Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “aqueous processing”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,153 records · Page 64

Hydrothermal Processing of Macroalgal Feedstocks in Continuous-Flow Reactors

Wet macroalgal slurries have been converted into a biocrude by hydrothermal liquefaction (HTL) in a bench-scale continuous-flow reactor system. Carbon conversion to a gravity-separable oil product of 58.8% was accomplished at relatively low temperature (350 °C) in a pressurized (subcritical liquid water) environment (20 MPa) when using feedstock slurries with a 21.7% concentration of dry solids. As opposed to earlier work in batch reactors reported by others, direct oil recovery was achieved without the use of a solvent, and biomass trace mineral components were removed by processing steps so that they did not cause processing difficulties. In addition, catalytic hydrothermal gasification (CHG) was effectively applied for HTL byproduct water cleanup and fuel gas production from water-soluble organics. Conversion of 99.2% of the carbon left in the aqueous phase was demonstrated. Finally, as a result, high conversion of macroalgae to liquid and gas fuel products was found with low levels of residual organic contamination in byproduct water. Both process steps were accomplished in continuous-flow reactor systems such that design data for process scale-up was generated.

biomass↗

Crystalline Ceramic Waste Forms: Report Detailing Data Collection In Support Of Potential FY13 Pilot Scale Melter Test

The research conducted in this work package is aimed at taking advantage of the long term thermodynamic stability of crystalline ceramics to create more durable waste forms (as compared to high level waste glass) in order to reduce the reliance on engineered and natural barrier systems. Durable ceramic waste forms that incorporate a wide range of radionuclides have the potential to broaden the available disposal options and to lower the storage and disposal costs associated with advanced fuel cycles. Assemblages of several titanate phases have been successfully demonstrated to incorporate radioactive waste elements, and the multiphase nature of these materials allows them to accommodate variation in the waste composition. Recent work has shown that they can be successfully produced from a melting and crystallization process. The objective of this report is to summarize the data collection in support of future melter demonstration testing for crystalline ceramic waste forms. The waste stream used as the basis for the development and testing is a combination of the projected Cs/Sr separated stream, the Trivalent Actinide - Lanthanide Separation by Phosphorous reagent Extraction from Aqueous Komplexes (TALSPEAK) waste stream consisting of lanthanide fission products, the transition metal fission product waste stream resulting from the transuranic extraction (TRUEX) process, and a high molybdenum concentration with relatively low noble metal concentrations. The principal difficulties encountered during processing of the “reference ceramic” waste form by a melt and crystallization process were the incomplete incorporation of Cs into the hollandite phase and the presence of secondary Cs-Mo non-durable phases. In the single phase hollandite system, these issues were addressed in this study by refining the compositions to include Cr as a transition metal element and the use of Ti/TiO 2 buffer to maintain reducing conditions. Initial viscosity studies of ceramic waste forms indicated that the pour spout must be maintained above 1400°C to avoid flow blockages due to crystallization. In-situ electron irradiations simulate radiolysis effects indicated hollandite undergoes a crystalline to amorphous transition after a radiation dose of 10 13 Gy which corresponds to approximately 1000 years at anticipated doses (2 10 10 -2 10 11 Gy). Dual-beam ion irradiations employing light ion beam (such as 5 MeV alpha) and heavy ion beam (such as 100 keV Kr) studies indicate that reference ceramic waste forms are radiation tolerant to the α-particles and β-particles, but are susceptible to a crystalline to amorphous transition under recoil nuclei effects. A path forward for refining the processing steps needed to form the targeted phase assemblages is outlined in this report. Processing modifications including melting in a reducing atmosphere with the use of Ti/TiO 2 buffers, and the addition of Cr to the transition metal additives to facilitate Cs-incorporation in the hollandite phase. In addition to melt processing, alternative fabrication routes are being considered including Spark Plasma Sintering (SPS) and Hot Isostatic Pressing (HIP).

