Learning from Each Other: Cross-Cutting Diagnostic Development Activities Between Magnetic and Inertial Confinement Fusion
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Nuclear science and engineering,Energy,Engineering↗
SEARCH · Search NASA
Results for “ICF”
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Characterization of the image plate multi-scan response to mono-energetic x-rays
Image plates (IPs), or phosphor storage screens, are a technology employed frequently in inertial confinement fusion (ICF) and high energy density plasma (HEDP) diagnostics because of their sensitivity to many types of radiation, including, x rays, protons, alphas, beta particles, and neutrons. Prior studies characterizing IPs are predicated on the signal level remaining below the scanner saturation threshold. Since the scanning process removes some signal from the IP via photostimulated luminescence, repeatedly scanning an IP can bring the signal level below the scanner saturation threshold. This process, in turn, raises concerns about the signal response of IPs after an arbitrary number of scans and whether such a process yields, for example, a constant ratio of signal between the nth and n + 1st scan. Here, the sensitivity of IPs is investigated when scanned multiple times. It is demonstrated that the ratio of signal decay is not a constant with the number of scans and that the signal decay depends on the x-ray energy. As such, repeatedly scanning an IP with a mixture of signal types (e.g., x ray, neutron, and protons) enables ICF and HEDP diagnostics employing IPs to better isolate a particular signal type.
Instruments & Instrumentation↗
First look at neutron emission shape characteristics of ignition hotspots at the National Ignition Facility (invited)
The nuclear imaging system has been capturing neutron images of inertial confinement fusion (ICF) driven implosions for over a decade at the National Ignition Facility. This imaging system has evolved from one to three nearly orthogonal lines-of-sight, allowing for the study of three-dimensional shape characteristics of ignition shots. Limited-view tomography algorithms help visualize the burning hotspot in 3D and assess neutron source geometry using Legendre mode parameters. With its neutron, gamma-ray, and x-ray image reconstruction capabilities, NIS has provided critical insight into mechanisms that have limited implosion performance, such as fill tube diameter for ignition-type targets. This comprehensive diagnostic suite opens a window into the shape characteristics of ignition shots and how symmetry affects ICF implosion performance. In more recent ignition shots, neutron yields have visibly increased. Analyzing the shape and size of the reconstructed neutron source has shown an expansion of the burn volume, which is indicative of more efficient alpha heating during the implosion process.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Optically multiplexed neutron time-of-flight technique for inertial confinement fusion
Neutron time-of-flight (nTOF) detectors are crucial in diagnosing the performance of inertial confinement fusion (ICF) experiments, which implode targets of deuterium–tritium fuel to achieve thermonuclear conditions. These detectors utilize the fusion neutron energy spectrum to extract key measurements, including the hotspot ion temperature and fuel areal density. Previous work [Danly et al., Rev. Sci. Instrum. 94, 043502 (2023)] has demonstrated adding 1D spatial resolution to an nTOF-like detector using a neutron aperture and streak camera to measure the ion temperature profile of an ICF implosion. By contrast, the study presented herein explores modifying the 1D detector to use a fast photomultiplier tube (PMT) to validate the design of a 2D spatially resolved instrument based on reconstruction from 1D profiles. The modification would collect time-of-flight traces from separate scintillators in an imaging array with one PMT using optical fibers of varying lengths to time-multiplex the signals. This technique has been demonstrated in ride-along experiments on the OMEGA laser with 20 fiber-coupled scintillator channels connected to a Photek PMT210. Results provide constraints on the fiber lengths and PMT gating requirements to promote pulse fidelity throughout all channels. Calibration of the detector to fixed nTOFs can provide a preliminary estimate of the instrument response function (IRF), although measurement of the IRF is currently under way. These results suggest that nTOF signals can potentially be time-multiplexed with fibers so long as the design is strategic to mitigate signal-to-noise reduction, modal dispersion, and charge build-up in the PMT, which has implications beyond ion temperature imaging.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
An experimental and computational study of thin-layer Rayleigh–Taylor instability development during deceleration with and without an externally applied magnetic field
