Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “stability”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 847 records · Page 47

High-Temperature Stability of Aqueous Foams as Potential Waterless Hydrofracking Fluid for Geothermal Reservoir Stimulation

Hydraulic fracturing is the process of fracturing rock formations with high-pressure water-based fluids. In Enhanced Geothermal Systems (EGS) hydraulic fracturing is carried out by injecting high-pressure fluids into the Hot Dry Rocks (HDR) under carefully controlled conditions. The fluid used for fracturing is an important component for EGS, not only concerning the technical approch but also environmental impact. Recent research has been carried out to develop waterless fracturing technologies for EGS, including foam-based hydrofracking, where foams are mixtures of gas and liquid fluids. Foam fracturing fluids have potential benefits over water-based fluids because of less water consumption, less damage in water sensitive formations, and less liquid to recover and handle after fracturing process. One challenge for implementing foam fracturing in EGS is to achieve stable foams at high temperatures, as the foam stability tends to decay with increase in temperature.This research is focused on investigating the stability of foams at high temperatures. Preliminary results show that 1) N2 foams are more stable compared to CO2 foams, 2) foams containing only surfactants were not stable at high temperatures, and 3) addition of different stabilizing agents increased the thermal stability of all the foams. It was observed that different stabilizing agents interacted differently with anionic, nonionic, and cationic surfactants. It was further shown that the crosslinking agent with a base solution of pH 6 and graphene oxide dispersion was the most effective stabilizing agent for anionic surfactant AOS, while bentonite clay effectively enhanced thermal stability for another anionic surfactant SDS. SiO2 nanoparticles showed limited improvement in thermal stability at high temperatures compared to other stabilizing agents.

Thakore, Virensinh↗

Chemical and Foaming Stability of Foam Decontaminating Agents - 16137

This study conducted experiments to evaluate the stability of nano foaming agents by adding various types of surfactants, silica nanoparticles, and viscosifiers with the aim of enhancing the stability of foaming agents containing nanoparticles. Nonionic surfactants such as EM100 showed higher stability as compared to the Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate (SDS) anionic surfactant, and the foam stability decreased as the surfactant concentration increased. The co-surfactant addition did not significantly affect the foam stability, but the addition of Xantan gum-one of the various viscosifiers tested in this study-resulted in the highest foam stability. When silica nanoparticles were added to the surfactant EM100, the foam stability improved further. In particular, the foam stability of the nano foaming agent was observed to be the maximum when a partially hydrophobic nano-porous silica such as KAERI 1 was added, as compared to the addition of a hydrophilic dry silica such as M5. This is because the partially hydrophobic particles were distributed over the liquid film between the foams, thereby preventing drainage and increasing the stability of the foaming agent fluid. The manufactured nano foaming agent can be used not only for the effective decontamination of large-sized equipment or large facilities but also for overcoming the problem of production of a large amount of radioactive waste during chemical decontamination. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

A multidimensional stability framework enhances interpretation and comparison of carbon cycling response to disturbance

Abstract The concept of stability is central to the study and sustainability of vital ecosystem goods and services as disturbances increase globally. While ecosystem ecologists, including carbon (C) cycling scientists, have long‐considered multiple dimensions of disturbance response, our discipline lacks an agreed‐upon analytical framework for characterizing multidimensional stability. Here, we advocate for the broader adoption of a standardized and normalized multidimensional stability framework for analyzing disturbance response. This framework includes four dimensions of stability: the degree of initial change in C fluxes (i.e., resistance ); rate (i.e., resilience ) and variability (i.e., temporal stability ) of return to pre‐disturbance C fluxes; and the extent of return to pre‐disturbance C fluxes (i.e., recovery ). Using this framework, we highlight findings not readily seen from analysis of absolute fluxes, including trade‐offs between initial and long‐term C flux responses to disturbance; different overall stability profiles among fluxes; and, using a pilot dataset, similar relative stability of net primary production following fire and insect disturbances. We conclude that ecosystem ecologists’ embrace of a unifying multidimensional stability framework as a complement to approaches focused on absolute C fluxes could advance global change research by aiding in the novel interpretation, comprehensive synthesis, and improved forecasting of ecosystems’ response to an increasing array of disturbances.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

