Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “ground-state configuration”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 91 records · Page 5

Origin of Ferromagnetic Exchange Coupling in Donor–Acceptor Biradical Analogues of Charge-Separated Excited States

A new donor–acceptor biradical complex, Tp Cum,Me Zn(SQ-VD) (Tp Cum,Me Zn + = zinc(II) hydro-tris(3-cumenyl-5-methylpyrazolyl)borate complex cation; SQ = orthosemiquinone; VD = oxoverdazyl), which is a ground-state analogue of a charge-separated excited state, has been synthesized and structurally characterized. Here, the magnetic exchange interaction between the S = 1/2 SQ and the S = 1/2 VD within the SQ-VD biradical ligand is observed to be ferromagnetic, with $J_{SQ-VD}$ = +77 cm –1 (H = -2$J_{SQ-VD}\bar{S}_{SQ}·\bar{S}_{VD}$) determined from an analysis of the variable-temperature magnetic susceptibility data. The pairwise biradical exchange interaction in Tp Cum,Me Zn(SQ-VD) can be compared with that of the related donor–acceptor biradical complex Tp Cum,Me Zn(SQ-NN) (NN = nitronyl nitroxide, S = 1/2), where $J_{SQ-NN}$ ≅ +550 cm –1 . This represents a dramatic reduction in the biradical exchange by a factor of ~7, despite the isolobal nature of the VD and NN acceptor radical SOMOs. Computations assessing the magnitude of the exchange were performed using a broken-symmetry density functional theory (DFT) approach. These computations are in good agreement with those computed at the CASSCF NEVPT2 level, which also reveals an S = 1 triplet ground state as observed in the magnetic susceptibility measurements. A combination of electronic absorption spectroscopy and CASSCF computations has been used to elucidate the electronic origin of the large difference in the magnitude of the biradical exchange coupling between Tp Cum,Me Zn(SQ-VD) and Tp Cum,Me Zn(SQ-NN). A Valence Bond Configuration Interaction (VBCI) model was previously employed to highlight the importance of mixing an SQ SOMO → NNLUMO charge transfer configuration into the electronic ground state to facilitate the stabilization of the high-spin triplet (S = 1) ground state in Tp Cum,Me Zn(SQ-NN). Here, CASSCF computations confirm the importance of mixing the pendant radical (e.g., VD, NN) LUMO (VD LUMO and NN LUMO ) with the SOMO of the SQ radical (SQ SOMO ) for stabilizing the triplet, in addition to spin polarization and charge transfer contributions to the exchange. An important electronic structure difference between Tp Cum,Me Zn(SQ-VD) and Tp Cum,Me Zn(SQ-NN), which leads to their different exchange couplings, is the reduced admixture of excited states that promote ferromagnetic exchange into the Tp Cum,Me Zn(SQ-VD) ground state, and the intrinsically weaker mixing between the VD LUMO and the SQ SOMO compared to that observed for Tp Cum,Me Zn(SQ-NN), where this orbital mixing is significant. The results of this comparative study contribute to a greater understanding of biradical exchange interactions, which are important to our understanding of excited-state singlet–triplet energy gaps, electron delocalization, and the generation of electron spin polarization in both the ground and excited states of (bpy)Pt(CAT-radical) complexes.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Modeling Strong Light-Matter Coupling in Correlated Systems: State-Averaged Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics Complete Active Space Self-Consistent Field Theory

The description of strongly correlated systems interacting with quantized cavity modes poses significant theoretical challenges due to the combinatorial scaling of electronic and photonic degrees of freedom. Recent advances addressing this complexity include cavity quantum electrodynamics (QED) generalizations of complete active space configuration interaction and density matrix renormalization group methods. In this work, we introduce a QED extension of state-averaged complete active space self-consistent field theory, which incorporates cavity-induced correlations through a second-order orbital optimization framework with robust convergence properties. The method is implemented using both photon number state and coherent state representations, with the latter showing robust origin invariance in the energies regardless of the completeness of the photonic Fock space. The implementation enables symmetry-free orbital relaxations to account for photon-mediated symmetry breaking in polaritonic systems. Numerical validation on lithium hydride, hydroxide anion, and magnesium hydride cation demonstrates that this method achieves significantly improved accuracy in modeling ground-state and polariton potential energy surfaces compared to QED-CASCI in a fixed orbital basis. In these studies, we reach sub-kcal/mol accuracy in potential energy surface in much smaller active spaces than are required for QED-CASCI. This advancement provides a more robust approach for studying cavity-altered chemical landscapes for ground and exited strongly coupled systems.

