Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “splitting methods”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 937 records · Page 52

Energy bands: Chern numbers and symmetry

Energy bands formed by rotation-vibrational states of molecules in the presence of symmetry and their qualitative modifications under variation of some control parameters are studied within the semi-quantum model. Rotational variables are treated as classical whereas a finite set of vibrational states is considered as quantum. In the two-state approximation the system is described in terms of a fiber bundle with the base space being a two-dimensional sphere, the classical phase space for rotational variables. Generically this rank 2 complex vector bundle can be decomposed into two complex line bundles characterized by a topological invariant, the first Chern class. A general method of explicit calculation of Chern classes and of their possible modifications under variation of control parameters in the presence of symmetry is suggested. The construction of iso-Chern diagrams which split the space of control parameters into connected domains with fixed Chern numbers is suggested. A detailed analysis of the rovibrational model Hamiltonian for a D{sub 3} invariant molecule possessing two vibrational states transforming according to the two-dimensional irreducible representation is done to illustrate non-trivial restrictions imposed by symmetry on possible values of Chern classes. - Highlights: > Complex line bundles associated with eigenvalues of 2x2 Hermitian matrix Hamiltonians. > Hamiltonians are defined on the 2-sphere and invariant under symmetry groups. > Symmetry permits only some special integers as Chern numbers. > For SO(2) symmetry, the possible values are 0, {+-}K, where K is an index of the representation. > For D{sub 3} symmetry, the possible values are {+-}2, {+-}4 within our model Hamiltonians.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

Design Considerations and Analysis of Multi-Level Erasure Coding in Large-Scale Data Centers

Multi-level erasure coding (MLEC) has seen large deployments in the field, but there is no in-depth study of design considerations for MLEC at scale. In this paper, we provide comprehensive design considerations and analysis of MLEC at scale. We introduce the design space of MLEC in multiple dimensions, including various code parameter selections, chunk placement schemes, and various repair methods. We quantify their performance and durability, and show which MLEC schemes and repair methods can provide the best tolerance against independent/correlated failures and reduce repair network traffic by orders of magnitude. To achieve this, we use various evaluation strategies including simulation, splitting, dynamic programming, and mathematical modeling. We also compare the performance and durability of MLEC with other EC schemes such as SLEC and LRC and show that MLEC can provide high durability with higher encoding throughput and less repair network traffic over both SLEC and LRC.