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Impacts of Methane on Carbon Dioxide Storage in Brine Formations

In the context of geological carbon sequestration (GCS), carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) is often injected into deep formations saturated with a brine that may contain dissolved light hydrocarbons, such as methane (CH 4 ). In this multicomponent multiphase displacement process, CO 2 competes with CH 4 in terms of dissolution, and CH 4 tends to exsolve from the aqueous into a gaseous phase. Because CH 4 has a lower viscosity than injected CO 2 , CH 4 is swept up into a ‘bank’ of CH 4 –rich gas ahead of the CO 2 displacement front. On the one hand, this may provide a useful tracer signal of an approaching CO 2 front. On the other hand, the emergence of gaseous CH 4 is undesirable because it poses a leakage risk of a far more potent greenhouse gas than CO 2 if the cap rock is compromised. Open fractures or faults and wells could result in CH 4 contamination of overlying groundwater aquifers as well as surface emissions. We investigate this process through detailed numerical simulations for a large–scale GCS pilot project (near Cranfield, Mississippi) for which a rich set of field data is available. An accurate cubic–plus–association equation–of–state is used to describe the non–linear phase behavior of multiphase brine–CH 4 –CO 2 mixtures, and breakthrough curves in two observation wells are used to constrain transport processes. Furthermore, both field data and simulations indeed show the development of an extensive plume of CH 4 –rich (up to 90 mol%) gas as a consequence of CO 2 injection, with important implications for the risk assessment of future GCS projects.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

Complexes of earth-abundant metals for catalytic electrochemical hydrogen generation under aqueous conditions.

Growing global energy demands and climate change motivate the development of new renewable energy technologies. In this context, water splitting using sustainable energy sources has emerged as an attractive process for carbon-neutral fuel cycles. A key scientific challenge to achieving this overall goal is the invention of new catalysts for the reductive and oxidative conversions of water to hydrogen and oxygen, respectively. This review article will highlight progress in molecular electrochemical approaches for catalytic reduction of protons to hydrogen, focusing on complexes of earth-abundant metals that can function in pure aqueous or mixed aqueous-organic media. The use of water as a reaction medium has dual benefits of maintaining high substrate concentration as well as minimizing the environmental impact from organic additives and by-products.

Thoi, V Sara↗

Roadmap for development of an advanced head-end reactor

A novel dry treatment process for used nuclear fuel (UNF) using nitrogen dioxide is being developed to remove volatile and semi-volatile fission products and convert the monolithic fuel material to a fine powder suitable as a feed to many different separations processes. The process may be considered an advanced form of voloxidation, which was envisioned to remove tritium from the fuel prior to introduction of the fuel into the aqueous separations systems, where subsequent separation of tritium from the water would be difficult and expensive. The product from NO{sub 2} reaction can be selectively chosen to be U{sub 3}O{sub 8}, UO{sub 3}, or a nitrate by adjusting the processing conditions; all products are generated at temperatures lower than those used in standard voloxidation. All the fundamental tenants of the process have been successfully demonstrated as a proof of principle, and many aspects have been corroborated multiple times at laboratory scale. The goal of this roadmap is to define the activities required to develop the process to a technology-readiness level sufficient to an engineering-scale implementation. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Surface Self-nanocrystallization in Copper Electroforming

The coarse columnar grain layer generated on top of electroforming deposits leads to low surface strength and poor global performance of deposits. Here, we introduce a particle abrasive-induced surface self-nanocrystallization process, which is a part of the electroforming process rather than involving complex poststeps using special equipment. It can generate a thickness-controllable surface nanocrystalline layer on top of copper deposits for performance enhancement. In this study, surface nanocrystalline layers of 10, 20, 50 and 120 μm were fabricated on top of 500-μm-thick copper deposits. The tensile strength of copper deposits increases from 234 to 246, 330, 383 and 421 MPa, with a corresponding decrease in elongation from 26 to 25, 24, 15 and 6%, respectively. The moderately thick surface nanocrystalline layer makes the copper deposits exhibit good comprehensive mechanical properties. In addition, the surface self-nanocrystallization also makes the copper deposits show a better corrosion resistance in a neutral aqueous 0.1 M NaCl solution. This study aims to promote a convenient, controllable and reliable surface self-nanocrystallization process in electroforming for improving the global performance of deposits.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Separation of chemical groups from bio-oil aqueous phase via sequential organic solvent extraction

