Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Breakthrough Curves”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 91 records · Page 5

Dimensionality effects on multicomponent ionic transport and surface complexation in porous media

Coulombic interactions between charged species in pore water and at surface/solution interfaces are of pivotal importance for multicomponent reactive transport in porous media. In this study, we investigate the impact of domain dimensionality on electrostatically coupled dispersion and surface-solution reactions during transport of acidic plumes and major ions in porous media. Column and quasi two-dimensional flow-through experiments were performed, with identical silica porous media and under the same advection-dominated conditions. Equal mass fluxes of different electrolyte solutions (i.e., HCl - pH ~ 2.8, NaBr - 100 mM, HCl - pH ~ 2.8 plus NaBr - 100 mM) were continuously injected in the 1-D and 2-D experiments and breakthrough curves of pH and major ions were measured at the outlet of the domains. The presence of pronounced ionic strength gradients in the transverse direction in the 2-D setup caused distinct retardation and transport behaviors of protons and major ions which were not observed in the one-dimensional column experiments. Furthermore, in the cases of salt electrolytes injection, considerably enhanced release of H + (>61%) from the quartz surface was observed in the multidimensional system compared to the one-dimensional setup. Reactive transport modeling was performed to reproduce the experimental outcomes and to analyse the coupling between transport processes, based on the Nernst-Planck formulation of diffusive/dispersive fluxes and on surface complexation reactions at the solid-solution interface. Electrostatic interactions between Na + , B – , and H + , and deprotonation of the quartz surface upon the formation of sodium outer-sphere complexes, are the primary controllers of the spatial and temporal features displayed by the pH and major ions measurements. The reactive transport simulations allowed us to interpret the experimental observations, to visualize the distribution and spatio-temporal evolution of dissolved and solid species, to identify a spatially heterogeneous zonation of Coulombic interactions with distinct behavior at the fringe and core of the injected plumes in the multidimensional setup, and to quantify the different components of the Nerst-Planck fluxes of the charged solutes. This study demonstrates that the domain dimensionality directly affects electrostatic interactions between charged aqueous species in the pore water and surface complexation reactions at the solid-solution interface. The non-trivial effects of dimensionality on multicomponent ionic transport result in a significantly different behavior in 1-D and 2-D systems.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

Climate change impact on residual contaminants under sustainable remediation

This study investigates the potential impact of climate change on residual contaminants in vadose zones and groundwater. We assume that the effect of climate changes can be represented by perturbations in the natural recharge through the aquifer system. We perform numerical modeling of unsaturated/saturated flow and transport and consider different performance metrics: contaminant concentrations at observation wells and contaminant export at the site's boundary. We evaluate the effect of increasing and decreasing recharge as well as the impact of potential failure of surface capping structures employed to immobilize vadose zone contaminants. Our approach is demonstrated in a real case study by simulating transport of non-reactive radioactive tritium at the U.S. Department of Energy's Savannah River Site. Results show that recharge changes significantly affect well concentrations: after an initial slight dilution we identify a significant concentration increase at different observation wells some years after the recharge increase and/or the cap failure, as a consequence of contaminants' mobilization. This effect is generally emphasized and occurs earlier as the recharge increases. Under decreased aquifers' recharge the concentration could slightly increase for some years, due to a decrease of dilution, depending on the magnitude of the negative recharge shift. We identify trigger levels of recharge above which the concentration/export breakthrough curves and the time of exceedance of the Maximum Contaminant Level for tritium are remarkably affected. Moreover, we observe that the contaminant export at the control plane, identified as the risk pathway to the downgradient population, may only be minimally affected by shifts in the natural recharge regime, except for some extreme cases. We conclude that more frequent sampling and in-situ monitoring near the source zone should be adopted to better explain concentrations' anomalies under changing climatic conditions. Moreover, the maintenance of the cap is critical not only to sequester residual contaminants in the vadose zone, but also to reduce the uncertainty associated with future precipitation changes. Finally, realistic flow and transport simulations achieved through proper calibration processes, rather than conservative modeling, should be adopted to identify non-trivial trade-offs which enable better allocation of resources towards reducing uncertainty in decision making.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Improving parameter estimation for column experiments by multi-model evaluation and comparison

