Myth and Reality in Hydrogeological Site Characterization at DD and R Sites
The science of hydrogeological site characterization has made significant progress over the last twenty years. Progress has been made in modeling of flow and transport in the heterogeneous subsurface, in understanding of the complex patterns of geological heterogeneity and in measurement technologies. Modeling of uncertainty has also advanced significantly, in recognition of the inherent limitations of subsurface characterization. Much less progress has been made in transforming this progress into practice, where characterization is determined to a large extent by regulations. Environmental regulations have not progressed as much as the science, for example, in recognizing uncertainty. As such, practitioners are less inclined to adopt advanced, science-based solutions, this opening the door for myths and conflicts. Myths develop where the science base is perceived to be weak, whereas conflicts arise in the face of a disconnect between the science and the regulations. Myths translate to ad-hoc solutions and misplaced empiricism, as well as to unjustified reliance on field experience, to the detriment of D and DR. This paper explores the roots for this situation and identifies ideas that may help in bridging the gap between research and applications. A rational approach for DD and R is needed that will encourage innovation in site characterization, reduce costs and accelerate completion. Such an approach needs to include several elements. DD and R regulations need to recognize the various aspects of uncertainty inherent to site characterization, and as such, should be formulated using probabilistic concepts. One of the immediate benefits will be in allowing a gradual approach for data acquisition in DD and R sites: decisions can be made even under the most severe data limitations, and can be modified as additional data become available. The definition of risk is another major element. There is no universal definition of risk or of a methodology to define risk. Different sites justify different definitions, depending on many environmental, economical and social factors. Despite the lack of consensus, it seems that a good place to start is in fact to recognize that there is a room for all these factors, and a need to balance between them. As experience is gained, through research and discussions among DD and R stakeholders, this may become less of a challenge. Regulations need to recognize the possibility of developing alternative, site-specific characterization strategies based on the various length and time scales that define specific environmental problems, including length scales of heterogeneity, source dimensions and distance to environmental targets. For example, point and distributed sources justify different characterization strategies. Development of problem- or site-specific strategies will create the context for defining innovative efficient DD and R strategies. Innovation in characterization can will also follow from recognizing the specific physiological aspects of the toxins and the related uncertainty. This will open the door for improving risk characterization not only from the hydrologic perspective, but also form the physiologic one.