A review of high order strong stability preserving two-derivative explicit, implicit, and IMEX methods

High order strong stability preserving time discretizations ensure the nonlinear non-inner-product strong stability properties of spatial discretizations suited for the stable simulation of hyperbolic PDEs in a wide variety of application areas including fluid dynamics, magnetohydrodynamics, semiconductor devices, electromagnetics, and astrophysics. Over the past decade multiderivative time-stepping have been increasingly used for the time-evolution hyperbolic PDEs, so that the strong stability properties of these methods have become important. In this work we review sufficient conditions for a two-derivative multistage method to preserve the strong stability properties of spatial discretizations in a forward Euler and different conditions on the second derivative. In particular we present the strong stability preserving theory for explicit and implicit two-derivative Runge–Kutta schemes, including a special condition on the second derivative under which these implicit methods may be unconditionally strong stability preserving. This special condition is natural for the stiff component of wide range of plasma physics problems, and can be useful in the context of strong stability preserving implicit-explicit multi-derivative Runge–Kutta schemes, where the time-step restriction is then independent of the stiff term. Lastly, we present the strong stability preserving theory for implicit-explicit multi-derivative general linear methods, and some novel second and third order methods where the time-step restriction is independent of the stiff term.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

On the conformational stability of the smallest RNA kissing complexes maintained through two G·C base pairs

Two identical 5′GACG3′ tetra-loop motifs with different stem sequences (called H2 and H3) are found in the 5′ end region of Moloney Murine Leukemia Virus (MMLV) genomic RNA. They play important roles in RNA dimerization and encapsidation through two identical tetra-loops (5′GACG3′) forming a loop-to-loop kissing complex, the smallest RNA kissing complex ever found in nature. We examined the effects of a loop-closing base pair as well as a stem sequence on the conformational stability of the kissing complex. UV melting analysis and gel electrophoresis were performed on eight RNA sequences mimicking the H2 and H3 hairpin tetra-loops with variation in loop-closing base pairs. Our results show that changing the loop-closing base pair from the wildtype (5′A·U3′ for H3, 5′U·A3′ for H2) to 5′G·C3’/5′C·G3′ has significant effect on the stability of the kissing complexes: the substitution to 5′C·G3′ significantly decreases both thermal and mechanical stability, while switching to the 5′G·C3′ significantly increases the mechanical stability only. The kissing complexes with the wildtype loop-closing base pairs (5′A·U3′ for H3 and 5′U·A3′ for H2) show different stability when attached to a different stem sequence (H2 stem vs. H3 stem). This suggests that not only the loop-closing base pair itself, but also the stem sequence, affects the conformational stability of the RNA kissing complex. - Highlights: • Thermodynamic parameters of the smallest RNA kissing interactions were measured. • The effects of loop-closing base pairs on the RNA kissing complex was investigated. • Changing the base pair to 5′CG3′ decreases the stability of the kissing complex. • Changing it to 5′GC3′ increases the mechanical resilience of the kissing complex. • Difference in its stem sequence also affects the stability of the kissing complex.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

On the thermal stability and grain boundary segregation in nanocrystalline PtAu alloys

Grain boundary (GB) solute segregation has been proposed as a new mechanism to stabilize nanocrystalline (NC) metals. In this study, we investigate the thermal stability and GB solute segregation in a noble metal alloy system (Pt–Au). Thermal stability of the Pt .90 Au .10 alloy system was evaluated by annealing a thin film (~20 nm in thickness) at 500°C and 700°C as well as a thick film (~2 µm in thickness) at a temperature range from 200°C to 700°C. The remarkable stability of the Pt .90 Au .10 alloy system was demonstrated by comparing its thermal stability to that of pure Pt films processed under identical conditions. Although presence of voids in the GBs may contribute to thermal stability, the enhanced thermal stability of the Pt .90 Au .10 alloy is mainly attributed to preferential Au segregation to GBs in the alloy film, which is revealed by aberration-corrected scanning transmission electron microscopy. Our results show that Au segregation to GBs is heterogeneous, with variation in solute content between different GBs as well as non-uniformity along individual GBs. The heterogeneity is dependent on the annealing temperature and is less pronounced at a higher processing temperatures (e.g., 700°C). Furthermore, by using the noble Pt–Au system, which avoids oxidation and impurities, this study validates the mechanism of GB solute segregation and provides further understanding of the thermodynamics and kinetics underlying NC stabilization.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