Reliability of column experiment data interpretation by fitting the data to a transport model using the nonlinear least squares method is of concern when the complexity of the experiment increases. Misfits often occur and are accepted with the excuse of system complexity. More often, overfits are published and accepted uncritically. The objective of this work was to improve the reliability of column experiment data interpretation to provide insights for future investigation and select estimates for application prediction. We proposed to achieve this goal by evaluating and comparing various estimates that consider the uncertainties in experimental conditions, sensitivities of model parameters, alternative parameterizations and models. Two examples from the literature were selected for the illustration. Sensitivity analysis showed that the experimentally-controlled parameters (water content, flow rate and pulse volume) are much more sensitive than the transport parameters (dispersivity and mass transfer coefficient) in breakthrough curve fitting. Fixing these sensitive parameters may lead to misfit or biased estimate. Estimating sensitive parameters helps diagnose and remediate the misfit. The dispersion coefficient was parameterized as a function of solute molecular diffusion coefficient, medium dispersivity and average pore water velocity to reduce the number of estimated parameters for multiple tracers. Nonlinear least squares statistics were used to evaluate the goodness-of-fit for the multiple estimates obtained using different fitting schemes (e.g., fixing or estimating parameters), parameterizations and models (e.g., equilibrium or nonequilibrium). The F-test and Akaike s Information Criteria were used for the discrimination of statistically reasonable estimates. Our results suggest that sensitivity/uncertainty analysis and model evaluation /discrimination are useful to improve the reliability of column experiment data interpretation.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

A comparative study of discrete fracture network and equivalent continuum models for simulating flow and transport in the far field of a hypothetical nuclear waste repository in crystalline host rock

One of the major challenges of simulating flow and transport in the far field of a geologic repository in crystalline host rock is related to reproducing the properties of the fracture network over the large volume of rock with sparse fracture characterization data. Various approaches have been developed to simulate flow and transport through the fractured rock. The approaches can be broadly divided into Discrete Fracture Network (DFN) and Equivalent Continuum Model (ECM). The DFN explicitly represents individual fractures, while the ECM uses fracture properties to determine equivalent continuum parameters. In this paper, we compare DFN and ECM in terms of upscaled observed transport properties through generic fracture networks. The major effort was directed on making the DFN and ECM approaches similar in their conceptual representations. This allows for separating differences related to the interpretation of the test conditions and parameters from the differences between the DFN and ECM approaches. The two models are compared using a benchmark test problem that is constructed to represent the far field (1 × 1 × 1 km 3 ) of a hypothetical repository in fractured crystalline rock. The test problem setting uses generic fracture properties that can be expected in crystalline rocks. The models are compared in terms of the: 1) effective permeability of the domain, and 2) nonreactive solute breakthrough curves through the domain. The principal differences between the models are mesh size, network connectivity, matrix diffusion and anisotropy. We demonstrate how these differences affect the flow and transport. Finally, we identify the factors that should be taken in consideration when selecting an approach most suitable for the site-specific conditions.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Mechanistic definition and prediction of the mass exchange coefficient between rivers and hyporheic zones: The $α$ of two $Ω$s

Solute transport in interconnected rivers and hyporheic zones is typically modeled through dual-domain models where first-order solute mass transfer between the two domains, Ω R and Ω HZ , is represented by a coefficient α. The transient storage model (TSM) is an example of such an approach. In practice, α is determined by fitting the tails of solute tracer breakthrough curves using a TSM. This approach has led to ambiguity regarding α’s physical meaning and transferability. Here, in this work, we investigated the physical basis for α and tested it with virtual experiments through the fully coupled multiphysics model hyporheicFoam for the Ω R – Ω HZ system. hyporheicFoam explicitly simulated coupled flow and solute transport over a kilometer with centimeter-scale resolution. Model results were analyzed to calculate α following its theoretical definition directly. Using the determined α within a TSM enables accurate reproduction of solute transport, underscoring α’s physical relevance and precision.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Characterizing the impact of finite matrix block size on conservative particle transport through three-dimensional fracture networks

