Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Verification study”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 127 records · Page 7

Open-source MFIX-DEM software for gas-solids flows: Part II — Validation studies

With rapid advancements in computer hardware and numerical algorithms, computational fluid dynamics (CFD) has been increasingly employed as a useful tool for investigating the complex hydrodynamics inherent in multiphase flows. An important step during the development of a CFD model and prior to its application is conducting careful and comprehensive verification and validation studies. Accordingly, efforts to verify and validate the open-source MFIX-DEM software, which can be used for simulating the gas–solids flow using an Eulerian reference frame for the continuum fluid and a Lagrangian discrete framework (Discrete Element Method) for the particles, have been made at the National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL). In part I of this paper, extensive verification studies were presented and in this part, detailed validation studies of MFIX-DEM are presented. A series of test cases covering a range of gas–solids flow applications were conducted. In particular the numerical results for the random packing of a binary particle mixture, the repose angle of a sandpile formed during a side charge process, velocity, granular temperature, and voidage profiles from a bounded granular shear flow, lateral voidage and velocity profiles from a monodisperse bubbling fluidized bed, lateral velocity profiles from a spouted bed, and the dynamics of segregation of a binary mixture in a bubbling bed were compared with available experimental data, and in some instances with empirical correlations. In addition, sensitivity studies were conducted for various parameters to quantify the error in the numerical simulation.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Three-dimensional continuum point cloud method for large deformation and its verification

This study presents a strong form based meshfree collocation method, which is named Continuum Point Cloud Method, to solve nonlinear field equations derived from classical mechanics for deformed bodies in three-dimensional Euclidean space. The method and its implementation are benchmarked against a nonlinear vector field using manufactured solutions. The analysis of mechanical fields firstly focuses on the study of St. Venant Kirchhoff and compressible neo-Hookean materials. Results for various initial boundary value problems are presented, including benchmark cases involving unidirectional tension and simple shear. Subsequently, the study concludes with an analysis of a displacement-controlled simulation of a compressible neo-Hookean material, specifically a bar that is pulled to 50% of its original length and rotated 90°. The pure tension case yields a 1.5% error in displacement between computed and expected values and a combined tension and torsion loading case provides further insight into material behavior under complex loading conditions. The resulting normal axial and transverse stress-strain curves are also presented. Lastly, the consistency and robustness of the proposed nonlinear numerical schemes are successfully demonstrated through various numerical experiments.

Compressible neo-Hookean materials↗

Thermo-acoustoelastic effect of Rayleigh wave: Theory and experimental verification

Previous studies showed that the thermally-induced ultrasonic bulk wave velocity change could be used to measure acoustoelastic coefficients and third-order elastic constants of elastic materials. This method is naturally immune from the ambient temperature effect and has improved sensitivity and a simpler test setup than the conventional acoustoelastic test. However, Rayleigh wave is preferred for thick components or structures with only one accessible surface. In this work, the thermo-hyperelastic constitutive equation, along with acoustoelastic theory, is used to derive the expression of the thermo-acoustoelastic coefficient (TAEC) of Rayleigh wave. The numerical relationship between the TAEC of Rayleigh wave and Murnaghan constants ( l, m and n ) are given for common metals. Further, the TAEC expressions for Rayleigh wave and shear wave are similar, and both are dominated by the constant m . The TAEC of Rayleigh wave was measured on an aluminum 6061 specimen using the thermal modulation experiment in a temperature range of 22 ~ 35°C. The measured TAEC shows good agreement with the theoretical calculation. Then the third-order elastic constants were calculated based on TAECs of bulk waves and Rayleigh wave.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Hybrid Enrichment Verification Array: Module Characterization Studies

The work presented in this report is focused on the characterization and refinement of the Hybrid Enrichment Verification Array (HEVA) approach, which combines the traditional 186-keV 235 U signature with high-energy prompt gamma rays from neutron capture in the detector and surrounding collimator material, to determine the relative enrichment and 235 U mass of the cylinder. The design of the HEVA modules (hardware and software) deployed in the current field trial builds on over seven years of study and evolution by PNNL, and consists of a ø3''×3'' NaI(Tl) scintillator coupled to an Osprey digital multi-channel analyzer tube base from Canberra. The core of the HEVA methodology, the high-energy prompt gamma-ray signature, serves as an indirect method for the measurement of total neutron emission from the cylinder. A method for measuring the intrinsic efficiency of this “non-traditional” neutron signature and the results from a benchmark experiment are presented. Also discussed are potential perturbing effects on the non-traditional signature, including short-lived activation of materials in the HEVA module. Modeling and empirical results are presented to demonstrate that such effects are expected to be negligible for the envisioned implementation scenario. In comparison to previous versions, the new design boosts the high-energy prompt gamma-ray signature, provides more flexible and effective collimation, and improves count-rate management via commercially available pulse-processing electronics with a special modification prompted by PNNL.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Exploring the Possible Use of Information Barriers for future Biological Weapons Verification Regimes

