Temperature-dependent changes in gas chromatographic separation metrics for trihexyl(tetradecyl)phosphonium-based ionic liquid stationary phases and comparison to conventional polysiloxane stationary phases
Here, to assess whether the trihexyl(tetradecyl)phosphonium chloride ([P 66614 + ][Cl - ]) ionic liquid (IL), employed as a gas chromatographic stationary phase, exhibits temperature-dependent phase transitions or structural heterogeneity, retention thermodynamics for probe molecules of varied chemical structure were investigated by gas chromatography (GC) over the temperature range of 25 to 64 °C using van’t Hoff analysis. All van’t Hoff plots for n-alkanes (C8–C12) and other probe analytes were linear, indicating the absence of detectable phase-transition behavior. The [P 66614 + ][Cl - ] IL was further compared with the [P 66614 + ] bis[(trifluoromethyl)sulfonyl]imide ([P 66614 + ][NTf 2 - ]) IL and commercial polysiloxane stationary phases in terms of temperature-dependent resolution behavior and chromatographic selectivity over the temperature range of 28–52 °C. The resolution factors of analytes in mixtures obtained using gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC–MS) and the summation of resolution values decreased smoothly with temperature on both IL stationary phases and on the dimethylphenylcyano-substituted polymeric stationary phase (OV-1701), whereas the poly(50% diphenyl/50% dimethyl siloxane) stationary phase (SPB-50) exhibited irregularities in its temperature-dependent summation of resolution profile, showing a distinct maximum in the temperature range of 34–40 °C. Selectivity values for the IL stationary phases were largely determined by the anion, with the [P 66614 + ][Cl - ] IL providing enhanced separation between polar and aromatic analytes, while the [P 66614 + ][NTf 2 - ] IL favored dispersive and π-π interactions that resulted in a reversal of elution order for some aliphatic–aromatic and alkyne-containing analyte pairs. Capillary columns prepared using different surface activation methods and coated with identical [P 66614 + ][Cl - ] IL stationary phase showed indistinguishable temperature-dependent trends in summation of resolution value and selectivity. An evaluation of analyte-specific selectivity provides insight into the characteristic separation behavior of the stationary phases and enables identification of analyte classes that are more efficiently separated on the [P 66614 + ]-based IL stationary phases compared to conventional stationary phase materials.