Mass transfer of solutes between fractures and the surrounding rock matrix exerts a noticeable signature on the tail of travel time distributions. When the width of the matrix is assumed to be infinite and advective transport through the fracture is sufficiently fast, the tails of the travel time distributions exhibit a classically expected slope of ψ(t) ∝ t -3/2 . However, studies have yet to characterize how solute transfer between fractures via diffusion through finite matrix blocks influences the tail’s slope in three-dimensional fractured media. Here, in this study, we assess the impact of finite matrix block size on breakthrough curve shape at different spatio-temporal scales by con ducting particle tracking simulations in three-dimensional discrete fracture networks. We consider a variety of hydrodynamic and geostructural proper ties to determine their relative impact on the resulting travel time distributions. We observe that the impact of matrix diffusion through a finite block on travel time distributions is similar to that of an infinite matrix block when the fracture spacing is sufficiently large, matrix diffusion is relatively weak, or transport is considered at an early control plane distance. We observe that the converse of these conditions, results in deviations from the classical ψ(t) ∝ t -3/2 scaling. These results provide a first step toward developing a metric to assess when finite block size effects are expected to significantly influence transport.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

Rate analysis of sorption of Ce 3+ , Sm 3+ , and Yb 3+ ions from aqueous solution using Dowex 50W-X8 as a sorbent in a continuous flow reactor

Kinetic analysis of removal of three rare earth elements metals, Ce 3+ , Sm 3+ , and Yb 3+ ions from aqueous solutions in a continuous flow fixed bed reactor using Dowex 50W-X8 ion-exchange resin was conducted here. The performance of the fixed bed sorption was evaluated using the concept of the sorption breakthrough process. Parameters characteristic of a fixed bed sorption such as breakthrough times, saturation times, critical reactor lengths, and lengths of mass transfer zone were inferred from the metal ion concentration breakthrough curves. The sorption capacity of Dowex 50W-X8 ion-exchange resin for Ce 3+ , Sm 3+ , and Yb 3+ are 191, 252, and 294 mg/g, respectively. The sorption kinetics were evaluated using a zero-order, first-order and second-order reaction models. The kinetics of the sorption process follows a zero-order model which has not been reported before. The rate constants of sorption using the zero-order kinetic model are obtained. Two different analysis were conducted to identify whether the diffusion is intraparticle or film diffusion. Finally, both analysis confirms that the film diffusion is the controlling mechanism in reactor bed.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Mussel-inspired surface modification of untreated wasted husks with stable polydopamine/polyethylenimine for efficient continuous Cr(VI) removal

Highlights: • Functional rice husks with abundant amino groups was firstly modified with PDA/PEI for Cr(VI) removal. • Potentiality of monolithic samples for dynamic continuous adsorption. • Expectable higher adsorption capacity than most of reported similar bio-sorbents. • Excellent mechanical stability, reusability and convenient separation. - Abstract: A cost-effective and chemically modified biological adsorbent based on agricultural wasted husks for heavy metal removal was fabricated by coating with Polydopamine–Polyethylenimine via the mussel inspired chemistry. Batch and fixed bed column adsorption experiments were carried out to explore the sorption capacity and potency of industrial application. The batch results indicated that the maximum adsorption capacity reached 42.8 mg/g which is much larger than most adsorbents based on bioresource and agricultural wastes for Cr(VI) removal in aqueous solution simultaneously with excellent recycling performance. In column adsorption experiments, it exhibited high mechanical stability and applied potential. The equilibrium time was 9130 min under the flow rate of 1 ml/min, and reached the equilibrium adsorption capacity of 47.14 mg/g. The breakthrough curves ploted by the data of fixed bed experiments under different flow rates (1 ml/min & 2 ml/min) fitted the Thomas model with R{sup 2} of 0.9510 and 0.9437 respectively.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Multiple-tracer tests for contaminant transport process identification in saturated municipal solid waste