The importance of mitigating the Rayleigh–Taylor instability (RTI) in inertial confinement fusion (ICF) is critical to successfully achieve high gain fusion yield. Consequently, understanding the seed mechanisms of RTI and the potential evolution of RTI in ICF relevant conditions is crucial. Single feature perturbations consistently demonstrate non-linear RTI evolution, for which an experimental platform on OMEGA-EP is developed. Manufacturing defects introduced into the target design require exploration of unanticipated changes to RTI development and an identification of targets that will still render quantifiable physics results. Consequently, it is presented that the inherent 3D nature of experimental targets necessitates 3D modeling for accurate design work and predictive modeling of experimental targets, especially when high resolution imaging diagnostics, like Fresnel Zone Plates, are utilized. A study of the morphology of the RTI evolution due to changing initial conditions and the presence of an externally applied magnetic field are also explored. Experimental data show thin-layer RTI morphology comparable to resistive magneto hydrodynamic 3D results. A discussion on the impacts of an externally applied magnetic field makes the case for continued efforts to observe a magnetic field's impact on RTI morphology.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Burn propagation in magnetized high-yield inertial fusion
Recent experiments at the National Ignition Facility (NIF) have demonstrated ignition for the first time in an inertial confinement fusion (ICF) experiment, a major milestone allowing the possibility of high energy gain through burn propagation. Use of external magnetic fields, applied primarily to reduce thermal losses, could increase hotspot temperature and ease requirements for ignition, opening up the capsule design space for high energy gain. However, this same restriction of thermal transport has the potential to inhibit burn propagation, which is vital in the attainment of high gain. In this work, radiation-magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) simulations carried out using the code Chimera are used to investigate the effect of a pre-imposed magnetic field on ignition and burn propagation. This paper studies the propagation of burn using both an idealized planar model and in fully integrated 2D MHD simulations of an igniting NIF capsule. A study of magnetized burn propagation in the idealized planar model identifies three regimes of magnetized burn propagation: (1) thermal conduction driven; (2) alpha transport driven; and (3) fully suppressed burn. Simulations of NIF shot N210808 with an applied 40 T axial field show clear indication of burn suppression perpendicular to field lines, with rapid burn observed along field lines. Implosion shape is altered by the field, and anisotropic conduction causes significant modification to the rate of ablation during stagnation. These results highlight the fundamental changes to implosion dynamics in high-yield magnetized ICF and motivate further study to better optimize future magnetized target designs for high gain.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Distortions in charged-particle images of laser direct-drive inertial confinement fusion implosions
Energetic charged particles generated by inertial confinement fusion (ICF) implosions encode information about the spatial morphology of the hotspot and dense fuel during the time of peak fusion reactions. The knock-on deuteron imager (KoDI) was developed at the Omega Laser Facility to image these particles in order to diagnose low-mode asymmetries in the hotspot and dense fuel layer of cryogenic deuterium–tritium ICF implosions. However, the images collected are distorted in several ways that prevent reconstruction of the deuteron source. In this paper, we describe these distortions and a series of attempts to mitigate or compensate for them. We present several potential mechanisms for the distortions, including a new model for scattering of charged particles in filamentary electric or magnetic fields surrounding the implosion. Particle-tracing is used to create synthetic KoDI data based on the filamentary field model that reproduces the main experimentally observed image distortions. We conclude that the filamentary scattering model best matches the observed image distortions. Finally, we discuss potential impacts of filamentary fields on other charged-particle diagnostics.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Toward an improved nonlocal thermodynamic equilibrium model for more predictive simulations of ignition scale hohlraums
Recently, nonlocal thermodynamic equilibrium (NLTE) modeling has been identified as the primary reason for discrepant predictions of the peak neutron production time in indirectly driven inertial confinement fusion (ICF) platforms. It has also been observed that predictions of collisional excitation rates differ by as much as 50% from measurements. Theoretical uncertainties in dielectronic recombination rates have also been posited as possibly contributing to errors in NLTE predictions. This work examines the impact of multipliers on collisional excitation and dielectronic recombination rates on simulations of a directly driven gold sphere and an indirect drive ICF implosion. It is found that multipliers on the collisional excitation rates have a strong impact on radiant intensity and electron temperature and a weaker impact on ionization state, whereas multipliers on dielectronic recombinations rates strongly impact ionization state with a smaller impact on radiant intensity and electron temperature. A self-consistent NLTE model which places multipliers on differing transitions, as motivated by experimental measurements and more detailed atomic physics predictions, improves agreement but does not completely eliminate discrepancies with measurements of the radiant intensity within the 2–4 keV spectral range.