CASSCF↗

Interaction of Th with H 0/–/+ : Combined Experimental and Theoretical Thermodynamic Properties

In this work, high-level electronic structure calculations of the lowlying energy electronic states for ThH, ThH – , and ThH + are reported and compared to experimental measurements. The inclusion of spin–orbit coupling is critical to predict the ground-state ordering as inclusion of spin–orbit switches the coupled-cluster CCSD(T) ordering of the two lowest energy states for ThH and ThH + . At the multireference spin–orbit SO-CASPT2 level, the ground states of ThH, ThH – , and ThH + are predicted to be the 2 Δ 3/2 , 3 Φ 2 , and 3 Δ 1 states, respectively. The adiabatic electron affinity is calculated to be 0.820 eV, and the vertical detachment energy is calculated to be 0.832 eV in comparison to an experimental value of 0.87 ± 0.02 eV. The observed ThH – photoelectron spectrum has many transitions, which approximately correlate with excitations of Th + and/or Th. The adiabatic ionization energy of ThH including spin–orbit corrections is calculated to be 6.181 eV. The natural bond orbital results are consistent with a significant contribution of the Th + H – ionic configuration to the bonding in ThH. The bond dissociation energies for ThH, ThH – , and ThH + using the Feller–Peterson–Dixon approach were calculated to be similar for all three molecules and lie between 259 and 280 kJ/mol.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Time-Resolved X-ray Emission Spectroscopy and Synthetic High-Spin Model Complexes Resolve Ambiguities in Excited-State Assignments of Transition-Metal Chromophores: A Case Study of Fe-Amido Complexes

To fully harness the potential of abundant metal coordination complex photosensitizers, a detailed understanding of the molecular properties that dictate and control the electronic excited-state population dynamics initiated by light absorption is critical. In the absence of detectable luminescence, optical transient absorption (TA) spectroscopy is the most widely employed method for interpreting electron redistribution in such excited states, particularly for those with a charge-transfer character. The assignment of excited-state TA spectral features often relies on spectroelectrochemical measurements, where the transient absorption spectrum generated by a metal-to-ligand charge-transfer (MLCT) electronic excited state, for instance, can be approximated using steady-state spectra generated by electrochemical ligand reduction and metal oxidation and accounting for the loss of absorptions by the electronic ground state. However, the reliability of this approach can be clouded when multiple electronic configurations have similar optical signatures. Using a case study of Fe(II) complexes supported by benzannulated diarylamido ligands, we highlight an example of such an ambiguity and show how time-resolved X-ray emission spectroscopy (XES) measurements can reliably assign excited states from the perspective of the metal, particularly in conjunction with accurate synthetic models of ligand-field electronic excited states, leading to a reinterpretation of the long-lived excited state as a ligand-field metal-centered quintet state. Furthermore, a detailed analysis of the XES data on the long-lived excited state is presented, along with a discussion of the ultrafast dynamics following the photoexcitation of low-spin Fe(II)-N amido complexes using a high-spin ground-state analogue as a spectral model for the 5 T 2 excited state.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

Chiral spin-liquid-like state in pyrochlore iridate thin films

The pyrochlore iridates have become ideal platforms to unravel fascinating correlated and topological phenomena that stem from the intricate interplay among strong spin-orbit coupling, electronic correlations, lattice with geometric frustration, and itinerancy of the 5d electrons. The all-in-all-out antiferromagnetic state, commonly considered as the magnetic ground state, can be dramatically altered in reduced dimensionality, leading to exotic or hidden quantum states inaccessible in bulk. Here, by means of magnetotransport, resonant elastic and inelastic x-ray scattering experiments, we discover an emergent quantum disordered state in (111) Y 2 Ir 2 O 7 thin films (thickness ≤30 nm) persisting down to 5 K, characterized by dispersionless magnetic excitations. The anomalous Hall effect observed below an onset temperature near 125 K corroborates the presence of chiral short-range spin configurations expressed in non-zero scalar spin chirality, breaking the macroscopic time-reversal symmetry. The origin of this chiral state is ascribed to the restoration of magnetic frustration on the pyrochlore lattice in lower dimensionality, where the competing exchange interactions together with enhanced quantum fluctuations suppress any long-range order and trigger spin-liquid-like behavior with degenerate ground-state manifold.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