This report describes a path forward for implementing information barriers in a future generic biological arms-control verification regime. Information barriers have become a staple of discussion in the area of arms control verification approaches for nuclear weapons and components. Information barriers when used with a measurement system allow for the determination that an item has sensitive characteristics without releasing any of the sensitive information. Over the last 15 years the United States (with the Russian Federation) has led on the development of information barriers in the area of the verification of nuclear weapons and nuclear components. The work of the US and the Russian Federation has prompted other states (e.g., UK and Norway) to consider the merits of information barriers for possible verification regimes. In the context of a biological weapons control verification regime, the dual-use nature of the biotechnology will require protection of sensitive information while allowing for the verification of treaty commitments. A major question that has arisen is whether - in a biological weapons verification regime - the presence or absence of a weapon pathogen can be determined without revealing any information about possible sensitive or proprietary information contained in the genetic materials being declared under a verification regime. This study indicates that a verification regime could be constructed using a small number of pathogens that spans the range of known biological weapons agents. Since the number of possible pathogens is small it is possible and prudent to treat these pathogens as analogies to attributes in a nuclear verification regime. This study has determined that there may be some information that needs to be protected in a biological weapons control verification regime. To protect this information, the study concludes that the Lawrence Livermore Microbial Detection Array may be a suitable technology for the detection of the genetic information associated with the various pathogens. In addition, it has been determined that a suitable information barrier could be applied to this technology when the verification regime has been defined. Finally, the report posits a path forward for additional development of information barriers in a biological weapons verification regime. This path forward has shown that a new analysis approach coined as Information Loss Analysis might need to be pursued so that a numerical understanding of how information can be lost in specific measurement systems can be achieved.

45 MILITARY TECHNOLOGY, WEAPONRY, AND NATIONAL DEF↗

SU-E-T-32: A Feasibility Study of Independent Dose Verification for IMAT

Purpose: To assess the feasibility of the independent dose verification (Indp) for intensity modulated arc therapy (IMAT). Methods: An independent dose calculation software program (Simple MU Analysis, Triangle Products, JP) was used in this study, which can compute the radiological path length from the surface to the reference point for each control point using patient’s CT image dataset and the MLC aperture shape was simultaneously modeled in reference to the information of MLC from DICOM-RT plan. Dose calculation was performed using a modified Clarkson method considering MLC transmission and dosimetric leaf gap. In this study, a retrospective analysis was conducted in which IMAT plans from 120 patients of the two sites (prostate / head and neck) from four institutes were retrospectively analyzed to compare the Indp to the TPS using patient CT images. In addition, an ion-chamber measurement was performed to verify the accuracy of the TPS and the Indp in water-equivalent phantom. Results: The agreements between the Indp and the TPS (mean±1SD) were −0.8±2.4% and −1.3±3.8% for the regions of prostate and head and neck, respectively. The measurement comparison showed similar results (−0.8±1.6% and 0.1±4.6% for prostate and head and neck). The variation was larger in the head and neck because the number of the segments was increased that the reference point was under the MLC and the modified Clarkson method cannot consider the smooth falloff of the leaf penumbra. Conclusion: The independent verification program would be practical and effective for secondary check for IMAT with the sufficient accuracy in the measurement and CT-based calculation. The accuracy would be improved if considering the falloff of the leaf penumbra.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

CFD-DEM solution verification: Fixed-bed studies

Fixed (frozen) particle configurations are used to study CFD-DEM convergence behavior in the limit of infinite grid resolution. A filtering scheme based on solving a diffusion equation, i.e., a Gaussian kernel, is used to interpolate particle information to the continuum grid, free of cell size limitations. A regression method is used for Richardson extrapolation of the discrete solutions to the grid-free solution. The regression method is shown to predict accurate extrapolation curves in the presence of the observed oscillatory convergence behavior. The extrapolation curve is used to complete the solution verification process by quantifying the numerical uncertainty present in the calculations. Several numerical and model parameters are studied including the spatial discretization method, the kernel width and the mean drag law. Here, a manageable level of discretization error is found with relative discretization errors generally <4%.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

