Durability of PGM-Free ORR Catalysts: Recent Progress
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Abstract Development of high‐performance electrocatalysts for water splitting is crucial for a sustainable hydrogen economy. In this study, rapid heating of ruthenium(III) acetylacetonate by magnetic induction heating (MIH) leads to the one‐step production of Ru‐RuO₂/C nanocomposites composed of closely integrated Ru and RuO₂ nanoparticles. The formation of Mott‐Schottky heterojunctions significantly enhances charge transfer across the Ru‐RuO 2 interface leading to remarkable electrocatalytic activities toward both hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and oxygen evolution reaction (OER) in 1 m KOH. Among the series, the sample prepares at 300 A for 10 s exhibits the best performance, with an overpotential of only −31 mV for HER and +240 mV for OER to reach the current density of 10 mA cm⁻ 2 . Additionally, the catalyst demonstrates excellent durability, with minimal impacts of electrolyte salinity. With the sample as the bifunctional catalysts for overall water splitting, an ultralow cell voltage of 1.43 V is needed to reach 10 mA cm⁻ 2 , 160 mV lower than that with a commercial 20% Pt/C and RuO₂/C mixture. These results highlight the significant potential of MIH in the ultrafast synthesis of high‐performance catalysts for electrochemical water splitting and sustainable hydrogen production from seawater.
The lifetime of commercial Proton Exchange Membrane Fuel Cells (PEMFCs) is circumscribed by the insufficient durability of commercial catalysts. The use of metal oxide supports in place of carbon significantly increases electrocatalyst durability. Herein, following density functional theory (DFT) predictions of improved Platinum (Pt) stability on antimony doped tin oxide (ATO) supports, we synthesized ATO whose morphology and crystal structure was engineered using a Pt anchoring technique. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) indicated that the Pt anchor sites aided in the reduction of Pt precursors to Pt on the ATO surface. X-ray absorption near-edge spectroscopy (XANES) revealed the existence of strong-metal-support interactions (SMSI) between Pt and ATO. The combination of SMSI and high control over Pt dispersion enabled the Pt/Pt-aerogel-ATO (Pt supported on aerogel ATO with Pt anchor sites) electrocatalyst to achieve 2x the area specific activity of Pt/C in ex-situ testing. In a H 2 /air PEMFC Pt/Pt-aerogel-ATO cathodes enabled 20% higher peak power density and <1/6 the loss of active surface area as compared to Pt/C. Notably, in a PEMFC under rigorous potential cycling, the Pt/Pt-aerogel-ATO retained its initial peak power density as opposed to a 58% loss for Pt/C. Further, cost models indicate that Pt/Pt-aerogel-ATO is 26% less expensive than Pt/C over its useful lifetime.
In this project, the objective was to develop new oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) electrocatalysts for proton exchange membrane fuel cells (PEMFCs) which could exceed all of the Department of Energy (DOE) 2020 targets listed in DE-FOA-0001224, Subtopic 1b, Table I. The expected outcome was development of one or more electrocatalysts which are substantially improved over the current state-of-the-art in terms of overall activity, durability, and cost, and are suitable for automotive traction and stationary fuel cell applications. This report summarizes this project’s progress towards meeting the stated objectives and includes a summary of key findings and conclusions. The development activities towards new highly active and durable thin film electrocatalysts has led to the discovery of several electrocatalysts which approached or exceeded several DOE 2020 targets for activity, durability, and performance in proton exchange membrane fuel cell (membrane electrode assemblies (MEAs). In this project, electrocatalyst development focused on systematic physical and electrochemical characterization of electrocatalyst activity, durability, and performance in MEAs as a function of electrocatalyst fabrication, compositional and structural variables. The project approach was to develop relationships between the catalyst functional responses (activity, durability and performance) with catalyst physical properties and catalyst fabrication methods. Additionally, the thin film catalysts were integrated onto the unique and durable 3M Nanostructured Thin Film (NSTF) support, consisting of arrays of self-assembled organic crystalline whiskers. The catalysts were evaluated against the project targets via extensive electrochemical characterization in MEA format at 3M, advanced structural and compositional microscopy at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), and atomic structure analysis via XAFS at Argonne National Laboratory (ANL). The extensive electrochemical and physical characterization resulted in development of several trends which correlate the catalysts’ electrochemical properties to their physical properties, including composition, structure, and method of fabrication. The development was guided by density functional theory (DFT) modeling at Purdue University and kinetic Monte Carlo (kMC) modeling at Johns Hopkins University. The catalyst simulations provided key insights into the observed experimental activity and durability trends, and additionally were utilized to assess new electrocatalyst concepts prior to or coincident with physical catalyst development. This development has led to several electrocatalyst candidates with activity and durability which approach or exceed DOE targets. One class of catalysts, based on nm-scale thin layers of Pt on Ir, met or exceeded 6 of the 6 DOE targets the project addressed.
