Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “methods - statistical”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 919 records · Page 51

A method for removing arm backscatter from EPID images

Purpose: To develop a method for removing the support arm backscatter from images acquired using current Varian electronic portal imaging devices (EPIDs).Methods: The effect of arm backscatter on EPID images was modeled using a kernel convolution method. The parameters of the model were optimized by comparing on-arm images to off-arm images. The model was used to develop a method to remove the effect of backscatter from measured EPID images. The performance of the backscatter removal method was tested by comparing backscatter corrected on-arm images to measured off-arm images for 17 rectangular fields of different sizes and locations on the imager. The method was also tested using on- and off-arm images from 42 intensity modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) fields.Results: Images generated by the backscatter removal method gave consistently better agreement with off-arm images than images without backscatter correction. For the 17 rectangular fields studied, the root mean square difference of in-plane profiles compared to off-arm profiles was reduced from 1.19% (standard deviation 0.59%) on average without backscatter removal to 0.38% (standard deviation 0.18%) when using the backscatter removal method. When comparing to the off-arm images from the 42 IMRT fields, the mean {gamma} and percentage of pixels with {gamma} < 1 were improved by the backscatter removal method in all but one of the images studied. The mean {gamma} value (1%, 1 mm) for the IMRT fields studied was reduced from 0.80 to 0.57 by using the backscatter removal method, while the mean {gamma} pass rate was increased from 72.2% to 84.6%.Conclusions: A backscatter removal method has been developed to estimate the image acquired by the EPID without any arm backscatter from an image acquired in the presence of arm backscatter. The method has been shown to produce consistently reliable results for a wide range of field sizes and jaw configurations.

62 RADIOLOGY AND NUCLEAR MEDICINE↗

Novel methods for the time-dependent Maxwell's equations and their applications

This dissertation investigates three different mathematical models based on the time-domain Maxwell's equations using three different numerical methods: a Yee scheme using a non-uniform grid, a nodal discontinuous Galerkin (nDG) method, and a newly developed discontinuous Galerkin method named the weak Galerkin (WG) method. The non-uniform Yee scheme is first applied to an electromagnetic metamaterial model. Stability and superconvergence error results are proved for the method, which are then confirmed through numerical results. Additionally, a numerical simulation of backwards wave propagation through a negative-index metamaterial is given using the presented method. Next, the nDG method is used to simulate signal propagation through a corrugated coaxial cable through the use of axisymmetric Maxwell's equations. Stability and error analysis are performed for the semi-discrete method, and are verified through numerical results. The nDG method is then used to simulate signal propagation through coaxial cables with a number of different corrugations. Finally, the WG method is developed for the standard time-domain Maxwell's equations. Similar to the other methods, stability and error analysis are performed on the method and are verified through a number of numerical experiments.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Involute Working Group – FSI Analysis of Fuel Plates Using Finite Volume and Finite Element Methods

The three involute plate research reactors RHF, HFIR, and FRM II have expressed an interest in using computational software to carry their steady-state safety analysis. Since these tools represent a significant departure from the methods used currently (one-dimensional), the acceptability of the new approach by regulators requires thorough verification and validation of these tools. Therefore, Argonne National Laboratory and the three involute-plate reactors formed an informal group called the Involute Working Group aiming at qualifying computational tools to perform steady-state safety analysis. The present report focuses on a comparison of finite volume and finite element methods to model solids in fluid-structure interaction problems with the goal to estimate the coolant flow-induced fuel plate deflections obtained with the two methods. The finite volume method will be obsoleted in STARCCM+ by the end of 2021, nevertheless, this evaluation is important because the method was used by ANL researchers to model the response of the fuel plates, despite its drawbacks, which are discussed in the report. It was essential to check how those estimates compare to the results obtained with the finite element method that is considered superior for structural analysis. Various geometries, i.e., flat, cylindrical and circle-involute fuel plates, as well as coolant flow speed, were considered. The comparison shows that, independently of the plate geometry, the finite volume method significantly underestimates the deflection as compared to finite element method for coarser meshes. When the discretization is developed as a result of a mesh sensitivity study using finite element method, the result obtained using finite volume method can be a few times smaller than the corresponding finite element method solution. A code-to-code comparison , between STAR-CCM+ and LS-DYNA was included in the analysis. Within the LS-DYNA models, two types of finite element formulations were used: solid and shell finite elements. Mesh sensitivity study showed that both approaches converge to a similar value that was obtained with STAR-CCM+ finite element solver. The evaluation of the computational solvers was extended by adding two benchmark cases from the STAR-CCM+ Verification Suite and presented in the Appendix A. The selected cases are: (1) bending of a cantilever beam under external load, and (2) cylindrical shell deformation analysis, known in the literature as ‘Scordelis-Lo roof’. The problems were solved with finite volume, and finite element methods, and the results confirmed the previously discussed findings. The analysis shows that the finite element solver is superior to the finite volume solver in terms of representation of model geometry and estimating the structural behavior of fuel plates. Depending on the ratio of the load to the flexibility of the plate, the finite volume solver can greatly under- or overestimate the structural response if a very carefully selected mesh is not used.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Solving the Bateman equations in CASMO5 using implicit ode numerical methods for stiff systems