Bio-oil aqueous phase contains a considerable amount of furans, alcohols, ketones, aldehydes and phenolics besides the major components of organic acids and anhydrosugars. The complexity of bio-oil aqueous phase limits its efficient utilization. To improve the efficiency of bio-oil biorefinery, this study focused on the separation of chemical groups from bio-oil aqueous phase via sequential organic solvent extractions. Due to their high recoverability and low solubility in water, four solvents (hexane, petroleum ether, chloroform, and ethyl acetate) with different polarities were evaluated, and the optimum process conditions for chemical extraction were determined. Chloroform had high extraction efficiency for furans, phenolics, and ketones. In addition to these chemical groups, ethyl acetate had high extraction efficiency for organic acids. The sequential extraction by using chloroform followed by ethyl acetate rendered that 62.2 wt.% of original furans, ketones, alcohols, and phenolics were extracted to chloroform, over 62 wt.% acetic acid was extracted to ethyl acetate, resulting in a high concentration of levoglucosan (~53.0 wt.%) in the final aqueous phase. Chemicals separated via the sequential extraction could be used as feedstocks in biorefinery using processes such as catalytic upgrading of furans and phenolics to hydrocarbons, fermentation of levoglucosan to produce alcohols and diols, and hydrogen production from organic acids via microbial electrolysis.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

High Areal Energy 3D-Interdigitated Micro-Supercapacitors in Aqueous and Ionic Liquid Electrolytes

The fabrication of high performance on-chip 3D micro-supercapacitors (MSCs) based on MnO 2 pseudocapacitive binder-free thin film electrodes (< 500 nm thick) with interdigitated topology is reported. An original technological process easily scalable to pilot production line is proposed on 3-inch silicon wafers. High areal energy (> 10 μWh.cm -2 ) and power densities (> 10 mW.cm -2 ) are reached on small footprint micro-supercapacitors (4 mm 2 ) tested in aqueous electrolyte (0.8 V). Furthermore, the cell voltage of such MSC can be increased up to 1.5 V with EMI TFSI ionic liquids but at the expense of the areal capacitance. The performance in ionic liquid is in the same order of magnitude than the one obtained for aqueous electrolyte. The benefit from the 3D topology is clearly demonstrated when the surface performance are normalized to the electrode thickness allowing to obtain an interesting energy vs power tradeoff (> 10 μWh.cm -2 μm -1 and > 1 mw.cm -2 μm -1 ). Here, this paper aims at improving the energy density of MSCs while keeping high power capability, by combining the use of ionic liquids and the deposition of MnO 2 thin film onto robust and efficient 3D scaffolds.

3D silicon microtubes↗

CO 2 capture from IGCC gas streams using the AC-ABC process

The objective of this project was to develop a novel, low-cost CO 2 capture process from pre-combustion gas streams. The bench-scale work was conducted at the SRI International. A 0.15-MWe integrated pilot plant was constructed and operated for over 700 hours at the National Carbon Capture Center, Wilsonville, AL. The AC-ABC (ammonium carbonate-ammonium bicarbonate) process for capture of CO 2 and H 2 S from the pre-combustion gas stream offers many advantages over Selexol-based technology. The process relies on the simple chemistry of the NH 3 -CO 2 -H 2 O-H 2 S system and on the ability of the aqueous ammoniated solution to absorb CO 2 at near ambient temperatures and to release it as a high-purity, high-pressure gas at a moderately elevated regeneration temperature. It is estimated the increase in cost of electricity (COE) with the AC-ABC process will be ~ 30%, and the cost of CO 2 captured is projected to be less than $27/metric ton of CO 2 while meeting 90% CO 2 capture goal. The Bechtel Pressure Swing Claus (BPSC) is a complementary technology offered by Bechtel Hydrocarbon Technology Solutions, Inc. BPSC is a high-pressure, sub-dew-point Claus process that allows for nearly complete removal of H 2 S from a gas stream. It operates at gasifier pressures and moderate temperatures and does not affect CO 2 content. When coupled with AC-ABC, the combined technologies allow a nearly pure CO 2 stream to be captured at high pressure, something which Selexol and other solvent-based technologies cannot achieve.

