Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “uniform method”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 937 records · Page 52

An implicit δf particle-in-cell method with sub-cycling and orbit averaging for Lorentz ions

A second order implicit δf Lorentz ion hybrid model with sub-cycling and orbit averaging has been developed to study low-frequency, quasi-neutral plasmas. Models using the full Lorentz force equations of motion for ions may be useful for verifying gyrokinetic ion simulation models in applications where higher order terms may be important. In the presence of a strong external magnetic field, previous Lorentz ion models are limited to simulating very short time scales due to the small time step required for resolving the ion gyromotion. Here, we use a simplified model for ion Landau damped ion acoustic waves in a uniform magnetic field as a test bed for developing efficient time stepping methods to be used with the Lorentz ion hybrid model. A detailed linear analysis of the model is derived to validate simulations and to examine the significance of ion Bernstein waves in the Lorentz ion model. Linear analysis of a gyrokinetic ion model is also performed, and excellent agreement with the dispersion results from the Lorentz ion model is demonstrated for the ion acoustic wave. The sub-cycling/orbit averaging algorithm is shown to produce accurate finite-Larmor-radius effects using large macro-time steps sizes, and numerical damping of high frequency fluctuations can be achieved by formulating the field model in terms of the perturbed flux density. Furthermore, a CPU–GPU implementation of the sub-cycling/orbit averaging is presented and is shown to achieve a significant speedup over an equivalent serial code.

Computer Science↗

Advantages of the Samarskii-type schemes on the Shishkin mesh

The schemes of the Samarskii type are simple modifications of the upwind scheme. We use them on the Shishkin mesh and discuss their advantages over the upwind scheme when applied to the linear one-dimensional singularly perturbed convection–diffusion problem. One of the advantages is that the Samarskii-type schemes have exact first-order accuracy uniform in the perturbation parameter, as opposed to the upwind scheme which is almost first-order uniformly accurate because its accuracy is diminished by logarithmic factors. Although this is not a new result, we re-emphasize it in the paper. We also demonstrate another advantage, that the Samarskii-type schemes are almost second-order uniformly accurate on the layer component of the solution. Motivated by this fact, we present a further improvement of the numerical method.

Convection–diffusion↗

Methods of fabricating nanostructures and nanowires and devices fabricated therefrom

One-dimensional nanostructures having uniform diameters of less than approximately 200 nm. These inventive nanostructures, which we refer to as "nanowires", include single-crystalline homostructures as well as heterostructures of at least two single-crystalline materials having different chemical compositions. Because single-crystalline materials are used to form the heterostructure, the resultant heterostructure will be single-crystalline as well. The nanowire heterostructures are generally based on a semiconducting wire wherein the doping and composition are controlled in either the longitudinal or radial directions, or in both directions, to yield a wire that comprises different materials. Examples of resulting nanowire heterostructures include a longitudinal heterostructure nanowire (LOHN) and a coaxial heterostructure nanowire (COHN).

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

On the in-plane vibrations and electromechanical resonance characteristics of non-uniformly polarized rectangular piezoelectric wafers: Selective mode-type excitation and specific mode enhancement

Here, we investigate the in-plane vibrations and electromechanical resonance characteristics of non-uniformly polarized rectangular piezoelectric wafers. Non-uniform polarization is represented as a non-uniform electromechanical coupling coefficient using a polarization function. Governing equations are derived for the forced in-plane vibrations of a thin wafer under the assumption of generalized plane stress. The effect of non-uniform polarization is explicitly obtained in the forcing terms of the governing equations. These equations are then recast into a variational weak form that is then solved using the finite element method to obtain the displacement fields for different modes. The electromechanical response of a non-uniformly polarized piezoelectric wafer is derived in terms of the out-of-plane displacement profile on the surface of the wafer. Using the derived analytical expression, a necessary and sufficient condition for the presence/absence of a vibrational mode in the electromechanical impedance spectrum is obtained. Based on this condition, criteria for selective mode-type excitation and specific mode enhancement of vibrational modes in the electromechanical impedance spectrum are postulated. Selective mode-type excitation of in-plane extensional and shear modes is demonstrated for a square wafer and that of in-plane bending modes is demonstrated for a rectangular wafer. Specific mode enhancement is demonstrated for both square and rectangular wafers. In addition, it is also demonstrated how the criteria can be used to suppress specific vibrational modes in the electromechanical impedance spectrum. The proposed methodology of using non-uniformly polarized piezoelectric wafers finds application in the design of single element transducers with multi-frequency operation, frequency-tuned receivers/sensors, acoustic holograms, designing acoustic beams of prescribed shape/lobes, and other non-traditional applications such as information storage.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

