. The CMFD formulation which originally served as an efficient nodal formulation is used in MPACT to accelerate the whole core transport calculation. The basic mesh in the CMFD formulation is a pin cell which is much coarser than the flat source regions defined for MOC calculations. The concept of dynamic homogenization of group constants for the pin cells provides the basis of the CMFD formulation in whole core transport calculation. The intra-cell flux distribution determined from the MOC calculation is used to generate the homogenized cell constants while the MOC cell surface averaged currents are used to determine the radial nodal coupling coefficients. This dynamic implementation of the equivalence theory formulation ensures the same transport solution is obtained with CMFD as the one obtained using unaccelerated MOC calculations alone. The ability of MPACT to predict the Hot, Zero Power (HZP) condition of a reactor was reported in CASL-U-2014-0045-000. The purpose of this report is to demonstrate the capability of MPACT to simulate the operation of a reactor at Hot, Full Power (HFP) conditions during normal operation throughout a full operating cycle. The time scale for a reactor burnup cycle is typically one to two years and therefore short time phenomena such as the effect of delayed neutrons can be neglected. Instead the time dependence can be treated quasi-statically using the depletion algorithm presented in CASL-U-2013-0276-001. The full power operation requires thermal hydraulic feedback to be present during the entire simulation which will utilize the work in CASL-U-2014-0051-000. However, due to the significant computational burden of the coupled physics simulation, a simplified thermal hydraulic model is used for the analysis reported here which is principally intended to demonstrate the full core neutronics depletion. In addition to the thermal hydraulic feedback, the effect of Boron 10 depletion should be modeled in cases where major boron additions are not performed for extended periods of time. Each of these capabilities will be described in the following sections.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Preliminary Study on TRISO Fuel Cross Section Generation

Cross section self-shielding methodologies for TRISO fuel were assessed to provide accurate multigroup cross sections for a high-fidelity reactor physics code so that the code is able to accurately model and simulate advanced reactors with TRISO fuel. Initially, the two existing methodologies (the SCALE method and the Sanchez-Pomraning method) were studied and implemented to MC2-3 for detailed performance tests. Additionally, a new spatial self-shielding method, named the iterative local spatial self-shielding (ILSS) method, for particulate fuels was developed based on the disadvantage factor and implemented to MC2-3 as well. The new method approximately accounts for the effect of randomly distributed particles on the particle shadowing effect using a homogenized compact region surrounding a particle of interest at the center. The self-shielded cross sections of the particle at the center are determined iteratively since the cross sections of the homogenized compact region are calculated using them. For the energy range above 100 keV where the fuel-to-moderator ratio is more important than the random distribution of particles, a single particle unit-cell model is used by preserving the average amount of moderator per fuel particle in the system. The three self-shielding methods implemented in MC2-3 were tested using numerical benchmark problems made based on fuel compact problems of a prismatic-type very high temperature reactor. Test results indicated that the ILSS method produced slightly better results than the SCALE and Sanchez-Pomraning methods, compared to the Serpent-2 Monte Carlo results obtained with 25 independent random particle configurations. The SCALE and Sanchez-Pomraning methods tend to underestimate the heterogeneity effect by 150 and 100 pcm, respectively, while the new ILSS method overestimates the heterogeneity effect by 70 pcm. In future, the new self-shielding method will be extended to perform pebble calculations and compare results with those from the SCALE and Sanchez-Pomraning methods. Furthermore, the new method will be optimized for practical applications to on-the-fly resonance treatment for lattice or whole-core calculations for advanced reactors.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Resonance Self-Shielding Methodologies in SCALE 6

