Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Ceramic Matrix Composites (CMCs)”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 91 records · Page 5

Multiscale characterization and representation of variability in ceramic matrix composites

Low density, high strength, and high creep and oxidation resistance properties of ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) make them an ideal choice for use in extreme environments in space and military applications. This paper presents a detailed characterization study of structural and manufacturing flaws in Carbon fiber Silicon-Carbide-Nitride matrix (C/SiNC) CMCs at different length-scales. Energy-dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) is used for the chemical characterization of the material’s elemental constituents. High-resolution multiscale graphs obtained from scanning electron microscope (SEM) and confocal laser scanning microscope (LSM) are used to characterize the distribution and morphology of defects at different length scales. This is followed by the classification and quantification of the common manufacturing defects. An image processing algorithm based on the image segmentation process is developed to quantify the variability of various scale-dependent architectural parameters. Finally, a three-dimensional stochastic representative volume element (SRVE) generation algorithm is developed to provide precise representations of material textures at multiple length scales. The developed algorithm accurately accounts for material features and flaws based on a range of multiscale structural and defects characterization results.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Temperature Dependence of Electrical Resistance of Woven Melt-Infiltrated SiCf/SiC Ceramic Matrix Composites

Recent studies have successfully shown the use of electrical resistance (ER)measurements to monitor room temperature damage accumulation in SiC fiber reinforced SiC matrix composites (SiCf/SiC) Ceramic Matrix Composites (CMCs). In order to determine the feasibility of resistance monitoring at elevated temperatures, the present work investigates the temperature dependent electrical response of various MI (Melt Infiltrated)-CVI (Chemical Vapor Infiltrated) SiC/SiC composites containing Hi-Nicalon Type S, Tyranno ZMI and SA reinforcing fibers. Test were conducted using a commercially available isothermal testing apparatus as well as a novel, laser-based heating approach developed to more accurately simulate thermomechanical testing of CMCs. Secondly, a post-test inspection technique is demonstrated to show the effect of high-temperature exposure on electrical properties. Analysis was performed to determine the respective contribution of the fiber and matrix to the overall composite conductivity at elevated temperatures. It was concluded that because the silicon-rich matrix material dominates the electrical response at high temperature, ER monitoring would continue to be a feasible method for monitoring stress dependent matrix cracking of melt-infiltrated SiC/SiC composites under high temperature mechanical testing conditions. Finally, the effect of thermal gradients generated during localized heating of tensile coupons on overall electrical response of the composite is determined.

Ceramic Matrix Composites↗

Siloxane-modified polycarbosilane flexible Prepregs for fabrication of ceramic matrix composites via compression molding and PIP densification

For this work, the development of ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) using 5 harness satin carbon fiber fabric impregnated with commercial polycarbosilane precursor plasticized by siloxane copolymer was investigated aiming to improve wetting behavior and shape conformability. The polycarbosilane precursor and polysiloxane plasticizer were mixed at varying weight ratios to obtain flexible preceramic resin prepreg cloths. 13 plies of preceramic polymer prepreg cloths were stacked in 0/90° layup and cured by compression molding, followed by densified via PIP process. The CMCs were densified with eight PIP cycles followed by final crystallization at 1600 °C. The CMCs made with 10 wt% polysiloxane loading showed lower viscosity of the prepreg resin as well as higher strength and displacement to failure compared to those fabricated from unplasticized polycarbosilane prepolymer. In contrast, at higher concentration of plasticizer, viscosity of the prepreg resin increased, and the CMC became more brittle; however, it exhibited considerably higher thermal conductivity.

