Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Aromatic Compounds”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 127 records · Page 7
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2020

Engineered Pseudomonas putida simultaneously catabolizes five major components of corn stover lignocellulose: Glucose, xylose, arabinose, p-coumaric acid, and acetic acid

Valorization of all major lignocellulose components, including lignin, cellulose, and hemicellulose is critical for an economically viable bioeconomy. In most biochemical conversion approaches, the standard process separately upgrades sugar hydrolysates and lignin. Here, we present a new process concept based on an engineered microbe that could enable simultaneous upgrading of all lignocellulose streams, which has the ultimate potential to reduce capital cost and enable new metabolic engineering strategies. Specifically, we engineered Pseudomonas putida, a robust microorganism capable of catabolizing aromatic compounds, organic acids, and D-glucose, to utilize D-xylose and L-arabinose by tuning D-xylose transport and pentose phosphate pathway flux. Distinct L-arabinose pathways enabled D-glucose, D-xylose, and L-arabinose co-utilization in minimal medium using model compounds as well as corn stover hydrolysate. After modifying catabolite repression, our engineered P. putida simultaneously co-utilized five representative compounds from cellulose, hemicellulose, and lignin, demonstrating the feasibility of simultaneously upgrading total lignocellulosic biomass to value-added chemicals.

Elmore, Joshua R.↗
DOE OSTI2020

Gene Amplification, Laboratory Evolution, and Biosensor Screening Reveal MucK as a Terephthalic Acid Transporter in Acinetobacter baylyi ADP1

Microbial terephthalic acid (TPA) catabolic pathways are conserved among the few bacteria known to turnover this xenobiotic aromatic compound. However, to date there are few reported cases in which this pathway has been successfully expressed in heterologous hosts to impart efficient utilization of TPA as a sole carbon source. In this work, we aimed to engineer TPA conversion in Acinetobacter baylyi ADP1 via the heterologous expression of catabolic and transporter genes from a native TPA-utilizing bacterium. Specifically, we obtained ADP1-derived strains capable of growing on TPA as the sole carbon source using chromosomal insertion and targeted amplification of the tph catabolic operon from Comamonas sp. E6. Adaptive laboratory evolution was then used to improve growth on this substrate. TPA consumption rates of the evolved strains, which retained multiple copies of the tph genes, were ~0.2 g/L/h (or ~1 g TPA/g cells/h), similar to that of Comamonas sp. E6 and almost 2-fold higher than that of Rhodococcus jostii RHA1, another native TPA-utilizing strain. To evaluate TPA transport in the evolved ADP1 strains, we engineered a TPA biosensor consisting of the transcription factor TphR and a fluorescent reporter. In combination with whole-genome sequencing, the TPA biosensor revealed that transport of TPA was not mediated by the heterologous proteins from Comamonas sp. E6. Instead, the endogenous ADP1 muconate transporter MucK, a member of the major facilitator superfamily, was responsible for TPA transport in several evolved strains in which MucK variants were found to enhance TPA uptake. Furthermore, the IclR-type transcriptional regulator DcaS was identified as a repressor of mucK expression. Overall, this work presents an unexpected function of a native protein identified through gene amplification, adaptive laboratory evolution, and a combination of screening methods. This study also provides a TPA biosensor for application in ADP1 and identifies transporter variants for use in metabolic engineering applications focused on plastic upcycling of polyesters.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2023

Modeling Ethanol-Blend Fuel Sprays under Direct-Injection Spark-Ignition Engine Conditions

Computational modeling of fuel-injection and fuel-impingement processes was carried out to provide insight into previous experimental results obtained from a direct-injection spark-ignition research engine operated with various ethanol and aromatic fuel blends. Seven model fuels were evaluated using both single- and split-injection strategies. Model results showed that droplet vaporization enriched the concentrations of aromatic species in the liquid phase, especially those with low vapor pressure, and ethanol-containing fuels altered droplet sizes and led to increased liquid-phase mass in the cylinder. For the spray-modeling conditions studied, most of the injected fuel remained in the liquid phase, which would be expected to result in more fuel impingement on cylinder or piston surfaces. Fuel impinging on lower cylinder-temperature surfaces was found to create wall films that could interact with the piston during the compression stroke. Fuel impinging on hotter piston-temperature surfaces vaporized more readily, but for fuels with high ethanol and aromatic content, wall films remained and were highly concentrated with lower vapor pressure and aromatic compounds. These films could lead to pool fires during combustion and therefore significant particulate matter emissions.