MO-DE-207B-07: Assessment of Reproducibility Of FDG-PET-Based Radiomics Features Across Scanners Using Phantom Imaging

Purpose: Use a NEMA-IEC PET phantom to assess the robustness of FDG-PET-based radiomics features to changes in reconstruction parameters across different scanners. Methods: We scanned a NEMA-IEC PET phantom on 3 different scanners (GE Discovery VCT, GE Discovery 710, and Siemens mCT) using a FDG source-to-background ratio of 10:1. Images were retrospectively reconstructed using different iterations (2–3), subsets (21–24), Gaussian filter widths (2, 4, 6mm), and matrix sizes (128,192,256). The 710 and mCT used time-of-flight and point-spread-functions in reconstruction. The axial-image through the center of the 6 active spheres was used for analysis. A region-of-interest containing all spheres was able to simulate a heterogeneous lesion due to partial volume effects. Maximum voxel deviations from all retrospectively reconstructed images (18 per scanner) was compared to our standard clinical protocol. PET Images from 195 non-small cell lung cancer patients were used to compare feature variation. The ratio of a feature’s standard deviation from the patient cohort versus the phantom images was calculated to assess for feature robustness. Results: Across all images, the percentage of voxels differing by <1SUV and <2SUV ranged from 61–92% and 88–99%, respectively. Voxel-voxel similarity decreased when using higher resolution image matrices (192/256 versus 128) and was comparable across scanners. Taking the ratio of patient and phantom feature standard deviation was able to identify features that were not robust to changes in reconstruction parameters (e.g. co-occurrence correlation). Metrics found to be reasonably robust (standard deviation ratios > 3) were observed for routinely used SUV metrics (e.g. SUVmean and SUVmax) as well as some radiomics features (e.g. co-occurrence contrast, co-occurrence energy, standard deviation, and uniformity). Similar standard deviation ratios were observed across scanners. Conclusions: Our method enabled a comparison of feature variability across scanners and was able to identify features that were not robust to changes in reconstruction parameters.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

Ferritin-Templated Quantum-Dots for Quantum Logic Gates

Quantum logic gates (QLGs) or other logic systems are based on quantum-dots (QD) with a stringent requirement of size uniformity. The QD are widely known building units for QLGs. The size control of QD is a critical issue in quantum-dot fabrication. The work presented here offers a new method to develop quantum-dots using a bio-template, called ferritin, that ensures QD production in uniform size of nano-scale proportion. The bio-template for uniform yield of QD is based on a ferritin protein that allows reconstitution of core material through the reduction and chelation processes. One of the biggest challenges for developing QLG is the requirement of ordered and uniform size of QD for arrays on a substrate with nanometer precision. The QD development by bio-template includes the electrochemical/chemical reconsitution of ferritins with different core materials, such as iron, cobalt, manganese, platinum, and nickel. The other bio-template method used in our laboratory is dendrimers, precisely defined chemical structures. With ferritin-templated QD, we fabricated the heptagonshaped patterned array via direct nano manipulation of the ferritin molecules with a tip of atomic force microscope (AFM). We also designed various nanofabrication methods of QD arrays using a wide range manipulation techniques. The precise control of the ferritin-templated QD for a patterned arrangement are offered by various methods, such as a site-specific immobilization of thiolated ferritins through local oxidation using the AFM tip, ferritin arrays induced by gold nanoparticle manipulation, thiolated ferritin positioning by shaving method, etc. In the signal measurements, the current-voltage curve is obtained by measuring the current through the ferritin, between the tip and the substrate for potential sweeping or at constant potential. The measured resistance near zero bias was 1.8 teraohm for single holoferritin and 5.7 teraohm for single apoferritin, respectively.

Choi, Sang H.↗

Nonlinear vibrations of rectangular plates.

A finite-difference method is developed to determine the large amplitude dynamic responses of thin elastic plates subjected to uniform pressure pulse-type loads. Four different sets of boundary conditions are considered. Some specific problems are solved. The results are compared with approximate solutions obtained by Yamaki (1961). The numerical method presented provides an accurate and efficient approximate solution to the problem, and should be useful as a check on other approximate methods. The grid-size and the time-step necessary for obtaining numerical stability depend on the particular problem. For many cases the method converges rapidly and a rather large grid-size and time-step is adequate.

