Comparisons between a priori Uncertainty Quantification and Calculation/Measurement Discrepancies Applied to the MERCI UO{sub 2} Fuel Rod Decay Heat Experiment
In 2008, an UO{sub 2} fuel rod was irradiated up to ∼ 3.5 GWd/tHL in the CEA/Saclay research reactor Osiris through the MERCI experiment. Some rod's pellets were analysed. Experimental results were obtained: - fuel rod decay heat measurement by calorimetry (cooling times from 27 minutes to 42 days), - evaluation of the amounts of some nuclei (U, Pu, Cs, Nd...) by isotopic dilution mass spectrometry, - nuclide activities. Comparison of type (C - M)/M where C is the calculated decay heat and M the experimentally measured decay heat was reported in reference. Neutronics flux was computed by CEA TRIPOLI-4 Monte-Carlo or APOLLO2 deterministic transport code system. Irradiation and cooling phases were simulated with CEA DARWIN/PEPIN2 code system. Good agreements were globally shown between numerical simulation results and experimental measurements on total decay heat. Uncertainty propagation in this previous work was established from Rebah's studies. These last years, within the framework of supports to its industrial partners EDF and Areva, the CEA/DEN has implemented two different approaches to propagate nuclear data uncertainties to depletion code outputs. A direct forward deterministic perturbation method using sensitivity profiles was implemented in the French industrial depletion code system DARWIN/PEPIN2. Meanwhile, a propagation based on Monte Carlo correlated sampling was achieved using the CEA uncertainty platform URANIE and the new generation depletion code MENDEL. Both methods will be described in this article. Uncertainties on nuclear data (independent fission yields, multigroup microscopic cross sections, radioactive decay constants, radioactive decay branching ratio and radioactive decay energies) are propagated to decay heat and isotopic concentrations. To match MERCI first study, flux computation is realized by APOLLO2. Furthermore, uncertainty quantification (UQ) is re-evaluated by both DARWIN/PEPIN2 and MENDEL codes. It is an important stage in the process of validating both depletion codes with their respective data library. (authors)