On the origin of ground-state vacuum-field catalysis: Equilibrium consideration

Recent experiments suggest that vibrational strong coupling (VSC) may significantly modify ground-state chemical reactions and their rates even without external pumping. The intrinsic mechanism of this “vacuum-field catalysis” remains largely unclear. Generally, modifications of thermal reactions in the ground electronic states can be caused by equilibrium or non-equilibrium effects. The former are associated with modifications of the reactant equilibrium distribution as expressed by the transition state theory of chemical reaction rates, while the latter stem from the dynamics of reaching and leaving transition state configurations. In this work, we examine how VSC can affect chemical reactions rates in a cavity environment according to transition state theory. Our approach is to examine the effect of coupling to cavity mode(s) on the potential of mean force (PMF) associated with the reaction coordinate. Within the context of classical nuclei and classical photons and also assuming no charge overlap between molecules, we find that while the PMF can be affected by the cavity environment, this effect is negligible for the usual micron-length cavities used to examine VSC situations.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Quantum many-body linear algebra, Hamiltonian moments, and a coupled-cluster inspired framework

Here, we propose a general strategy to develop quantum many-body approximations of primitives in linear algebra algorithms. As a practical example, we introduce a coupled-cluster inspired framework to produce approximate Hamiltonian moments and demonstrate its application in various linear algebra algorithms for ground state estimation. Through numerical examples, we illustrate the difference between the ground-state energies arising from quantum many-body linear algebra and those from the analogous many-body perturbation theory. Our results support the general idea of designing quantum many-body approximations outside of perturbation theory, providing a route to new algorithms and approximations.

Algorithms and data structure↗

Prediction of exotic magnetic states in the alkali-metal quasi-one-dimensional iron selenide compound Na 2 FeSe 2

The magnetic and electronic phase diagram of a model for the quasi-one-dimensional alkali-metal iron selenide compound Na 2 FeSe 2 is presented. The novelty of this material is that the valence of iron is Fe 2+ , contrary to most other iron-chain compounds with valence Fe 3+ . Using first-principles techniques, we developed a three-orbital tight-binding model that reproduces the ab initio band structure near the Fermi level. Including Hubbard and Hund couplings and studying the model via the density-matrix renormalization group and Lanczos methods, we constructed the ground-state phase diagram. A robust region where the block state ↑↑↓↓↑↑↓↓ is stabilized was unveiled. The analog state in iron ladders, employing 2×2 ferromagnetic blocks, is by now well established, but in chains a block magnetic order has not been observed yet in real materials. The phase diagram also contains a large region of canonical staggered spin order ↑↓↑↓↑↓↑ at very large Hubbard repulsion. At the block-to-staggered transition region, an exotic phase is stabilized with a mixture of both states: an inhomogeneous orbital-selective charge density wave with the exotic spin configuration ↑↑↓↑↓↓↑↓. Our predictions for Na 2 FeSe 2 may guide crystal growers and neutron-scattering experimentalists towards the realization of block states in one-dimensional iron selenide chain materials.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Critical role of magnetic moments in heavy-fermion materials: Revisiting mysteries of SmB 6

