Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Diffusion NMR”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 109 records · Page 6

Complete characterization of a lithium battery electrolyte using a combination of electrophoretic NMR and electrochemical methods

Improving transport properties of electrolytes is important for developing lithium-ion batteries for future energy storage applications. In Newman's concentrated solution theory, electrolytes are characterized by three transport parameters, conductivity, diffusion coefficient, and transference number, in addition to the thermodynamic factor. In this work, these parameters are all determined for an exemplar liquid electrolyte, lithium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide mixed in tetraethylene glycol dimethyl ether, using electrochemical methods. The intrinsic coupling between parameters obtained by electrochemical methods results in large error bars in the transference number that obscure the transport behavior of the electrolyte. Here, we use electrophoretic NMR (eNMR) to measure the electric-field-induced ion and solvent velocities to obtain the transference number directly, which enables determination of the thermodynamic factor with greater certainty. In conclusion, our work indicates that the combination of eNMR and electrochemical methods provides a robust approach for complete characterization of battery electrolytes.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Anion chemical composition of poly(ethylene oxide)-based sulfonylimide and sulfonate lithium ionomers controls ion aggregation and conduction

Maximizing ion conduction in single-ion-conducting ionomers is essential for their application in energy-related technologies such as Li-ion batteries. Understanding the anion chemical composition impacts on ion conduction offers new perspectives to maximize ion transport, since the current approach of lowering T g has apparently reached a limit (lowest T g ~ 190 K, highest conductivity ~10 -5 –10 -4 S cm -1 ). Here, a series of random ionomers are synthesized by copolymerizing poly(ethylene glycol)methacrylate with either sulfonylimide lithium methacrylate (MTLi) or sulfonate lithium methacrylate (MSLi) using reversible addition–fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT) polymerization. Li-Ion conduction and self-diffusion coefficients (DLi+) of the ionomers are characterized with dielectric relaxation spectroscopy (DRS) and pulsed-field-gradient (PFG) NMR diffusometry, respectively. Increasing ion content decreases the Li-ion conductivity and D Li+ , as expected from the increased T g . Moreover, a considerably lower ionic conductivity and D Li+ are observed for MSLi compared to MTLi at constant ion content and T g /T. As revealed from X-ray scattering, strong ion aggregation in MSLi results in much lower conductivity and DLi+ compared with less aggregated MTLi based on the more delocalized sulfonylimide anion. These results emphasize the detrimental and molecularly specific role of ion aggregation in Li-ion conductivity, and highlight the necessity for minimizing ion aggregation via the rational choice of anion chemical composition.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Electrochemical Reactivity of Hydrogen Storage Materials: Exploring Borohydride and Hydrazinium Salt Mixtures

Electrochemical characterization of hydrogen storage materials was conducted in a non-aqueous environment to investigate the direct electrochemical release and consumption of hydrogen and the potential for regeneration. We first address the challenge of minimal solubility of the synthetic precursors, sodium borohydride (NaBH 4 ) and hydrazinium bromide (N 2 H 5 Br), in both organic and inorganic solvents. We next determine and calibrate a reference electrode formulation compatible with our non-aqueous media and analytes that demonstrates a stable reference potential. We employ cyclic voltammetry (CV) to characterize the precursors and mixtures thereof. Each CV peak is assigned to a corresponding electrochemical reaction. Using the rate-dependent CV method and Randles–Ševčík equation, we calculate the diffusion coefficient of each chemical (NaBH 4 and N 2 H 5 Br). Analysis of the CVs, coupled with 11B NMR analysis, reveals a room temperature chemical transformation of NaBH 4 and N 2 H 5 Br mixtures into hydrazine borane (N 2 H 4 BH 3 ). These results are particularly significant, considering the limited information available on the electrochemical characterization of metal borohydride and hydrazinium salt in non-aqueous media. This work establishes a foundation for adapting a non-aqueous electrochemical system to further study the borohydride family of chemistries and to design and develop electrochemical devices for direct electrical and chemical energy interconversion with hydrogen storage materials.