BIOMASS FUELS,INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND AN↗
DOE OSTI2020

Molecular Dynamics Simulation of the Structures, Dynamics, and Aggregation of Dissolved Organic Matter

Dissolved organic matter (DOM) plays a significant role in the transport and transformation of pollutants in the aquatic environment. However, the experimental characterization of DOM has been limited mainly to bulk properties, and the molecular-level interactions among various components of DOM remain to be fully characterized. In this study, we use molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to probe the structural properties of model DOM systems at atomic detail. The 200 ns simulations, validated by available experimental data, reveal processes and mechanisms by which chemical species (cations, peptides, lipids, lignin, carbohydrates, and some low-molecular-weight aliphatic and aromatic compounds) aggregate to form complex DOM. The DOM aggregates are dynamic, consisting of a hydrophobic core and amphiphilic exterior. The lipid tails and other hydrophobic fragments form the core, with hydrophilic and amphiphilic groups exposed to water, making DOM accessible to both polar and nonpolar species. Thus, the lipid component acts as a nucleator, whereas cations (especially Ca 2+ ) connect the molecular fragments on the surface by coordinating with the O-containing functional groups of DOM. The structural details revealed here provide new insights including surface accessible atoms, overall assemblage, and interactions among the molecules of DOM for understanding the kinetics and mechanisms through which DOM interacts with metal and other contaminants.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2025

Revolutionizing Methane Transformation with the Dual Production of Aromatics and Electricity in a Protonic Ceramic Electrocatalytic Membrane Reactor

Reducing the energy and carbon intensity of the conventional chemical processing industry can be achieved by electrochemically transforming natural gases into higher-value chemicals with higher efficiency and near-zero emissions. In this work, the direct conversion of methane to aromatics and electricity has been achieved in a protonic ceramic electrocatalytic membrane reactor through the integration of a proton-conducting membrane assembly and a trimetallic Pt–Cu/Mo/ZSM-5 catalyst for the nonoxidative methane dehydro-aromatization reaction. In this integrated system, a remarkable 15.6% single-pass methane conversion with an 11.4% benzene yield has been demonstrated, while a peak power density of 276 mW cm –2 is obtained at 700 °C. The enhanced 15.7% increase in conversion and 16.0% improvement in the yield are observed when compared with the thermochemical process, which is attributed to the shift of reaction equilibrium by the removal of hydrogen through the protonic membrane. Concurrently, the faster H2 removal at a higher electrical current gave rise to a higher methane conversion and benzene yield. Furthermore, the catalyst can be efficiently regenerated by eliminating carbon deposition. A stable cell potential is maintained for 45 h under a constant current load of 0.13 A cm –2 . Lastly, the dual production of aromatics and electricity in the electrocatalytic membrane reactor has been demonstrated to be an attractive approach for decarbonizing chemical processing.

aromatic compounds↗
DOE OSTI2023

Molecular Nature of Mineral-Organic Associations within Redox-Active Mountainous Floodplain Sediments

