Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Cost Benefit Analysis”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 109 records · Page 6
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
NASA NTRS1995

Atmospheric environmental implications of propulsion systems

Three independent studies have been conducted for assessing the impact of rocket launches on the earth's environment. These studies have addressed issues of acid rain in the troposphere, ozone depletion in the stratosphere, toxicity of chemical rocket exhaust products, and the potential impact on global warming from carbon dioxide emissions from rocket launches. Local, regional, and global impact assessments were examined and compared with both natural sources and anthropogenic sources of known atmospheric pollutants with the following conclusions: (1) Neither solid nor liquid rocket launches have a significant impact on the earth's global environment, and there is no real significant difference between the two. (2) Regional and local atmospheric impacts are more significant than global impacts, but quickly return to normal background conditions within a few hours after launch. And (3) vastly increased space launch activities equivalent to 50 U.S. Space Shuttles or 50 Russian Energia launches per year would not significantly impact these conclusions. However, these assessments, for the most part, are based upon homogeneous gas phase chemistry analysis; heterogeneous chemistry from exhaust particulates, such as aluminum oxide, ice contrails, soot, etc., and the influence of plume temperature and afterburning of fuel-rich exhaust products, need to be further addressed. It was the consensus of these studies that computer modeling of interactive plume chemistry with the atmosphere needs to be improved and computer models need to be verified with experimental data. Rocket exhaust plume chemistry can be modified with propellant reformulation and changes in operating conditions, but, based upon the current state of knowledge, it does not appear that significant environmental improvements from propellant formulation changes can be made or are warranted. Flight safety, reliability, and cost improvements are paramount for any new rocket system, and these important aspects cannot be compromised. A detailed environmental cost-benefit-risk analysis must be conducted before any new chemistry or changes in rocket operating conditions should be seriously considered for any future space or defense applications. This paper presents a summary of the results of environmental assessments contained in these independent studies.

Mcdonald, Allan J.↗
NASA NTRS1990

Risk and value analysis of SETI

This paper attempts to apply a traditional risk and value analysis to the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence--SETI. In view of the difficulties of assessing the probability of success, a comparison is made between SETI and a previous search for extraterrestrial life, the biological component of Project Viking. Our application of simple Utility Theory, given some reasonable assumptions, suggests that SETI is at least as worthwhile as the biological experiment on Viking.

NASA Program Exobiology↗
NASA NTRS2021

Financial feasibility of water conservation in agriculture

Global water use for food production needs to be reduced to remain within planetary boundaries, yet the financial feasibility of crucial measures to reduce water use is poorly quantified. Here, we introduce a novel method to compare the costs of water conservation measures with the added value that reallocation of water savings might generate if used for expansion of irrigation. Based on detailed water accounting through the use of a high-resolution hydrology-crop model, we modify the traditional cost curve approach with an improved estimation of demand, increasing marginal cost per water conservation measure combination and add a correction to control for impacts on downstream water availability. We apply the method to three major river basins in the Indo-Gangetic plain (Indus, Ganges and Brahmaputra), a major global food producing region but increasingly water stressed. Our analysis shows that at basin level only about 10% (Brahmaputra) to just over 20% (Indus and Ganges) of potential water savings would be realised; the equilibrium price for water is too low to make the majority of water conservation measures cost effective. The associated expansion of irrigated area is moderate, about 7% in the Indus basin, 5% in the Ganges and negligible in the Brahmaputra, but farmers' gross profit increases more substantially, by 11%. Increasing the volumetric cost of irrigation water influences supply and demand in a similar way and has little influence on water reallocation. Controlling for the impact on return flows is important and more than halves the amount of water available for reallocation.

Geography / Land Utilization↗
NASA NTRS2004

Lunar and Planetary Science XXXV: Human Occupation of Space: Radiation, Risk, and Refuse

The titles in this section include: 1) Discrimination of Heavy Charged Particles in a Mixed Irradiation Using Optically Stimulated Luminescence Methods 2) MARIE: Current Status and Results from 20 Months of Observations at Mars 3) Mars Surface Analog Project: Preparing for Astronauts First Hours on Mars 4) The Need for Analogue Missions in Scientific Human and Robotic Planetary Exploration 5) Space Debris in the Geosynchronous Earth Orbit: Debris Environmental Asssessment and its Implications on Cost and Benefit Analysis.