L{sup 2}-stability of the Vlasov-Maxwell-Boltzmann system near global Maxwellians

We present a L{sup 2}-stability theory of the Vlasov-Maxwell-Boltzmann system for the two-species collisional plasma. We show that in a perturbative regime of a global Maxwellian, the L{sup 2}-distance between two strong solutions can be controlled by that between initial data in a Lipschitz manner. Our stability result extends earlier results [Ha, S.-Y. and Xiao, Q.-H., “A revisiting to the L{sup 2}-stability theory of the Boltzmann equation near global Maxwellians,” (submitted) and Ha, S.-Y., Yang, X.-F., and Yun, S.-B., “L{sup 2} stability theory of the Boltzmann equation near a global Maxwellian,” Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 197, 657–688 (2010)] on the L{sup 2}-stability of the Boltzmann equation to the Boltzmann equation coupled with self-consistent external forces. As a direct application of our stability result, we show that classical solutions in Duan et al. [“Optimal large-time behavior of the Vlasov-Maxwell-Boltzmann system in the whole space,” Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 24, 1497–1546 (2011)] and Guo [“The Vlasov-Maxwell-Boltzmann system near Maxwellians,” Invent. Math. 153(3), 593–630 (2003)] satisfy a uniform L{sup 2}-stability estimate. This is the first result on the L{sup 2}-stability of the Boltzmann equation coupled with self-consistent field equations in three dimensions.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

Stability regions for synchronized τ-periodic orbits of coupled maps with coupling delay τ

Motivated by the chaos suppression methods based on stabilizing an unstable periodic orbit, we study the stability of synchronized periodic orbits of coupled map systems when the period of the orbit is the same as the delay in the information transmission between coupled units. We show that the stability region of a synchronized periodic orbit is determined by the Floquet multiplier of the periodic orbit for the uncoupled map, the coupling constant, the smallest and the largest Laplacian eigenvalue of the adjacency matrix. We prove that the stabilization of an unstable τ-periodic orbit via coupling with delay τ is possible only when the Floquet multiplier of the orbit is negative and the connection structure is not bipartite. For a given coupling structure, it is possible to find the values of the coupling strength that stabilizes unstable periodic orbits. The most suitable connection topology for stabilization is found to be the all-to-all coupling. On the other hand, a negative coupling constant may lead to destabilization of τ-periodic orbits that are stable for the uncoupled map. We provide examples of coupled logistic maps demonstrating the stabilization and destabilization of synchronized τ-periodic orbits as well as chaos suppression via stabilization of a synchronized τ-periodic orbit.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

Effect of anisotropic fast ions on internal kink stability in DIII-D negative and positive triangularity plasmas

Recent DIII-D experiments show that sawtooth stability is strongly affected by anisotropic fast ions from neutral beam injection (NBI) in both negative and positive triangularity plasmas. Fast ions from co-current NBI are stabilizing for the sawtooth stability, resulting in longer sawtooth periods. On the other hand, fast ions from counter-current NBI are destabilizing, leading to small and frequent sawteeth. The relative change of sawtooth period and amplitude is more than a factor of two. These observations appear to hold in both plasma shapes. Non-perturbative toroidal modeling, utilizing the magnetohydrodynamic-kinetic hybrid stability code MARS-K (Liu et al 2008 Phys. Plasmas 15 112503), reveals an asymmetric dependence of the stability of the n = 1 (n is the toroidal mode number) internal kink mode on the injection direction of NBI, being qualitatively consistent with the experimentally observed sawtooth behavior. The MARS-K modeling results suggest that anisotropic fast ions affect the mode growth rate and frequency through both adiabatic and non-adiabatic contributions. Here, the asymmetry of the internal kink mode instability relative to the NBI direction is mainly due to the non-adiabatic contribution of passing fast ions, which stabilize (destabilize) the internal kink with the co-(counter-) current NBI as compared to the fluid counterpart. However, finite orbit width (FOW) correction to passing particles partially cancels the asymmetry. Trapped particles are always stabilizing due to precessional drift resonance. Modeling also shows that fast ions affect the internal kink in a similar manner in both negative and positive triangularity plasmas, although being slightly more unstable in the negative triangularity configuration already in the fluid limit. The similarity is mainly attributed to the fact that the mode is localized in the plasma core region, with very similar eigenmode structures in both negative and positive configurations. Furthermore, MARS-K modeling indicates that other factors, such as the plasma rotation and the drift kinetic effects of thermal plasmas, weakly modify the mode stability as compared to the drift kinetic resonance effects and FOW correction of fast ions.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Identification of a window for quiescent H-mode operation in MHD stability diagram of DIII-D plasmas