Farmer, W. A. [Lawrence Livermore National Laborat↗
Detailed simulations of the first deuterium-tritium-filled double shell implosions on the National Ignition Facility
The first indirectly driven, liquid DT-filled double shell inertial confinement fusion (ICF) implosions have recently been successfully performed on the National Ignition Facility (NIF). Double shells are a class of alternative designs that use a low-Z outer shell to compress a foam cushion that accelerates a high-Z inner shell to efficiently compress a liquid DT core. Double shells are challenging to fabricate, field, and model. Important engineering features enabling double shell fabrication include a fill-tube penetrating all shells and a carefully designed and very narrow (few μm) step-joint in the ablator. Due to the higher density materials involved, high Atwood number instabilities are also important at many material interfaces. In this paper, numerical simulations of double shell implosions using the Los Alamos National Laboratory multi-physics radiation-hydrodynamics code xRAGE will be discussed. An extensive effort has been under way for several years to develop the code capabilities for ICF simulations in a common modeling framework to allow ease of simulation setup and standardization of the computational methodology. This paper will present a wide range of simulation results capturing, quantifying, and comparing the impact of all these degradation mechanisms on implosion performance. Brief comparisons with recent experimental results and suggestions for future improvements will also be discussed. Our results suggest that capsule surface roughness and the step-joint gap have the largest impact on implosion performance. Initial experimental data may suggest that the sensitivity to the step-joint gap could provide the dominant explanation for DT-filled double shell experiments that have been fielded on NIF thus far.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
High-rate magnetron sputter deposition of low-stress boron carbide films on tilted substrates
Boron carbide is attractive for several applications, including nuclear fuel capsules for inertial confinement fusion (ICF). The fabrication of ICF capsules involves the deposition of ultrathick coatings with density and thickness uniformity on submicron length scales on non-planar (spherical) substrates. Such a deposition requires control of the deposition rate, residual stress, and film microstructure. Here, we systematically study the direct-current magnetron sputter deposition of B 4 C coatings with a full-face-erosion magnetron source as a function of substrate tilt and Ar working gas pressure. Film properties are correlated with results of plasma diagnostics and predictions of Monte Carlo simulations of ballistic sputtering and gas-phase transport. The fabrication of low-stress amorphous B 4 C films with deposition rates of 7μm/h is demonstrated.
Kawasaki, K. [Lawrence Livermore National Laborato↗
Bremsstrahlung constraints on proton-boron 11 inertial fusion
Proton-boron 11 (pB11) fusion is relatively safe and clean, but difficult to use for net power production, since bremsstrahlung radiation tends to radiate away power more quickly than it can be generated by fusion power, particularly once poisoning by alpha particles is taken into account. While in magnetic confinement fusion, this problem can be addressed by deconfining the alphas, in inertial confinement fusion (ICF), the alphas that heat the plasma linger for the duration of the reaction. Thus, it becomes essential to trap the bremsstrahlung radiation in the hotspot. Through burn simulations incorporating bremsstrahlung emission and reabsorption, we infer the necessary conditions to capture enough radiation to produce scientific breakeven in a pB11 ICF plasma. We find that breakeven requires a stagnation areal density roughly two orders of magnitude higher than the current state-of-the-art, at pressures three orders of magnitude higher.