Wang, Meng↗

Low-Cost Preform and Molding Processes

The entry cost for prototyping a composite component for manufacture using automated, high rate processes is prohibitively expensive in many cases, especially for small business, where tooling costs may be several $100k. Discussions with industry also indicate that many small companies, tier 1 and 2 suppliers, have an interest to mold composite parts but do not want to deal with the capital cost, material handling issues, and labor associated with dry fiber preforming operations. While the molders may locate near the end user for logistics reasons, it may be more cost effective for the performer to remain regional and invest in capital equipment to support preform automation, thus keeping costs to a minimum. This project was designed to explore and demonstrate several options to meet these industry needs. Dry fiber preforming approaches were evaluated which allow for low pressure resin infusion, single sided tooling options such a vacuum assisted resin transfer molding (VARTM) or low pressure resin transfer molding (RTM-light). Unlike sheet molding compound, SMC compression molding where typical molding pressures of 1000 psi are required to push material into the desired location; positioning of a dry fiber preform into the desired location on the tool allows for low molding pressures of 10-50 psi. Lower molding pressures allow for use of low cost, additive fabrication of polymeric tooling. Polymeric tooling is suitable for rapid part prototyping and limited production. Dry fiber preforming approaches evaluated included use of commercial chopped strand mat, robotic chopper gun deposition, and continuous fiber preform augmentation using tailored fiber placement (TFP). Use of chopped strand mat does not require a robotic deposition method, however a cutting table is generally required and there is typically 20-30% scrap generation. While various fiber areal weights are available, the preform is not readily optimized for minimal fiber use or weight savings. In contrast, a robotic chopper gun approach allows for localized deposition where fiber is required to meet structural requirements. The robotic method is highly automated and minimizes fiber scrap, however the capital cost of the equipment and engineering labor for programming can result in higher preform cost compared to chopped strand mat in certain cases depending on preform complexity. Dry fiber preforming using the robotic chopper gun method allows for creation of three dimensional forms. This approach may be ideal for molding in-house, or if the preforms stack together densely to allow for efficient shipping. Applications evaluated for this program considered trade-off between fabrication of a fully 3D preform versus production of a flat preform which is designed to readily drape into the final desired shape. Such a preform design greatly simplifies robotic programming and requires no specialized tooling. The flat preforms are easily stacked and shipped to the final molding location. Flat preforms are much easier to augment with TFP continuous fiber to provide local reinforcement. The demonstration and evaluation of these preforming and tooling methods were completed on three component applications. The first application was a battery box cover for an electric vehicle which was highly three dimensional. The second demonstrator article was comprised of complex contours and was used to demonstrate the use of TFP and RTM-light molding process. The third demonstration article was the roof of an operator’s cab for large construction equipment. The roof is relatively flat however it is comprised of complex changes in thickness which clearly demonstrate the advantage of robotic chopper gun approach as compared to using numerous preform layers of chopped strand mat. The cost trades for the various preforming methods are summarized to help guide the reader as to preforming method considerations. Finally, these demonstrations all used glass fiber roving. A fourth, exploratory task was added to evaluate the ability to make preforms using Zoltek’s carbon fiber split tow roving. We were able to adapt the chopper gun to make flat preforms for laminate testing, but further development effort would be required to make suitable preforms.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Event Reconstruction in the NOvA Experiment

The NOvA experiment observes oscillations in two channels (electron-neutrino appearance and muon-neutrino disappearance) using a predominantly muon-neutrino NuMI beam. The Near Detector records multiple overlapping neutrino interactions in each event and the Far Detector has a large background of cosmic rays due to being located on the surface. The oscillation analyses rely on the accurate reconstruction of neutrino interactions in order to precisely measure the neutrino energy and identify the neutrino flavor and interaction mode. Similarly, measurements of neutrino cross sections using the Near Detector require accurate identification of the particle content of each interaction. A series of pattern recognition techniques have been developed to split event records into individual spatially and temporally separated interactions, to estimate the interaction vertex, and to isolate and classify individual particles within the event. This combination of methods to achieve full event reconstruction in the NOvA detectors has discussed.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Sustainable Oxide Electrocatalyst for Hydrogen- and Oxygen-Evolution Reactions

In this work, an electrocatalyst for water splitting based on earth-abundant metals is reported. This perovskite-oxide catalyst, CaSrFe 0.75 Co 0.75 Mn 0.5 O 6-δ (CSFCM), is examined using both experimental and computational methods. It demonstrates a combination of properties, which include (a) very high activity for the oxygen-evolution reaction with an overpotential of eta = 0.19 V at 10 mA/cm 2 , (b) high stability over 1000 cycles of catalysis, (c) the ability to catalyze the hydrogen-evolution reaction effectively in both acidic and basic conditions, and (d) catalytic activity as a single-phase bulk material without the need for any additional processing, multicomponent composite preparation, or nanofabrication. Therefore, the catalytic activity of CSFCM is intrinsic, making it a good benchmark compound for future studies of electrocatalytic parameters. This work also highlights the impact of systematic structural design on electrocatalytic activity. Results from density functional theory calculations indicate that in addition to an optimal e g occupancy of similar to 1, an additional descriptor, i.e., maximizing the number of free e g carriers, correlates with the electrocatalytic activity.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Band structures and Z 2 invariants of two-dimensional transition metal dichalcogenide monolayers from fully relativistic Dirac-Kohn-Sham theory using Gaussian-type orbitals