SCALE 6 includes several problem-independent multigroup (MG) libraries that were processed from the evaluated nuclear data file ENDF/B using a generic flux spectrum. The library data must be self-shielded and corrected for problem-specific spectral effects for use in MG neutron transport calculations. SCALE 6 computes problem-dependent MG cross sections through a combination of the conventional Bondarenko shielding-factor method and a deterministic continuous-energy (CE) calculation of the fine-structure spectra in the resolved resonance and thermal energy ranges. The CE calculation can be performed using an infinite medium approximation, a simplified two-region method for lattices, or a one-dimensional discrete ordinates transport calculation with pointwise (PW) cross-section data. This paper describes the SCALE-resonance self-shielding methodologies, including the deterministic calculation of the CE flux spectra using PW nuclear data and the method for using CE spectra to produce problem-specific MG cross sections for various configurations (including doubly heterogeneous lattices). It also presents results of verification and validation studies.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

MPACT 4.4 Theory Manual

MPACT is a three-dimensional (3D) full-core neutron transport code capable of calculating subpin power distributions. Calculations are based on the Boltzmann transport equation for neutron fluxes for problems in which the detailed geometrical configuration of fuel components such as the pellet and cladding are explicitly retained. The cross-section data needed for the neutron transport calculation are obtained directly from a multigroup cross section library, which has traditionally been used by lattice physics codes to generate few-group homogenized cross sections for nodal core simulators. Hence, MPACT assumes neither a priori homogenization nor group condensation for the full core spatial solution. The 3D MPACT transport solution can be obtained using the method of characteristics (MOC), which employs discrete ray tracing within each fuel pin. However, for practical reactor applications, the direct application of MOC to 3D core configurations requires an excessive amount of memory and computing time due to the very large number of rays. For practical 3D full-core calculations, MPACT commonly uses an approximate “2D/1D” method that treats the radial (x and y) variables differently from the axial (z) variable. In particular, the radial dependence of the solution is calculated using transport theory, and the axial dependence is calculated using diffusion or P 3 theory. The 2D/1D method requires the core to be divided into a vertical stack of axial slices with a thickness of Δ z ≈ 5–10 cm. Each axial slice is divided radially into coarse spatial cells with boundaries that usually constitute the pin cell boundaries, for which Δ x = Δ y ≈ 1.5 cm. Then, each coarse radial cell (pin cell) is divided into 50–100 fine radial cells, which resolve the angular flux in the fuel, cladding, and moderator regions.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Accelerated Deterministic Phonon Transport With Consistent Material Temperature and Intensities

Abstract We present a method for deterministically solving the frequency and temperature dependent phonon radiative transport (PRT) equation in the single-mode relaxation time (SMRT) approximation in the self-adjoint angular flux (SAAF) form. To handle the nonlinear coupling between the phonon intensities and the material temperature, we apply a linearization approach that is similar to one in thermal radiative transport. This procedure leads to the PRT equation with pseudo-scattering. The method presented includes acceleration of both the inner pseudo-scattering source iterations and outer temperature iteration with a gray diffusion synthetic acceleration (DSA) and Anderson acceleration, respectively. We use the finite-element method to discretize the PRT equation in space and the method of discrete ordinates (SN) for angular discretization. The proposed method is verified by a gray method of manufactured solutions problem and demonstrated on a problem using temperature and direction dependent multigroup data from lithium aluminate (LiAlO2). The iterative performance of the acceleration method in each test is then compared to the unaccelerated method.

Engineering↗

MOCMC: Method of Characteristics Moment Closure, a Numerical Method for Covariant Radiation Magnetohydrodynamics

In this work, we present a conservative numerical method for radiation magnetohydrodynamics with frequency-dependent full transport in stationary spacetimes. This method is stable and accurate for both large and small optical depths and radiation pressures. The radiation stress–energy tensor is evolved in flux-conservative form, and closed with a swarm of samples that each transport a multigroup representation of the invariant specific intensity along a null geodesic. In each zone, the enclosed samples are used to efficiently construct a Delaunay triangulation of the unit sphere in the comoving frame, which in turn is used to calculate the Eddington tensor, average source terms, and adaptively refine the sample swarm. Furthermore, radiation four-forces are evaluated in the moment sector in a semi-implicit fashion. The radiative transfer equation is solved in invariant form deterministically for each sample. Since each sample carries a discrete representation of the full spectrum, the cost of evaluating the transport operator is independent of the number of frequency groups, representing a significant reduction of algorithmic complexity for transport in frequency-dependent problems. The major approximation we make in this work is performing scattering in an angle-averaged way. Local adaptivity in samples also makes this scheme more amenable to nonuniform meshes than a traditional Monte Carlo method. We describe the method and present results on a suite of test problems. We find that Method of Characteristics Moment Closure converges at least as ~N -1 , rather than the canonical Monte Carlo N -1/2 , where N is the number of samples per zone.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