Alpha particles↗
Burn mode signatures enabled by high dynamic range fusion reaction history
The evolution of the fusion burn of a compressed inertial confinement fusion (ICF) implosion gives information about the evolution of the temperature, mass, and volume of the hot spot. Currently, the fusion reaction history has been measured with about a decade of dynamic range, giving information about just the peak of the fusion burn. There are proposals for extending the dynamic range to 1000×, measuring the rising edge of the burn earlier in time. Using fusion hot spot theory and a set of ICF simulations, we identify and categorize different stages of fusion burn and what signatures could be measured. For ice layered implosions, the details, conditions, and dynamics of the fusion burn propagation could be observed. For double shell and OMEGA scale implosions, the evolution of the final compression and rebounding shock before ignition could be observed. Higher dynamic range expands investigation into the logarithmic derivative, α, as a signature of various mechanisms.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Laser polarization effects on crossed-beam energy transfer in inertial confinement fusion
Crossed-beam energy transfer (CBET) is a consequential process in inertial confinement fusion (ICF) experiments. CBET depends on the polarization state of the interacting lasers and can, in turn, alter their polarization. Here, we derive analytical expressions for two-beam CBET with linearly and circularly polarized light, and present simulations of CBET that include polarization effects for ICF conditions relevant to experiments on the National Ignition Facility. The results show that CBET mixes the polarization of the beams as they propagate through the target and leads to azimuthal power imbalances between beams within a given cone (i.e., at the same polar angle in the target chamber). These variations are shown to correlate with variations in measured backscatter between beams of a same quadruplet. Using circularly polarized, instead of linearly polarized, light produces similar overall levels of CBET within a cone of beams but tends to reduce the azimuthal variations. This is expected to slightly improve irradiation symmetry and reduce the risk of backscatter from stimulated Brillouin scattering. Circular polarization may therefore be beneficial for the next generation of laser fusion drivers.
Physics - Plasma physics↗
Precision Polishing of Ablator Capsules via in situ Process Monitoring and Machine Learning–Based Optimization
In inertial confinement fusion (ICF) experiments seeking output gains of unity and beyond, the quality of the ablator capsule is paramount for minimizing the hydrodynamic mix that quenches the central hot spot. Defects in the form of foreign particles or missing mass on the surface and within the wall of the capsule are primary offenders. High-density carbon capsules made for ICF experiments at the National Ignition Facility are precision polished to achieve surface smoothness on the order of a few nanometers as well as to minimize isolated defects in the form of pits. Given the critical role of this process, we are developing smart manufacturing techniques with the goal of elevating the efficiency of this process. Our approach is to use MEMS (micro-electromechanical systems)–based sensors to capture the fine vibration signals generated during the polishing process and combine them with synchronized visual feedback as needed. Beyond using these sensors for process monitoring, we use specific deep learning methods to analyze the data and extract correlations with both the process parameters and the final performance of the polishing run. Here, in this work, we describe the multiple fronts we have explored in this regard and the results we have gotten so far. This approach promises to have the potential to ultimately provide real-time feedback that can be used to ensure the progress of the run as well as a means for faster optimization.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
High-Power Impulse Magnetron Sputter Deposition of Ultrathick Amorphous Carbon
Diamond-like carbon (DLC) is a material of interest for inertial confinement fusion (ICF) ablators. However, the deposition of ultrathick DLC coatings, as required for ICF ablator fabrication, remains a challenge. Here, in this study, we use high-power impulse magnetron sputtering to deposit DLC and demonstrate a set of process parameters leading to high-purity, amorphous DLC coatings with a low compressive residual stress of <400 MPa. Coatings with thicknesses of up to 80 μm are demonstrated.