Carbosilane↗

Microstructure Evolution and Durability of Advanced Environmental Barrier Coating Systems for SiC/SiC Ceramic Matrix Composites

Environmental barrier coated SiC-SiC ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) systems will play a crucial role in next generation turbine engines for hot-section component applications because of their ability to significantly increase engine operating temperatures with improved efficiency, reduce engine weight and cooling requirements. Advanced HfO2 and rare earth silicate environmental barrier coatings (EBCs), along with multicomponent hafnium and rare earth silicide EBC bond coats have been developed. The coating degradation mechanisms in the laboratory simulated engine thermal cycling, and fatigue-creep operating environments are also being investigated. This paper will focus on the microstructural and compositional evolutions of an advanced environmental barrier coating system on a SiC-SiC CMC substrate during the high temperature simulated durability tests, by using a Field Emission Gun Scanning Electron Microscopy, Energy Dispersive Spectroscopy (EDS) and Wavelength Dispersive Spectroscopy (WDS). The effects of Calcium-Magnesium-Alumino-Silicate (CMAS) from road sand or volcano-ash deposits on the degradation mechanisms of the environmental barrier coating systems will also be discussed. The detailed analysis results help understand the EBC-CMC system performance, aiming at the durability improvements to achieve more robust, prime-reliant environmental barrier coatings.

ceramic matrix composites↗

Thermal History Mapping Technology for Turbine Engine Diagnostics

The infusion of ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) in next generation gas turbines represents daunting challenges as the failure of protective coating, known as Environmental Barrier Coating (EBC), means little remnant life of CMC components. Consequently reliable lifing is critical to the success of CMC components. Accurate thermal mapping of EBC in rig and engine test is of paramount importance because temperature is the most critical variable for EBC life. Current temperature measurement technologies include thermocouples, pyrometers, IR cameras, and thermal paints. Thermocouples require a passage to access the components and pyrometers and IR cameras require line-of-sight. Thermal paints are based on color-sensitive pigments that visually indicate the temperature that a component experienced. Thermal paints do not require line-of-sight, however, they have a low resolution and a limited temperature capability (~1400°C). Thermal history coating is based on oxide ceramic which luminesces when excited with a light source. The luminescence changes when the material's structure changes triggered by heat impact. The maximum temperature to which the material was exposed can be determined from the luminescence change. This paper describes the principles of this new technique and demonstrates its capabilities for EBCs exposed to excess of 1500°C.

Lee, Kang N.↗

In situ characterization of residual stress evolution during heat treatment of SiC/SiC ceramic matrix composites using high-energy X-ray diffraction

Volumetric strains were measured in silicon carbide/silicon carbide melt-infiltrated ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) at ambient and high temperatures using high-energy synchrotron X-ray diffraction (XRD). Both silicon and silicon carbide constituents were interrogated utilizing a broad spectrum of diffracting planes that would be largely inaccessible to common laboratory XRD equipment. Residual room-temperature principal strains in the melt-infiltrated silicon phase were found to be approximately 1100 mu epsilon in compression, corresponding to stresses of approximately 300 MPa using simplifying constitutive assumptions. Residual room-temperature principal strains in silicon carbide particles found throughout the matrix were approximately 500 mu epsilon in tension, corresponding to approximately 300 MPa. Residual strains were found to decrease considerably as temperatures increased from ambient temperature to 1250 degrees C. Additionally, residual strains returned to approximately preheat treatment values after cool-down to ambient temperature. Strain measurements in the silicon phase were found to be significantly affected by dissolved boron dopant levels causing contraction of the silicon lattice. This contraction must be accounted for in high-temperature experiments for accurate calculation of stresses in the silicon phase.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

SiC Fibers and SiCf/SiC Ceramic Matrix Minicomposites Damage Behavior

Silicon Carbide based Ceramic Matrix Composites (CMCs) are attractive materials for use in high-temperature applications in the aerospace industry. Performance and durability of CMCs depend on the properties of its constituents such as fibers and matrix. Therefore, CMCs constituents limitations and damage mechanisms are discussed and characterized in representative simulated application conditions and dominant damage mechanisms are identified at elevated temperatures. In this work, the initiation and evolution of damage in Hi-Nicalon type S fiber-reinforced minicomposites with different interphases thicknesses from different manufacturers were investigated employing several nondestructive evaluation techniques such as acoustic emission, electrical resistance and microscopy. Moreover, the tensile creep behavior of single Hi-Nicalon Type S SiC fibers were tested and characterized and creep parameters were extracted. Fibers creep tests were performed in air or vacuum at 1200-1482 C under high stresses. Creep parameters was then used in understanding load sharing and lifing of ceramic matrix minicomposites. Future work plans will be reviewed.