A window for quiescent H-mode (QH-mode) operation in DIII-D plasmas in the diagram of pedestal magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) stability was identified through linear MHD stability analysis, accounting for the effects of plasma rotation and ion diamagnetic drift. The operation window lies between the stability boundaries of the kink/peeling mode (K/PM) identified with and without the inclusion of plasma rotation effects. In this region, the mode remains unstable unless rotation effects are considered alongside the ion diamagnetic drift, which is consistently included in the analysis. The stabilization of the MHD mode, facilitated by the coupled effects of plasma rotation and ion diamagnetic drift, plays a crucial role in widening the window, enabling the attainment of the QH-mode state. Furthermore, the suppression of edge localized modes (ELM) can be achieved by controlling the pedestal structure to ensure the plasma state remains within the operation window. The location of the operation window in the stability diagram depends on the K/PM stability properties. Therefore, optimizing conditions for QH-mode requires adjustments based on changes in stability characteristics. A pressure pedestal and its associated bootstrap current density near the last closed flux surface are advantageous for situating the plasma state within the window. However, excessive current density can trigger ELMs. This trend was confirmed through comparisons of MHD stability diagrams between QH-mode and ELMy H-mode plasmas.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Distributed Conditions for Small-signal Stability of Power Grids and Local Control Design

Operating modern power grids with stability guarantees is markedly important. Typical methods for analyzing and certifying power grid stability are largely centralized relying on the ability of the system operator to gather network-wide information and accurately compute the system's eigenvalues. These methods are oftentimes not privacy-preserving and computationally burdensome. They are therefore, not well-suited to modern power grids where small-signal stability has to be evaluated timely, efficiently and in a privacy-preserving fashion. Herein, we introduce a distributed methodology for certifying small-signal stability of power grids and designing the local controllers. First, we analytically derive distributed conditions for network-wide stability that bus agents can inspect using local information. By leveraging these conditions, we then introduce a distributed control design algorithm (DCDA) that can guide the local control design so that stability of the interconnected system is guaranteed. The agents that adopt the proposed distributed algorithm are responsible for tuning their local controllers, producing their local control commands and ensuring that their local stability condition is met. The system operator is only responsible for verifying network-wide stability upon receiving affirmative responses from all agents and, announcing, that the overall system is stable. The proposed DCDA algorithm is numerically validated via simulations using the IEEE 39-bus system.

24 POWER TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION↗

Chatter Stability of Machining Operations

Here, this paper reviews the dynamics of machining and chatter stability research since the first stability laws were introduced by Tlusty and Tobias in the 1950s. The paper aims to introduce the fundamentals of dynamic machining and chatter stability, as well as the state of the art and research challenges, to readers who are new to the area. First, the unified dynamic models of mode coupling and regenerative chatter are introduced. The chatter stability laws in both the frequency and time domains are presented. The dynamic models of intermittent cutting, such as milling, are presented and their stability solutions are derived by considering the time-periodic behavior. The complexities contributed by highly intermittent cutting, which leads to additional stability pockets, and the contribution of the tool's flank face to process damping are explained. The stability of parallel machining operations is explained. The design of variable pitch and serrated cutting tools to suppress chatter is presented. The paper concludes with current challenges in chatter stability of machining which remains to be the main obstacle in increasing the productivity and quality of manufactured parts.