amorphous carbon↗
Quantification of Changes in Fill Tube Curvature During Target Assembly
National Ignition Facility (NIF) targets used for inertial confinement fusion (ICF) experiments are precision-engineered assemblies composed of more than 100 components carefully and precisely assembled with accuracies no larger than a few micrometers in most cases. When individual components deviate from these strict specifications during the assembly process, they can induce target failure. An integral component essential to ICF targets is the capsule-fill-tube assembly. This assembly involves bonding the capsule to a fused silica tube less than 5 μm in thickness, through which the tritium and deuterium (T 2 + D 2 ) fuel mixture is injected into the capsule prior to the NIF shot. The filling tube is bonded to a larger fused silica capillary, about 130 μm in outer diameter, which is coated with a polymeric layer on the order of a 10-μm thickness or less. Only tubes exhibiting a deflection equivalent to less than 1% of their total length from a perfectly straight line are suitable for assembly. Slight curvatures on the order of 1 mm over 10 cm can induce unwanted stresses, potentially causing capsule misalignment and resulting in clogging or leaks during the filling process. Despite manually qualitatively sorting each tube for straightness prior assembly, it has been found that the treatments the tubes undergo once attached to the capsule can alter their curvature. Filling tubes that initially satisfy straightness tolerances can undergo geometric deformation, resulting in curvature deviations exceeding 1% of their total length and thus failing to meet target assembly requirements. Here, in this study, we propose a metric to assess the degree of curvature of the filling tubes and to gauge their changes in curvature caused by the standard thermal processing methods employed in target assembly. In addition, we suggest alternatives to mitigate tube curvature, ensuring they conform to specifications following assembly in the final targets.
Materials science↗
Fully Additively Manufactured Wetted Foam Capsules for Inertial Confinement Fusion
In the pursuit of realizing reliable clean energy generation via inertial confinement fusion (ICF), wetted foam (WF) capsule targets have long been coveted due to their potential to simplify the target fielding process and suppress hydrodynamic instabilities and material mixing that limit achievable energy output, yet producing and deploying a WF target has proven challenging. Here, in this work, we demonstrate the design, fabrication, metrology, and testing of fully additively manufactured (AM) foam-lined capsules using two-photon polymerization (2PP) for ICF. We successfully fielded an AM polymeric foam capsule with a 3-mm outer diameter, a nominally 15-µm-thick solid outer layer, a 120-µm-thick inner foam layer, and a 250-µm outer diameter copper fill tube on the National Ignition Facility for a polar direct-drive shot, and we showcase deuterium wetting of the capsule foam layer inside an ignition target proofing station. Our exploration showed that 2PP can produce fieldable targets with complex geometries and potentially shorten the design iteration turnaround time and the overall target fabrication time.
Target↗
Multi-Fidelity Bayesian Optimization with Gaussian Processes for Double Shell Inertial Confinement Fusion Target Design
Reliable, secure access to energy is a major focus for national security efforts. One potential route to such energy is through fusion reactions in inertial confinement fusion (ICF) experiments. Such experiments are carried out at facilities such as the National Ignition Facility (NIF) in Livermore, California, where high powered lasers are used to compress a DT fuel-containing target to the necessary high temperature, high pressure conditions. These experiments are limited in number, which creates a heavy dependence on high fidelity predictive physics simulations and analysis performed “pre shot,” or before the experiment occurs. Many of these simulations in higher dimensions (2D and 3D) are computationally expensive, so finding optimal simulation-based designs presents its own challenges. In this work, we present our multi-fidelity Bayesian optimization with Gaussian processes (GPs) for ICF double shell targets, where a 1D surrogate model is used to help find a 2D surrogate model, enabling us to find optimal targets in the higher fidelity (2D), while saving computational cost.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