Heavy-fermion family exhibits fascinating and often puzzling properties due to the presence of open-shell f ions and the complexity of the associated charge, orbital, and spin degrees of freedom. SmB 6 is a prototypical heavy-fermion compound that is electrically insulating but yet it displays quantum oscillations, which are a telltale signature of the metallic state. Adding to the enigma is the possibility that SmB 6 is a topological Kondo insulator. Here, by treating the spin degree of freedom on an equal footing with other degrees of freedom using the parameter-free strongly-constrained and appropriately-normed (SCAN) density functional, we explore the ground-state electronic structure of SmB6. A number of competing magnetic phases lying very closely in energy are found, indicating the key role of spin fluctuations in the material. The computed band structure, crystal-field splittings in the f-electron complex, the heavy effective electron mass at the Fermi energy, and the large specific heat are all in good agreement with the corresponding experimental results. In particular, our predicted FS explains the experimentally observed bulk quantum oscillations as well as the low electrical conductivity of SmB 6 . The topological Kondo state of SmB6 is shown to be robust regardless of its magnetic configuration. The excellent performance of SCAN in heavy-fermion systems is explained in terms of its ability to treat self-interaction errors and symmetry breaking within the framework of the density functional theory. Our study provides a new approach for modeling heavy-fermion materials

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Ground-state degeneracy and complex magnetism of geometrically frustrated Gd 2 Ir 0.97 Si 2.97

We report a new triangular-lattice intermetallic compound Gd 2 Ir 0.97 Si 2.97 was successfully synthesized as single phase by deliberately introducing vacancies. Theoretical analysis suggests that the ground state is competing with several low-energy spin configurations due to magnetic frustration on a nearly ideal triangular lattice. Despite a number of competing magnetic states, the compound exhibits long-range antiferromagnetic order at16K, a long-range ferrimagnetic transition at 6.5 K, and a reentrant cluster-glass transition below T f ~ 3K. The complex magnetism in the compound could be correlated with competing antiferromagnetic and ferrimagnetic structures predicted theoretically.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Single-nucleon knockout cross sections for reactions producing resonance states at or beyond the drip line

Single-nucleon knockout cross sections from fast secondary beams of the proton-drip-line nuclei 9 C, 13 O, and 17 Ne on a 9 Be target have been studied with emphasis on the production of resonance states. These states were identified by their invariant mass, and resonances with two-, three-, and five-body exit channels were examined. The measured cross sections for these states were compared with eikonal-model predictions using shell-model or variational Monte Carlo spectroscopic factors. The experimental yields were found to be suppressed relative to the model predictions, especially when a well-bound neutron or proton is removed. This suppression exceeds that found systematically in measured inclusive cross sections to particle-bound final states. In neutron knockout from 9 C and 13 O projectiles, this suppression of the unbound ground-state residuals yield is a factor of two to three times larger than that found in the bound final-state studies. Modifications to the structure of these systems due to coupling of the shell-model configurations to the continuum is expected to contribute to this extra suppression, especially when the final state is a near-threshold resonance. Furthermore, other considerations including the role of nuclear dynamics may be required to explain all the observed trends.

6 ≤ A ≤ 19↗

Possible quenching of static neutron pairing near the N=98 deformed shell gap: Rotational structures in 160,161 Gd

A 160 Gd beam was accelerated to an energy of 1000 MeV and, separately, bombarded thick targets of 154 Sm and 164 Dy in order to observe neutron-rich, rare-earth nuclei via deep-inelastic collision processes. Gammasphere was utilized to observe g-ray emissions. Here, many new states and transitions were observed in 160 Gd as a result of so-called "unsafe" Coulomb excitation. The ground-state band in 160 Gd has been extended to I π = 20 + and a rotational band based on the K π = 4 + state, previously associated with a hexadecapole vibration, was observed up to 18 + . The quasiparticle configuration of the K π = 4 + band has been determined, and its unusual alignment behavior may result from a possible quenching of static neutron pairing. In addition, the band based on the [523]5/2 quasineutron orbital in 161 Gd was extended from 11/2 – to 33/2 – , and also displays the same unusual alignment behavior.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Lifetime measurements in the even-even Cd 102 – 108 isotopes