Bayles, D. J.↗

Optimization of flow in additively manufactured porous columns with graded permeability

Chemical engineering systems often involve a functional porous medium, such as in catalyzed reactive flows, fluid purifiers, and chromatographic separations. Ideally, the flow rates throughout the porous medium are uniform, and all portions of the medium contribute efficiently to its function. The permeability is a property of a porous medium that depends on pore geometry and relates flow rate to pressure drop. Additive manufacturing techniques raise the possibilities that permeability can be arbitrarily specified in three dimensions, and that a broader range of permeabilities can be achieved than by traditional manufacturing methods. Using numerical optimization methods, we show that designs with spatially varying permeability can achieve greater flow uniformity than designs with uniform permeability. We consider geometries involving hemispherical regions that distribute flow, as in many glass chromatography columns. By several measures, significant improvements in flow uniformity can be obtained by modifying permeability only near the inlet and outlet.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

ON THE DETECTION OF GLOBAL 21-cm SIGNAL FROM REIONIZATION USING INTERFEROMETERS

Detection of the global redshifted 21-cm signal is an excellent means of deciphering the physical processes during the Dark Ages and subsequent Epoch of Reionization (EoR). However, detection of this faint monopole is challenging due to the high precision required in instrumental calibration and modeling of substantially brighter foregrounds and instrumental systematics. In particular, modeling of receiver noise with mK accuracy and its separation remains a formidable task in experiments aiming to detect the global signal using single-element spectral radiometers. Interferometers do not respond to receiver noise; therefore, here we explore the theory of the response of interferometers to global signals. In other words, we discuss the spatial coherence in the electric field arising from the monopole component of the 21-cm signal and methods for its detection using sensor arrays. We proceed by first deriving the response to uniform sky of two-element interferometers made of unit dipole and resonant loop antennas, then extend the analysis to interferometers made of one-dimensional arrays and also consider two-dimensional aperture antennas. Finally, we describe methods by which the coherence might be enhanced so that the interferometer measurements yield improved sensitivity to the monopole component. We conclude (a) that it is indeed possible to measure the global 21-cm from EoR using interferometers, (b) that a practically useful configuration is with omnidirectional antennas as interferometer elements, and (c) that the spatial coherence may be enhanced using, for example, a space beam splitter between the interferometer elements.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

Time dependent inflow-outflow boundary conditions for 2D acoustic systems

An analysis of the number and form of the required inflow-outflow boundary conditions for the full two-dimensional time-dependent nonlinear acoustic system in subsonic mean flow is performed. The explicit predictor-corrector method of MacCormack (1969) is used. The methodology is tested on both uniform and sheared mean flows with plane and nonplanar sources. Results show that the acoustic system requires three physical boundary conditions on the inflow and one on the outflow boundary. The most natural choice for the inflow boundary conditions is judged to be a specification of the vorticity, the normal acoustic impedance, and a pressure gradient-density gradient relationship normal to the boundary. Specification of the acoustic pressure at the outflow boundary along with these inflow boundary conditions is found to give consistent reliable results. A set of boundary conditions developed earlier, which were intended to be nonreflecting is tested using the current method and is shown to yield unstable results for nonplanar acoustic waves.

Watson, Willie R.↗

TH-AB-207A-06: The Use of Realistic Phantoms to Predict CT Dose to Pediatric Patients

