Preliminary Examination of Ethanol Fuel Effects on EPA’s R-factor for Vehicle Fuel Economy
The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) supported a test program from 2007 through 2012 to evaluate the potential impacts of intermediate ethanol blends (also known as mid-level blends) on legacy vehicles and other engines. The purpose of the program was to assess the viability of using intermediate ethanol blends as a contributor to meeting national goals for the use of renewable fuels. Appendix A lists a bibliography of related studies. The catalyst durability program involved aging and emissions testing vehicles on a range of ethanol blends. The study was completed in 2011 and a final report issued shortly after. This report describes a preliminary analysis of the fuel economy data from the catalyst durability study, to determine the proper value for the R factor which is called out in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) for computing vehicle fuel economy on the certification cycle. The fuel economy equation that is specified in CFR for gasoline-fuelled vehicles is based on a carbon mass balance (CMB) approach to determine the amount of fuel consumed during the test by measuring the carbon-bearing emissions that are produced; however, it also incorporates a scaling factor (R factor) based on the net heating value of the fuel and the sensitivity of fuel economy to changes in the heating value. The impact of the R factor is a fixed ratio in the resultant fuel economy that is dependent upon fuel properties other than those required for a typical CMB calculation. This equation was put in place in 1988 to correct for differences between certification fuels to address corporate average fuel economy (CAFE) credit issues associated with fuel property variations. The algorithm adjusts the calculated fuel economy to compute what would have been measured had the 1975 certification fuel been used for the test. The R factor was defined as the sensitivity of the fuel economy result to changes in fuel energy content. When R equals 1.0, the fuel economy change exactly tracks the energy density difference between the fuels. If R is less than 1.0, the fuel economy change is smaller than the change in energy density. The R factor was defined to be 0.6 based on tests using 1980s vehicles. Since that time, the Auto/Oil test program has established that the R factor for 1990s vehicles is higher (about 0.93). More recently EPA analyzed the EPAct/V2/E-89 dataset to compute the R factor, resulting in an average of 0.82 to 0.86. It is important to note that the EPAct/V2/E89 test program used the LA92 test cycle, a cycle known to contain more aggressive accelerations than the FTP. To date, EPA has only required emissions and fuel economy testing of gasoline vehicles with a certification fuel that does not contain ethanol. However in 2013 EPA issued a Proposed Rule seeking comment on the establishment of an emissions certification fuel containing ethanol, such as E10 or E15. Calculating modern vehicle fuel economy with the existing CFR equation with an R factor of 0.6 when ethanol blends are used produces significant errors. For the catalyst durability program, a straightforward CMB approach was used to compute fuel economy, thereby allowing a straightforward evaluation of the impact of ethanol content on fuel economy. However, if an ethanol-containing fuel is to become the new certification fuel for light-duty vehicles, consistent application of the CFR equation needs to be considered for the benefit of manufacturers’ CAFE compliance. Analysis of city cycle Federal Test Procedure (FTP) fuel economy test results and fuel analyses from the catalyst durability study indicates that the average R-factor for modern vehicles is very close to unity at about 0.94±0.04. This result is very similar to the results of the 1993 Auto/Oil test program. Future work should examine other drive cycles, and advanced vehicle technologies which may reveal sensitivities to properties other than heating value.