SiC fibers↗

Lightweight, Ultra-High-Temperature, CMC-Lined Carbon/Carbon Structures

Carbon/carbon (C/C) is an established engineering material used extensively in aerospace. The beneficial properties of C/C include high strength, low density, and toughness. Its shortcoming is its limited usability at temperatures higher than the oxidation temperature of carbon . approximately 400 C. Ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) are used instead, but carry a weight penalty. Combining a thin laminate of CMC to a bulk structure of C/C retains all of the benefits of C/C with the high temperature oxidizing environment usability of CMCs. Ultramet demonstrated the feasibility of combining the light weight of C/C composites with the oxidation resistance of zirconium carbide (ZrC) and zirconium- silicon carbide (Zr-Si-C) CMCs in a unique system composed of a C/C primary structure with an integral CMC liner with temperature capability up to 4,200 F (.2,315 C). The system effectively bridged the gap in weight and performance between coated C/C and bulk CMCs. Fabrication was demonstrated through an innovative variant of Ultramet fs rapid, pressureless melt infiltration processing technology. The fully developed material system has strength that is comparable with that of C/C, lower density than Cf/SiC, and ultra-high-temperature oxidation stability. Application of the reinforced ceramic casing to a predominantly C/C structure creates a highly innovative material with the potential to achieve the long-sought goal of long-term, cyclic high-temperature use of C/C in an oxidizing environment. The C/C substructure provided most of the mechanical integrity, and the CMC strengths achieved appeared to be sufficient to allow the CMC to perform its primary function of protecting the C/C. Nozzle extension components were fabricated and successfully hot-fire tested. Test results showed good thermochemical and thermomechanical stability of the CMC, as well as excellent interfacial bonding between the CMC liner and the underlying C/C structure. In particular, hafnium-containing CMCs on C/C were shown to perform well at temperatures exceeding 3,500 F (.1,925 C). The melt-infiltrated CMC-lined C/C composites offered a lower density than Cf/SiC. The melt-infiltrated composites offer greater use temperature than Cf/SiC because of the more refractory ceramic matrices and the C/C substructure provides greater high-temperature strength. The progress made in this work will allow multiple high-temperature components used in oxidizing environments to take advantage of the low density and high strength of C/C combined with the high-temperature oxidation resistance of melt-infiltrated CMCs.

Wright, Matthew J.↗

NASA's Advanced Environmental Barrier Coatings Development for SiC/SiC Ceramic Matrix Composites: Understanding Calcium Magnesium Alumino-Silicate (CMAS) Degradations and Resistance

Environmental barrier coatings (EBCs) and SiCSiC ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) systems will play a crucial role in next generation turbine engines for hot-section component applications because of their ability to significantly increase engine operating temperatures with improved efficiency, reduce engine weight and cooling requirements. The development of prime-reliant environmental barrier coatings is essential to the viability and reliability of the envisioned CMC engine component applications, ensuring integrated EBC-CMC system durability and designs are achievable for successful applications of the game-changing component technologies and lifing methodologies.This paper will emphasize recent NASA environmental barrier coating developments for SiCSiC turbine airfoil components, utilizing advanced coating compositions, state-of-the-art processing methods, and combined mechanical and environment testing and durability evaluations. The coating-CMC degradations in the engine fatigue-creep and operating environments are particularly complex; one of the important coating development aspects is to better understand engine environmental interactions and coating life debits, and we have particularly addressed the effect of Calcium-Magnesium-Alumino-Silicate (CMAS) from road sand or volcano-ash deposits on the durability of the environmental barrier coating systems, and how the temperature capability, stability and cyclic life of the candidate rare earth oxide and silicate coating systems will be impacted in the presence of the CMAS at high temperatures and under simulated heat flux conditions. Advanced environmental barrier coating systems, including HfO2-Si with rare earth dopant based bond coat systems, will be discussed for the performance improvements to achieve better temperature capability and CMAS resistance for future engine operating conditions.