The design of oxygen evolution reaction (OER) electrocatalysts demands a delicate balance between activity and stability. Here, in this study, we present a rational design approach that leverages catalyst-support interactions to enhance both the intrinsic activity and durability of Ir-based catalysts. Our study reveals that while Mo doping energetically promotes the formation of high-valent Ir species, enhancing intrinsic catalytic activity, it also leads to a reduction in electrical conductivity. These findings emphasize that supporting doping can introduce both beneficial and limiting effects, highlighting the need for a carefully balanced design strategy to optimize the overall OER performance. Simultaneously, in situ analytical techniques and comparative evaluation reveal the crucial role of oxide supports in stabilizing the catalyst. These findings highlight the pivotal role of interface engineering in maintaining catalyst integrity and the need for support materials that balance dopant-driven electronic promotion with structural and electrochemical robustness. These interconnected degradation pathways highlight the need to move beyond a catalyst-centric view and instead adopt a system-level understanding of the stability. Our approach offers a strong foundation for the rational design and evaluation of high-performance OER electrocatalysts for electrochemical energy applications.
Pt 3 Co-alloy based nanoparticle catalysts are very active for oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) thereby enabling high performance of proton exchange membrane fuel cells (PEMFC) for automotive propulsion. However, these catalyst materials degrade due to a combination of electrochemical surface area (ECSA) loss and dissolution of cobalt-alloying element from the nanoparticles. Dissolution of cobalt has a two-fold impact on the durability of fuel cells—i) a loss in the low-current density kinetic region due to a decrease in specific activity and ii) a loss in the high-current density transport region due to Co 2+ contamination of the ionomer phase. Cobalt dissolution-contamination needs to be mitigated as it limits fuel cell performance and lifetime for heavy-duty automotive applications. In this article, we study the use of PtCo-alloy catalysts with Pt-rich compositions using catalyst-specific accelerated stress test measurement in membrane electrode assemblies to decrease the amount of dissolved Co and mitigate its subsequent contamination effects. We demonstrate Pt 5 Co and Pt 7 Co compositions to enable significant improvements in durability (∼50 mV and ∼100 mV with respect to Pt 3 Co after 30,000 voltage cycles) with a minor but acceptable compromise in the initial specific activity of the catalyst.
PtM (M = 3d transition metals) alloys are known as the promising oxygen reduction reaction catalysts and have been considered as the replacement of pure Pt catalysts for the commercialization of proton exchange membrane fuel cells. Although great progress has been made in the past three decades, the performance and durability of PtM catalysts still face stringent challenges from practical applications. Functionalization of a catalyst carbon support with nitrogen-contained groups can add charges onto its surface, which can be utilized to build a more complete ionomer/catalyst interface, to reduce the catalyst particle size, and to improve particle size distribution. Nitriding of PtNi catalysts can effectively improve the catalyst activity and stability by the modification of lattice strain. Hereby, we propose a synergistic approach of combining polybenzimidazole-grafted Vulcan XC72 carbon as the catalyst carbon support and the nitriding of PtNi to develop PtNiN/XC72-polybenzimidazole catalysts. Such PtNiN/XC72-PBI catalysts exhibit the excellent performance of fuel cell membrane electrode assembly (i.e., mass activity, 440 mA mgPt –1 ; electrochemical surface area, 51 m 2 gPt –1 ; and rated power density, 836 mW cm –2 ) as well as promising catalyst stability. The developed PtNiN/XC72-PBI meets the US DOE 2020 targets of mass activity for the fuel cell catalysts. This work provides a novel approach and a promising pathway on the development of the catalyst using such a synergistic approach-modification of the catalyst structure by nitrogen doping and functionalization of carbon support by polybenzimidazole for both high performance and high durability.