Verification of the LOTUS code with C5G7 benchmark

In this study, the verification of the neutron transport code LOTUS through the well-known C5G7 benchmark is performed. LOTUS uses the current coupled collision probability method with the expansion of the flux by orthogonal polynomials (CCCPO) for the solution of the neutron transport equation. The expansion of the flux by orthogonal polynomials allows one to avoid discretization of the calculation regions and significantly decreases the simulation time. The results of the LOTUS calculations are compared with the results of the reference OpenMC Monte Carlo simulations. The results of the comparison demonstrate almost perfect agreement with Monte-Carlo for the second order of the flux expansion. Even though the results obtained in the presented study agree well with the results of reference Monte Carlo calculations, further investigations are necessary for a better understanding of the stability and limitations of the code.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

AZTRAN and AZKIND verification with a BWR study case

The AZTLAN Platform project is a national initiative led by the National Institute of Nuclear Research which gather the main public institutions of higher education in Mexico: the National Polytechnic Institute, the National Autonomous University of Mexico and the Autonomous Metropolitan University. It consists in the development of a modeling platform for the analysis and design of nuclear reactors. This project aims to modernize, improve and integrate the neutronic, thermohydraulics and thermomechanical codes, developed in the national institutions, in a platform integrated and developed by Mexican experts. The development of AZTLAN Platform is divided technically into four working groups: neutronics, thermohydraulics, coupling and uncertainty analysis, and users group. The present work is the result of the activities of the Users Group focused on the follow-up, testing and use of the different codes (modules) being developed under the AZTLAN project; with the objective of providing feedback and to suggest development priorities to the team of developers, as well as to promote collaboration and synergy between the participating institutions. In particular, in this work, the AZTRAN and the AZKIND modules were verified and tested against the results of well-known codes of the nuclear industry for boiling water reactor (BWR) models. AZTRAN is a 3D transport code which solves numerically the multi-group time independent neutron transport equation in Cartesian geometry, based on the discrete ordinates (SN) method and the RTN-0 nodal scheme. AZKIND is a 3D diffusion code that solves numerically the time dependent neutron diffusion equations in Cartesian geometry, based on a Galerkin Finite Element Method using the RTN-0 polynomial nodal approximation.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

SU-E-T-602: Patient-Specific Online Dose Verification Based On Transmission Detector Measurements

Purpose: Intensity modulated radiotherapy requires a comprehensive quality assurance program in general and ideally independent verification of dose delivery. Since conventional 2D detector arrays allow only pre-treatment verification, there is a debate concerning the need of online dose verification. This study presents the clinical performance, including dosimetric plan verification in 2D as well as in 3D and the error detection abilities of a new transmission detector (TD) for online dose verification of 6MV photon beam. Methods: To validate the dosimetric performance of the new device, dose reconstruction based on TD measurements were compared to a conventional pre-treatment verification method (reference) and treatment planning system (TPS) for 18 IMRT and VMAT treatment plans. Furthermore, dose reconstruction inside the patient based on TD read-out was evaluated by comparing various dose volume indices and 3D gamma evaluations against independent dose computation and TPS. To investigate the sensitivity of the new device, different types of systematic and random errors for leaf positions and linac output were introduced in IMRT treatment sequences. Results: The 2D gamma index evaluation of transmission detector based dose reconstruction showed an excellent agreement for all IMRT and VMAT plans compared to reference measurements (99.3±1.2)% and TPS (99.1±0.7)%. Good agreement was also obtained for 3D dose reconstruction based on TD read-out compared to dose computation (mean gamma value of PTV = 0.27±0.04). Only a minimal dose underestimation within the target volume was observed when analyzing DVH indices (<1%). Positional errors in leaf banks larger than 1mm and errors in linac output larger than 2% could clearly identified with the TD. Conclusion: Since 2D and 3D evaluations for all IMRT and VMAT treatment plans were in excellent agreement with reference measurements and dose computation, the new TD is suitable to qualify for routine treatment plan verification. Funding Support, Disclosures, and Conflict of Interest: COIs: Frank Lohr: Elekta: research grant, travel grants, teaching honoraria IBA: research grant, travel grants, teaching honoraria, advisory board C-Rad: board honoraria, travel grants Frederik Wenz: Elekta: research grant, teaching honoraria, consultant, advisory board Zeiss: research grant, teaching honoraria, patent Hansjoerg Wertz: Elekta: research grant, teaching honoraria IBA: research grant.