Floodplains are critical terrestrial-aquatic interfaces that act as hotspots of organic carbon (OC) cycling, regulating ecosystem carbon storage as well as export to riverine systems. Within floodplain sediments, regular flooding and textural gradients interact to create dynamic redox conditions. While anaerobic protection of OC upon burial is a well-recognized carbon storage mechanism in redox-active floodplain sediments, the impact of protective mineral-organic associations is relatively unknown. Here we determined the quantitative importance and chemical composition of mineral-organic associations along well-defined redox gradients emerging from textural variations and depth within meander sediments of the subalpine East River watershed (Gothic, CO). Here we characterized mineral-organic associations using a combination of sequential extractions, physical fractionation, and high-resolution mass spectrometry. Across the meander, we found that mineral-associated OC constitutes a significant fraction of total OC, and that extractable iron (Fe) and aluminum (Al) phases as well as high-density isolates were strongly correlated with total OC content, suggesting that mineral-organic associations are quantitatively important for floodplain sediment OC protection. Our mass spectrometry results showed OC associated with increasingly ordered Fe and Al phases are relatively enriched in low-molecular weight, oxidized, aromatic compounds. Surprisingly, however, total OC content showed weak or no correlation with indicators of anaerobic protection, such as relatively bioavailable OC pools (water-extractable and particulate OC) or the molecular weight and oxidation state of OC. Overall, this work highlights that protection of OC bound to reactive mineral phases-in addition to anaerobic protection-can play a quantitatively important role in controlling soil carbon storage in redox-active floodplain sediments.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2024

Triplet Management at Ligand-Perovskite Interface to Enhanced Photovoltaics Performance

Aromatic organic molecules are widely used as passivators in perovskite solar cells (PSCs). Efforts have been devoted to improving the energy alignments, band edge states, and defect passivation functionalities. However, potential energy loss through triplet states in such conjugated molecules has not been investigated in the past. Here, we report the observation of charge transfer from FAPbI 3 to the triplet state of a pyrene (Pyr)-based cationic ligand. Such a potential loss channel can be suppressed via delicate triplet management in polycyclic aromatic compounds. Interestingly, a subtle structural modification from Pyr to the triphenylene (TP) core gave rise to shallower triplets that prohibit electron transfer from perovskites. This strategy has led to TP-passivated PSCs achieving an enhanced power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 24.69% from 23.10% in Pyr-passivated counterparts. Moreover, the devices retained above 80% initial PCE after 4000 h of light soaking, which likely benefited from the reduced triplet electron trapping at the ligand-perovskite interface.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2024

Structural Characteristics and Graphitizability of Tars from Thermal versus Microwave Plasma Pyrolysis of Coals

This work investigates the structural characteristics and graphitizability of tars obtained from thermal pyrolysis versus the reactive microwave (MW) plasma pyrolysis of coals. Powder River Basin (PRB) coal tars obtained by thermal pyrolysis have been compared with tars obtained from MW plasma pyrolysis containing H 2 . To study the effect of coal rank and MW plasma environment, the PRB tars have been compared with Middle Kittanning (MK) coal tars obtained from an argon–hydrogen MW plasma (hp) and an argon-CO 2 MW plasma (cdp) environment. Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy has been used for investigating the structural differences among the tar samples. The tars have been graphitized (GR-) at 2500 °C and the graphitic quality assessment has been performed using X-ray diffraction and transmission electron microscopy. MW plasma-derived tars have higher aromaticity, lower condensation, and lower oxygenated molecules compared to thermally derived tars. These advantageous features of MW plasma-derived tars lead to the formation of crystallites several times larger than thermally derived tars after graphitization. When considering coal of the same rank (bituminous), the choice of the MW plasma environment has a substantial impact on the graphitic quality of the tars. The utilization of MW plasma containing H 2 leads to a significant increase in both the crystallite diameter (by 60%) and stacking height (by 40%) compared to MW plasma containing CO 2 . Furthermore, within the same MW plasma environment, the coal rank plays a significant role in determining the crystallite diameter and stacking height of the GR-tars. In particular, GR-MK tar obtained from hp exhibits a 135% larger crystallite diameter and 85% larger stacking height compared with GR-PRB tar obtained from hp. These findings demonstrate the potential to tailor the composition of coal-derived tars and consequently influence their graphitizability by adjusting the reactive environment during MW plasma treatment.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2020

Investigation of a Lignin-Based Deep Eutectic Solvent Using p -Hydroxybenzoic Acid for Efficient Woody Biomass Conversion