08 HYDROGEN↗

Transition from Vehicular to Structural Ionic Transport in Electrified Alkali Aqueous Solutions

A molecular understanding of the solvation and dynamics of ions under static electric fields is crucial for modelling a wide range of natural and technological processes. Yet, traditional simulation methods suffer from a trade-off that has to be made between accuracy and statistical convergence. To bridge this gap, herein we extend our recently introduced Perturbed Neural Network Potential Molecular Dynamics (PNNP MD) approach to investigate the solvation structures and ionic transport mechanisms of electrified alkali cationic solutions. We obtain ionic conductivities for Li+, Na+ and Cs+ from the field dependence of the ionic current density in good agreement with experiment. Surprisingly, the migration mechanism is found to be strikingly different for the three ions despite their similar ionic conductivities. While Li+ conducts predominantly through vehicular migration of a stable 4-fold coordinated ion at all field strengths, Cs+ conducts strictly through a structural diffusion mechanism, where 9-12 transient first shell water coordination bonds are broken and renewed. Notably, aqueous Na+ emerges as a “Goldilocks” ion: its ion-water interactions are strong enough to maintain distinct 5-6 fold coordination shells at zero field (unlike Cs+) yet labile enough to be strongly perturbed by electric fields (unlike Li+). As a consequence, we observe an electric field-induced transition from vehicular to structural ionic transport for Na+ that is accompanied by a marked increase in the ionic current density. Our results imply that the conductance mechanism of ions with moderate ion-solvent interactions can be effectively tuned by external electric fields.

Joll, Kit↗

Intermediate-Scale Experimental Study to Improve Fundamental Understanding of Attenuation Capacity for Leaking CO 2 in Heterogeneous Shallow Aquifers

In order to assess the risks of Geologic Carbon Sequestration (GCS), it is crucial to understand the fundamental physicochemical processes that may occur if and when stored CO 2 leaks upward from a deep storage reservoir into the shallow subsurface. Intermediate-scale experiments allow for improved understanding of the multiphase evolution processes that control CO 2 migration behaviour in the subsurface, because the boundary conditions, initial conditions, and porous media parameters can be better controlled and monitored in the laboratory than in field settings. For this study, a large experimental test bed was designed to mimic a cross-section of a shallow aquifer with layered geologic heterogeneity. As water with aqueous CO 2 was injected into the system to mimic a CO 2 -charged water leakage scenario, the spatiotemporal evolution of the multiphase CO 2 plume was monitored. Similar experiments were performed with two different sand combinations to assess the relative effects of different types of geologic facies transitions on the CO 2 evolution processes. Significant CO 2 attenuation was observed in both scenarios, but by fundamentally different mechanisms. When the porous media layers had very different permeabilities, attenuation was caused by local accumulation (structural trapping) and slow re-dissolution of gas phase CO 2 . When the permeability difference between the layers was relatively small, on the other hand, gas phase continually evolved over widespread areas near the leading edge of the aqueous plume, which also attenuated CO 2 migration. In conclusion, this improved process understanding will aid in the development of models that could be used for effective risk assessment and monitoring programs for GCS projects.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

TALSPEAK CURVE: AN ILLUSTRATION OF A SEE-SAW EFFECT IN SEPARATIONS

A superbly balanced thermodynamic struggle for metal ion coordination by aqueous aminopolycarboxylate reagent, DTPA, and non-aqueous organophosphorous phase transfer reagent, HDEHP, affords the separation of trivalent actinides from trivalent lanthanides under the umbrella of the Talspeak liquid-liquid distribution process. This thermodynamic relationship has been linked to an analogous “see-saw” behavior, where the balance is distorted when either of the key complexing players is subject to adverse conditions that interfere with their optimal operation. The thermodynamic balance is tipped in favour of HDEHP whenever increased acidity of the aqueous solution out-competes the metal ion complexation by aqueous complexing agent. Also enhanced steric crowding may switch-off efficient coordination of the metal ion. When HDEHP is depolymerised due to the presence of aliphatic alcohol in the organic phase its phase transferring power is diminished. Such complication paves way for DTPA to establish its dominance on the distribution of trivalent metal ions in the 2-phase system. The illustrated sensitivity of the thermodynamic balance between DTPA and HDEHP in Talspeak-type systems may serve as informative tool when studying less-predictable realms of Talspeak chemistry.