61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗

Renewable Hydrogen to Vehicle (RH2V) – Operation Verification and Risk Mitigation Studies: Original Agreement (Modification 0) (CRADA Final Report)

Toyota has announced plans for commercial fuel cell vehicle deployment in 2015. To fully realize the benefits of fuel cell vehicles (zero emission with no performance loss in terms of vehicle range and capability), hydrogen produced efficiently from renewable sources is necessary. Most of the hydrogen fueling stations today utilize hydrogen reformed from natural gas (produced onsite or delivered). This enables more stations to be deployed cost-effectively within a network. Producing and using cost-effective renewable hydrogen in fuel cell vehicles will enable realization of the full potential. A viable option of green hydrogen that reliably delivers on the full suite of benefits for Toyota fuel cell vehicle drivers is needed. NREL is in a unique position to analyze and optimize renewable hydrogen production scenarios using the Energy Systems Integration Facility (ESIF), a facility that is specifically designed to evaluate renewable energy integration technologies. As the U.S. Department of Energy's (DOE) primary national laboratory for renewable energy and energy efficiency research and development, NREL has extensive knowledge of photovoltaic systems as well as alternative renewable technologies for efficient and reliable production of green hydrogen.

08 HYDROGEN↗

SU-E-J-82: Intra-Fraction Proton Beam-Range Verification with PET Imaging: Feasibility Studies with Monte Carlo Simulations and Statistical Modeling

Purpose: To study the feasibility of intra-fraction proton beam-range verification with PET imaging. Methods: Two phantoms homogeneous cylindrical PMMA phantoms (290 mm axial length, 38 mm and 200 mm diameter respectively) were studied using PET imaging: a small phantom using a mouse-sized PET (61 mm diameter field of view (FOV)) and a larger phantom using a human brain-sized PET (300 mm FOV). Monte Carlo (MC) simulations (MCNPX and GATE) were used to simulate 179.2 MeV proton pencil beams irradiating the two phantoms and be imaged by the two PET systems. A total of 50 simulations were conducted to generate 50 positron activity distributions and correspondingly 50 measured activity-ranges. The accuracy and precision of these activity-ranges were calculated under different conditions (including count statistics and other factors, such as crystal cross-section). Separate from the MC simulations, an activity distribution measured from a simulated PET image was modeled as a noiseless positron activity distribution corrupted by Poisson counting noise. The results from these two approaches were compared to assess the impact of count statistics on the accuracy and precision of activity-range calculations. Results: MC Simulations show that the accuracy and precision of an activity-range are dominated by the number (N) of coincidence events of the reconstructed image. They are improved in a manner that is inversely proportional to 1/sqrt(N), which can be understood from the statistical modeling. MC simulations also indicate that the coincidence events acquired within the first 60 seconds with 10{sup 9} protons (small phantom) and 10{sup 10} protons (large phantom) are sufficient to achieve both sub-millimeter accuracy and precision. Conclusion: Under the current MC simulation conditions, the initial study indicates that the accuracy and precision of beam-range verification are dominated by count statistics, and intra-fraction PET image-based beam-range verification is feasible. This work was supported by a research award RP120326 from Cancer Prevention and Research Institute of Texas.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

Verification of 5D continuum gyrokinetic code COGENT: Studies of kinetic drift wave instability

COGENT (Continuum Gyrokinetic Edge New Technology) is a kinetic plasma simulation code that is being developed by the edge simulation laboratory (ESL) collaboration. The original version of the code has been developed in a 4D phase space (2D configuration space and 2D velocity space) to address kinetic plasma phenomena in a complex magnetic field geometry including the core, magnetic separatrix, and scrape-off layer regions. This paper is focused on extending the original 4D phase space to a 5D phase space (3D2V) to address full kinetic turbulences in a tokamak edge region. Here, we report on the current status of 5D COGENT, which presently operates in a shear-less, simple slab geometry. As a verification study, we use the problems of collision-less drift wave instability (universal instability) including its modification in the presence of collisional effects. The simulation model includes the gyrokinetic equations for ion and electron species coupled to the long-wavelength limit of the gyro-Poisson equation. Collisional effects are represented by the Krook collision model. Linear analytical results for the drift mode growth rate and real frequency are recovered, and the non-linear stage is modelled and analysed as well. In addition, extensive 5D runs have been performed to address the effects of the drift wave instability on blob/filamentary structures characteristic of a tokamak edge. Finally, a helical-shaped potential perturbation is observed to grow exponentially in time while spinning around the filament axis with electron drift frequency.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

National Energy Efficiency Evaluation, Measurement and Verification (EM&V) Standard: Scoping Study of Issues and Implementation Requirements

