Lagrangian and Eulerian drag models that are consistent between Euler-Lagrange and Euler-Euler (two-fluid) approaches for homogeneous systems
The undisturbed flow of a particle is of fundamental importance since it controls both the undisturbed flow force and the perturbation force (which includes quasisteady, added-mass, and history forces). Here we use the pairwise interaction extended point particle framework to evaluate the undisturbed flow of each particle through superposition of the perturbation flow induced by all its neighbors. This approach allows calculation of various statistics related to undisturbed fluid velocity under conditions of both stationary and nonstationary particles. In a random distribution of stationary particles, while the macroscale undisturbed flow is slowly varying, the microscale undisturbed flow that arises due to the perturbation flow of neighbors varies substantially from one particle to another and this in turn leads to large variation in the hydrodynamic force exerted on the particles. The effect of particle motion is generally to increase the particle-to-particle variation in the undisturbed fluid velocity of the particles. We observe that this increase is greater for the transverse component than for the streamwise component. As a result, with increasing random particle motion, the distribution of undisturbed fluid-velocity fluctuation becomes isotropic. Three different normalized forces are defined: $Φ^L$ is the Lagrangian normalized force on an individual particle suitable for application in a microscale-informed Euler-Lagrange simulation, $Φ^E$ is the Eulerian normalized average force suitable for application in an Euler-Euler simulation, and $Φ^{LE}$ is the Lagrangian normalized force on an individual particle suitable for application in the standard Euler-Lagrange simulation. In this work, we establish precise relations between these different definitions. The drag laws developed based on particle-resolved direct numerical simulation results and experiments are appropriate for application only as the Eulerian normalized average force. We introduce the force consistency relation and use it to obtain an expression for $Φ^L$, which when applied to each particle and averaged over all the particles equals $Φ^E$. The results are first obtained in the limit of stationary particles and then extended to the general case of nonstationary particles.