08 HYDROGEN↗

High-temperature and high-pressure NMR investigations of low viscous fluids confined in mesoporous systems

Abstract In this contribution, the relaxation and diffusional behaviors of low viscous fluids, water and methanol confined into mesoporous silica and controlled size pore glass were investigated. The engineered porous systems are relevant to geologically important subsurface energy materials. The engineered porous proxies were characterized by Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) surface analyzer, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, and electron microscopy (EM) to determine surface area, pore-wall protonation and morphology of these materials, respectively. The confined behavior of the low viscous fluids was studied by varying pore diameter, fluid-to-solid ratio, temperature, and pressure, and then compared to bulk liquid state. Both relaxation and diffusion behaviors for the confined fluids showed increasing deviation from pure bulk fluids as the fluid-to-solid ratio was decreased, and surface-to-volume ratio ( S / V ) was varied. Variable pressure deuteron NMR relaxation of confined D 2 O and confined methanol, deuterated at the hydroxyl or methyl positions, were performed to exploit the sensitivity of the deuteron quadrupole moment to molecular rotation. The methanol results demonstrated greater pressure dependence than those for water only in bulk. The deviations from bulk liquid behavior arise from different reasons such as confinement and the interactions between confined fluid and the nano-pore wall. The results of the present report give insight into the behavior of low viscosity fluid in nano-confined geometries under different state conditions.

Chemistry↗

Core–Shell Gold Nanoparticle-Star Copolymer Composites with Gradient Transfer and Transport Properties: Toward Electro-Optical Sensors and Catalysis

A series of hybrid core–shell nanomaterials was prepared by solvent phase transfer methods with gold (Au) nanoparticles (NPs) as a core and star copolymers (h-PEI-b-PCL-Cbz) as a shell—consisting of hyperbranched polyethyleneimine (h-PEI) with different poly(ε-caprolactone) (PCL) chain lengths and a carbazole-contained terminating agent (Cbz). By varying the PCL chain length, these core–shell nanomaterials exhibited gradient energy transfer properties, surface hydrophobicity, electropolymerizability, and ionic probe transport and diffusion properties. The systematic copolymer formation was verified with quadruple-detector size exclusion chromatography (SEC) and 1H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). High-resolution atomic force microscopy-infrared spectroscopy (AFM-IR) chemical mapping verified nanoparticle-substrate adhesion and film formation. The design of these hybrid NPs and elucidation of gradient properties will be useful for future applications of the core–shell systems in electro-optical sensing and catalysis.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Low-Temperature Characterization of a Nonaqueous Liquid Electrolyte for Lithium Batteries

Rechargeable batteries exhibit poor performance at low temperatures due to sluggish ion transport through the electrolytic phase. Ion transport is governed by three transport parameters—conductivity, diffusion coefficient, and the cation transference number with respect to the solvent velocity—and the thermodynamic factor. Understanding how these parameters change with temperature is necessary for designing improved electrolytes. In this work, we combine electrochemical techniques with electrophoretic NMR to determine the temperature dependence of these parameters for a liquid electrolyte, LiTFSI salt dissolved in tetraglyme between −20 and 45 °C. At colder temperatures, all species in the electrolyte tend to move more slowly due to increasing viscosity, which translates to a monotonic decrease in conductivity and diffusion coefficient with decreasing temperature. Surprisingly, we find that the field-induced velocity of solvent molecules at a particular salt concentration is a nonmonotonic function of temperature. The cation transference number with respect to the solvent velocity thus exhibits a complex dependence on temperature and salt concentration. The measured thermodynamic and transport properties are used to predict concentration gradients that will form in a lithium-lithium symmetric cell under a constant applied potential as a function of temperature using concentrated solution theory. The calculated steady current at −20 °C is lower than that at 45 °C by roughly two orders of magnitude.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Structuring, stochastic behavior, and charge storage capacity of redox-active microemulsions formulated with mixtures of toluene and ionic liquid as oil phase