Source record↗
NASA NTRS2005

Manufacture of Solar Cells on the Moon

In support of the space exploration initiative a new architecture for the production of solar cells on the lunar surface is devised. The paper discusses experimental data on the fabrication and properties of lunar glass substrates, evaporated lunar regolith thin film (antireflect coatings and insulators), and preliminary attempts in the fabrication of thin film (silicon/II-VI) photovoltaic materials on lunar regolith substrates. A conceptual design for a solar powered robotic rover capable of fabricating solar cells directly on the lunar surface is provided. Technical challenges in the development of such a facility and strategies to alleviate perceived difficulties are discussed. Finally, preliminary cost benefit ratio analysis for different in situ solar cell production scenarios (using exclusively in-situ planetary resources or hybrid) are discussed.

Freundich, Alex↗
NASA NTRS2004

The minimal cost of life in space

The cost of keeping people alive in space is assessed from a theoretical viewpoint and using two actual designs for plant growth systems. While life support is theoretically not very demanding, our ability to implement life support is well below theoretical limits. A theoretical limit has been calculated from requirements and the state of the art for plant growth has been calculated using data from the BIO-Plex PDR and from the Cornell CEA prototype system. The very low efficiency of our current approaches results in a high mission impact, though we can still see how to get a significant reduction in cost of food when compared to supplying it from Earth. Seeing the distribution of costs should allow us to improve our current designs. c2004 COSPAR. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

NASA Discipline Life Support Systems↗
NASA NTRS2003

Optimizing spacecraft design - optimization engine development : progress and plans

At JPL and NASA, a process has been developed to perform life cycle risk management. This process requires users to identify: goals and objectives to be achieved (and their relative priorities), the various risks to achieving those goals and objectives, and options for risk mitigation (prevention, detection ahead of time, and alleviation). Risks are broadly defined to include the risk of failing to design a system with adequate performance, compatibility and robustness in addition to more traditional implementation and operational risks. The options for mitigating these different kinds of risks can include architectural and design choices, technology plans and technology back-up options, test-bed and simulation options, engineering models and hardware/software development techniques and other more traditional risk reduction techniques.

risk↗
NASA NTRS2010

U.S. Air Force Research Laboratory's Need for Flow Physics and Control With Applications Involving Aero-Optics and Weapon Bay Cavities

To develop New Flow Control Techniques: a) Knowledge of the Flow Physics with and without control. b) How does Flow Control Effect Flow Physics (What Works to Optimize the Design?). c) Energy or Work Efficiency of the Control Technique (Cost - Risk - Benefit Analysis). d) Supportability, e.g. (size of equipment, computational power, power supply) (Allows Designer to include Flow Control in Plans).

Schmit, Ryan↗
NASA NTRS2023

Exploring Interactive Visuals for Orbital Debris Report

NASA often produces reports or memos that include complex data and these findings can often be most effectively communicated using dynamic or interactive visualizations. While newsrooms, such as the New York Times, and academic journals, such as Distill, have demonstrated the power of interactivity within a prose context (i.e., not dashboards), NASA is still lagging in this area. A shift towards more interactive NASA publications will require new technology and expertise. In this presentation, we begin to explore the avenues that the Office of Technology, Policy, and Strategy are using to make its reports interactive by using results from the “Cost and benefit Analysis of Orbital Debris Remediation” as initial examples. We share our current findings and aim to start a discussion with other members of the NASA analytics community interested in or currently adding interactivity to Agency products.

data visualization↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Exploring the Use of a Ground-Based Laser System to Deorbit Small Orbital Debris

In March 2023, NASA Office of Technology, Policy, and Strategy (OTPS) released its Cost and Benefit Analysis of Orbital Debris Remediation report. This analysis found that the two most efficient methods for remediating orbital debris were the removal of small (1-10 cm) debris and nudging large debris away from predicted collisions; both methods could be performed by high-energy laser systems. To further explore the concept, OTPS has been assessing a reference mission using ground-based, pulsed lasers to detect, engage, and rapidly deorbit 1- to 10-cm debris that would otherwise threaten the safety of the International Space Station and future crewed platforms in low Earth orbit. In March of 2024, OTPS convened a technical interchange meeting (TIM) of experts in detection and tracking of debris, high-energy glass and excimer lasers, laser-matter interactions, atmospheric propagation, and adaptive optics. The TIM spanned two days, covering the unclassified state of the art, uncertainties, and technical challenges for the entire concept of operations of the reference mission. In this presentation, we will summarize the reference mission analyzed, key findings from the TIM, and solicit the feedback from this community to further define “what is good enough” for debris remediation.