The Bateman equations, which describe the transmutation of nuclides over time as a result of radioactive decay, absorption, and fission, are often numerically stiff. This is especially true if short-lived nuclides are included in the system. This paper describes the use of implicit numerical methods for o D Es applied to the stiff Bateman equations, specifically employing the Backward Differentiation Formulas (BDF) form of the linear multistep method. As is true in other domains, using an implicit method removes or lessens the (sometimes severe) step-length constraints by which explicit methods must abide. To gauge its accuracy and speed, the BDF method is compared to a variety of other solution methods, including Runge-Kutta explicit methods and matrix exponential methods such as the Chebyshev Rational Approximation Method (CRAM). A preliminary test case was chosen as representative of a PWR lattice depletion step and was solved with numerical libraries called from a Python front-end. The Figure of Merit (a combined measure of accuracy and efficiency) for the BDF method was nearly identical to that for CRAM, while explicit methods and other matrix exponential approximations trailed behind. The test case includes 319 nuclides, in which the shortest-lived nuclide is {sup 98}Nb with a half-life of 2.86 seconds. Finally, the BDF and CRAM methods were compared within CASMO5, where CRAM had a FOM about four times better than BDF, although the BDF implementation was not fully optimized. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Geometric multigrid for an implicit-time immersed boundary method

The immersed boundary (IB) method is an approach to fluid-structure interaction that uses Lagrangian variables to describe the deformations and resulting forces of the structure and Eulerian variables to describe the motion and forces of the fluid. Explicit time stepping schemes for the IB method require solvers only for Eulerian equations, for which fast Cartesian grid solution methods are available. Such methods are relatively straightforward to develop and are widely used in practice but often require very small time steps to maintain stability. Implicit-time IB methods permit the stable use of large time steps, but efficient implementations of such methods require significantly more complex solvers that effectively treat both Lagrangian and Eulerian variables simultaneously. Moreover, several different approaches to solving the coupled Lagrangian-Eulerian equations have been proposed, but a complete understanding of this problem is still emerging. This paper presents a geometric multigrid method for an implicit-time discretization of the IB equations. This multigrid scheme uses a generalization of box relaxation that is shown to handle problems in which the physical stiffness of the structure is very large. Numerical examples are provided to illustrate the effectiveness and efficiency of the algorithms described herein. Finally, these tests show that using multigrid as a preconditioner for a Krylov method yields improvements in both robustness and efficiency as compared to using multigrid as a solver. They also demonstrate that with a time step 100–1000 times larger than that permitted by an explicit IB method, the multigrid-preconditioned implicit IB method is approximately 50–200 times more efficient than the explicit method.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Variational multiscale element-free Galerkin method combined with the moving Kriging interpolation for solving some partial differential equations with discontinuous solutions