Two-dimensional (2D) materials exhibit a wide range of remarkable phenomena, many of which owe their existence to the relativistic spin-orbit coupling (SOC) effects. To understand and predict properties of materials containing heavy elements, such as the transition-metal dichalcogenides (TMDs), relativistic effects must be taken into account in first-principles calculations. We present an all-electron method based on the four-component Dirac Hamiltonian and Gaussian-type orbitals (GTOs) that overcomes complications associated with linear dependencies and ill-conditioned matrices that arise when diffuse functions are included in the basis. Until now, there has been no systematic study of the convergence of GTO basis sets for periodic solids either at the nonrelativistic or the relativistic level. Here, in this study, we provide such a study of relativistic band structures of the 2D TMDs in the hexagonal (2H), tetragonal (1T), and distorted tetragonal (1T') structures, along with a discussion of their SOC-driven properties (Rashba splitting and Z 2 topological invariants). We demonstrate the viability of our approach even when large basis sets with multiple basis functions involving various valence orbitals (denoted triple- and quadruple-ζ) are used in the relativistic regime. Our method does not require the use of pseudopotentials and provides access to all electronic states within the same framework. Our study paves the way for direct studies of material properties, such as the parameters in spin Hamiltonians, that depend heavily on the electron density near atomic nuclei where relativistic and SOC effects are the strongest.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Description of superheavy nuclei on the basis of a modified version of the DF3 energy functional

The possibility of describing nuclei of the uranium and transuranium region within the generalized method of the energy functional proposed by Fayans and his coauthors is studied. It turned out that, in the functional DF3, it is necessary, for this purpose, to modify the spin-orbit terms whose parameters were chosen in such a way as to describe the binding energies and charge radii of spherical nuclei from calcium to lead. The modified functional (DF3-a) describes well the energy features and charged radii for isotopic chains of uranium and neighboring elements. For deformed nuclei, the deformation was taken into account approximately. The nucleon-drip-line position obtained for these chains proved to be close to the predictions of one of the most successful calculations by the Skyrme-Hartree-Fock method with the HFB-17 functional. It is verified that the use of the functional DF3-a does not impair the description of the properties of lighter nuclei, for which the functional DF3 was devised. Moreover, the modified functional describes better, than the original one, new data on spin-orbit splitting in magic and semimagic nuclei. The calculation with the functional DF3-a confirms the doubly magic nature of the superheavy nuclide {sub 114}{sup 298}X{sub 184}. As for the neutron-separation energies S{sub n} along the isotopic chain of this element, our results are close to the predictions of the so-called micro-macro method.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

A high-order finite difference method for moving immersed domain boundaries and material interfaces

Here, we present a high-order sharp treatment of immersed moving domain boundaries and material interfaces, and apply it to the advection-diffusion equation in two and three dimensions. The spatial discretization combines dimension-split finite difference schemes with an immersed boundary treatment based on a weighted least-squares reconstruction of the solution, providing stable discretizations with up to sixth order accuracy for diffusion terms and third order accuracy for advection terms. The temporal discretization relies on a novel strategy for maintaining high-order temporal accuracy in problems with moving boundaries that minimizes implementation complexity and allows arbitrary explicit or diagonally-implicit Runge-Kutta schemes. The approach is broadly compatible with popular PDE-specialized Runge-Kutta time integrators, including low-storage, strong stability preserving, and diagonally implicit schemes. Through numerical experiments we demonstrate that the full discretization maintains high-order spatial and temporal accuracy in the presence of complex 3D geometries and for a range of boundary conditions, including Dirichlet, Neumann, and flux conditions with large jumps in coefficients.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

d{sup 0} Half-Metallic Ferromagnetism in CaN and CaAs Pnictides: an Ab Initio Study

