Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “guidelines”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 127 records · Page 7
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2026

A review of United States energy-only generator interconnection service policy and considerations for reform

Grid interconnection has emerged as a significant obstacle to the development of new electricity resources. There is growing interest in energy-only interconnection, which is an interconnection service option meant to allow the interconnection of new generators without ensuring their energy deliverability during all hours through the transmission system to customers. This approach potentially avoids upfront congestion-related transmission upgrades but could increase curtailment risk. Interest in energy-only interconnection is shaped by incomplete understanding of how interconnection policy functions in different jurisdictions, a knowledge gap that makes it difficult to determine how energy-only interconnection might be better used or re-designed. In this paper, we provide a regulatory review of energy-only interconnection in U.S. interconnection policy and practice, identifying jurisdictions in which rules are close to -or farther from-the theoretical concept of energy-only interconnection service. We find substantial jurisdictional differences in how energy-only interconnection is implemented, driven by differences in resource adequacy frameworks, real-time transmission operations, and state-level procurement practices. U.S. regulators have preferred local jurisdictional flexibility over federal prescription of interconnection study methods and procedures, which also contributes to differences among regions. Such findings raise fundamental questions about whether competition policies in electricity markets should extend beyond spot energy markets and into more prescriptive guidelines around interconnection rules and market entry. This paper sheds light on tensions that energy-only interconnection raises in allowing generators to access the transmission system on an as available basis and discusses how controlling thresholds for congestion-related network upgrades may be a barrier to electricity market entry.

Gorman, Will↗
DOE OSTI2024

Probing degradation at solid-state battery interfaces using machine-learning interatomic potential

Solid-state batteries featuring fast ion-conducting solid electrolytes are promising next-generation energy storage technologies, yet challenges remain for practical deployment due to electro-chemo-mechanical instabilities at solid-solid interfaces. These interfaces, which include homogeneous/internal interfaces such as grain boundaries (GBs) and heterogeneous/external interfaces between solid-electrolyte and electrode materials, can impede Li-ion transport, deteriorate performance, and eventually lead to cell failure. Here, in this study, we leverage large-scale molecular simulations, enabled by validated machine-learning interatomic potentials, to directly probe the onset of interfacial degradation at the garnet Li 7 La 3 Zr 2 O 12 (LLZO) solid-electrolyte/LiCoO 2 (LCO) cathode interface. By surveying different interfacial geometries and compositions, it is found that Li-deficient interfaces can lead to severe interfacial disordering with cation mixing and Co interdiffusion from LCO into LLZO. By contrast, Li-sufficient interfaces are less disordered, although elemental segregation with local ordering is observed. As a consequence of Co interdiffusion, Co-rich regions are formed at the GBs of LLZO due to cation segregation and trapping effects. This behavior is independent of the GB tilting axis, degree of disorder at the GBs, and Co concentration, which implies Co clustering at GBs is a general phenomenon in polycrystalline LLZO and can dictate its overall transport and mechanical properties. Our findings elucidate the underlying fundamental mechanisms that give rise to experimentally observed physicochemical properties and provide guidelines for interface design that can mitigate interfacial degradation and improve cycling performance.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Finite element procedure for thermomechanical and structural integrity analysis of beam intercepting devices subjected to free electron laser

High-energy particles, including photons (x-ray, γ-ray, bremsstrahlung), electrons, and protons, possess the capability to penetrate materials and deposit energy within them. The degree of absorption depends on both the energy and type of particles, as well as the properties of the materials with which they interact. This energy deposition can manifest either at the material's surface or throughout its volume, potentially resulting in various failure modes. The primary aim of this paper is to establish a structured analysis methodology for evaluating the structural integrity of beam-intercepting devices when subjected to high-energy particles. Here, the paper also reviews some of the underlying physics, pertinent to the scope of the thermomechanical analysis, potential failure modes, and introduces verification and validation methodologies. Engineers and researchers can utilize the guidelines presented in this paper to effectively plan the development of beam intercepting devices, thereby ensuring their reliability and performance in the presence of high-energy particle exposure.