The heaviest T z = 0 doubly-magic nucleus, Sn 100 , and the neighboring nuclei offer unique opportunities to investigate the properties of nuclear interaction. For instance, the structure of light-Sn nuclei has been shown to be affected by the delicate balance between nuclear-interaction components, such as pairing and quadrupole correlations. From Cd to Te, many common features and phenomena have been observed experimentally along the isotopic chains, leading to theoretical studies devoted to a more general and comprehensive study of the region. In this context, having only two proton holes in the Z = 50 shell, the Cd isotopes are expected to present properties similar to those found in the Sn isotopic chain. The aim of this work was to measure lifetimes of excited states in neutron-deficient nuclei in the vicinity of Sn 100 . Here, the neutron-deficient nuclei in the N ≈ Z ≈ 50 region were populated using a multinucleon transfer reaction with a Cd 106 beam and a Mo 92 target. The beamlike products were identified by the VAMOS + + spectrometer, while the γ rays were detected using the AGATA array. Lifetimes of excited states were determined using the recoil distance Doppler-shift method, employing the Cologne differential plunger. Lifetimes of low-lying states were measured in the even-mass Cd 102 – 108 isotopes. In particular, multiple states with excitation energy up to ≈ 3 MeV, belonging to various bands, were populated in Cd 106 via inelastic scattering. The transition strengths corresponding to the measured lifetimes were compared with those resulting from state-of-the-art beyond-mean-field calculations using the symmetry-conserving configuration-mixing approach. Conclusions: Despite the similarities in the electromagnetic properties of the low-lying states, there is a fundamental structural difference between the ground-state bands in the Z = 48 and Z = 50 isotopes. The comparison between experimental and theoretical results revealed a rotational character of the Cd nuclei, which have prolate-deformed ground states with β 2 ≈ 0.2 . At this deformation Z = 48 becomes a closed-shell configuration, which is favored with respect to the spherical one.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

𝛽−decay of neutron-rich 45 Cl located at the magic number 𝑁 = 28

Results from the β-decay study of 45 Cl, produced in the fragmentation of a 140-MeV/u 48 Ca beam, are presented. The half-life of 45 Cl is measured to be 513(36) ms. β – and β – 1n decay populate excited states in 45 Ar and 44 Ar, respectively, and decay schemes for both daughter nuclei are established based on γ-ray singles and γ-γ coincidence data. Comparison with shell-model calculations using the FSU interaction shows that the low-lying negative-parity states in 45 Ar are well described by single-neutron configurations near the Fermi surface, whereas positive-parity states require neutron excitations across the N = 20 shell gap, consistent with allowed Gamow–Teller decay from 45 Cl. The strong β-feeding to the 5/2 + state in 45 Ar supports a 3/2 + ground-state assignment for 45 Cl over 1/2 + . Furthermore, the high Q β – value enables population of 1p1h states above the neutron separation energy in 45 Ar, leading to positive-parity states in 44 Ar through neutron emission. Tentative spin-parity assignments for excited levels in 44 Ar are made for the first time based on comparison with shell-model predictions, and the 2978-keV level is identified as an excited 0 + state with a configuration distinct from the ground state.

39 ≤ A ≤ 58↗

Solving the Puzzles of the Decay of the Heaviest Known Proton-Emitting Nucleus 185 Bi

Two long-standing puzzles in the decay of 185 Bi, the heaviest known proton-emitting nucleus are revisited. These are the non-observation of the 9/2 – state, which is the ground state of all heavier odd-A Bi isotopes, and the hindered nature of proton and α decays of its presumed 60-μs 1/2 + ground state. The 185 Bi nucleus has now been studied with the 95 Mo( 93 Nb; 3n) reaction in complementary experiments using the Fragment Mass Analyzer and Argonne Gas-Filled Analyzer at Argonne National Laboratory’s ATLAS facility. The experiments have established the existence of two states in 185 Bi; the short-lived T 1/2 = $2.8$$^{+2.3}_{–1.0}$ μs, proton- and α-decaying ground state, and a 58(2)–μs γ-decaying isomer, the half-life of which was previously attributed to the ground state. The reassignment of the ground-state lifetime results in a proton-decay spectroscopic factor close to unity and represents the only known example of a ground-state proton decay to a daughter nucleus ( 184 Pb) with a major shell closure. Furthermore, the data also demonstrate that the ordering of low- and high-spin states in 185 Bi is reversed relative to the heavier odd-A Bi isotopes, with the intruder-based 1/2 + configuration becoming the ground state, similar to the lightest At nuclides.