Oil/water microemulsions (µEs) are promising electrolytes for redox flow batteries (RFBs) as they simultaneously improve charge capacity and ionic conductivity. Here, we report the successful formulation of bicontinuous µEs where the oil phase is a solution of trihexyltetradecylphosphonium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide ionic liquid in toluene with redox-active ferrocene. We examined the effect of supporting electrolyte anion (NO 3 – , Cl – , ClO 4 – ) on the structure, reactivity, transport, and electrolytic performance of redox-active µEs. Neutron scattering and nuclear magnetic resonance showed that the domain size increased as Cl – > NO 3 – > ClO 4 – while the ferrocene diffusion coefficient increased as NO 3 – > Cl – > ClO 4 – . Scanning electrochemical microscopy indicated anion-dependent current fluctuations during electrolysis, with ClO 4 – exhibiting the least high-frequency oscillations, which correlate to the highest charge and discharge capacity and reversibility. All ionic liquid containing systems improved the performance of toluene-based µEs, highlighting new design principles for these electrolytes.

diffusion↗

Quantifying Lithium Ion Exchange in Solid Electrolyte Interphase (SEI) on Graphite Anode Surfaces

Solid Electrolyte Interphase (SEI) has been identified as the most important and least understood component in lithium-ion batteries. Despite extensive studies in the past two decades, a few mysteries remain: what is the chemical form of and degree of mobility of Li + in the interphase? What fraction of Li + is permanently immobilized in the SEI, while the rest are still able to participate in the cell reactions via the ion-exchange process with Li + in the electrolyte? This study attempted to answer, in part, these questions by using 6 Li and 7 Li-isotopes to label SEIs and electrolytes, and then quantifying the distribution of permanently immobilized and ion-exchangeable Li + with solid-state NMR and ToF-SIMS. The results showed that the majority of Li + were exchanged after one SEI formation cycle, and a complete exchange after 25 cycles. Ion exchange by diffusion based on concentration gradient in the absence of applied potential also occurred simultaneously. This knowledge will provide a foundation for not only understanding but also designing better SEIs for future battery chemistries.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Heterolytic Scission of Hydrogen Within a Crystalline Frustrated Lewis Pair

We report the heterolysis of molecular hydrogen under ambient conditions by the crystalline frustrated Lewis pair (FLP) 1-{2-[bis(pentafluorophenyl)boryl]phenyl}-2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine (KCAT). The gas–solid reaction provides an approach to prepare the solvent-free, polycrystalline ion pair KCATH2 through a single crystal to single crystal transformation. The crystal lattice of KCATH2 increases in size relative to the parent KCAT by approximately 2%. Microscopy was used to follow the transformation of the highly colored red/orange KCAT to the colorless KCATH2 over a period of 2 h at 300 K under a flow of H2 gas. There is no evidence of crystal decrepitation during hydrogen uptake. Inelastic neutron scattering employed over a temperature range from 4–200 K did not provide evidence for the formation of polarized H2 in a precursor complex within the crystal at low temperatures and high pressures. However, at 300 K, the INS spectrum of KCAT transformed to the INS spectrum of KCATH2. Calculations suggest that the driving force is more favorable in the solid state compared to the solution or gas phase, but the addition of H2 into the KCAT crystal is unfavorable. Ab Initio methods were used to calculate the INS spectra of KCAT, KCATH2, and a possible precursor complex of H2 in the pocket between the B and N of crystalline KCAT. Ex-situ NMR showed that the transformation from KCAT to KCATH2 is quantitative and our results suggest that the hydrogen heterolysis process occurs via H2 diffusion into the FLP crystal with a rate-limiting movement of H2 from inactive positions to reactive sites.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Carbon capture in polymer-based electrolytes