Highlights: • Multiple tracers were applied to saturated MSW to test dual-porosity properties. • Lithium demonstrated to be non-conservative as a tracer. • 260 mm diameter column too small to test transport properties of MSW. • The classical advection-dispersion mode was rejected due to high dispersivity. • Characteristic diffusion times did not vary with the tracer. - Abstract: Two column tests were performed in conditions emulating vertical flow beneath the leachate table in a biologically active landfill to determine dominant transport mechanisms occurring in landfills. An improved understanding of contaminant transport process in wastes is required for developing better predictions about potential length of the long term aftercare of landfills, currently measured in timescales of centuries. Three tracers (lithium, bromide and deuterium) were used. Lithium did not behave conservatively. Given that lithium has been used extensively for tracing in landfill wastes, the tracer itself and the findings of previous tests which assume that it has behaved conservatively may need revisiting. The smaller column test could not be fitted with continuum models, probably because the volume of waste was below a representative elemental volume. Modelling compared advection-dispersion (AD), dual porosity (DP) and hybrid AD–DP models. Of these models, the DP model was found to be the most suitable. Although there is good evidence to suggest that diffusion is an important transport mechanism, the breakthrough curves of the different tracers did not differ from each other as would be predicted based on the free-water diffusion coefficients. This suggested that solute diffusion in wastes requires further study.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Understanding How Ligand Functionalization Influences CO2 and N2 Adsorption in a Sodalite Metal–Organic Framework

In this work, a detailed study is conducted to understand how ligand substitution influences the CO2 and N2 adsorption properties of two highly crystalline sodalite metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) known as Cu–BTT (BTT–3 = 1,3,5-benzenetristetrazolate) and Cu–BTTri (BTTri–3 = 1,3,5-benzenetristriazolate). The enthalpy of adsorption and observed adsorption capacities at a given pressure are significantly lower for Cu–BTTri compared to its tetrazole counterpart, Cu–BTT. In situ X-ray and neutron diffraction, which allow visualization of the CO2 and N2 binding sites on the internal surface of Cu–BTTri, provide insights into understanding the subtle differences. As expected, slightly elongated distances between the open Cu2+ sites and surface-bound CO2 in Cu–BTTri can be explained by the fact that the triazolate ligand is a better electron donor than the tetrazolate. The more pronounced Jahn–Teller effect in Cu–BTTri leads to weaker guest binding. The results of the aforementioned structural analysis were complemented by the prediction of the binding energies at each CO2 and N2 adsorption site by density functional theory calculations. In addition, variable temperature in situ diffraction measurements shed light on the fine structural changes of the framework and CO2 occupancies at different adsorption sites as a function of temperature. Finally, simulated breakthrough curves obtained for both sodalite MOFs demonstrate the materials’ potential performance in dry postcombustion CO2 capture. The simulation, which considers both framework uptake capacity and selectivity, predicts better separation performance for Cu–BTT. The information obtained in this work highlights how ligand substitution can influence adsorption properties and hence provides further insights into the material optimization for important separations.