The research under this CRADA adds to the understanding of how catalyst activity and durability should be balanced and tailored for oxygen evolution reaction. The research also provides technical insights in how catalyst degradation might occur under long-term operation under highly oxidative and acidic conditions. In longer term, the project could benefit the pubic by enabling more efficient, affordable and reliable electrolysis technologies.
Developing efficient and stable electrocatalysts for the acidic oxygen evolution reaction (OER) is vital for advancing proton exchange membrane water electrolysis (PEMWE) technologies. Here, in this study, we report a flux synthesis of nitrogen-doped Ti–Ru rutile-type solid-solution oxides (M-TiRu 4 ) using molten NaNO 3 as the flux medium. The flux medium promotes the low-temperature conversion of TiN to rutile TiO 2 , while in situ-formed RuO 2 nanoparticles facilitate lattice templating and couple with interfacial ion migration, enabling the formation of homogeneous solid solutions with abundant lattice heterogeneity. Simultaneously, nitrogen atoms are stably incorporated into the lattice of solid solutions, inducing bandgap narrowing, which enhances electronic conductivity. The developed M-TiRu 4 catalyst exhibits exceptional acidic OER performance, delivering a low overpotential of 194 mV at 10 mA cm −2 , superior durability over 600 h, and a Ru mass activity 7.8 times that of commercial RuO 2 . At the device level, M-TiRu 4 enables PEMWE operation at 1.64 V @ 2 A cm −2 and maintains stable performance at 500 mA cm −2 for 200 h with a minimal degradation rate of 20 µV h −1 . This work demonstrates a robust approach for designing high-performance, durable acidic OER catalysts via synergistic lattice and electronic structure engineering, paving the way for next-generation water-splitting technologies.
The durability of the CATCOM catalyst for use in catalytically supported thermal combustion has been demonstrated at 5 atm, complementing a previous 1000 hour durability study at 1 atm. Both of these studies were conducted at about 640 K air preheat temperature at a reference velocity of about 14 m/s; the adiabatic flame temperature of the fuel/air mixture was about 1530 K. The catalyst proved to be capable of low emissions operations after 1000 hours of diesel fuel aging. However, more severe deactivation occurred in the 5 atm test; this was attributed to a loss in kinetic (ignition) activity.
Based on the hydrogen spillover effect, versatile binary-site catalysts are promising for the alkaline hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). In which one site can adsorb and dissociate water, while the neighboring site is favorable for liberating hydrogen. Inspired by these possibilities, oxygen vacancy (O v )-rich LaCeO x coupled N-doped graphene/Ru single-atoms (LaCeO x @NGr/Ru 1 ) was synthesized as an efficient dual-site HER catalyst. It delivered an impressive low overpotential of 22 mV at a current density of 10mAcm –2 and a slight Tafel slope of 40 mV dec –1 in an alkaline medium, outstanding the advanced Ru-based catalysts. Moreover, this promising binary-component catalyst exhibited higher mass activity and longer lasting durability than commercial Pt/C catalyst (20 wt%). Finally, experimental and theoretical investigations provided insights into the HER mechanisms of LaCeO x @NGr/Ru 1 based on three indispensable steps: water adsorption and dissociation on O v -rich LaCeO x , diffusion of generated H* species towards Ce 3+ -N-Ru 1 bridges, and hydrogen evolution on Ru 1 sites.