Localized Radial Basis Functions for Radiation Transport in Slab Geometry

Meshing the spatial domain for the neutron transport equation can be computationally expensive and labor-intensive. Mesh-free methods, such as radial basis function (RBF) approximations, may alleviate these concerns by using a pointwise solution of the transport equation instead of the standard volume-integrated solution using cells or elements. This allows for the use of any geometric description that can provide the material at solution points and the boundary normal directions for boundary points. RBFs give spectral convergence when used to solve differential equations, but only if they are infinitely smooth. This occurs when the RBFs are effectively flat, creating an ill-conditioned, dense system of equations. One simple way to alleviate this issue is to use localized RBFs. Global RBFs have been applied previously to the monoenergetic radiative transport equation in X-Y geometry using source iteration. In this summary, localized RBFs are applied to the multigroup neutron transport equation in slab geometry using Krylov iteration. The results show agreement with benchmark solutions, provided the coefficients for the RBF basis are properly chosen. (authors)

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Equilibrium Core Model for Micro Pebble Bed Reactors Using OpenMC

Estimating the equilibrium state for pebble bed reactors (PBRs) presents complex challenges as it requires simultaneous consideration of changes in the pebbles’ movement as well as their fuel compositions. Whereas traditional approaches use multigroup diffusion codes for neutronics calculations of PBRs’ equilibrium state, the double-heterogeneity of PBRs complicates neutron cross-section generation. Continuous-energy Monte Carlo (MC) methods are better suited for detailed PBR analysis because of their natural handling of double-heterogeneity, but they demand substantially more computational resources. Here, this study introduces a novel method for efficiently estimating the equilibrium state in small and micro PBRs with reduced computational cost. The method is anticipated to accelerate the processes of core design and performing parametric studies for utilizing advanced fuel and structural materials. The HTR-10 reactor design was used for validating the method’s predictions and evaluating its computational efficiency. When compared to reference calculation values from the literature, criticality (k-effective) was predicted to be approximately within the margin of error of the MC transport calculation, average core power density (in megawatts per cubic meter) was predicted within 2.5% relative error, and maximum thermal flux (10 13 n/cm 2 .s −1 ) was predicted within 1.8% relative error. The calculated inventory of fission products and fuel composition in the equilibrium core were within 15% and 16.6%, respectively, when compared to reported values from the literature. The difference is attributed to variance in the considered values of the core temperature, which was found to significantly affect the depletion analyses.

Equilibrium core↗

Summary: Verification of the ENDF/B-VII.1 and VIII.0 AMPX 1597-group Libraries for Advanced Reactor Analysis

The SCALE/AMPX multigroup (MG) cross section processing procedure has been updated to minimize reactivity differences for various advanced thermal and fast reactor designs, as observed for the current MG libraries, resulting in excellent agreement between the calculations with the new MG libraries and the continuous-energy reference calculations. The SCALE MG calculations are widely applied to thermal spectrum light-water reactor systems, as well as fast spectrum metallic systems. Due to growing interest from industry and regulators in applying SCALE for the design of fast spectrum reactors—both sodium and molten salt—it was desirable to review and improve the SCALE/AMPX procedure for unresolved resonance self-shielded data and high-energy neutron spectra. The data were improved by generating MG unresolved resonance data based on the analytic probability table method with the narrow resonance approximation and by using very fine and intermediate group structures that are typical for fast system analysis. This study focused on verifying the improved SCALE/AMPX MG cross section processing procedure and the new AMPX 1597-group library with the ENDF/B-VII.1 and VIII.0 evaluated nuclear data. The verification was made by performing reaction rate analysis and benchmark calculations for various thermal and fast reactor systems. Results indicate that the improved SCALE/AMPX MG cross section processing and libraries provide excellent results for advanced reactor analysis.