Purpose: To predict pediatric patient dose from diagnostic CT scans using Monte Carlo simulation of realistic reference phantoms of various ages, weights, and heights. Methods: A series of deformable pediatric reference phantoms using Non-Uniform Rational B-Splines (NURBS) was developed for a large range of ages, percentiles, and reference anatomy. Individual bones were modeled using age-dependent factors, and red marrow was modeled as functions of age and spatial distribution based on Cristy1. Organ and effective doses for the phantom series were calculated using Monte Carlo simulation of chest, abdominopelvic, and chest-abdomen-pelvis CT exams. Non-linear regression was performed to determine the relationship between dose-length-product (DLP)-normalized organ and effective doses and phantom diameter. Patient-specific voxel computational phantoms were also created by manual segmentation of previously acquired CT images for 40 pediatric patients (0.7 to 17 years). Organ and effective doses were determined by Monte Carlo simulation of these patient-specific phantoms. Each patient was matched to the closest pediatric reference phantom based primarily on age and diameter for all major organs within the torso. Results: A total of 80 NURBS phantoms were created ranging from newborn to 15 years with height/weight percentiles from 10 to 90%. Organ and effective dose normalized by DLP correlated strongly with exponentially decreasing average phantom diameter (R{sup 2} > 0.95 for most organs). A similar relationship was determined for the patient-specific voxel phantoms. Differences between patient-phantom matched organ-dose values ranged from 0.37 to 2.39 mGy (2.87% to 22.1%). Conclusion: Dose estimation using NURBS-based pediatric reference phantoms offers the ability to predict patient dose before and after CT examinations, and physicians and scientists can use this information in their analysis of dose prescriptions for particular subjects and study types. This may lead to practices that minimize radiation dose while still achieving high quality images and, ultimately, improved patient care. NIH/NCI 1 R01 CA155400-01A1.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

Methodology for Producing a Uniform Distribution of UO2 in a Tungsten Matrix

Current work at NASA's Marshall Space Flight Center (MSFC) is focused on the development CERMET fuel materials for Nuclear Thermal Propulsion (NTP). The CERMETs consist of uranium dioxide (UO2) fuel particles embedded in a tungsten (W) metal matrix. Initial testing of W-UO2 samples fabricated from fine angular powders performed reasonably well, but suffered from significant fuel loss during repeated thermal cycling due to agglomeration of the UO2 (1). The blended powder mixtures resulted in a non-uniform dispersion of the UO2 particles in the tungsten matrix, which allows rapid vaporization of the interconnected UO2 from the sample edges into the bulk material. Also, the angular powders create areas of stress concentrations due to thermal expansion mismatch, which eventually cracks the tungsten matrix. Evenly coating spherical UO2 particles with chemical vapor deposited (CVD) tungsten prior to consolidation was previously demonstrated to provide improved performance. However, the CVD processing technology is expensive and not currently available. In order to reduce cost and enhance performance, a powder coating process has been developed at MSFC to produce a uniform distribution of the spherical UO2 particles in a tungsten matrix. The method involves utilization of a polyethylene binder during mixing which leads to fine tungsten powders clinging to the larger UO2 spherical particles. This process was developed using HfO2 as a surrogate for UO2. Enough powder was mixed to make 8 discs (2cm diameter x 8mm thickness) using spark plasma sintering. A uniaxial pressure of 50 MPa was used at four different temperatures (2 samples at each temperature). The first two samples were heated to 1400C and 1500C respectively for 5 minutes. Densities for these samples were less than 85% of theoretical, so the time at temperature was increased to 20 minutes for the remaining samples. The highest densities were achieved for the two samples sintered at 1700C (approx. 92% of theoretical). Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) of the mixed powders and the sintered samples along with energy dispersive x-ray analysis was obtained. The SEM of the powders clearly show the fine W powder adhered to the larger HfO2 particles and a uniform distribution of HfO2 particles in a tungsten matrix upon densification. Vicker's Microhardness testing was also performed on all samples using 0.5, 1.0 and 2.0 kg loads. Five indents were made at each load level. All indents were placed in the tungsten matrix to assist as a proxy in measuring densification. The highest hardness value was obtained for the 1700C specimens. The hardness average for these samples was 312.14 MPa. This powder processing method has been applied to W/UO2 powders with the SEM of the powders appearing similar to the W/HfO2 powder images.

Tucker, Dennis S.↗

High Throughput, High Precision Hot Testing Tool for HBLED Wafer Level Testing

The Socrates research effort developed an in depth understanding and demonstrated in a prototype tool new precise methods for teh characterization of color characteristics and flux from individual LEDs for the production of uniform quality lighting. This effort was focused on improving the color quality and consistency of solid state lighting and potentially reducing characterization costs for all LED product types. The patented laser hot testing method was demonstrated to be far more accurate than all current state of the art color and flux characterization methods in use by the solid state lighting industry today. A seperately patented LED grouping method (statistical binning) was demonstrated to be a useful approach to improving utilization of entire lots of large color and flux distributions of manufactured LEDs for high quality color solid-state lighting. At the conclusion of the research in late 2015 the solid-state lighting industry was however generally satisfied with its existing production methods for high quality color products for the small segment of customers that demand it, albeit with added costs.