38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗

The investigation of NaTi2(PO4)3@C/Ag as a high-performance anode material for aqueous rechargeable sodium-ion batteries

Highlights: • Facile preparation of NaTi{sub 2}(PO{sub 4}){sub 3}@C/Ag. • An extraordinary self-rejuvenation process was observed every other 20–30 cycles. • Retain a capacity of 71.7 mA h g{sup −1} even at 5 C after 200 cycles. - Abstract: Silver and carbon coated NaTi{sub 2}(PO{sub 4}){sub 3} is synthesized via a facile sol-gel method, with polyvinyl alcohol as carbon source and silver nitrate as Ag source. NaTi{sub 2}(PO{sub 4}){sub 3}@C/Ag is characterized by XRD, SEM, TEM, EDS and XPS. It can be found that C/Ag composite layer is uniformly coated on the surface of NaTi{sub 2}(PO{sub 4}){sub 3}. Compared with the pure NaTi{sub 2}(PO{sub 4}){sub 3}, NaTi{sub 2}(PO{sub 4}){sub 3}@C/Ag material demonstrates significantly higher rate capability and cycling stability. It can deliver an initial discharge capacity of 126.5 mA h g{sup −1} at a current rate of 2 C with the capacity retention of 94.5% after 100 cycles. It can still deliver an initial discharge capacity of 97.5 mA h g{sup −1} at a current rate of 5 C with a substantial capacity retention of 83.8% after 400 cycles. It is worth mentioning that NaTi{sub 2}(PO{sub 4}){sub 3}@C/Ag also exhibits pretty good rate capacity. When the current density ranges from 1 C, 2 C, 5 C, 10 C and finally back to 1 C, NaTi{sub 2}(PO{sub 4}){sub 3}@C/Ag electrode still retains a discharge capacity of 84.6 mAh g{sup −1} after 200 cycles at 5 C corresponding to a capacity retention ratio of 83.5%.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Activating magnetite ores for aqueous ironmaking at high current densities

Low-temperature electrochemical cells reducing iron oxides to metal in alkaline electrolytes can support fully electrified steelmaking processes. Previous studies on these cells have primarily focused on high-surface-area hematite, Fe 2 O 3 , reactants whereas attempts to reduce suspensions of magnetite, Fe 3 O 4 —one of the two feedstocks for existing ironmaking reactors—have generally been limited to low rates of reaction (<30 mA cm −2 ). Here, in this study, we control the crystalline domain size of Fe 2 O 3 and Fe 3 O 4 particles in 10 M NaOH electrolytes to study how the nanoscale morphology of oxides controls the rate of electrochemical ironmaking. Rotating-ring disk electrode measurements of Fe 2+ , in situ Raman spectroscopy of the electrode surface, and ex situ electron microscopy were consistent with a hypothesized passivation process at Fe 3 O 4 surfaces that may prevent the continuous formation of soluble intermediates. Sufficiently small (<100 nm diameter) oxide particles yielded Fe partial current densities >160 mA cm −2 , a fivefold increase relative to previously reported rates for Fe 3 O 4 suspensions and comparable to active Fe 2 O 3 . Electron microscopy revealed that electrodeposited films were composed of micron-scale crystalline Fe domains with a porous film of Fe 3 O 4 nanoparticles and supports a model where Fe is grown primarily from soluble Fe 2+ intermediates. Based on these insights, inactive blast-furnace-grade iron-oxides were transformed into high surface area nanoparticles (1.6 to 229.2 m 2 g −1 ) via reprecipitation, leading to a ninefold enhancement in faradaic efficiency and an Fe partial current density of 120 mA cm −2 . When integrated with chlor-iron cells producing reagents for reprecipitation, this approach could lead to a cost-competitive process for electrochemical ironmaking from industrially relevant feedstocks.