Nanoparticle organic hybrid materials (NOHMs) have been proposed as excellent electrolytes for combined CO 2 capture and electrochemical conversion due to their conductive nature and chemical tunability. However, CO 2 capture behavior and transport properties of these electrolytes after CO 2 capture have not yet been studied. Here, we use a variety of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques to explore the carbon speciation and transport properties of branched polyethylenimine (PEI) and PEI-grafted silica nanoparticles (denoted as NOHM-I-PEI) after CO 2 capture. Quantitative 13 C NMR spectra collected at variable temperatures reveal that absorbed CO 2 exists as carbamates (RHNCOO – or RR'NCOO – ) and carbonate/bicarbonate (CO 3 2– /HCO 3 – ). The transport properties of PEI and NOHM-I-PEI studied using 1 H pulsed-field-gradient NMR, combined with molecular dynamics simulations, demonstrate that coulombic interactions between negatively and positively charged chains dominate in PEI, while the self-diffusion in NOHM-I-PEI is dominated by silica nanoparticles. These results provide strategies for selecting adsorbed forms of carbon for electrochemical reduction.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Choline Chloride-Based Water-in-Salt Electrolyte for Efficient Iron Electrodeposition

Electrochemical production of iron is a promising low-cost and modular approach to replace the traditional blast furnace. Aqueous electrolytes for iron electrolysis are advantageous as they can be operated at near-ambient temperatures, but they suffer from inefficiencies due to the parasitic hydrogen evolution reaction. In this work, we identify a new water-in-salt electrolyte (WiSE) based on choline chloride (ChCl) for high coulombic efficiency (>85%) iron deposition. Electrochemical analysis of the partial current densities of iron plating and hydrogen co-evolution revealed that, at optimal WiSE compositions, water reduction is kinetically suppressed resulting in an increase in the Fe plating efficiency. Decreased coordination of water and increased coordination of choline’s alcohol group with the Fe 2+ ion were observed through 1 H NMR providing evidence that water reduction is kinetically suppressed in WiSE. Additionally, Raman spectroscopy revealed that complexation effects (with Cl – ) reduce Fe 2+ diffusion coefficients and corresponding limiting currents as the ChCl concentration is increased. This results in an optimal WiSE composition (4 M ChCl + 1 M FeCl 2 ) that provides kinetic suppression of HER but also low transport resistance to Fe plating yielding 85% coulombic efficiency at high current densities.

Sinclair, Nicholas Scott [Case Western Reserve Uni↗

Double Paddle‐Wheel Enhanced Sodium Ion Conduction in an Antiperovskite Solid Electrolyte

Abstract Antiperovskite structure compounds (X 3 AB, where X is an alkali cation and A and B are anions) have the potential for highly correlated motion between the cation and a cluster anion on the A or B site. This so‐called “paddle‐wheel” mechanism may be the basis for enhanced cation mobility in solid electrolytes. Through combined experiments and modeling, the first instance of a double paddle‐wheel mechanism, leading to fast sodium ion conduction in the antiperovskite Na 3− x O 1− x (NH 2 ) x (BH 4 ), is shown. As the concentration of amide (NH 2 − ) cluster anions is increased, large positive deviations in ionic conductivity above that predicted from a vacancy diffusion model are observed. Using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy, powder X‐ray diffraction, synchrotron X‐ray diffraction, neutron diffraction, ab initio molecular dynamics simulations, and NMR, the cluster anion rotational dynamics are characterized and it is found that cation mobility is influenced by the rotation of both NH 2 − and BH 4 − species, resulting in sodium ion conductivity a factor of 10 2 higher at x = 1 than expected for the vacancy mechanism alone. Generalization of this phenomenon to other compounds could accelerate fast ion conductor exploration and design.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Crosslinked Polyethyleneimine Gel Polymer Interface to Improve Cycling Stability of RFBs

Redox flow batteries are considered a promising technology for grid energy storage. However, capacity decay caused by crossover of active materials is a universal challenge for many flow battery systems, which are based on various chemistries. In this paper, using the vanadium redox flow battery as an example, we demonstrate a new gel polymer interface (GPI) consisting of crosslinked polyethyleneimine with a large amount of amino and carboxylic acid groups introduced between the positive electrode and the membrane. The GPI functions as a key component to prevent vanadium ions from crossing the membrane, thus supporting stable long-term cycling. Cyclic voltammetry (CV) and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) measurements were conducted to investigate the effect of GPI on the electrochemical properties of graphitic carbon electrodes (GCFs) and redox reaction of catholyte. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) and 1 H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra demonstrated that the crosslinked GPI is chemically stable for 100 cycles without dissolution of polymers and swelling in the strong acidic electrolytes. Results from inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS), Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy, and energy-dispersive X-ray (EDX) spectroscopy proved that the GPI is effective in maintaining the concentration of vanadium species in their respective half-cells, resulting in improved cycling stability because of it prevents active species from crossing the membrane and stabilizes the oxidation states of active species.