29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗

The Test and Evaluation of a Non-Chromate Finishing Agent

This research is focused on the design, development and implementation of an industry, military and commercial standard testing cell for surface coatings, which focuses on advanced non-chromate materials technology and their commercialization. Currently, within both private and commercial sectors, chromates are used in the corrosion prevention. processes. However, there is a great demand for chromate-free systems that are able to provide equal protection. At the end of this effort, it is intended that a patented alternative to chromate conversion coatings would be tested and processed for commercialization. Thus far, research studies have been concerned primarily with current corrosion knowledge and testing methods. Corrosion can be classified into five categories: The first type is uniform corrosion which is dominated by a uniform thinning due to an even and regular loss of metal. The second type is called localized corrosion in which most of the loss occurs in discrete areas. The third type, metallurgically influenced corrosion is a form of attack where metallurgy plays a significant role. The fourth type, titled mechanically assisted degradation is a form of attack where velocity, abrasion, and hydrodynamics control the corrosion process. The last type of corrosion is defined as environmentally induced cracking which occurs when cracks are produced under specific, premeditated stress. Oddly enough, with these varying classifications, there are not as many standardized corrosion testing sites. Two of the most common testing methods for corrosion are salt spray testing and filiform. Although neither has proven to be absolute, in terms of the resulting observations, our research aims to help provide data that may be used to support the standardization for corrosion testing. We would acquire and use a Singleton Cyclic Corrosion Testing Chamber. Singleton test chambers perform a wide range of commonly used catalytic corrosion tests. They are used throughout the industry, some of which are - automotive, aerospace, electronic and many more. In addition to this, Singleton test chambers are fully expandable to accommodate cyclic corrosion testing needs. Singleton chambers are also designed for complete compliance and conformity with ASTM (American Society for Testing and Materials), military and commercial standards.

Gulley, H.↗

Application of Nano-Indentation Test in Estimating Constituent Phase Properties for Microstructure-Based Modeling of Multiphase Steels

For multiphase advanced high strength steels (AHSS), the constituent phase properties play a crucial role in determining the overall mechanical behaviors. Therefore, it is important to accurately measure/estimate the constituent phase properties in the research of AHSS. In this study, a new nanoindentation-based inverse method that we developed was adopted in estimating the phase properties of a low alloy Quenching and Partitioning (Q&P) steel. A microstructure-based Finite Element (FE) model was also generated based on the Electron BackScatter Diffraction (EBSD) and Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) images of the Q&P steel. The phase properties estimated from nanoindentation were first compared with those estimated from in-situ High Energy X-Ray Diffraction (HEXRD) test and, then, employed in the generated FE model to examine whether they can be appropriately used as the input properties for the model. The results show that the estimated phase properties from the inverse method are similar to those from HEXRD, and that the Ultimate Tensile Strength (UTS) and Uniform Elongation (UE) predicted from the FE model based on the estimated phase properties are also similar to those of tensile experiment of the Q&P steel. Based on the results in this study, the nanoindentation-based inverse method appears to be a viable way in determining the phase properties of complex multiphase steels with submicrometer grain sizes.

Cheng, Guang↗

Control of Ionomer Distribution and Porosity in Roll-to-Roll Coated Fuel Cell Catalyst Layers