adsorption capacities↗

Transport and Retention of Concentrated Oil-in-Water Emulsions in Porous Media

Oil-in-water emulsions are routinely used in subsurface remediation. In these applications, high oil loadings present a challenge to remedial design as mechanistic insights into transport and retention of concentrated emulsions is limited. In this paper, column experiments were designed to examine emulsion transport and retention over a range of input concentrations (1.3–23% wt). Droplet breakthrough and retention data from low concentration experiments were successfully described by existing particle transport models. These models, however, failed to capture droplet transport in more concentrated systems. At high oil fraction, breakthrough curves exhibited an early fall at the end of the emulsion pulse and extending tailing. Irrespective of input concentration, all retention profiles displayed hyper-exponential behavior. Here, we extended existing model formulations to include the additional mixing processes occurring when at high oil concentrations—with focus on the influence of deposited mass and viscous instabilities. The resulting model was parametrized with low concentration data and can successfully predict concentrated emulsion transport and retention. Finally, the role of retained mass and viscous instabilities on mixing conditions can also be applied more broadly to systems with temporal or spatially variant water saturation or when viscosity contrasts exist between fluids.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

A Microporous Amic Acid Polymer for Enhanced Ammonia Capture

Amic acids, consisting of carboxylic acids and amides, are often utilized as intermediates that can further undergo a dehydration–cyclization step to yield polymeric cyclic imides. Compared with imide-based materials, the presence of Brønsted acidic groups and multiple hydrogen-bond donors and acceptors in materials incorporating amic acids opens up the possibility for a variety of host–guest interactions. Here in this paper we report a facile and catalyst-free synthesis of a Brønsted acidic porous poly(amic acid) (PAA) and present its NH 3 uptake properties using gas adsorption and breakthrough measurements. Simple addition of water as a cosolvent to a mixture of tetrakis(4-aminophenyl)methane and pyromellitic anhydride resulted in the formation of PAA in almost quantitative yield. Further mechanistic studies with model compounds revealed the importance of additive water to generate amic acid species selectively without forming cyclic imides at high temperatures. Gas adsorption isotherms and breakthrough curves obtained under dry and humid conditions demonstrate the enhanced NH 3 uptake in the case of PAA compared with the related polycyclic imide at both low and high pressures. Furthermore, the results of adsorption/desorption cycling experiments provide insights into the strength of the interaction between ammonia and the polymers.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Flagella-Mediated Differences in Deposition Dynamics for Azotobacter vinelandii in Porous Media

A multi-scale approach was designed to investigate deposition of flagellated and non-flagellated strains of Azotobacter vinelandii in porous media. In a radial stagnation point flow cell (RSPF), the deposition rate of the flagellated strain (DJ77) on quartz was higher than that of the non-flagellated (Fla-) strain. In contrast, deposition of the Fla- strain exceeded that of DJ77 in two-dimensional silicon microfluidic models (micromodels) and in columns packed with glass beads. Direct cell counts in micromodel experiments showed decreasing values of clean collector removal efficiencies over time, suggesting that approaching cells were blocked from deposition by cells already attached to the collector surface. Column breakthrough curves for both strains also showed a decrease in deposition rates with time. Modeling results showed that blocking becomes effective for DJ77 strain at lower ionic strengths (1mM and 10mM), while for Fla- strain blocking was similar at all ionic strengths. In later stages of micromodel experiments, a ripening effect was also observed, where cells preferentially attached to already attached cells. Ripening happened earlier with the Fla- strain, which suggested that flagella interfered with ripening. Different mechanisms dominate at different stages of bacteria transport in porous media.

bacteria transport, porous media, flagella, microm↗

Transport of Strontium and Cesium in Simulated Hanford Tank Waste Leachate through Quartz Sand under Saturated and Unsaturated Flow