Lim, Hyung-Seok↗

Enhancing CO 2 Transport Across a PEEK‐Ionene Membrane and Water‐Lean Solvent Interface

Abstract Efficient direct air capture (DAC) of CO 2 will require strategies to deal with the relatively low concentration in the atmosphere. One such strategy is to employ the combination of a CO 2 ‐selective membrane coupled with a CO 2 capture solvent acting as a draw solution. Here, the interactions between a leading water‐lean carbon‐capture solvent, a polyether ether ketone (PEEK)‐ionene membrane, CO 2 , and combinations were probed using advanced NMR techniques coupled with advanced simulations. We identify the speciation and dynamics of the solvent, membrane, and CO 2 , presenting spectroscopic evidence of CO 2 diffusion through benzylic regions within the PEEK‐ionene membrane, not spaces in the ionic lattice as expected. Our results demonstrate that water‐lean capture solvents provide a thermodynamic and kinetic funnel to draw CO 2 from the air through the membrane and into the bulk solvent, thus enhancing the performance of the membrane. The reaction between the carbon‐capture solvent and CO 2 produces carbamic acid, disrupting interactions between the imidazolium (Im + ) cations and the bistriflimide anions within the PEEK‐ionene membrane, thereby creating structural changes through which CO 2 can diffuse more readily. Consequently, this restructuring results in CO 2 diffusion at the interface that is faster than CO 2 diffusion in the bulk carbon‐capture solvent.

Walter, Eric D.↗

Poison or Promoter? Investigating the Dual-Role of Carbon Monoxide in Pincer-Iridium-Based Alkane Dehydrogenation Systems via Operando Diffuse Reflectance Infrared Fourier Transform Spectroscopy

Pincer-ligated iridium complexes of the form [( R 4 PCP)IrL] ( R 4 PCP = κ 3 -C 6 H 3 -2,6-(XPR 2 ) 2 ; X = CH 2 , O; R = tBu, iPr) have previously been shown competent for acceptorless alkane dehydrogenation when supported on silica. It was observed by postcatalysis solid-state NMR that silica-tethered [(≡SiO- tBu 4 POCOP)Ir(C 2 H 4 )] (3-C 2 H 4 ) was converted fully to [(≡SiO- tBu 4 POCOP)Ir(CO)] (3-CO) at 300 °C. In this work, the characterization of species under dehydrogenation reaction conditions far from equilibrium between butane and butenes (approach to equilibrium Q/K eq = 0.3 at 300 °C) is performed with operando Diffuse Reflectance Infrared Fourier–Transform Spectroscopy (DRIFTS) to show the kinetics of species conversion from 3-C 2 H 4 to 3-CO. It is further found that [(≡SiO- tBu 4 POCOP)IrHCl] (3-HCl), a species considered to be a precatalyst for alkane dehydrogenation, is also fully converted to 3-CO. Here, a mechanism of decomposition is proposed that implicates surface silanol groups, while carbon monoxide acts as a “stabilizer” for the catalyst by promoting their reductive elimination and maintaining the complex in the I oxidation state.