Environmental barrier coatings↗

Modeling of Different Fiber Type and Content SiC/SiC Minicomposites Creep Behavior

Silicon Carbide based Ceramic Matrix Composites (CMCs) are attractive materials for use in high-temperature applications in the aerospace and nuclear industries. However, creep damage mechanism in CMCs is the most dominant mechanism at elevated temperatures. Consequently, the tensile creep behavior of Hi-Nicalon, Hi-Nicalon Type S SiC fibers and Chemical vapor infiltrated Silicon Carbide matrix (CVI-SiC) were characterized and creep parameters were extracted from creep experiments. Some fiber creep tests were performed in inert environment at 1200 C on individual fibers. Creep behavior of different fiber content pristine and precracked Hi-Nicalon and Hi-Nicalon Type S reinforced minicomposites with BN interphases and CVI-SiC matrix were then modelled using the creep data found in this study and the literature and compared with creep experiments results for the pristine and precracked Hi-Nicalon and Hi-Nicalon Type S minicomposites. Finally, the effects of load-sharing and matrix cracking on CMC creep behavior will be discussed.

ceramic matrix minicomposites↗

Micromechanics-based Modeling of Laminated SiC/SiC Ceramic Matrix Composites

The behavior and response of ceramic matrix composites (CMCs), in particular silicon carbide fiber reinforced silicon carbide matrix (SiC/SiC), is affected by many factors such as variation of fiber volume fraction, residual stresses resulting from processing of the composites at high temperature, random microstructures, and the presence of matrix flaws (e.g., voids, pores, cracks etc.) as well as general material nonlinearity and heterogeneity that occurs randomly in a composite. Residual stresses arising from the phase change of constituents are evaluated in this paper and it is shown that they do influence composite strength and need to be properly accounted for. Additionally, the microstructures (location of fiber centers, coating thickness etc.) of advanced CMCs are usually disordered (or random) and fiber diameter and strength typically have a distribution. They rarely resemble the ordered fiber packing (square, rectangular, or hexagonal) that is generally assumed in micromechanics-based models with periodic boundary conditions for computational expediency. These issues raise the question of how should one model such systems effectively? Can an ordered hexagonal packed repeating unit cell (RUC) accurately represent the random microstructure behavior? How many fibers need to be included to enable accurate representation? Clearly, the number of fibers within an RUC must be limited to insure a balance between accuracy and efficiency. NASA’s in-house micromechanics-based code MAC/GMC provides a framework to analyze such RUCs for the overall composite behavior and the FEAMAC computer code provides linkage of MAC/GMC to the commercial FEA code, ABAQUS. The appropriate level of discretization of the RUC as well as the analysis method employed, i.e., Generalized Method of Cells (GMC) or High Fidelity Generalized Method of Cells (HFGMC), is investigated in this paper in the context of a unidirectional as well as a cross-ply laminated CMC. Results including effective composite properties, proportional limit stress (an important design parameter) and fatigue are shown utilizing both GMC as well as HFGMC. Finally, a few multiscale analyses are performed on smooth bar test coupons as well as test coupons with features such as open-hole and double notches using FEAMAC. Best practices and guidance are provided to take these phenomena into account and keep a proper balance between fidelity (accuracy) and efficiency. Following these guidelines can account for important physics of the problem and provide significant advantages when performing large multiscale composite structural analyses.

Ceramic Matrix Composites↗

Correlation of Electrical Resistance to CMC Stress-Strain and Fracture Behavior Under High Heat-Flux Thermal and Stress Gradients

Because SiCSiC ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) are under consideration for use as turbine engine hot-section components in extreme environments, it becomes necessary to investigate their performance and damage morphologies under complex loading and environmental conditions. Monitoring of electrical resistance (ER) has been shown as an effective tool for detecting damage accumulation of woven melt-infiltrated SiCSiC CMCs. However, ER change under complicated thermo-mechanical loading is not well understood. In this study a systematic approach is taken to determine the capabilities of ER as a relevant non-destructive evaluation technique for high heat-flux testing, including thermal gradients and localized stress concentrations. Room temperature and high temperature, laser-based tensile tests were conducted in which stress-dependent damage locations were determined using modal acoustic emission (AE) monitoring and compared to full-field strain mapping using digital image correlation (DIC). This information is then compared with the results of in-situ ER monitoring, post-test ER inspection and fractography in order to correlate ER response to convoluted loading conditions and damage evolution.

electrical resistance↗

Characterization of SiO 2 Thermally Grown Oxide Stress Evolution of EBCs with Al-Containing Dopants