Deep eutectic solvents (DESs) are effective solvents for biomass conversion and have been proposed as alternatives to ionic liquids (ILs). In this paper, we first report an effective pretreatment of woody biomass using a novel hardwood lignin-based DES prepared from p -hydroxybenzoic acid (PB) and choline chloride (ChCl), which are used as the hydrogen bond donor and acceptor, respectively. The impacts of the ChCl-PB DES on structural properties and enzymatic hydrolysis of poplar wood were comprehensively evaluated. The performance of ChCl-PB DES was also compared with two other DESs with p -coumaric acid (PCA) and 4-hydroxybenzaldehyde (PHA) as the hydrogen bond donors, which have been successfully applied to herbaceous biomass conversion in previous studies. The results showed that hemicellulose and lignin were effectively fractionated during the proposed ChCl-PB DES pretreatment under a relatively mild temperature. The ChCl-PB DES pretreatment resulted in up to 69% of delignification, and the pretreated poplar residues had over 90% of glucose yield by a 72 h-enzymatic hydrolysis. Transformation of poplar biomass during the DES pretreatment was evaluated by gel permeation chromatography (GPC), two-dimensional heteronuclear single quantum coherence (2D-HSQC), and 31 P nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopies. The recovered lignin showed relatively high purity, narrow molecular weight distribution (PDI < 1.6), and relatively low molecular weight (~1400 g/mol for M w ). A sustainable process was achieved by recycling DES as well as the utilization of PB, which is a producible aromatic compound from hardwood lignin, for the proposed DES formation in the system. This study indicates that the proposed novel DES with a hardwood lignin-based PB compound is a promising pretreatment solvent to achieve an economically feasible biomass conversion process.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2020

Molecular structure determination: Equilibrium structure of pyrimidine (m-C 4 H 4 N 2 ) from rotational spectroscopy (reSE) and high-level ab initio calculation (re) agree within the uncertainty of experimental measurement

The pure rotational spectrum of pyrimidine (m-C 4 H 4 N 2 ), the meta-substituted dinitrogen analog of benzene, has been studied in the millimeter-wave region from 235 GHz to 360 GHz. The rotational spectrum of the ground vibrational state has been assigned and fit to yield accurate rotational and distortion constants. Over 1700 distinct transitions were identified for the normal isotopologue in its ground vibrational state and least-squares fit to a partial sextic S-reduced Hamiltonian. Transitions for all four singly substituted 13 C and 15 N isotopologues were observed at natural abundance and were likewise fit. Deuterium-enriched samples of pyrimidine were synthesized, giving access to all eleven possible deuterium-substituted isotopologues, ten of which were previously unreported. Experimental values of rotational constants and computed values of vibration–rotation interaction constants and electron-mass corrections were used to determine semi-experimental equilibrium structures (r e SE ) of pyrimidine. The r e SE structure obtained using coupled-cluster with single, double, and perturbative triple excitations [CCSD(T)] corrections shows exceptional agreement with the re structure computed at the CCSD(T)/cc-pCV5Z level (≤0.0002 Å in bond distance and ≤0.03° in bond angle). Of the various computational methods examined, CCSD(T)/cc-pCV5Z is the only method for which the computed value of each geometric parameter lies within the statistical experimental uncertainty (2σ) of the corresponding semi-experimental coordinate. The exceptionally high accuracy and precision of the structure determination is a consequence of the large number of isotopologues measured, the precision and extent of the experimental frequency measurements, and the sophisticated theoretical treatment of the effects of vibration–rotation coupling and electron mass. Taken together, these demanding experimental and computational studies establish the capabilities of modern structural analysis for a prototypical monocyclic aromatic compound.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2023

Versatile microbial communities rapidly assimilate ammonium hydroxide-treated plastic waste

