Energy deposition validation results for the evaluated electron data library in FRENSIE - 25357
The Framework for Research in Nuclear Science and Engineering (FRENSIE) is a collection of packages written in C++ that are designed primarily to aid in methods development. A recent development in FRENSIE is the modeling of single scattering electron interactions using the data in the Evaluated Electron Data Library (EEDL) from Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL). Preliminary verification and validation (V and V) results using the well-known Lockwood energy deposition experiment and a comparison with MCNP6.2 were performed using several bivariate grid policies (Unit-base, Correlated, Unit-base Correlated), interpolation schemes (lin-lin, log-log, lin-log), and physics options (Coupled and Decoupled Elastic Scattering). The results show an agreement to within 0.5% between MCNP6.2 and FRENSIE when using the same bivariate grid policy (Correlated) and interpolation scheme (log-log). When compared to the experimental results of the Lockwood experiment, it was found that a Unit-base bivariate grid policy, lin-lin interpolation scheme, and lin-log interpolation scheme did not produce accurate results for the energy deposition in test problems. The log-log Correlated and Unit-base Correlated results showed the greatest agreement with the Lockwood experiment. The total energy deposition matched the experimental data to within 3%. Both the Correlated and Unit-base Correlated results had a tendency to estimate a higher energy deposition near the peaks and a lower energy deposition near the tails. The differences between coupled elastic scattering and decoupled scattering models were shown to be more prominent at higher energies with the results of the coupled elastic scattering being more accurate for the peak and less accurate for the tail of the energy deposition profiles. (authors)