orbital debris↗
NASA NTRS1972

NASTRAN benefits analysis. Volume 2: Final technical report

Baseline data are considered for comparisons of the costs and benefits of the NASA structural analysis program and to determine impacts and benefits to current users. To develop this information, questionnaires were mailed to users. Personal and telephone interviews were made to solicit further information. The questions in the questionnaire and in the interview were related to benefits derived from the programs, areas of needed improvement, and applicable usage comments. The collected information was compiled and analyzed. Methodology, analyses, and results are presented. The information is applicable to issues preceding NASTRAN Level 15.

Source record↗
NASA NTRS1986

Study of selected tether applications in space, phase 3, volume 2

The results of a Phase 3 study of two Selected Tether Applications in Space (STAIS); deorbit of a Shuttle and launch of an Orbital Transfer Vehicle (OTV), both from the space station using a tether were examined. The study objectives were to: perform a preliminary engineering design, define operational scenarios, develop a common cost model, perform cost benefits analyses, and develop a Work Breakdown Structure (WBS). Key features of the performance analysis were to identify the net increases in effective Shuttle cargo capability if tethers are used to assist in the deorbit of Shuttles and the launching of the OTVs from the space station and to define deployer system designs required to accomplish these tasks. Deployer concepts were designed and discussed. Operational scenarios, including timelines, for both tethered and nontethered Shuttle and OTV operations at the space station were evaluated. A summary discussion of the Selected Tether Applications Cost Model (STACOM) and the results of the cost benefits analysis are presented. Several critical technologies needed to implement tether assisted deployment of payloads are also discussed. Conclusions and recommendations are presented.

Source record↗
NASA NTRS1983

Space station needs, attributes and architectural options study. Volume 1: Executive summary

Planetary explorations, Earth observations, space physics, astronomy-astrophysics, solar physics, life/biological/medical sciences, materials processing in space, communications, and technology development are addressed. Mission requirements, integrated user requirements, and space station user accommodation requirements are discussed. Mission implementation concepts and cost, benefits and programmatic analysis are discussed.

Source record↗
NASA NTRS1974

An evaluation of the ERTS data collection system as a potential operational tool

The Earth Resources Technology Satellite Data Collection System has been shown to be, from the users vantage point, a reliable and simple system for collecting data from U.S. Geological Survey operational field instrumentation. It is technically feasible to expand the ERTS system into an operational polar-orbiting data collection system to gather data from the Geological Survey's Hydrologic Data Network. This could permit more efficient internal management of the Network, and could enable the Geological Survey to make data available to cooperating agencies in near-real time. The Geological Survey is conducting an analysis of the costs and benefits of satellite data-relay systems.

Paulson, R. W.↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Demonstration of How Manufacturing Innovations Challenge Conventional Structural Design