Abstract Waste plastic presently accumulates in landfills or the environment. While natural microbial metabolisms can degrade plastic polymers, biodegradation of plastic is very slow. This study demonstrates that chemical deconstruction of polyethylene terephthalate (PET) with ammonium hydroxide can replace the rate limiting step (depolymerization) and by producing plastic-derived terephthalic acid and terephthalic acid monoamide. The deconstructed PET (DCPET) is neutralized with phosphoric acid prior to bioprocessing, resulting in a product containing biologically accessible nitrogen and phosphorus from the process reactants. Three microbial consortia obtained from compost and sediment degraded DCPET in ultrapure water and scavenged river water without addition of nutrients. No statistically significant difference was observed in growth rate compared to communities grown on DCPET in minimal culture medium. The consortia were dominated by Rhodococcus spp., Hydrogenophaga spp., and many lower abundance genera. All taxa were related to species known to degrade aromatic compounds. Microbial consortia are known to confer flexibility in processing diverse substrates. To highlight this, we also demonstrate that two microbial consortia can grow on similarly deconstructed polyesters, polyamides, and polyurethanes in water instead of medium. Our findings suggest that microbial communities may enable flexible bioprocessing of mixed plastic wastes when coupled with chemical deconstruction.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2021

Low-intensity frequent fires in coniferous forests transform soil organic matter in ways that may offset ecosystem carbon losses

The impact of shifting disturbance regimes on soil carbon (C) storage is a key uncertainty in global change research. Wildfires in coniferous forests are becoming more frequent in many regions, potentially causing large C emissions. Repeated low-intensity prescribed fires can mitigate wildfire severity, but repeated combustion may decrease soil C unless compensatory responses stabilize soil organic matter. Here, we tested how 30 years of decadal prescribed burning affected C and nitrogen (N) in plants, detritus, and soils in coniferous forests in the Sierra Nevada mountains, USA. Tree basal area and litter stocks were resilient to fire, but fire reduced forest floor C by 77% (-36.4 Mg C/ha). In mineral soils, fire reduced C that was free from minerals by 41% (-4.4 Mg C/ha) but not C associated with minerals, and only in depths ≤ 5 cm. Fire also transformed the properties of remaining mineral soil organic matter by increasing the proportion of C in a pyrogenic form (from 3.2% to 7.5%) and associated with minerals (from 46% to 58%), suggesting the remaining soil C is more resistant to decomposition. Laboratory assays illustrated that fire reduced microbial CO2 respiration rates by 55% and the activity of eight extracellular enzymes that degrade cellulosic and aromatic compounds by 40–66%. Lower decomposition was correlated with lower inorganic N (-49%), especially ammonium, suggesting N availability is coupled with decomposition. The relative increase in forms of soil organic matter that are resistant to decay or stabilized onto mineral surfaces, and the associated decline in decomposition suggest that low-intensity fires may promote mineral soil C storage in pools with long mean residence times in coniferous forests.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2020

Asphaltene-induced spontaneous emulsification: Effects of interfacial co-adsorption and viscoelasticity

Asphaltenes are a class of high molecular weight aromatic compounds found in crude oil. They adsorb onto toluene-water interfaces and induce a spontaneous emulsification phenomenon, whereby stable water-in-oil emulsions form without the need of an external energy input. This work aims to control and understand the factors affecting spontaneous droplet formation in the presence of asphaltene adsorption. This is particularly useful for crude oil refining, where the presence of a stable emulsion hampers the efficiency of downstream processing operations. We explore the effect of the addition of copolymers designed as crude oil flow improvers as a means to control the extent of emulsion formation. We find that the polymers competitively adsorb onto the toluene-water interface and diminish spontaneous emulsification. Additionally, we conduct fluorescence microscopy experiments and measurements of the interfacial energy to determine the mechanism of spontaneous emulsification in asphaltene systems. We conclude that an emulsion forms via the diffusion of molecular water into the oil phase and subsequent binding with asphaltene aggregates, leading to the nucleation of micrometer-sized water droplets. We find that the polymer forms complexes with the dissolved asphaltenes, possibly hampering the ability of diffused water to bind to the asphaltenes and reducing the extent of spontaneous emulsification. Finally, we investigate the role of interfacial shear and dilatational viscoelasticity to better understand which fundamental interfacial properties are important in the emulsification of asphaltene-laden systems. We find that the rate of formation of an interfacial microstructural network is inversely correlated with the extent and rate of spontaneous emulsification.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2025