Solving partial differential equations with discontinuous solutions is an important challenging problem in numerical analysis. To this end, there are some methods such as finite volume method, discontinuous Galerkin approach and particle technique that are able to solve these problems. In the current paper, the moving Kriging element-free Galerkin method has been combined with the variational multiscale algorithm to obtain acceptable and high-resolution solutions. For testing this technique, we select some PDEs with discontinuous solution such as Burgers’, Sod’s shock tube, advection–reaction–diffusion, Kuramoto–Sivashinsky, Boussinesq and shallow water equations. First, we obtain a time-discrete scheme by approximating time derivative via finite difference technique. Then we introduce the moving Kriging interpolation and also obtain their shape functions. We use the element-free Galerkin method for approximating the spatial derivatives. This method uses a weak form of the considered equation that is similar to the finite element method with the difference that in the classical element-free Galerkin method test and trial functions are moving least squares approximation (MLS) shape functions. Since the shape functions of moving least squares (MLS) approximation do not have Kronecker delta property, we cannot implement the essential boundary condition, directly. Thus, we employ the shape functions of moving Kriging interpolation and radial point interpolation technique which have the mentioned property. Also, in the element-free Galekin method, we do not use any triangular, quadrangular or other type of meshes. The element-free Galerkin method is a global method while finite element method is a local one. This technique employs a background mesh for integration which makes it different from the truly mesh procedures. Several test problems are solved and numerical simulations are reported which confirm the efficiency of the proposed schemes.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

A harmonic polynomial cell (HPC) method for 3D Laplace equation with application in marine hydrodynamics

We propose a new efficient and accurate numerical method based on harmonic polynomials to solve boundary value problems governed by 3D Laplace equation. The computational domain is discretized by overlapping cells. Within each cell, the velocity potential is represented by the linear superposition of a complete set of harmonic polynomials, which are the elementary solutions of Laplace equation. By its definition, the method is named as Harmonic Polynomial Cell (HPC) method. The characteristics of the accuracy and efficiency of the HPC method are demonstrated by studying analytical cases. Comparisons will be made with some other existing boundary element based methods, e.g. Quadratic Boundary Element Method (QBEM) and the Fast Multipole Accelerated QBEM (FMA-QBEM) and a fourth order Finite Difference Method (FDM). To demonstrate the applications of the method, it is applied to some studies relevant for marine hydrodynamics. Sloshing in 3D rectangular tanks, a fully-nonlinear numerical wave tank, fully-nonlinear wave focusing on a semi-circular shoal, and the nonlinear wave diffraction of a bottom-mounted cylinder in regular waves are studied. The comparisons with the experimental results and other numerical results are all in satisfactory agreement, indicating that the present HPC method is a promising method in solving potential-flow problems. The underlying procedure of the HPC method could also be useful in other fields than marine hydrodynamics involved with solving Laplace equation.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

An extension of the localized artificial diffusivity method for immiscible and high density ratio flows

The localized artificial diffusivity (LAD) method is widely regarded as the preferred multi-material regularization scheme for the compact finite difference method, because it is conservative, easy to implement, and generally robust for a wide range of multi-material problems. However, traditional LAD methods face significant challenges when applied to flows with large density ratios and when maintaining thermodynamic equilibrium across material interfaces. These limitations arise from the formulation of the artificial diffusivity flux and the reliance on enthalpy diffusion for interface regularization. Additionally, traditional LAD methods struggle to ensure stability under large density ratio conditions, fail to maintain a finite interface thickness, and are therefore unsuitable for modeling immiscible interfaces. Here, in this work, we discuss the origins of these issues in traditional LAD methods and propose modifications which enable the simulation of large density ratio and immiscible flows. The proposed method targets the artificial diffusion fluxes at gradients and ringing in the volume fraction, rather than the mass fraction in traditional methods, to consistently regularize large density ratio interfaces. Furthermore, the proposed method introduces an artificial bulk density diffusion term to enforce equilibrium conditions across interfaces. To address the challenge of modeling immiscible flows, a conservative diffuse interface term is incorporated into the formulation to ensure a finite interface thickness. Specific consideration is taken in the design of the method to ensure that these crucial properties are maintained for N -material flows. The effectiveness of the proposed method is demonstrated through a series of canonical test cases, and its accuracy is validated by comparison with experimental data on micro-bubble collapse in water. These results highlight the method’s robustness and its ability to overcome the limitations of traditional LAD approaches.