Conventional magnetism occurs in systems which contain transition metals or rare earth ions with partially filled d or f shells. It is theoretically predicted that compounds of groups IA and IIA with IV and V, in some structural phases, are ferromagnetic half-metals which made them new candidates for spintronics applications. Employing density functional theory (DFT), we investigate magnetism in binary compounds CaN and CaAs. Regarding the structure of analogous magnetic materials and experimental results of CaAs synthesis, we have considered two cubic structures: rocksalt (RS) and zincblende (ZB), and four hexagonal structures: NiAs, wurtzite (WZ), anti-NiAs, and NaO. The calculated results show that CaN in cubic, NiAs, and wurtzite structures, and CaAs only in zincblende phase have ferromagnetic ground states with a magnetic moment of 1 μ{sub B}. Electronic structure analysis of these materials indicates that magnetism originates from anion p states. Existence of flat p bands and consequently high density of states at the Fermi level of magnetic structures gives rise to Stoner spin splitting and spontaneous ferromagnetism.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Atomic Structure and Cohesion Energy of ZnSe and CdSe Clusters

The first-principle calculations of the atomic and electronic structures of fullerene-like Zn{sub n}Se{sub n} and Cd{sub n}Se{sub n} have been carried out for n = 12, 36, 48, and 60. A model of two-layer fullerene-like (ZnSe){sub 60} and (CdSe){sub 60} clusters with mixed sp{sup 2}/sp{sup 3} bonds has been built for the first time. Ab initio calculations are performed in terms of the electron density functional and the hybrid B3LYP functional theory. The stability and the energy gap width of the clusters are estimated in the dependence on the number of atoms in a cluster and its geometry. It is shown that the relaxation of 1.7–1.8-nm two-layer (ZnSe){sub 60} and (CdSe){sub 60} clusters with mixed sp{sup 2}/sp{sup 3} bonds is accompanied by splitting out of the external layer.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Self-consistent description of electrokinetic phenomena in particle-based simulations

A new computational method is presented for study suspensions of charged particles undergoing fluctuating hydrodynamic and electrostatic interactions. The proposed model is appropriate for polymers, proteins, and porous particles embedded in a continuum electrolyte. A self-consistent Langevin description of the particles is adopted in which hydrodynamic and electrostatic interactions are included through a Green's function formalism. An Ewald-like split is adopted in order to satisfy arbitrary boundary conditions for the Stokeslet and Poisson Green functions, thereby providing a formalism that is applicable to any geometry and that can be extended to deformable objects. The convection-diffusion equation for the continuum ions is solved simultaneously considering Nernst-Planck diffusion. In conclusion, the method can be applied to systems at equilibrium and far from equilibrium. Its applicability is demonstrated in the context of electrokinetic motion, where it is shown that the ionic clouds associated with individual particles can be severely altered by the flow and concentration, leading to intriguing cooperative effects.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

The Kinetics and Thermodynamics of CO2 Capture by Aqueous Ammonia Derived Using Meta-GGA Density Functional Theory and Wavefunction-Based Model Chemistry Methods

A meta GGA-DFT study of CO{sub 2} activation in aqueous ammonia solutions, with an emphasis on the reaction barrier and molecularity, has been undertaken using the M06-2X functional with an augmented triple-zeta split-valence basis set (6-311++G(d,p)). Up to five base molecules were treated explicitly in order to establish the effects of solvent catalysis in the chemical capture process. Aqueous free energies of solvation were determined for optimized reactant and transition structures using SM8/M06-2X/6-311++G(d,p). The concept of the solvent pre-complex as presented by Dixon and coworkers (Nguyen, M. T.; Matus, M. H.; Jackson, V. E.; Ngan, V. T.; Rustad, J. R.; Dixon, D. A. J. Phys. Chem. A 2008, 112, 10386-10398) was exploited to account for the energetics of disruption of the hydrogen-bonding solvent nano-network prior to the CO{sub 2} activation step. Selected gas- and aqueous-phase thermodynamic quantities have also been derived.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Investigations on the multiple-sector hard-copper X-band accelerating structures