Kim, Kang Seog↗

Verification of the ENDF/B-VII.1 and VIII.0 AMPX 1597-Group Libraries for Advanced Reactor Analysis

The SCALE/AMPX multigroup (MG) cross section processing procedure has been updated to minimize reactivity differences for various advanced thermal and fast reactor designs, as observed for the current MG libraries, resulting in excellent agreement between the calculations with the new MG libraries and the continuous-energy reference calculations. The SCALE MG calculations are widely applied to thermal spectrum light-water reactor systems, as well as fast spectrum metallic systems. Due to growing interest from industry and regulators in applying SCALE for the design of fast spectrum reactors—both sodium and molten salt—it was desirable to review and improve the SCALE/AMPX procedure for unresolved resonance self-shielded data and high-energy neutron spectra. The data were improved by generating MG unresolved resonance data based on the analytic probability table method with the narrow resonance approximation and by using very fine and intermediate group structures that are typical for fast system analysis. This study focused on verifying the improved SCALE/AMPX MG cross section processing procedure and the new AMPX 1597-group library with the ENDF/B-VII.1 and VIII.0 evaluated nuclear data. The verification was made by performing reaction rate analysis and benchmark calculations for various thermal and fast reactor systems. Results indicate that the improved SCALE/AMPX MG cross section processing and libraries provide excellent results for advanced reactor analysis.

Kim, Kang Seog↗

The SCALE/AMPX multigroup cross section processing for fast reactor analysis

The SCALE/AMPX multigroup (MG) cross section processing procedure has been updated to minimize reactivity differences for fast reactor designs and boiling water reactors (BWRs) with very high void fractions to provide excellent agreement with continuous-energy reference calculations. SCALE MG calculations are widely applied to thermal spectrum light-water reactor (LWR) systems as well as fast spectrum metallic systems of interest to National Nuclear Security Administration. With growing interest from industry and regulators in applying SCALE for the design of fast spectrum reactors, both sodium and molten salt, and in the licensing of power up rates for BWRs, it is desirable to review the SCALE/AMPX procedure for unresolved resonance self-shielded data and high energy neutron spectra. The data were improved by generating MG unresolved resonance data based on the analytic probability table method with the narrow resonance approximation as well as the use of a very fine group structure typically used in fast system analysis. This study focused on verifying the probability table and the SCALE/AMPX MG cross section processing procedure by performing reaction rate analysis and benchmark calculations for various fast reactor and high void BWR systems. Here, results indicate that the improved SCALE/AMPX MG cross section processing provides excellent results for the fast reactor analysis.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Some Nuclear Calculations of U-235-D2O Gaseous-Core Cavity Reactors

The results of a multigroup, diffusion theory study of spherical gaseous-core cavity reactors are presented in this report. The reactor cavity of gaseous U235 is enclosed by a region of hydrogen gas and is separated from an external D2O moderator-reflector by a zirconium structural shell. Some cylindrical reactors are also investigated. A parametric study of spherical reactors indicates that, for the range of variables studied, critical mass increases as: (1) Fuel region is compressed within the reactor cavity, (2) moderator thickness is decreased, (3) structural shell thickness is increased, and (4) moderator temperature is increased. A buckling analogy is used to estimate the critical mass of fully reflected cylindrical reactors from spherical results without fuel compression. For a reactor cavity of a 120-centimeter radius uniformly filled with fuel, no structural shell, a moderator temperature of 70 F, and a moderator thickness of 100 centimeters, the critical mass of a spherical reactor is 3.1 kilograms while that of a cylinder with a length-to-diameter ratio of 1.0 (L/D = 1) is approximately 3.8 kilograms and, with L/D = 2, 5.9 kilograms. For the range of variables considered for U235-D2O gaseous-core cavity reactors, the systems are characterized by 95 to 99 percent thermal absorptions, with the flux reaching a maximum in the moderator about 10 to 15 centimeters from the reactor cavity.