For almost 100 years, commercial aircraft have been fabricated using riveted aluminum alloy structures. Aside from refining aircraft designs for better aerodynamic efficiency, improving alloy compositions, and automating assembly steps, fuselage construction remains largely unchanged today. The intent of the lightweight metallic fuselage prototype undertaken in NASA’s Advanced Air Transport Technology project was to demonstrate innovative forming and joining processes that advance the design paradigm, i.e. achieve high-rate manufacturing and reduce assembly time/costs. Over the past decade, researchers at NASA Langley Research Center have evaluated the potential to modify the flow forming process to produce near-net shaped cylinders, integrally stiffened along the cylinder axis, for space launch vehicles. The production of integral stiffeners in a formed aluminum cylinder, the size of the Space Shuttle external tank, replaced machined thick plate and welding steps to eliminate > 500,000 pounds of machining chips and ~ 0.5 miles of welds. The flow forming method, called the Integrally Stiffened Cylinder (ISC) process, was successfully demonstrated up to the 10-foot diameter scale, which laid the groundwork for the current investigation of metallic fuselage structures. Using the ISC process as the basis for the re-design of a metallic fuselage eliminates hundreds of thousands of holes and rivets, while significantly reducing assembly time and crack initiation sites in the integral structure. However, the ISC process is not currently configured to fabricate circumferential ring frames for carrying fuselage internal pressure loads. Consequently, a trade study was performed to assess existing and advanced manufacturing processes, including additive manufacturing, forming, and welding. The approach with the lowest barriers to success, while simultaneously improving manufacturing time and cost, was to use formed ring frame segments attached to the ISC via Refill Friction Stir Spot Welding (RFSSW). The RFSSW process is five times faster than drilling, reaming, and riveting and provides similar mechanical performance. Finishing the fuselage structure with conventional windows, floor beams, and floor panels can then be accomplished using incumbent assembly methods, thereby maximizing reuse of existing infrastructure for aircraft construction. Structural analyses were performed to assess and optimize the geometric variables of integrated skin and stiffener configurations. A cost benefit and manufacturing rate analysis was also performed to compare against the current state-of-the-art for single aisle transport class aircraft. The resulting structure offers a weight reduction that rivals current graphite-epoxy composite fuselage structures. The projected manufacturing rate is close to double current metallic fuselages and six times faster than current composite manufacturing practices. The damage tolerance properties of a monocoque fuselage structure have yet to be assessed, but past integral airframe structural work has exploited geometric features to blunt or turn cracks. This concept offers promise that integrated structures can meet stringent aircraft durability specifications. An important benefit is that such aluminum fuselage structures may be inspected and repaired using established practices and existing expertise. Finally, pursuit of advanced manufacturing processes for future aluminum fuselages minimizes waste and the structure is 100% recyclable at the end-of-life for maximum sustainability.

aluminum↗
NASA NTRS1981

Structures performance, benefit, cost-study

New technology concepts and structural analysis development needs which could lead to improved life cycle cost for future high-bypass turbofans were studied. The NASA-GE energy efficient engine technology is used as a base to assess the concept benefits. Recommended programs are identified for attaining these generic structural and other beneficial technologies.

Woike, O. G.↗
NASA NTRS1983

AFB/open cycle gas turbine conceptual design study

Applications of coal fired atmospheric fluidized bed gas turbine systems in industrial cogeneration are identified. Based on site-specific conceptual designs, the potential benefits of the AFB/gas turbine system were compared with an atmospheric fluidized design steam boiler/steam turbine system. The application of these cogeneration systems at four industrial plant sites is reviewed. A performance and benefit analysis was made along with a study of the representativeness of the sites both in regard to their own industry and compared to industry as a whole. A site was selected for the conceptual design, which included detailed site definition, AFB/gas turbine and AFB/steam turbine cogeneration system designs, detailed cost estimates, and comparative performance and benefit analysis. Market and benefit analyses identified the potential market penetration for the cogeneration technologies and quantified the potential benefits.

Dickinson, T. W.↗
NASA NTRS2002

Sensor Web Architectural Concepts and Implementation Challenges - An Heuristic Approach

There is a significant interest in the Earth Science remote sensing community to increase the number of observations. The obvious reasons for such a push is to improve the temporal and surface coverage of measurements. However, there is little analysis available in terms of benefits, costs and optimized set of sensors needed to make these necessary observations. In reality, this is a complex problem that should be carefully studied and balanced over many boundaries. For example, the question of technology maturity versus users desire to obtain additional measurements is non congruent. This is further complicated by the limitations of the laws of physics and the economic conditions. With the advent of advance technology, it is anticipated that the cost of the spacecraft technology will become more affordable. However, the specialized detector subsystems, and the precision flying techniques may still require substantial innovation, development time and cost. Additionally, the space deployment scheme should also be given a careful attention because of a high expense. Nonetheless, it is important to carefully examine the science priorities and steer the development efforts that can commensurate with the tangible requirements. This paper outlines a possible set of architectural concepts, operational scenarios and potential benefits of one scheme versus another. It further makes some suggestions where one can draw some boundary conditions to incrementally solve this predicament.

Habib, Shahid↗