02 PETROLEUM↗

Vanadyl Phosphates A x VOPO 4 (A = Li, Na, K) as Multielectron Cathodes for Alkali-Ion Batteries

Vanadyl phosphates comprise a class of multielectron cathode materials capable of cycling two Li + , about 1.66 Na + , and some K + ions per redox center. In this review, structures, thermodynamic stabilities, and ion diffusion kinetics of various A x VOPO 4 (A = Li, Na, K, NH 4 ) polymorphs are discussed. Both the experimental data and first-principle calculations indicate kinetic limitations for alkali metal ions cycling, especially between for 0 ≤ x ≤ 1, and metastability of phases with x > 1. This creates challenges for multiple-ion cycling, as the slow kinetics call for nanosized particles, which being metastable and reactive with organic electrolytes are prone to side reactions. Thus, various synthesis approaches, surface coating, and transition metal ion substitution strategies are discussed here as possible ways to stabilize A x VOPO 4 structures and improve alkali metal ion diffusion. Finally, the role of advanced characterization techniques, such as X-ray absorption spectroscopy, diffraction, pair distribution function analysis and 7 Li and 31 P NMR, in understanding the reaction mechanism from both structural and electronic points of view is emphasized.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Restructuring of the Lewis Acid Sites in Y-Modified Dealuminated Beta-Zeolite by Hydrothermal Treatment

Yttrium-modified dealuminated Betazeolite (Y-BEA) represents a type of Lewis acid zeolite that has gained attention for its potential to efficiently catalyze the conversion of biomass-derived oxygenates. The structure of the Y active sites and their dynamics during biomass conversion reactions, which normally involve substantial amounts of water, necessitate thorough investigation for the rational design of more active and stable catalysts. Here, we conducted a study where a series of Y-BEA catalysts with different yttrium loadings (1–7 wt.%) were subjected to hydrothermal treatment (450 °C, 20% water) and investigated for their structural and catalytic activity changes through a combination of multiple characterizations and kinetic measurements. The number of acid sites of Y-BEA decreased without a change in acid strength following the hydrothermal treatment, which was confirmed by the results of acid site titration, infrared spectroscopy of probe molecules, and kinetic measurements for probe reactions (acetone aldol condensation). Structural analysis using X-ray diffraction (XRD), specific surface area measurement, X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS), and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) demonstrated that both the zeolite structure and the isolation status of the Y site remain intact after hydrothermal treatment. Further, the Diffuse Reflectance Infrared Fourier Transform Spectroscopy (DRIFTS) spectra, thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), and operando 1 H and 29 Si magic-angle spinning (MAS) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) revealed the dehydroxylation of Y-BEA induced by hydration-rearrangement-condensation restructuring during the high-temperature steam treatment. Dehydroxylation affects the structure of Y sites by reducing their vicinal silanol sites. In conclusion, this conversion of Lewis acidic Y sites into nonacidic sites is the primary factor behind the change in acid site quantity and catalytic activity on Y-BEA.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Surface Interactions and Nanoconfinement of Methane and Methane plus CO2 Revealed by High-Pressure Magic Angle Spinning NMR Spectroscopy and Molecular Dynamics

This study explores the fundamental, molecular- to microscopic-level behavior of methane gas confined into nanoporous silica proxies with different pore diameters and surface-to-volume (S/V) ratios. Surfaces and pore walls of nanoporous silica matrices are decorated with hydroxyl (-OH) groups, resembling natural heterogeneity. High-pressure MAS NMR was utilized to characterize the interactions between methane and the engineered nanoporous silica proxies under various temperature and pressure regimes. There was a change in the chemical shift position of confined methane slightly in the mixtures with nanoporous silica up to 393 K, as shown by high-pressure 13C-NMR. The 13C-NMR chemical shift of methane was changed by pressure, explained by the densification of methane inside the nanoporous silica materials. The influence of pore diameter and S/V of the nanoporous silica materials on the behaviors and dynamics of methane were studied. The presence of CO2 in mixtures of silica and methane needs analysis with caution because CO2 in a supercritical state and gaseous CO2 change the original structure of nanoporous silica and change surface area and pore volume. According to simulation, the picosecond scale dynamics of methane confined in larger pores of amorphous silica is faster. In the 4 nm pore, the diffusivity obtained from MD simulations in the pore with a higher S/V ratio is slower due to the trapping of methane molecules in adsorbed layers close to the corrugated pore surface. In contrast, relaxation measured with NMR for smaller pores (higher S/V) exhibits larger T1, indicating slower relaxation.

03 NATURAL GAS↗