150 ≤ A ≤ 189↗

Circumventing superexponential runtimes for hard instances of quantum adiabatic optimization

Classical optimization problems can be solved by adiabatically preparing the ground state of a quantum Hamiltonian that encodes the problem. The performance of this approach is determined by the smallest gap encountered during the evolution. Here, we consider the maximum independent set problem, which can be efficiently encoded in the Hamiltonian describing a Rydberg atom array. We present a general construction of instances of the problem for which the minimum gap decays superexponentially with system size, implying a superexponentially large time to solution via adiabatic evolution. The small gap arises from locally independent choices which cause the system to initially evolve and localize into a configuration far from the solution in terms of Hamming distance. We investigate remedies to this problem. Specifically, we show that quantum quenches in these models can exhibit signatures of quantum many-body scars, which in turn, can circumvent the superexponential gaps. By quenching from a suboptimal configuration, states with a larger ground-state overlap can be prepared, illustrating the utility of quantum quenches as an algorithmic tool. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

Schiffer, Benjamin F. (ORCID:0000000189512157)↗

Isomeric states in the neutron-rich 𝑁 = 108 nuclei 178 Yb and 179 Lu

A multinucleon transfer reaction with a 136 Xe beam and a gold-backed 176 Yb target populated isomers in N = 108 178 Yb and 179 Lu. The single decay from the t 1/2 = 203(16) ns isomer in 178 Yb to the I π = 4 + level in the ground-state band suggests a I π = 4 − assignment, and multiquasiparticle calculations associate this state with the K π = 4 − , ν 2 (1/2[510], 9/2[624]) configuration. At least two isomers were observed in 179 Lu. One likely couples the K π = 4 − configuration found in 178 Yb to the 9/2[514] quasiproton orbital to form a K π = 17/2 + level (t 1/2 = 1.0(4) µs) which primarily decays into the rotational band based on the 9/2[514] state. A second isomer was observed to decay into this same band, but at higher energy and spin. Based on its feeding pattern, its similarity to an isomer found in 181 Ta, and a multiquasiparticle calculation, it is proposed to correspond to a K π = 29/2 − state based on the π9/2[514]ν 2 (9/2[624], 11/2[615]) configuration. As a result, an analysis of the reduced hindrance factors for negative-parity, two-quasineutron isomers in the rare-earth region is presented as well.

150 ≤ A ≤ 189↗

Persistence of collectivity in the low-lying states of 30,31 Na inside the 𝑁 = 20 island of inversion

Near the 𝛽-stability line, nuclei with magic numbers are expected to exhibit spherical ground states. However, mass measurements of neutron-rich nuclei near the 𝑁 = 20 island of inversion have indicated an excess in the binding energies. These results, together with subsequent spectroscopic studies and theoretical works, point to the structural evolution from normal configurations to intruder-deformed configurations characterized by particle-hole excitations across the shell gap. Despite evidence of intruder-dominant ground states for the 30,31 Na isotopes in the vicinity of 𝑁 = 20, a question remains as to whether the deformation persists into the ground-state bands beyond the first excited states. Here, in this work, we report on a heavy-ion inelastic scattering measurement performed with GRETINA, the TRIPLEX device, and the S800 spectrograph to study the low-lying excitations in neutron-rich 30,31 Na . The observed gamma rays for the (4 + ) → (3 + ), (3 + ) → 2$^+_{g.s.}$, and (4 + ) → 2$^+_{g.s.}$ decays in 30 Na and for the (7/2 + ) → (5/2 + ) and (5/2 + )→3/2$^+_{g.s.}$ decays in 31 Na were used to extract the reduced transition probabilities 𝐵⁡(𝐸⁢2↑). We report the first measurement of the 𝐵⁡(𝐸⁢2↑) between the 3/2$^+_{g.s.}$ and the (7/2 + ) states in 31 Na . The results from this study are compared to shell-model calculations, confirming the persistence of large collectivity in the low-lying excited states consistent with the formation of the well-deformed ground-state bands in 30,31 Na .

collective models↗