The development of advanced, high gradient accelerating structures is one of the leading activity of the particle accelerator community. In the technological research of new construction methods for these devices, high-power testing is a critical step for the verification of their viability. Recent experiments showed that accelerating cavities made out of hard copper, fabricated without high-temperature processes, can achieve better performance as compared with soft copper ones. Recently, we have built cavities using Tungsten Inert Gas welding and the high-power experiments confirmed that this joining process is a robust and low-cost alternative to brazing or diffusion bonding. This is a good solution for high-gradient operation, with a gradient of about 150 MV/m in X-band, at a breakdown rate of 10 -3 /pulse/meter using a shaped RF pulse with a 150 ns flat part. We continue the design, construction and high power tests of three-cells standing-wave X-band accelerating cavities fabricated with a split-open geometry, made of hard copper and vacuum-sealed by welding. Our aim is the fabrication of accelerating structures made out of hard copper alloys by using innovative cost-effective technologies. Moreover, our method of multiple-sector structures opens the way to new technological approaches and design methods, for example providing the possibility of placing dampers of the parasitic higher-order modes. Such structures with dampers allow for acceleration of multi-bunch beams, both in standing and in travelling-wave accelerating modality. Here, this paper describes the design of two cavities made of multiple sectors that were fabricated at the Italian Institute for Nuclear Physics in Frascati, Italy (INFN-LNF), assembled by means of clamping and then joined with the Tungsten Inert Gas welding in order to preserve the hardness of the metal. These are three-cell standing-wave X-band accelerating cavities, to be operated in the π-mode. We report the low-power RF tests of the first one, made of two halves, and the RF design of the second one, made of four quadrants. Both structures were built for high-gradient tests at SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Spectroscopy of charmed baryons from lattice QCD

We present the ground and excited state spectra of singly, doubly and triply charmed baryons by using dynamical lattice QCD. A large set of baryonic operators that respect the symmetries of the lattice and are obtained after subduction from their continuum analogues are utilized. Using novel computational techniques correlation functions of these operators are generated and the variational method is exploited to extract excited states. The lattice spectra that we obtain have baryonic states with well-defined total spins up to 7/2 and the low lying states remarkably resemble the expectations of quantum numbers from SU(6) x O(3) symmetry. Various energy splittings between the extracted states, including splittings due to hyperfine as well as spin-orbit coupling, are considered and those are also compared against similar energy splittings at other quark masses.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Flux Synthesis, Optical and Photocatalytic Properties of n -type Sn 2 TiO 4 : Hydrogen and Oxygen Evolution under Visible Light

Here, the n -type Sn 2 TiO 4 phase was synthesized using flux methods and found to have one of the smallest visible-light bandgap sizes known that also maintains suitable conduction and valence band energies for driving photocatalytic water-splitting reactions. The Sn 2 TiO 4 phase was synthesized using either a SnCl 2 flux or a SnCl 2 /SnF 2 peritectic flux in a 2:1 flux-to-precursor ratio heated at 600 and 400 °C for 24 h, respectively. The two types of salt fluxes resulted in large rod-shaped particles at 600 °C and smaller tetragonal prism-shaped particles at 400 °C. Surface photovoltage spectroscopy measurements produced a negative photovoltage under illumination >1.50 eV, which confirmed electrons as the majority charge carriers and ~1.50 eV as the effective band gap. Mott–Schottky measurements at pH 9.0 showed the conduction (–0.54 V vs NHE) and valence band (+1.01 V vs NHE) positions meet the critical thermodynamic requirements for total water splitting. The Sn 2 TiO 4 particles were deposited and annealed as polycrystalline films on FTO slides, and exhibited photoanodic currents in aqueous solutions under visible-light irradiation. The Sn 2 TiO 4 particles were also suspended in aqueous methanol solutions and irradiated with visible and ultraviolet light. The larger rod-shaped Sn 2 TiO 4 particles had the higher rates of photocatalytic hydrogen production (~11.6 μmol H 2 h –1 ) in comparison to the smaller tetragonal prism-shaped Sn 2 TiO 4 particles (~3.4 μmol H 2 h –1 ). Conversely, for photocatalytic oxygen production, the rates for the smaller tetragonal prism-shaped particles in aqueous AgNO 3 solution were slightly higher (~16.3 μmol O 2 h –1 ) than for the larger rod-shaped particles (~11.9 μmol O 2 h –1 ). Apparent quantum yields of 0.995% and 0.0098% were measured for O 2 and H 2 production, respectively, under 435 nm light.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Spectroscopic and Computational Studies of Spin States of Iron(IV) Nitrido and Imido Complexes