Artificial diffusivity↗

Hermite analogs of the lowest order Raviart–Thomas mixed method for convection–diffusion equations

The Raviart–Thomas mixed finite-element method of the lowest order (Raviart and Thomas in mixed finite-element methods for second-order elliptic problems, Lecture Notes in mathematics, Springer, New York, 1977) commonly known as the RT{sub 0} method, is a well-established and popular numerical tool to solve diffusion-like problems providing flux continuity across inter-element boundaries. Douglas and Roberts extended the method to the case of more general second-order boundary-value problems including the convection–diffusion equations (cf. this journal Douglas in Comput Appl Math 1:91–103; 1982). The main drawback of these methods, however, is the poor representation of the primal variable by piecewise constant functions. The Hermite analog of the RT{sub 0} method for treating pure diffusion phenomena proposed in Ruas (J Comput Appl Math, 246:234–242; 2013) proved to be a valid alternative to attain higher order approximation of the primal variable while keeping intact the matrix structure and the quality of the discrete flux variable of the original RT{sub 0} method. Non-trivial extensions of this method are studied here that can be viewed as Hermite analogs of the two Douglas and Roberts’ versions of the RT{sub 0} method, to solve convection–diffusion equations. A detailed convergence study is carried out for one of the Hermite methods, and numerical results illustrate the performance of both of them, as compared to each other and to the corresponding mixed methods.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Subplane collision probabilities method applied to control rod cusping in 2D/1D

The MPACT code is being jointly developed by the University of Michigan and Oak Ridge National Laboratory. It uses the 2D/1D method to solve neutron transport problems for reactors. The 2D/1D method decomposes the problem into a stack of 2D planes, and uses a high fidelity transport method to resolve all heterogeneity in each plane. These planes are then coupled axially using a lower order solver. Using this scheme, 3D solutions to the transport equation can be obtained at a much lower cost.One assumption made by the 2D/1D method is that the materials are axially homogeneous for each 2D plane. Violation of this assumption requires homogenization, which can significantly reduce the accuracy of the calculation. This paper presents two new subgrid methods to address this issue. The first method is polynomial decusping, a simple correction used to address control rods partially inserted into a 2D plane. The second is the subplane collision probabilities method, which is a more accurate, more robust subgrid method that can be applied to other axial heterogeneities.Each method was applied to a variety of problems. Results were compared to fine mesh solutions which had no axial heterogeneity and to Monte Carlo reference solutions generated using KENO-VI. It was shown that the polynomial decusping method was effective in many cases, but it had some limitations, with 3D pin power errors as high as 25% compared to KENO-VI. In conclusion, the subplane collision probabilities method performed much better, lowering the maximum pin power error to less than 5% in every calculation.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Impacts of building geometry modeling methods on the simulation results of urban building energy models

We present that urban-scale building energy modeling (UBEM)—using building modeling to understand how a group of buildings will perform together—is attracting increasing attention in the energy modeling field. Unlike modeling a single building, which will use detailed information, UBEM generally uses existing building stock data consisting of high-level building information. This study evaluated the impacts of three zoning methods and the use of floor multipliers on the simulated energy use of 940 office and retail buildings in three climate zones using City Building Energy Saver. The first zoning method, OneZone, creates one thermal zone per floor using the target building's footprint. The second zoning method, AutoZone, splits the building's footprint into perimeter and core zones. A novel, pixel-based automatic zoning algorithm is developed for the AutoZone method. The third zoning method, Prototype, uses the U.S. Department of Energy's reference building prototype shapes. Results show that simulated source energy use of buildings with the floor multiplier are marginally higher by up to 2.6% than those modeling each floor explicitly, which take two to three times longer to run. Compared with the AutoZone method, the OneZone method results in decreased thermal loads and less equipment capacities: 15.2% smaller fan capacity, 11.1% smaller cooling capacity, 11.0% smaller heating capacity, 16.9% less heating loads, and 7.5% less cooling loads. Source energy use differences range from -7.6% to 5.1%. When comparing the Prototype method with the AutoZone method, source energy use differences range from -12.1% to 19.0%, and larger ranges of differences are found for the thermal loads and equipment capacities. This study demonstrated that zoning methods have a significant impact on the simulated energy use of UBEM. Finally, one recommendation resulting from this study is to use the AutoZone method with floor multiplier to obtain accurate results while balancing the simulation run time for UBEM.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Assessment of diffuse-interface methods for compressible multiphase fluid flows and elastic-plastic deformation in solids