This report is a scoping study that identifies issues associated with developing a national evaluation, measurement and verification (EM&V) standard for end-use, non-transportation, energy efficiency activities. The objectives of this study are to identify the scope of such a standard and define EM&V requirements and issues that will need to be addressed in a standard. To explore these issues, we provide and discuss: (1) a set of definitions applicable to an EM&V standard; (2) a literature review of existing guidelines, standards, and 'initiatives' relating to EM&V standards as well as a review of 'bottom-up' versus 'top-down' evaluation approaches; (3) a summary of EM&V related provisions of two recent federal legislative proposals (Congressman Waxman's and Markey's American Clean Energy and Security Act of 2009 and Senator Bingaman's American Clean Energy Leadership Act of 2009) that include national efficiency resource requirements; (4) an annotated list of issues that that are likely to be central to, and need to be considered when, developing a national EM&V standard; and (5) a discussion of the implications of such issues. There are three primary reasons for developing a national efficiency EM&V standard. First, some policy makers, regulators and practitioners believe that a national standard would streamline EM&V implementation, reduce costs and complexity, and improve comparability of results across jurisdictions; although there are benefits associated with each jurisdiction setting its own EM&V requirements based on their specific portfolio and evaluation budgets and objectives. Secondly, if energy efficiency is determined by the US Environmental Protection Agency to be a Best Available Control Technology (BACT) for avoiding criteria pollutant and/or greenhouse gas emissions, then a standard can be required for documenting the emission reductions resulting from efficiency actions. The third reason for a national EM&V standard is that such a standard is likely to be required as a result of future federal energy legislation that includes end-use energy efficiency, either as a stand-alone energy-efficiency resource standard (EERS) or as part of a clean energy or renewable energy standard. This study is focused primarily on this third reason and thus explores issues associated with a national EM&V standard if energy efficiency is a qualifying resource in federal clean energy legislation. Developing a national EM&V standard is likely to be a lengthy process; this study focuses on the critical first step of identifying the issues that must be addressed in a future standard. Perhaps the most fundamental of these issues is 'how good is good enough?' This has always been the fundamental issue of EM&V for energy efficiency and is a result of the counter-factual nature of efficiency. Counter-factual in that savings are not measured, but estimated to varying degrees of accuracy by comparing energy consumption after a project (program) is implemented with what is assumed to have been the consumption of energy in the absence of the project (program). Therefore, the how good is good enough question is a short version of asking how certain does one have to be of the energy savings estimate that results from EM&V activities and is that level of certainty properly balanced against the amount of effort (resources, time, money) that is utilized to obtain that level of certainty. The implication is that not only should energy efficiency investments be cost-effective, but EM&V investments should consider risk management principles and thus also balance the costs and value of information derived from EM&V (EM&V should also be cost-effective).

29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗

Hybrid Gamma Emission Tomography for the Verification of Unirradiated Fuel: A Viability Study

Current International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) methodologies for the verification of fresh low-enriched uranium (LEU) and mixed oxide (MOX) fuel assemblies are volume-averaging methods that lack sensitivity to individual pins. Further, as unirradiated fuel assemblies become more and more complex (e.g., heavy gadolinium loading, high degrees of axial and radial variation in fissile concentration), the accuracy of current IAEA instruments degrades and measurement time increases. Particularly in light of the fact that no special tooling is required to remove individual pins from modern fuel assemblies, new capabilities for the verification of unirradiated (i.e., fresh LEU and MOX) assemblies are needed to ensure that fissile material has not been diverted. Passive gamma emission tomography has demonstrated potential to provide pin-level verification of spent fuel, but gamma-ray emission rates from unirradiated fuel emissions are significantly lower, precluding purely passive tomography methods. The work presented here introduces the concept of Hybrid Gamma Emission Tomography (HGET) for verification of unirradiated fuels, in which a neutron source is used to actively interrogate the fuel assembly and the resulting gamma-ray emissions are imaged using tomographic methods to provide pin-level verification of fissile material concentration. This paper describes the status of a viability study on the HGET concept, including: envisioned use-case scenarios and corresponding definitions of fuel assemblies; modeling framework based on Monte Carlo and deterministic transport methods, and its validation; quantitative assessment of candidate HGET signatures with a focus on prompt fission gamma rays and delayed fission gamma rays; a nominal HGETv1 instrument design; candidate HGET-specific tomographic reconstruction methods that fully incorporate declared information; and examples of simulation-based predictions of HGET performance.

Miller, Erin A.↗