We investigated the effects of water saturation and formation of secondary precipitates on transport of Sr and Cs through sand columns under unsaturated water flow. A series of column experiments was run at effective water saturations ranging from 0.2 to 1.0 under steady-state flow using columns filled with quartz sand. The solution phase was either 0.1 M NaNO3 or a simulated tank waste leachate (STWL), mimicking the leaks of tank wastes at the Hanford Site, Washington, USA. In STWL, the mobility of Sr was significantly reduced as the water saturation decreased, because Sr was incorporated into or sorbed to neo-formed secondary precipitates. In contrast, the transport of Cs in STWL was similar to that of a nonreactive tracer. In 0.1 M NaNO3, Sr moved like a conservative tracer, showing no retardation, whereas Cs was retarded relative to Sr. The flow regime for the 0.1 M NaNO3 columns under all water saturations could be described with the equilibrium convection-dispersion equation (CDE). However, for STWL, the Sr and Cs breakthrough curves indicated the presence of non-equilibria under unsaturated flow conditions. Such non-equilibrium conditions, caused by physical and chemical processes can reduce the mobility of radionuclides at the Hanford vadose zone.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

A Field-Scale Reactive Transport Model for U(VI) Migration Influenced by Coupled Multirate Mass Transfer and Surface Complexation Reactions

A field-scale reactive transport model was developed that incorporates laboratory-characterized U(VI) surface complexation reactions (SCR) and multi-rate mass transfer processes, and field-measured hydrogeochemical conditions at Department of Energy, Hanford 300A site, Washington, where an Integrated Field Research Challenge project is ongoing. The model was used to assess the importance of multi-rate mass transfer processes on sorption-retarded U(VI) reactive transport at the 300A site and to evaluate the effect of variable geochemical conditions on U(VI) plume migration caused by dynamic river stage fluctuations at the east side of the site. Model simulations revealed a complex spatio-temporal variations of groundwater geochemistry that affects U(VI) speciation, adsorption, and plume migration. In general, the river water intrusion enhances uranium adsorption and lowers groundwater aqueous uranium concentration as a result of river water dilution that decreases aqueous carbonate concentration, which subsequently weakens aqueous U(VI)-carbonate complexation and enhances U(VI)-surface complexation. The simulations also found that SCR-retarded U migration becomes more dynamic and more in sync with the groundwater flow field when multi-rate mass transfer processes are involved. Strong U(VI) adsorption was simulated at the 300A site based on the field-measured hydrogeochemical conditions, suggesting a slow dissipation of U(VI) plume, a phenomenon consistent with the observation at the site. Uranium breakthrough curves at selected observation points and the mass changes over time in the simulation indicate that uranium adsorption/desorption never attains steady state as a result of both the highly dynamic flow field and the chemistry variations caused by river water intrusion. Thus, the multi-rate SCM model appears to be a crucial feature for future reactive transport simulations of uranium at the 300A site.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Field-Scale Model for the Natural Attenuation of Uranium at the Hanford 300 Area using High Performance Computing

Three-dimensional reactive flow and transport simulations are carried out to better understand the persistence of uranium [U(VI)] at the Hanford 300 Area bordering the Columbia River. The massively parallel code PFLOTRAN developed under a DOE SciDAC-2 project is employed in the simulations. A new conceptual model is presented for understanding present-day and future attenuation rates of U(VI) at the 300 Area site. Unique to the conceptual model is the recognition of three distinct phases in the evolution of the site corresponding to: (I) initial emplacement of waste; (II) present-day conditions of slow leaching of U(VI) from the Hanford sediments; and (III) the complete removal of non-labile U(VI) from the source region. This work focuses on Phase II. Both labile and non-labile forms of U(VI) are included in the model as sorbed and mineralized forms of U(VI), respectively. The non-labile form plays an important role in providing a long-term source of U(VI) as it slowly leaches out of the Hanford sediment. Rapid fluctuations in the Columbia River stage on hourly, weekly and seasonal time scales are found to play a major role in determining the migration behavior of U(VI). The calculations demonstrate that U(VI) is released into the Columbia River at a highly fluctuating rate in a ratchet-like behavior with nonzero U(VI) flux occurring only during flow from contaminated sediment into the river. The cumulative flux, however, is found to increase approximately linearly with time. The flow rate and U(VI) flux into the Columbia River predicted by the model is highly sensitive to the value used in the conductance boundary condition at the river-sediment interface. By fitting the conductance to the observed piezometric head at well 399-2-1, good agreement was obtained for both the mean flux of water and U(VI) at the river-aquifer boundary. It was found that a multirate sorption model developed to account for long tails observed in U(VI) breakthrough curves obtained from column experiments with contaminated Hanford sediments, gave similar results for Phase II as an equilibrium surface complexation model for the discharge rate of U(VI) into the Columbia River.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Three-Dimensional Bayesian Geostatistical Aquifer Characterization at the Hanford 300 Area using Tracer Test Data