42 ENGINEERING↗

A unified framework of stabilized finite element method for solving the Boltzmann transport equation

This paper presents a unified framework of stabilized finite element method for solving the Boltzmann transport equation. Unlike the traditional Petrov-Galerkin finite element method which modifies the test function to construct the stabilization term, we derive the stabilization methods from the standard Galerkin weak form with Sub-grid scale model. The basic idea of this method is to decompose the unknowns into its numerical solution and residual, with an approximation for the residual and embeds it in the Galerkin weak form to yield a stabilized variational formula. Different approximations of the residual lead to different stabilization methods, all the frequently used stabilized methods, including the Streamline Upwinding Petrov-Galerkin (SUPG) method, Galerkin/Least-Square (GLS) method, and Algebraic Sub-Grid Scale (ASGS) method can be obtained from this framework. The similarities and differences of the different approximations are compared in this paper. The numerical results show that the behaviors of the different methods area similar with the same stabilization parameter, and all these stabilized techniques can obtain a correct and stable solution. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Control Parameter Sensitivity Study for Inverter-Based-Resource Dominated Grids: A Small Signal Stability Approach and Framework

The growing adoption of renewable energy is driving the prevalence of inverter-based resources (IBRs) within power grids. Future power grids will integrate both grid-following IBRs (GFM-IBRs) and grid-forming IBRs (GFL-IBRs) alongside synchronous generators. Therefore, it is crucial to perform stability studies that account for all components and especially control interactions related to IBRs. Extensive research has performed to study the IBR-related stability, however, the sensitivity study of IBRs' control parameters on system stability has not been adequately studied yet, especially from a systematic way. Therefore, this paper conducts a small signal stability analysis for a generic grid with multiple types of resources and develops an analytical framework for assessing the sensitivity of control parameters affecting stability margins. To achieve that, the non-autonomous reduced-order non-linear dynamic model is developed for a generic power system with multiple synchronous generator-based resources (SGBRs), GFM-IBRs, and GFL-IBRs. Based on the analytic model, a systematic framework for parametric sensitivity on systems' asymptotic stability is developed. A parameter sensitivity analysis based on eigenvalue methods is proposed. The impact of the droop controllers of GFM-IBRs, PQ-dispatch and the PLL controller of GFL-IBR on the system asymptotic stability is discussed. This sensitivity study is aiming to provide deep insights on control parameters' impact on system stability, and gives direction for parameter tuning in case of instability.

24 POWER TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION↗

ESBWR - Robust design for natural circulation and stability performance effectiveness

ESBWR is a 4500 MWt Generation III+ natural circulation reactor with an array of robust design features and passive safety systems to deliver highly effective plant performance during normal operation and to keep the reactor safe during postulated transients and accidents. With the submittal of the latest revision of the Design Control Document (DCD) to US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, ESBWR is nearing the completion of the US design certification process. This paper focuses on the natural circulation-driven plant performance aspects during normal operation, and stability evaluation of the robust ESBWR design. The TRACG computer code is used for the analysis of ESBWR plant performance, safety analysis, and stability margins. The paper describes the evaluation of ESBWR stability performance during normal power operation including operation in the Core Power-Feed Water Temperature Operating Domain. For ESBWR the normal power operation condition has the highest power/flow ratio and is limiting from the perspective of stability. The paper includes results from detailed evaluation of the most limiting decay ratio for out-of-phase regional oscillations calculated by perturbing the core inlet flow rate in this out-of-phase mode about the line of symmetry for the azimuthal harmonic mode. The paper also summarizes the ESBWR regional mode stability evaluations during a limiting transient (Loss of Feedwater Heating), and during ATWS (Anticipated Transient without Scram). Nominal decay ratios of limiting Channel oscillation, Core wide oscillation and Regional oscillation are within the maximum acceptance criterion of 0.8, at 95% content and 95% confidence. These stability evaluation results indicate decay ratio is within design limits. The paper also describes the evaluation of ESBWR stability performance during plant startup, and summarizes the defense-in-depth stability solution for ESBWR. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Study on the well-posedness, convergence and the stability of the semi-implicit upwind numerical solver for the multi-fluid model