This work describes three diffuse-interface methods for the simulation of immiscible, compressible multiphase fluid flows and elastic-plastic deformation in solids. The first method is the localized-artificial-diffusivity approach of Cook, Subramaniam et al., and Adler and Lele, in which artificial diffusion terms are added to the individual phase mass fraction transport equations and are coupled with the other conservation equations. The second method is the gradient-form approach that is based on the quasi-conservative method of Shukla et al., in which the diffusion and sharpening terms (together called regularization terms) are added to the individual phase volume fraction transport equations and are coupled with the other conservation equations. The third approach is the divergence-form approach that is based on the fully conservative method of Jain et al., in which the regularization terms are added to the individual phase volume fraction transport equations and are coupled with the other conservation equations. In the present study, all three diffuse-interface methods are used in conjunction with a four-equation, multicomponent mixture model, in which pressure and temperature equilibria are assumed among the various phases. The primary objective of this work is to compare these three methods in terms of their ability to: maintain constant interface thickness throughout the simulation; conserve mass, momentum, and energy; and maintain accurate interface shape for long-time integration. The second objective of this work is to consistently extend these methods to model interfaces between solid materials with strength. To assess and compare the methods, they are used to simulate a wide variety of problems, including (1) advection of an air bubble in water, (2) shock interaction with a helium bubble in air, (3) shock interaction and the collapse of an air bubble in water, and (4) Richtmyer–Meshkov instability of a copper–aluminum interface. The current work focuses on comparing these methods in the limit of relatively coarse grid resolution, which illustrates the true performance of these methods. In conclusion, this is because it is rarely practical to use hundreds of grid points to resolve a single bubble or drop in large-scale simulations of engineering interest.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Comparison of Monte Carlo collimator transport methods for photon treatment planning in radiotherapy

Purpose: The aim of this work was a Monte Carlo (MC) based investigation of the impact of different radiation transport methods in collimators of a linear accelerator on photon beam characteristics, dose distributions, and efficiency. Thereby it is investigated if it is possible to use different simplifications in the radiation transport for some clinical situations in order to save calculation time. Methods: Within the Swiss Monte Carlo Plan, a GUI-based framework for photon MC treatment planning, different MC methods are available for the radiation transport through the collimators [secondary jaws and multileaf collimator (MLC)]: EGSnrc (reference), VMC++, and Pin (an in-house developed MC code). Additional nonfull transport methods were implemented in order to provide different complexity levels for the MC simulation: Considering collimator attenuation only, considering Compton scatter only or just the firstCompton process, and considering the collimators as totally absorbing. Furthermore, either a simple or an exact geometry of the collimators can be selected for the absorbing or attenuation method. Phasespaces directly above and dose distributions in a water phantom are analyzed for academic and clinical treatment fields using 6 and 15 MV beams, including intensity modulated radiation therapy with dynamic MLC. Results: For all MC transport methods, differences in the radial mean energy and radial energy fluence are within 1% inside the geometric field. Below the collimators, the energy fluence is underestimated for nonfull MC transport methods ranging from 5% for Compton to 100% for Absorbing. Gamma analysis using EGSnrc calculated doses as reference shows that the percentage of voxels fulfilling a 1% /1 mm criterion is at least 98% when using VMC++, Compton, or firstCompton transport methods. When using the methods Pin, Transmission, Flat-Transmission, Flat-Absorbing or Absorbing, the mean value of points fulfilling this criterion over all tested cases is 97%, 88%, 74%, 68%, or 65%, respectively. However, compared to EGSnrc calculations, the gain in efficiency is a factor of up to 10 for VMC++ and up to 48 for the absorbing method. Conclusions: The results of this investigation suggest that it is an option to use a simple transport technique in the initial treatment planning process and use more accurate transport methods for the final dose calculation accepting longer calculation times.