As proton exchange membrane fuel cells mature into commercial devices capable of powering a wide range of stationary and automotive applications, they need materials with tunable properties to improve their performance and durability. Carbon supports used for platinum (Pt) nanoparticle dispersion is typically based on a furnace black-type material with a random structure, thereby hindering progress in catalyst development. To address this challenge, engineered carbons with a tunable mesoporous structure offer an opportunity to maximize catalyst performance and durability. In this article, we report on the development of a graphitized, mesoporous carbon support with a high degree of ordering, labeled here as ECS4005, for the dispersion of Pt nanoparticles. Pt/ECS4005 shows significantly improved kinetic activity due to its mesoporous structure that mitigates Pt poisoning by sulfonate functional groups in the ionomer while simultaneously enabling favorable accessibility to reactants.
The limited durability of Pt electrocatalysis toward cathodic oxygen reduction reaction remains challenging, yet crucial for the development of Proton Exchange Membrane Fuel Cell. Here, we present a rational design of a robust catalyst consisting of PtCo nanoparticles supported on Pt-Co-N-graphene nanofiber prepared through electrospun Cobalt-Metal-Organic-Framework. The catalyst delivers unprecedented mass activity of 2.48 A·mgPt -1 , and retains 80% of initial value after 60,000 Accelerated-Stress-Test cycles. Operando X-ray absorption spectroscopies show that the electronic configurations of Pt sites in PtCo and Co sites in Co-N4 in the hybrid catalyst are modified toward high catalytic activities. Density Functional Theory unveils that the enhanced curvature of the substrate induced by the morphology engineering lowers the reaction thermodynamic barrier on Co-N4 sites, favoring the formation of H2O and suppressing that of H2O2. This result along with the strong affinity of PtCo nanoparticles to the Pt-Co-N-graphene fiber endows the catalyst an exceptional durability.
Radiolysis of water in nuclear waste storage generates hydrogen gas that can accumulate within sludge style waste and be rapidly released during agitation events, creating a significant flammability hazard. Engineering controls are therefore required to limit hydrogen concentrations during both quiescent storage and transient disturbances. Catalytic recombination of hydrogen in waste storage offgas is a proven mitigation strategy, maintaining hydrogen levels below flammability limits and managing sudden concentration spikes. Conventional recombiners rely on platinum and/or palladium catalysts, with development efforts focused on extending service life, increasing active surface area, and ensuring safe deployment in radioactive environments. Savannah River National Laboratory (SRNL) is evaluating a newly developed hydrogen recombiner catalyst from Canadian Nuclear Laboratories as a cost-effective and durable alternative for nuclear waste applications. Testing was conducted in SRNL’s Shielded Cells facility, which enables reduced-scale experimental modeling under radiation fields and near-use-case conditions relevant to radioactive waste storage. Catalyst performance was evaluated using a custom offgas characterization system designed for near-zero flow conditions. The experimental apparatus consisted of a gas-tight 2.7 L PTFE vessel equipped with temperature monitoring, gas flow controls, and a variable-speed mixer to simulate sludge agitation. Offgas composition was monitored using a dedicated gas chromatograph with argon carrier gas and a krypton internal standard. Measurements were obtained for an empty vessel, the vessel containing a well characterized radioactive tank waste sample, and the same configuration with the candidate catalyst installed. Results demonstrate that the new catalyst effectively reduced hydrogen concentrations in the offgas within the constraints of the experimental design. In addition to confirming catalytic activity, the testing provided valuable insights into experimental optimization and considerations for future performance evaluations. These findings support the potential scalability of the technology and highlight its applicability to broader nuclear waste management operations, offering improved safety and reduced operational costs through enhanced catalyst durability and lower replacement frequency.
This project aims to systematically investigate the fundamental interfacial chemistry that underlies the four-electron, four-proton oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) mediated by heteroatom-doped graphitic carbon electrodes. Heteroatom-doped (Fe, N, etc.) graphitic carbons have emerged as a rich class of materials that are promising ORR catalysts in low temperature fuel cells because of their earth-abundant elements, extremely low cost, environmental harmlessness, and high tolerance to impurities in the fuel stream. However, despite decades of research, systematic efforts to improve the activity, selectivity, and durability of these catalysts has been hampered both by a complex heterogeneous distribution of potential N- and Fe-dopant active sites and by the inability to tune the local electronic structure and environment of the active site with molecular precision. Understanding the fundamental chemistry that influences the turnover-limiting and selectivity determining steps for ORR and other multielectron/multiproton electrocatalytic transformations requires new and innovative methods to prepare heteroatom active sites with molecular precision on carbon surfaces.