The well-posedness, convergence and the stability of the two-fluid code has been studied for a long time. Most of the investigations concern the semi-implicit upwind solution scheme for the six equation two-fluid model such as used in RELAP5 3 or TRACE 21. Since the system code, SPACE 2, adopts one more field, a droplet field, it consists of nine equations (3 mass, 3 momentum and 3 energy balance equations) and thus more involved investigations are necessary to confirm the stability and convergence. For this objective, the old issue of the well-posedness, convergence and the stability is revisited and some general guidelines to develop a well-posed numerical multi-fluid model are derived as follows; (1) Hyperbolicity of the corresponding system of partial differential equations is not a necessary condition for the development of a numerical model for multi-phase flow, but whether or not it is hyperbolic can provide guidance relative to initial conditions, boundary conditions, and expected high frequency behavior of the model. (2) A necessary condition for a well-posed numerical model is stability in the von Neumann sense, i.e. growth factor less than 1.0 for the shortest wave-length, 2{Delta}x. (3) The smallest node size used for convergence studies should be of the order of the characteristic dimension of the average description, i.e. smaller nodes can be used so long as they do not result in unphysical growth of wave-lengths less than the characteristic dimension. The usual mathematical definition of convergence i.e. the behavior of the solution as the node size approaches zero, is not appropriate for the discrete averaged numerical model, since there is diminished physical meaning to behavior at wavelengths less than the characteristic dimension of the average description. Under these guidelines, dispersion analysis and von Neumann stability analysis are performed for the three field multi-fluid, semi-implicit, upwind numerical model to show that the necessary conditions for well-posedness are met. To study the non-linear stability and the convergence, various runs with the torus problem using the SPACE code are utilized to confirm the frequency cascading effects that augment non-linear stability. A robust mechanism for the flow regime change is also a very important factor for developing non-linearly stable and convergent code. A open pipe flow problem is also simulated to investigate the non-linear stability effects in a flow geometry more typical of real safety code applications. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

AI-Based Faster-Than-Real-Time Stability Assessment of Large Power Systems with Applications on WECC System

Achieving clean energy goals will require significant advances in regard to addressing the computational needs for next-generation renewable-dominated power grids. One critical obstacle that lies in the way of transitioning today’s power grid to a renewable-dominated power grid is the lack of a faster-than-real-time stability assessment technology for operating a fast-changing power grid. This paper proposes an artificial intelligence (AI) -based method that predicts the system’s stability margin information (e.g., the frequency nadir in the frequency stability assessment and the critical clearing time (CCT) value in the transient stability assessment) directly from the system operating conditions without performing the conventional time-consuming time-domain simulations over detailed dynamic models. Since the AI method shifts the majority of the computational burden to offline training, the online evaluation is extremely fast. This paper has tested the AI-based stability assessment method using multiple dispatch cases that are converted and tuned from actual dispatch cases of the Western Electricity Coordinating Council (WECC) system model with more than 20,000 buses. The results show that the AI-based method could accurately predict the stability margin of such a large power system in less than 0.2 milliseconds using the offline-trained AI agent. Therefore, the proposed method has great potential to achieve faster-than-real-time stability assessment for practical large power systems while preserving sufficient accuracy.

24 POWER TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION↗

Homological stabilizer codes

In this paper we define homological stabilizer codes on qubits which encompass codes such as Kitaev's toric code and the topological color codes. These codes are defined solely by the graphs they reside on. This feature allows us to use properties of topological graph theory to determine the graphs which are suitable as homological stabilizer codes. We then show that all toric codes are equivalent to homological stabilizer codes on 4-valent graphs. We show that the topological color codes and toric codes correspond to two distinct classes of graphs. We define the notion of label set equivalencies and show that under a small set of constraints the only homological stabilizer codes without local logical operators are equivalent to Kitaev's toric code or to the topological color codes. - Highlights: Black-Right-Pointing-Pointer We show that Kitaev's toric codes are equivalent to homological stabilizer codes on 4-valent graphs. Black-Right-Pointing-Pointer We show that toric codes and color codes correspond to homological stabilizer codes on distinct graphs. Black-Right-Pointing-Pointer We find and classify all 2D homological stabilizer codes. Black-Right-Pointing-Pointer We find optimal codes among the homological stabilizer codes.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