Tracer testing under natural or forced gradient flow holds the potential to provide useful information for characterizing subsurface properties, through monitoring, modeling and interpretation of the tracer plume migration in an aquifer. Non-reactive tracer experiments were conducted at the Hanford 300 Area, along with constant-rate injection tests and electromagnetic borehole flowmeter (EBF) profiling. A Bayesian data assimilation technique, the method of anchored distributions (MAD) [Rubin et al., 2010], was applied to assimilate the experimental tracer test data with the other types of data and to infer the three-dimensional heterogeneous structure of the hydraulic conductivity in the saturated zone of the Hanford formation. In this study, the Bayesian prior information on the underlying random hydraulic conductivity field was obtained from previous field characterization efforts using the constant-rate injection tests and the EBF data. The posterior distribution of the conductivity field was obtained by further conditioning the field on the temporal moments of tracer breakthrough curves at various observation wells. MAD was implemented with the massively-parallel three-dimensional flow and transport code PFLOTRAN to cope with the highly transient flow boundary conditions at the site and to meet the computational demands of MAD. A synthetic study proved that the proposed method could effectively invert tracer test data to capture the essential spatial heterogeneity of the three-dimensional hydraulic conductivity field. Application of MAD to actual field data shows that the hydrogeological model, when conditioned on the tracer test data, can reproduce the tracer transport behavior better than the field characterized without the tracer test data. This study successfully demonstrates that MAD can sequentially assimilate multi-scale multi-type field data through a consistent Bayesian framework.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Comparison of Fickian and temporally nonlocal transport theories over many scales in an exhaustively sampled sandstone slab

It is not a compelling argument, solely on the basis of a better fit to solute breakthrough curve (BTC) data, that a temporally nonlocal model is necessary to simulate transport in an advection-dominated system. One may counter that the classical advection-dispersion equation (ADE) is a valid model at some small scale and that the detailed hydraulic conductivity (K) data must be well-represented: then the nonlocality is only a result of upscaling and loss of information. But is the nonlocal model demonstrably necessary at all scales? We examine the experiment conducted by Klise et al. (2008) in which a 30.5 by 30.5 cm slab of relatively homogeneous, cross-bedded sandstone was exhaustively sampled for K. The slab was sealed, saturated with potassium iodide, and X-rayed 10 times while being flushed with fresh water. The 8,649 air-permeameter measurements were down- and upscaled to make finer and coarser grids on which the velocity field was solved and the ADE applied. The optimized parameters in the ADE were found to scale predictably, most notably the longitudinal dispersivity (α L ), which grew linearly with upscaling. But at all levels of up- and downscaling, including the original K measurement scale of 0.33 cm, the ADE did not adequately represent the late-time tails. The temporally nonlocal, time- fractional ADE (t-FADE) was applied and the optimized parameters (α L and the immobile capacity beta) did not depend on scale. The better fit provided by the t-FADE in the late BTC tails did not bring about a sacrificed fit elsewhere in the BTC. Furthermore, the optimized ADE and t-FADE solutions do not converge at the smallest scale, directly implying that the temporal nonlocality is a necessary model component. We conclude that the logical inference if the ADE is valid in heterogeneous material, then there is tailing in the BTC'' is not a proof that the reverse is true. We provide a clear counterexample. A corollary is that a mismatch between data and a discretized solution to the ADE does not imply that more data will improve fits or predictive ability.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