TEM↗

Process for the preparation of lactic acid and glyceric acid

Hexose and pentose monosaccharides are degraded to lactic acid and glyceric acid in an aqueous solution in the presence of an excess of a strongly anionic exchange resin, such as AMBERLITE IRN78 and AMBERLITE IRA400. The glyceric acid and lactic acid can be separated from the aqueous solution. Lactic acid and glyceric acid are staple articles of commerce.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Purification of Gas and Liquid Streams Using Composite Sorbents Embedded in a Polyacrylonitrile Matrix

As new sorbents are developed for purifying gases or fluids via physisorption and/or chemisorption processes, the push is typically to increase the available specific surface area (SSA) to maximize the available binding sites for capturing various species of interest. One downfall to making a sorbent more porous is that it often leads to a product that is fragile or friable and can be damaged (resulting in unwanted powders), thus imposing process limitations. Techniques can be used to enhance the mechanical integrity of a sorbent including heat treatments or pelletization with extrusion or granulation processes but these can result in collapsed, unavailable pore structures within the sorbent, which leads to decreased diffusivity and eventual reduction of desired capacities of target species. An alternative approach for improving the mechanical integrity of the sorbent is to bind it (or encapsulate it) within a porous matrix that passively holds the sorbent in place. Typically, this approach leads to a decrease in sorption efficiency on the basis of starting sorbent mass, because the active sorbent is diluted by the binding matrix material and the active surfaces of the sorbent are somewhat obscured by the binding matrix, but it comes with the advantage that the active sorbent is held in place and better protected from powderization during operation. One approach to accomplish this is to embed the active sorbent in a macroporous passive polyacrylonitrile (PAN) matrix to create a composite sorbent. When optimized, the PAN matrix is highly porous and allows for gaseous or aqueous media transport through the product providing adequate binding site access between the active sorbent and the species of interest. Including a polymer in the composite sorbent limits the maximum operating temperature above which the composite sorbent incurs loss of structural integrity (e.g., decomposes) and/or reduction in SSA. Composite sorbents have been demonstrated with sulfide aerogels (SnS-PAN) for capturing I2(g), hydrogen mordenite (HZ-PAN) and silver-exchanged mordenite (AgZ-PAN) for capturing Kr and Xe, nano-particle metal oxides (N-CAS) for removing arsenic from water, ammonium molybdophosphate (AMP-PAN) for removing 137Cs from aqueous nuclear waste streams, and the phosphate sponge (TPS) composite, which is being used to remove inorganic and orthophosphates from water treatment processes to mitigate introduction to the environment impeding toxic algae bloom formations. This chapter provides details on production of these materials along with options to optimize of the synthesis process. It also includes experimental techniques to characterize products and assess their performances.

polyacrylonitrile, aerogel, gaseous capture, aqueo↗

The Key Role of U 28 in the Aqueous Self‐Assembly of Uranyl Peroxide Nanocages

Abstract For 11 years now, the structural diversity and aesthetic beauty of uranyl–peroxide capsules have fascinated researchers from the diverse fields of mineralogy, polyoxometalate chemistry, and nuclear fuel technologies. There is still much to be learned about the mechanisms of the self‐assembly process, and the role of solution parameters including pH, alkali template, temperature, time, and others. Here we have exploited the high solubility of the UO 2 2+ /H 2 O 2 /LiOH aqueous system to address the effect of the hydroxide concentration. Important techniques of this study are single‐crystal X‐ray diffraction, small‐angle X‐ray scattering, and Raman spectroscopy. Three key phases dominate the solution speciation as a function of time and the LiOH/UO 2 2+ ratio: the uranyl–triperoxide monomer [UO 2 (O 2 ) 3 ] 4− and the two capsules [(UO 2 )(O 2 )(OH)] 24 24− (U 24 ) and [(UO 2 )(O 2 ) 1.5 ] 28 28− (U 28 ). When the LiOH/U ratio is around three, U 28 forms rapidly and this cluster can be isolated in high yield and purity. This result was most surprising and challenges the hypothesis that alkali templating is the most important determinant in the cluster geometry. Moreover, analogous experiments with KOH, NH 4 OH, and TEAOH (TEA=tetraethylammonium) also rapidly yield U 28 , which suggests that U 28 is the kinetically favored species. Complete mapping of the pH–time phase space reveals only a narrow window of the U 28 dominance, which is why it was previously overlooked as an important kinetic species in this chemical system, as well as others with different counterions.

Falaise, Clément↗