62 RADIOLOGY AND NUCLEAR MEDICINE↗

SU-C-9A-03: Simultaneous Deconvolution and Segmentation for PET Tumor Delineation Using a Variational Method

Purpose: To implement a new method that integrates deconvolution with segmentation under the variational framework for PET tumor delineation. Methods: Deconvolution and segmentation are both challenging problems in image processing. The partial volume effect (PVE) makes tumor boundaries in PET image blurred which affects the accuracy of tumor segmentation. Deconvolution aims to obtain a PVE-free image, which can help to improve the segmentation accuracy. Conversely, a correct localization of the object boundaries is helpful to estimate the blur kernel, and thus assist in the deconvolution. In this study, we proposed to solve the two problems simultaneously using a variational method so that they can benefit each other. The energy functional consists of a fidelity term and a regularization term, and the blur kernel was limited to be the isotropic Gaussian kernel. We minimized the energy functional by solving the associated Euler-Lagrange equations and taking the derivative with respect to the parameters of the kernel function. An alternate minimization method was used to iterate between segmentation, deconvolution and blur-kernel recovery. The performance of the proposed method was tested on clinic PET images of patients with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, and compared with seven other segmentation methods using the dice similarity index (DSI) and volume error (VE). Results: Among all segmentation methods, the proposed one (DSI=0.81, VE=0.05) has the highest accuracy, followed by the active contours without edges (DSI=0.81, VE=0.25), while other methods including the Graph Cut and the Mumford-Shah (MS) method have lower accuracy. A visual inspection shows that the proposed method localizes the real tumor contour very well. Conclusion: The result showed that deconvolution and segmentation can contribute to each other. The proposed variational method solve the two problems simultaneously, and leads to a high performance for tumor segmentation in PET. This work was supported in part by National Natural Science Foundation of China (NNSFC), under Grant Nos. 60971112 and 61375018, and Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities, under Grant No. 2012QN086. Wei Lu was supported in part by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) Grant No. R01 CA172638.

62 RADIOLOGY AND NUCLEAR MEDICINE↗

Comparison of Infiltration Test Methods for Soil Health Assessment

Infiltration rate (IR) has been commonly used as a metric to evaluate soil quality and health. For the USDA Soil Quality Test Kit, a 15-cm (6-in) diameter (ID) cylinder is used to measure IR with 444 cm 3 (equivalent to 2.54 cm or 1 in) of water while other standard IR procedures require substantially larger volumes of water. The general objective of this study was to compare different methods for IR measurement. Using three replications, IR measurements were conducted along a 9-m (27-ft) long transect in two different soil types by the double-ring infiltrometer (DRI) using 25- and 50-cm (10-and 20-in, respectively) cylinders, single-ring infiltrometer (SRI) using 25- and 50-cm cylinders, Cornell sprinkle infiltrometer (CSI) using a 24.1-cm (9.5-in) cylinder, the USDA recommended procedure using a 15-cm diameter cylinder (hereafter referred to as USDA-15 method), and a modified USDA method using a 24.1-cm diameter cylinder. Although the USDA-15 method is simple and requires a small amount of water, based on high variability among replications and significant reduction in IR during early stages of water entry into the soil, the procedure does not offer an accurate estimate of the soil infiltration potential. The CSI procedure was reproducible, but it is more cumbersome to perform than other methods. The DRI, SRI, and CSI methods required a much greater volume of water than the USDA-15 method but produced results that are more consistent. The most consistent results were obtained by the CSI and DRI methods. The modified USDA method results were similar to the SRI method and were an improvement over the original USDA-15 method. For assessing soil health, additional investigations should be conducted to evaluate a modified version of the USDA procedure using a larger cylinder.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Assessment of Multiple Monitoring Methods for Detection of Brine and CO2 Leakage