Not Available
When combined with earth-abundant metals, Pt-based alloy nanoparticles (NPs) can be cost-effective electrocatalysts. However, these NPs can experience leaching of non-noble-metal components under harsh electrocatalytic conditions. In this work, the Skrabalak group has demonstrated a novel NP construct in which Pt-based random alloy surfaces are stabilized against non-noble-metal leaching by their deposition onto intermetallic seeds. These core@shell NPs are highly durable electrocatalysts, with the ability to tune catalytic performance by the core@shell architecture, surface alloy composition, and NP shape. This versatility was demonstrated in a model system in which random alloy (ra-) PtM surfaces were deposited onto ordered intermetallic (i-) PdCu seeds using seed-mediated co-reduction (SMCR). In the initial demonstration, ra-PtCu shells were deposited on i-PdCu seeds, with these core@shell NPs exhibiting higher specific and mass activities for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) when compared to similarly sized ra-PtCu NPs. These NPs also showed outstanding durability, maintaining ~85% in specific activity after 5000 cycles. Characterization of the NPs after use revealed minimal loss of Cu. The activity enhancement was attributed to the strained surface that arises from the lattice mismatch between the intermetallic core and random alloy surface. The outstanding durability was attributed to the ordered structure of the intermetallic core. The origin of this durability enhancement was investigated by classical molecular dynamics simulations, where Pt atoms were found to have a lower potential energy when deposited on an intermetallic core than when deposited on a random alloy core. Also, ordering of Cu atoms at the core@shell interface appears to enhance the overall binding between the core and the shell materials. Inspired by this initial demonstration, SMCR has been used to achieve shells of different random alloy compositions, PtM (M = Ni, Co, Cu, or Fe). This advance is significant because ligand effects vary as a function of PtM identity and Pt/M ratio. These features also influence the degree of surface strain imparted from the lattice mismatch between the core and shell materials. Like the initial demonstration, standout features of these core@shell NPs were high durability and resistance to non-noble metal leaching. Moving forward, efforts have been directed toward integrating shape-control to this core@shell NP construct. This integration is motivated by the shape-dependent catalytic performance of NPs derived from the selective expression of specific facets. Considering the initial i-PdCu@ra-PtCu system, NPs with a cubic shape have been achieved by judicious selection of capping ligands during SMCR. Evaluation of these NPs as catalysts for the electrooxidation of formic acid found that the nanocubic shape enhances catalytic performance compared to similar core@shell NPs with a spherical morphology. We envision that SMCR can be applied to other NP systems to achieve highly durable catalysts as the syntheses of monodisperse and shape-controlled intermetallic seeds are advanced. This Account highlights the role of intermetallic cores in providing more durable electrocatalysts. More broadly, the versatility of SMCR is highlighted as a route to integrate architecture, alloy surfaces, and shape within one NP system, and how this achievement is inspiring new high-performance and robust catalysts is discussed.
Fuel cell heavy-duty vehicles (HDVs) require increased durability of oxygen-reduction-reaction electrocatalysts, making knowledge of realistic degradation mechanisms critical. Here identical-location micro-X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy was performed on membrane electrode assemblies. The results exposed heavy in-plane movement of electrocatalyst after HDV lifetime, suggesting that electrochemical Ostwald ripening may not be a local effect. Development of local loading hotspots and preferential movement of electrocatalyst away from cathode catalyst layer cracks was observed. The heterogeneous degradation exhibited by a modified cathode gas diffusion layer membrane electrode assembly after HDV lifetime was successfully quantified by the identical-location approach. Further synchrotron micro-X-ray diffraction and micro-X-ray fluorescence experiments were performed to obtain the currently unknown correlation between electrocatalyst nanoparticle size increase and loading change. A direct correlation was discovered which developed only after HDV lifetime. Finally, the work provides a route to engineer immediate system-level mitigation strategies and to develop structured cathode catalyst layers with durable electrocatalysts.