High-oxidation state metal complexes with multiply bonded ligands are of great interest for both their reactivity as well as their fundamental bonding properties. This paper reports a combined spectroscopic and theoretical investigation into the effect of the apical multiply bonded ligand on the spin state preferences of three-fold symmetric iron(IV) complexes with tris(carbene) donor ligands. Specifically, singlet (S = 0) nitrido [{PhB(Im R ) 3 }FeN], R = t Bu (1), Mes (mesityl, 2) and the related triplet (S = 1) imido complexes, [{PhB(Im R ) 3 }Fe(NR')] + , R = Mes, R' = Ad (1- adamantyl, 3), t Bu (4), have been investigated by electronic absorption and Mössbauer effect spectroscopies. For comparison, two other Fe(IV) nitrido complexes, [(TIMEN Ar )FeN] + , (TIMEN Ar = tris[2-(3-aryl-imidazol-2-ylidene)ethyl]amine; Ar = Xyl (xylyl), Mes), have been investigated by 57 Fe Mössbauer spectroscopy, including applied-field measurements. The paramagnetic imido complexes 3 and 4 were also studied by magnetic susceptibility measurements (for 3) and paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy: high-frequency and -field electron paramagnetic resonance (HFEPR) (for 3 and 4) and frequency-domain Fouriertransform (FD-FT) THz EPR (for 3), which reveal their zero-field splitting (zfs) parameters. Experimentally correlated theoretical studies comprising ligand-field theory (LFT) and quantum chemical theory (QCT), the latter including both density functional theory (DFT) and ab initio methods reveal the key role played by the Fe3 d z 2 (a1) orbital in these systems: the nature of its interaction with the nitrido or imido ligand dictates the spin state preference of the complex. Lastly, the ability to tune the spin state through the energy and nature of a single orbital has general relevance to the factors controlling spin states in complexes with applicability as single molecule devices.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Photon energy-resolved velocity map imaging from spectral domain ghost imaging

Abstract We present an approach that combines photon spectrum correlation analysis with the reconstruction of three-dimensional momentum distribution from velocity map images in an efficient, single-step procedure. We demonstrate its efficacy with the results from the photoionization of the 2 p -shell of argon using the Free-electron LASer in Hamburg free-electron laser (FEL). Distinct spectral features due to the spin-orbit splitting of Ar + ( 2 p − 1 ) are resolved, despite the large average bandwidth of the ionizing pulses from the FEL. This demonstrates a clear advantage over the conventional analysis method, and it will be broadly beneficial for velocity map imaging experiments with FEL sources. The retrieved linewidth of the binding energy spectrum approaches the resolution limitation prescribed by the spectrometers used to collect the data. Our approach presents a path to extend spectral-domain ghost imaging to the case where the photoproduct observable is high-dimensional.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗

Magnetic field dependent dynamics and field-driven metal-to-insulator transition of the half-filled Hubbard model: A DMFT+DMRG study

Here, we study the magnetic field-driven metal-to-insulator transition in half-filled Hubbard model on the Bethe lattice, using the dynamical mean-field theory by solving the quantum impurity problem with density-matrix renormalization group algorithm. The method enables us to obtain a high-resolution spectral densities in the presence of a magnetic field. It is found that the Kondo resonance at the Fermi level splits at relatively high magnetic field: the spin-up and -down components move away from the Fermi level and finally form a spin-polarized band insulator. By calculating the magnetization and spin susceptibility, we clarify that an applied magnetic field drives a transition from a paramagnetic metallic phase to a band insulating phase. In the weak interaction regime, the nature of the transition is continuous and captured by the Stoner's description, while in the strong interaction regime the transition is very likely to be metamagnetic, evidenced by the hysteresis curve. Furthermore, we determine the phase boundary by tracking the kink in the magnetic susceptibility, and the steplike change of the entanglement entropy and the entanglement gap closing. Interestingly, the phase boundaries determined from these two different ways are largely consistent with each other.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