Ragsdale, Robert G.↗

On the Degradation of the Effectiveness of Nonlinear Diffusion Acceleration with Parallel Block Jacobi Splitting

MOOSE's radiation transport module Rattlesnake comprises a first order S N solver that can be accelerated with a flexible Nonlinear Diffusion Acceleration. At each NDA iteration, the streaming and collision operator of the S{sub N} equations are (approximately) inverted using a transport sweep. When executed on multiple processors parallel block Jacobi (PBJ) splitting is utilized lagging the processor sub-domain's incoming angular fluxes making the implemented method asynchronous, i.e. the convergence properties of NDA become dependent on the number of concurrent tasks and details of the partitioning. Within this work, we study the NDA convergence properties for the two-dimensional C5G7 benchmark problem PBJ with p = 1, 2, 4, 8, 12, 16, 24, 32, 48, 60, 72, 96 and 144 concurrent tasks. Rosa studied the convergence properties of PBJ splitting methods with and without transport synthetic acceleration (TSA) in slab geometry and two-dimensional Cartesian geometry, respectively. Rosa's iteration scheme lags both the incoming angular fluxes and the scattering source making it very similar to the method described here. Rosa found by means of Fourier analysis that convergence of unaccelerated PBJ can degrade for optically thin subdomains, i.e. for a large number of processors given a fixed domain size. Depending on the choice of parameters application of TSA can lead to an effective algorithm. In contrast to Rosa's work, this work focuses on PBJ splitting for NDA accelerated solution of the multigroup eigenvalue problem. Later, Zerr and Anistratov used their integral transport matrix method in conjunction with PBJ. This iteration scheme is different as it does not lag the scattering source. Nevertheless, Fourier analysis with Diamond Difference spatial discretization showed that the method degrades with increasing the overall size of the spatial domain while keeping the sub-domain size constant. In the case of an infinite medium, the observed spectral radius becomes unity. These references establish the iterative performance of PBJ for one-group fixed source problems discretized on rectangular cells, but for the Rattlesnake first order NDA method, an emphasis lies on multigroup eigenvalue problems. In this setting, the additional complication arises that the low order equations are not exactly inverted, but only to some iterative criterion. Further, as the low order problem is solved using Jacobian-Free Newton Krylov methods, a suitable preconditioner for the GMRES iterations is required. As the effectiveness of the preconditioners may decrease when more concurrent processes are used, we expect the low order solve to impact the overall effectiveness of the NDA method in parallel execution as well. Therefore, this work focuses on the question of how detrimental the asynchronicity of the high and low order iterative solutions is for the effectiveness of NDA solutions of realistic, unstructured grid, multigroup eigenvalue problems. The iterative convergence properties of Rattlesnake's NDA method for multigroup eigenvalue problems are studied for varying number of concurrent processes. Rattlesnake's NDA method is asynchronous because the high order transport sweep uses PBJ splitting and because the low order solve's preconditioners, algebraic multigrid and additive Schwarz, are asynchronous. We found that up to 144 processes the number of Picard iterations increases by a factor of 2-3 affecting but not destroying NDA's parallel performance for the C5G7 benchmark problem, a representative LWR (light water reactor) configuration. The solution of the NDA low order eigenvalue problem posed greater problems than expected for the solvers currently available in Rattlesnake mainly because of problems to effectively precondition the modified low-order problem. As a matter of fact, the low order problem becomes an advection-diffusion problem. Non-robustness was observed for the AMG preconditioned coarse mesh acceleration for more than 60 concurrent processes, which was fixed by increasing the number of permissible V-cycles per AMG call. For fine mesh acceleration AMG proved to be ineffective and we resorted to ASM. For both AMG and ASM, increasing number of linear iterations per nonlinear are observed when increasing the number of processes, but for ASM this problem appears to be worse. The results from this work also indicate that initial development efforts should be diverted from implementation of a high-order parallel sweeping algorithm to the effective and robust iterative solution of the low order NDA multigroup eigenvalue problem. (authors)

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