DOE OSTI2008
Evaluations are under way to support U.S. Department of Energy decisions on how to manage cesium and strontium capsules currently in storage at the Hanford site. Health-based exposure limits for drinking water, oral toxicity data, and environmental fate information were combined in an initial evaluation to frame performance targets for managing chemicals and radionuclides that could leach from the capsules and migrate to groundwater over time. More than 50 relevant benchmarks were identified for 15 of the 17 contaminants in the study set. Of those multiple benchmarks, EPA limits for drinking water served as the main basis for the leachate performance targets. For the remaining two contaminants, stable cesium and zirconium, preliminary indicators were derived from a limited review of toxicity data. Thus, preliminary candidate concentrations were identified for the full study set to support the ongoing evaluation of capsule management options. In summary: In an earlier scoping study, three radionuclides and eight chemicals were identified as contaminants of interest for leachate from cesium and strontium capsules stored at the Hanford site. To frame management options for these capsules, it is assumed that contaminants will leach to groundwater and serve as a drinking water source in the long-term future. Before developing performance targets for the initial set of contaminants, a combined fate and toxicity evaluation was conducted to determine if any others should be added to account for decay or fate products and chemical toxicity. From this review, the list was expanded to produce a final study set of 17 contaminants. Established exposure limits and toxicity data were then reviewed and integrated to develop candidate health-based concentrations to frame performance targets for assessing options for long-term capsule management. This review of more than a dozen different benchmarks and toxicity sources translated to hundreds of individual data checks to support the identification of these target concentrations. In most cases, an EPA drinking water standard served as the key basis for the suggested target. Exceptions were warranted when the drinking water standard reflects dated information and more recent studies suggest a different concentration. Thus, for contaminants with older limits (such as Sr-90), the drinking water standard is identified and an alternate value is also provided that reflects more recent scientific knowledge. Although multiple limits or guidelines exist for most study chemicals, no benchmarks were found for stable cesium or zirconium. Thus, the preliminary target concentrations for these two metals were based on an initial limited review of toxicity data from the scientific literature. In conclusion, fate and toxicity information can be effectively integrated to develop target concentrations for managing contaminated materials at cleanup sites. These targets are simply intended to serve as guides, not as part of a formal compliance review process. For this reason, to the extent possible, it is useful to incorporate current health-based information relevant to the given application. For the Hanford application, it is expected that the preliminary targets will be refined to reflect evolving knowledge. That knowledge may extend from additional characterization of the capsules and their disposition options, and further context for setting-related conditions, to the refinement of benchmarks and underlying models, and further toxicity assessments. The overall goal is to support technical risk analyses for Hanford with current scientific knowledge and practice, to assure health protection into the long term. (authors)
54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