SiC/SiC ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) are desired for use in combustion environments to achieve higher turbine operating temperatures. However, CMCs require environmental barrier coatings (EBCs) for protection from the gas environment. EBC systems are known to primarily fail through coating delamination via growth of a thermally grown oxide (TGO) at the EBC—silicon bond coating interface when exposed to steam, which accelerates the TGO growth rate. The TGO undergoes a phase transformation during thermal cycling, which results in stresses that may encourage EBC spallation. Yb-silicate EBCs with mullite and yttrium aluminum garnet (YAG) dopant additions were deposited on SiC substrates with a Si intermediate bond coating and exposed to thermal cycling in steam at 1350 °C. The impact of Al dopant additions on the TGO growth rate and the SiO 2 phase transformation was assessed. Photo-stimulated luminescence spectroscopy (PSLS) was used to characterize the Al-containing phases and to measure stress evolution in the EBC following exposure using the stress-induced peak shift of the R-lines of mullite. Raman microscopy was used to map the stresses in the Si bond coating following exposure. It was found that the TGO phase transformation upon cooling increased compressive stress in the Si bond coating within 15 µm of the TGO.

Building Materials↗

An Improved Fracture Mechanics-Informed Multiscale Thermomechanical Damage Model for Ceramic Matrix Composites

This paper extends recent work done by the authors in modeling length scale-dependent damage behavior of ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) to include effects of local anisotropy introduced by matrix cracking. This model captures scale-dependent damage initiation and propagation behavior of the brittle matrix by employing internal state variable (ISV) theory within a multiscale modeling framework to obtain damaged matrix stress/strain constitutive relationships at each length scale. The damage ISV captures the effects of matrix cracking and growth by using fracture mechanics and the self-consistent scheme to determine the reduced stiffness of the cracked matrix. Matrix cracks, which activate when stress intensity factors near manufacturing induced cavities exceed the fracture toughness of the material, are assumed to be transversely isotropic in the plane of the crack, and matrix anisotropy occurs when the damaged stiffness tensor is rotated from the crack plane to the global axes. The crack progression and temporal evolution of the damage ISV are governed by fracture mechanics and crack growth kinetics. The model effectively captures first matrix cracking, which is the first significant deviation from linear elasticity. The nonlinear predictive capabilities of the material model are demonstrated for monolithic silicon carbide (SiC) and a 2D woven five-harness satin (5HS) carbon fiber SiC matrix (C/SiC) CMC.

Skinner, Travis↗

High pressure effects on EBC systems in high temperature environments

Environmental barrier coatings (EBCs) are designed to protect SiCfiber/SiCmatrix ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) in turbine engines by mitigating wear in high-temperature water vapor environments. The failure of EBCs is frequently attributed to the accelerated oxidation of the silicon bond coating layer when exposed to high-temperature steam, leading to the formation of a thickened thermally grown oxide (TGO). TGO growth increases interfacial stress, weakens adhesion, and results in coating spallation. Understanding the impact of high-temperature oxidation of EBC systems is essential for developing accurate lifespan models for turbine components, although pressurized oxidation testing is extremely sparse in the open literature. In this work, oxidation tests were performed on rare earth silicate EBCs coated onto SiC substrates under increased pressure conditions. The coated specimens were tested at 1100°C, 1200°C, and 1300°C at both 1 atm and 10 atm total pressure in steam environments. Subsequent characterization focused on the microstructural evolution of the EBC/Si/SiC system. The experimental findings indicated that TGO behavior is dependent on high-pressure conditions, with elevated pressure leading to an increase in oxide scale thickness and modifications in its morphology.