We assess the effectiveness of four surface-based geophysical methods and in situ monitoring of pressure and chemical changes for detecting brine and CO2 leakage from legacy wells into underground sources of drinking water (USDW) overlying a CO2 storage reservoir. This is the first such effort to evaluate and compare six monitoring methods for detection of CO2 leakage. This assessment, conducted in support of the USDOE National Risk Assessment Partnership (NRAP), utilizes 3000 synthetic data sets, generated in an uncertainty quantification (UQ) model framework. This framework combines the results of (1) a CO2 storage reservoir model of a hypothetical storage operation of 5 MT/yr for 50 years into the 1700-m deep Vedder Fm. at a site near Kimberlina, California with (2) wellbore leakage models of a legacy well and (3) multi-phase flow and reactive transport models of brine and CO2 plume migration in aquifer layers overlying the storage reservoir. Leakage drives subsurface changes, quantified by pressure plumes, CO2-saturation plumes, and total dissolved solids (TDS) plumes, the latter being related to changes in pH and species concentrations. Depending on the depth of leakage, aquifer permeability, and regional groundwater gradient, pressure plume volumes can become larger than the CO2 and TDS plumes; however, reaching detectable thresholds may take too long to be useful. For a single monitoring well located 500 m downgradient of a leaky legacy well, a depth of 570 m is found to be optimal for sampling pressure and chemical changes. We assess four surface-based geophysical monitoring methods: electrical resistivity tomography (ERT), magnetotellurics (MT), gravity, and seismic methods. Sensors cover a 4-km × 2-km area. Both ERT and MT methods are sensitive to changes in CO2 saturation and TDS concentration, whereas gravity and seismic methods detect changes in CO2 saturation. The six monitoring methods complement each other in space and time, and we find that a minimum of 20 kT of CO2 leakage is required for the leakage plume to be detected. Of the four surface-based geophysical methods, gravity monitoring appears to be the most sensitive to CO2 leaks, while the usefulness of in situ pressure and chemical monitoring will depend on the level of unfilterable background noise. Geophysical monitoring methods may detect a leak anywhere in a large area and in a large depth range, but the effectiveness of pressure and chemical monitoring depends on the number of monitoring wells, where those wells are located, and the depth of sampling. Surface-based geophysical monitoring methods are cost-effective alternatives to in situ pressure and chemical monitoring methods.

NRAP, CCS, monitoring, geophysical methods, gravit↗

Extending the subspace hybrid method for eigenvalue problems in reactor physics calculation

This paper presents an innovative hybrid Monte-Carlo-Deterministic method denoted by the SUBSPACE method designed for improving the efficiency of hybrid methods for reactor analysis applications. The SUBSPACE method achieves its high computational efficiency by taking advantage of the existing correlations between desired responses. Recently, significant gains in computational efficiency have been demonstrated using this method for source driven problems. Within this work the mathematical theory behind the SUBSPACE method is introduced and extended to address core wide level k-eigenvalue problems. The method's efficiency is demonstrated based on a three-dimensional quarter-core problem, where responses are sought on the pin cell level. The SUBSPACE method is compared to the FW-CADIS method and is found to be more efficient for the utilized test problem because of the reason that the FW-CADIS method solves a forward eigenvalue problem and an adjoint fixed-source problem while the SUBSPACE method only solves an adjoint fixed-source problem. Based on the favorable results obtained here, we are confident that the applicability of Monte Carlo for large scale reactor analysis could be realized in the near future. (authors)

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

A Comparison of the FW-CADIS and MR-CADIS Variance Reduction Methods

The Consistent Adjoint Driven Importance Sampling (CADIS) method, which uses an adjoint deterministic estimate for making variance reduction parameters that optimize Monte Carlo (MC) shielding calculations, was introduced in 1998. This method was designed to optimize a single tally, typically an integrated response such as a detector count rate or a dose rate. Because both deterministic and stochastic methods are employed, CADIS is referred to as a hybrid method. In 2007, the forward-weighted CADIS (FW-CADIS) method was introduced to optimize several tallies at once, giving more uniform relative uncertainties among the tallies for both high-flux and low-flux areas of the problem. This method can be used for several small detectors, for semi-global problems (mesh tally over a large fraction of the problem), or for global problems (mesh tally over the entire problem). Optimization can be done for an integrated response such as a dose rate D(r) as a function of position, the total flux {phi}(r) as a function of position, or the space/energy flux {phi}(r,E). Both the CADIS and FW-CADIS methods have been in the MAVRIC sequence of SCALE for three versions (6.0 in 2009, 6.1 in 2011, and 6.2 in 2016). The ADVANTG package released in 2015 uses the CADIS and FW-CADIS methods to accelerate MCNP neutron/photon shielding calculations. In 2014, the multi-response CADIS (MR-CADIS) method was presented as a way to obtain even more uniform relative uncertainties for problems with multiple tallies than those obtained with FW-CADIS. The method does not use a forward deterministic calculation but instead uses one adjoint calculation for every tally to be optimized in the Monte Carlo calculation. This work compares the above methods.

42 ENGINEERING↗