As fuel cells transition from the laboratory to industrial production for vehicles and other applications there is a need to understand how manufacturing processes impact the properties and, ultimately, the performance of materials. Roll-to-roll coating enables processing at meters per second speeds with physics that can be quite different from common laboratory coating methods. In this work, we have focused on the coating of catalyst layers for proton exchange membrane fuel cells. Commonly, laboratory samples are prepared using spray coating or hand painting, which effectively coat many thin layers to achieve the desired catalyst layer thickness. This creates catalyst layers with uniform distributions of materials throughout the thickness of the full catalyst layer. In contrast, roll-to-roll methods, like slot die and gravure, coat the catalyst layer as a single wet film. As the film dries, ink constituents are able to segregate, leading to a heterogeneous distribution of materials through the thickness of the layer. It is also known that solvent and drying rate can affect the morphology of the catalyst layer. Thus, there is a need to understand how ink formulation and the drying process influence the distribution of materials and catalyst layer morphology. Here, we have explored the influence of solvent and drying rate on morphology of roll-to-roll coated catalyst layers. We show the development of the Kelvin probe method as a rapid screening technique for qualitative analysis of ionomer distribution. We also utilize nano X-ray computed tomography to visualize electrode structure and to quantify particle-size and pore-size distributions, thickness-dependent ionomer distribution, tortuosity, and effective transport properties. We find that solvent has a strong influence on ionomer distribution, with less of an effect on porosity. Conversely, drying temperature has a strong influence on porosity, but less influence on ionomer distribution. Finally, we utilize in situ fuel cell performance testing and other advanced diagnostics to quantify the impact of catalyst layer properties on fuel cell performance and demonstrate that roll-to-roll coating is capable of coating high performance catalyst layers in multi-meter lengths. have focused on the coating of catalyst layers for proton exchange membrane fuel cells. Commonly, laboratory samples are prepared using spray coating or hand painting, which effectively coat many thin layers to achieve the desired catalyst layer thickness. This creates catalyst layers with uniform distributions of materials throughout the thickness of the full catalyst layer. In contrast, roll-to-roll methods, like slot die and gravure, coat the catalyst layer as a single wet film. As the film dries, ink constituents are able to segregate, leading to a heterogeneous distribution of materials through the thickness of the layer. It is also known that solvent and drying rate can affect the morphology of the catalyst layer. Thus, there is a need to understand how ink formulation and the drying process influence the distribution of materials and catalyst layer morphology. Here, we have explored the influence of solvent and drying rate on morphology of roll-to-roll coated catalyst layers. We show the development of the Kelvin probe method as a rapid screening technique for qualitative analysis of ionomer distribution. We also utilize nano X-ray computed tomography to visualize electrode structure and to quantify particle-size and pore-size distributions, thickness-dependent ionomer distribution, tortuosity, and effective transport properties. We find that solvent has a strong influence on ionomer distribution, with less of an effect on porosity. Conversely, drying temperature has a strong influence on porosity, but less influence on ionomer distribution. Finally, we utilize in situ fuel cell performance testing and other advanced diagnostics to quantify the impact of catalyst layer properties on fuel cell performance and demonstrate that roll-to-roll coating is capable of coating high performance catalyst layers in multi-meter lengths.

30 DIRECT ENERGY CONVERSION↗

Comparison of Shadowgraphy and X-Ray Phase Contrast Methods for Characterizing a DT Ice Layer in an Inertial Confinement Fusion Target

Shadowgraphy and x-ray phase contrast (XPC) imaging are two techniques that are used for characterizing the deuterium-tritium ice layer in Inertial Confinement Fusion targets. Each technique has limitations that affect how accurately they can characterize small crystalline defects and measure the ice-thickness non-uniformities that may be only a few micrometers in height. The concern is that shadowgraphy may be overly sensitive to the shape and depth of defects in the surface and insufficiently sensitive to the shape of longer-wavelength roughness, while x-ray phase contrast may be too insensitive to defects in the ice surface. Multiple ice layers with different thicknesses (40 to 63 μm), thickness uniformities (peak-valley variations that range from <2- to 12 μm), and crystal defects were analyzed using shadowgraphy and x-ray phase contrast techniques. The results from each method agree when the ice layer is uniformly thick and the crystal lacks defects. That agreement worsens as the number of defects in the surface of the ice layer increases and the roughness that is determined from a shadowgram image of the target’s limb is greater than can be justified by the number of defects that are seen in the target’s front and rear surfaces. The XPC technique is considerably less sensitive to surface defects, in part due to the poorer dynamic range and image resolution compared to shadowgraphy. Localized regions of the ice layer that are thicker or thinner than the average thickness of the layer are reported by shadowgraphy to be smaller in height and footprint (by up to 30%) than by XPC. As a result, the two techniques report different ice layer thicknesses that can vary by up to 10%. Shadowgraphy results from two caustics that trace different paths through the target, and, in theory, image the same ice-vapor surface (but reflect from either the vapor or ice side of the interface) did not consistently characterize the size or shape of ice features to be the same magnitude. Here, the XPC technique provides the best assessment of low-mode (l < 7) roughness in the ice layer. Shadowgraphy results using the strongest caustic is best for detecting the presence of grooves in the ice, though not for quantifying the size of them. If multiple grooves are present it is best to discard and reform the ice layer.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