A Rhodopseudomonas strain with a substantially smaller genome retains the core metabolic versatility of its genus

ABSTRACT Rhodopseudomonas are a group of phototrophic microbes with a marked metabolic versatility and flexibility that underpins their potential use in the production of value-added products, bioremediation, and plant growth promotion. Members of this group have an average genome size of about 5.5 Mb, but two closely related strains have genome sizes of about 4.0 Mb. To identify the types of genes missing in a reduced genome strain, we compared strain DSM127 with other Rhodopseudomonas isolates at the genomic and phenotypic levels. We found that DSM127 can grow as well as other members of the Rhodopseudomonas genus and retains most of their metabolic versatility, but it has many fewer genes associated with high-affinity transport of nutrients, iron uptake, nitrogen metabolism, and biodegradation of aromatic compounds. This analysis indicates genes that can be deleted in genome reduction campaigns and suggests that DSM127 could be a favorable choice for biotechnology applications using Rhodopseudomonas or as a strain that can be engineered further to reside in a specialized natural environment. IMPORTANCE Rhodopseudomonas are a cohort of phototrophic bacteria with broad metabolic versatility. Members of this group are present in diverse soil and water environments, and some strains are found associated with plants and have plant growth-promoting activity. Motivated by the idea that it may be possible to design bacteria with reduced genomes that can survive well only in a specific environment or that may be more metabolically efficient, we compared Rhodopseudomonas strains with typical genome sizes of about 5.5 Mb to a strain with a reduced genome size of 4.0 Mb. From this, we concluded that metabolic versatility is part of the identity of the Rhodopseudomonas group, but high-affinity transport genes and genes of apparent redundant function can be dispensed with.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2025

Laboratory evolution in Novosphingobium aromaticivorans enables rapid catabolism of a model lignin-derived aromatic dimer

Lignin contains a variety of interunit linkages, leading to a range of potential decomposition products that can be used as carbon and energy sources by microbes. β-O-4 linkages are the most common in native lignin, and associated catabolic pathways have been well characterized. However, the fate of the mono-aromatic intermediates that result from β-O-4 dimer cleavage has not been fully elucidated. Here, we used experimental evolution to identify mutant strains of Novosphingobium aromaticivorans with improved catabolism of a model aromatic dimer containing a β-O-4 linkage, guaiacylglycerol-β-guaiacyl ether (GGE). We identified several parallel causal mutations, including a single nucleotide polymorphism in the promoter of an uncharacterized gene that roughly doubled the growth yield with GGE. We characterized the associated enzyme and demonstrated that it oxidizes an intermediate in GGE catabolism, β-hydroxypropiovanillone, to vanilloyl acetaldehyde. Identification of this enzyme and its key role in GGE catabolism furthers our understanding of catabolic pathways for lignin-derived aromatic compounds.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2024

Catabolic pathway acquisition by rhizosphere bacteria readily enables growth with a root exudate component but does not affect root colonization

Horizontal gene transfer (HGT) is a fundamental evolutionary process that plays a key role in bacterial evolution. The likelihood of a successful transfer event is expected to depend on the precise balance of costs and benefits resulting from pathway acquisition. Most experimental analyses of HGT have focused on phenotypes that have large fitness benefits under appropriate selective conditions, such as antibiotic resistance. However, many examples of HGT involve phenotypes that are predicted to provide smaller benefits, such as the ability to catabolize additional carbon sources. We have experimentally simulated the consequences of one such HGT event in the laboratory, studying the effects of transferring a pathway for catabolism of the plant-derived aromatic compound salicyl alcohol between rhizosphere isolates from the Pseudomonas genus. We find that pathway acquisition enables rapid catabolism of salicyl alcohol with only minor disruptions to the existing metabolic and regulatory networks of the new host. However, this new catabolic potential does not confer a measurable fitness advantage during competitive growth in the rhizosphere. We conclude that the phenotype of salicyl alcohol catabolism is readily transferable but is selectively neutral under environmentally relevant conditions. We propose that this condition is common and that HGT of many pathways will be self-limiting because the selective benefits are small.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