Ardrey, Kristyn [ORNL] (ORCID:0000000184407796)↗

Advanced thermal/environmental barrier coatings of high-entropy rare earth disilicates tuned by strong anharmonicity of Eu 2 Si 2 O 7

Advancing thermal/environmental barrier coating (TEBC) materials with integrated thermal-mechanical functions is paramount for safeguarding SiC-based ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) in high-efficiency gas turbines. Herein, we employ a synergistic approach, combining density functional theory (DFT) methods and combinatorial chemistry techniques, to design high-performance and low-cost RE 2 Si 2 O 7 (RE = rare earth elements) TEBC materials tailored for enhanced compatibility with SiC-based CMCs. Expanding on phase stability of alloying pure RE 2 Si 2 O 7 , the investigation extends to the mechanical and thermal properties of solid solution systems, including Er 1/2 Y 3/4 Yb 3/4 Si 2 O 7 , Gd 1/4 Er 1/4 Y 3/4 Yb 3/4 Si 2 O 7 , and Eu 1/4 Er 1/4 Y 3/4 Yb 3/4 Si 2 O 7 . The solid solution systems exhibit a major reduction in lattice thermal conductivity relative to their pure counterparts, achieving ultralow values of 0.25 to 0.39 W m −1 K −1 at 1500 K. Furthermore, the coefficients of thermal expansion (CTE) of these solid solutions are precisely tuned within the desired range for SiC (4.4 to 5.5 × 10 −6 K −1 ), while maintaining good mechanical properties. Here, in particular, the addition of Eu 2 Si 2 O 7 demonstrates to be an important variable to the tuning of CTE and lattice thermal conductivity by leveraging its strong anharmonicity, presenting a pioneering avenue for fine-tuning material properties. In summary, this research not only identifies promising TEBC materials with superior thermal properties, but also introduces a valuable computational material design methodology for the rapid discovery of complex materials for harsh environments.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

A statistical representation of bond coating oxidation under environmental barrier coatings

Environmental barrier coatings (EBCs) protect SiC-based ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) in turbine hot sections from high-temperature volatilization in combustion gases. The formation of a SiO 2 thermally grown oxide (TGO) is expected under the EBC after long-term operation. The oxidation resistance of the EBC is understood as a life-limiting factor for the CMC, and this work predicts long-term oxidation behavior under EBCs through a simple statistical approach. Specimens were exposed to 1350°C isothermal conditions for 100-h thermal cycles in flowing steam for up to 1000 h. The EBC morphology, SiO 2 thickness, and SiO 2 cracking behavior were assessed. Using thousands of SiO 2 thickness measurements across many millimeters of the interface, a realistic representation of the entire TGO was captured via a lognormal distribution. The lognormal fit parameters were extrapolated out to 25 000 h to assess the degree of SiO 2 growth, the spread of SiO 2 thicknesses related to the rough oxidizing interface, and percentages of the intermediate bond coating consumed. In conclusion, local interfacial defects from the coating deposition process are identified as local failure points for EBC—CMC systems.

SiO 2↗

In situ characterization of foreign object damage (FOD) in environmental-barrier-coated silicon carbide (SiC) ceramic

Environmental barrier coatings (EBCs) protect advanced ceramics and ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) from oxidation and corrosion in gas turbine engine environments. Foreign object damage (FOD), where debris impact the protective coatings, is a critical hazard which limits the turbine durability. Despite previous efforts to understand FOD in EBCs, a detailed understanding of the fundamental transient damage mechanisms is still lacking. In the current work, the real-time FOD behavior of a Mullite / Silicon EBC was visualized via a dynamic synchrotron X-ray source in phase contrast imaging (PCI) configuration. Prior to the in situ FOD experiments, the microstructure and composition of the coating were respectively characterized using a scanning electron microscope (SEM) and X-ray diffraction (XRD). The variation in the properties of the debris was modeled by ~ 1.5 mm diameter Partially Stabilized Zirconia (PSZ) and Silicon Nitride (Si 3 N 4 ) spheres. A modified light-gas gun setup, synchronized with the X-ray beam, was used to propel the projectiles at velocities ranging between 300 and 355 m·s -1 . Coated samples were impacted under a fully backed support configuration and at normal incidence. Coating penetration and delamination, as well as projectile deformation at the bond coat resulted for FOD by PSZ spheres. Comparatively, projectile fracture, with subsequent rebound of fragments, as well as complete coating penetration and delamination at the substrate interface occurred for FOD by Si 3 N 4 spheres. It should be noted that only cone cracking was observed for FOD by PSZ spheres while back surface cracking was present for both projectile types. Qualitative understanding of the driving forces for the observed damage mechanisms were provided.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