Finite element analysis↗
DOE OSTI2025

Designing slippery rough surfaces to enhance dropwise condensation of low surface tension fluid

Enhancing low surface tension liquid condensation is critical for achieving high energy efficiency and reducing the size of thermal energy systems. Extensive research has focused on promoting dropwise condensation of these liquids using state-of-the-art coatings on plain surfaces. However, maintaining dropwise condensation with low surface tension fluids is challenging due to rivulet formation, resulting in wetted tails that transition to filmwise condensation at elevated heat fluxes. Here, to address this issue, we uncover the role of surface structures and surface chemistry in the dropwise condensation of low surface tension ethanol on slippery rough surfaces (SRS). High-performance dropwise condensation has been achieved on slippery microchannels grafted with perfluoropolyether. The SRS uniquely facilitates rapid lateral droplet removal, enabling faster directional droplet shedding without rivulet formation. The resulting higher droplet removal frequency on SRS leads to heat transfer coefficients 100 % and 500 % higher than conventional dropwise and filmwise condensation on plain surfaces, respectively. Our findings uncover the pivotal role of rapid droplet removal through slippery microchannels in sustaining dropwise condensation of low surface tension liquids. This study introduces a new paradigm for promoting dropwise condensation using engineered SRS that incorporates surface structure and surface chemistry. The work will provide fundamental design guidelines to design efficient and compact condensers that use costly or flammable low global warming potential refrigerants in future refrigeration systems.

Dropwise condensation↗
DOE OSTI2026

Metal additively manufactured wavy fin cold-plate architecture for improved thermal-hydraulic performance

Rapid growth in artificial intelligence and data center workloads demands high-performance liquid cooling to manage increasing chip power. This study presents two metal-additive-manufactured cold plates with sinusoidal fins, constant-amplitude wavy fins and linearly variable-amplitude wavy fins and compares them against metal-additive-manufactured straight fins using experiments conducted at 1 kW heat dissipation as well as high-fidelity 3D conjugate computational fluid dynamic simulations. The cold plates were printed in AlSi10Mg material and underwent design using a Python-automated workflow prior to manufacture and testing. The experiments show that wavy fins reduce the normalized thermal resistance by 35 to 45 % at water flow rates from 1 to 4 LPM. At a fixed 20 kPa pressure drop, the variable-waviness design lowered peak surface temperature by 9 °C and thermal resistance by 51 %, while edge-channel maldistribution in the constant wavy fin design limited gains. A thermal resistance breakdown revealed that 55–63 % of the total thermal resistance in wavy designs comes from base heat conduction, 27–33 % from fin heat conduction, and 9–13 % from fin heat convection, indicating the need to address conduction bottlenecks. Parametric sweeps identify a 3 mm fin pitch as optimal, and that horizontal inlet/outlet manifolds further reduce pressure drop by 30–60 % and thermal resistance by 9–16 % relative to vertical inlet-outlet manifolds. The results yield comprehensive guidelines for fin geometry, manifold alignment, material selection and additive-manufacturing constraints to realize high-performance liquid-cooled cold plates for power-dense electronics.

3d printing↗
DOE OSTI2024

Effect of impurities on hydrogen defect stability and migration barrier in yttrium dihydride crystal

The impurity or alloying atoms in YH 2 can alter the local electronic structure and so the hydrogen defect stability, as well as the H migration barrier energy. Thus, DFT calculations were employed to determine the effect of foreign elements from alkali and alkaline earth metals to transition metals and one critical impurity element, O, on H vacancy stability and retention characteristics in YH2. Results revealed that alloying elements act as hydrogen vacancy sinks by reducing the vacancy formation energy at neighboring sites. The implantation of non-magnetic foreign elements (s1, s2, and d10 valence electrons) in hydrogen energy landscape was calculated to be minor; while the hydrogen vacancy formation energy was reduced from 1.37 eV to 1.00 eV, the migration energy barrier of hydrogen was increased from 0.87 eV to 1.15 eV for non-magnetic foreign elements. The migration energy barrier monotonically decreased with increasing d-shell occupancy, reaching as low as 0.4 eV for Cr, Mo(d4), and Fe (d4). Alloying with late transition metals (d8 and d9) moderately impacted the hydrogen vacancy formation. Finally, it was found to be O addition into the YH 2- lattice did not alter the energy landscape of hydrogen vacancies. Since alloyed YH 2 has not been studied extensively, this study provides an atomistic understanding how alloying elements and impurities trap vacancies and affects hydrogen mobility YH 2 . Meanwhile, the main findings of this study may serve as guidelines for introducing alloying elements in ZrH 2 as well.

08 HYDROGEN↗
DOE OSTI2026

A single-zone zero-dimensional study of HCCI combustion of methanol dehydration products to enable ignition of direct-injected methanol

Methanol is an alternative fuel gaining traction in the maritime sector. Its direct adoption, however, is accompanied by a unique set of technical challenges, such as low cetane number and high latent heat of vaporization. An approach to overcome these challenges is being developed at the US Department of Energy’s Oak Ridge National Laboratory, where onboard generation of dimethyl ether (DME) via catalytic dehydration of methanol can be used to assist in the mixing controlled combustion of direct-injected (DI) methanol. The generated mixture from this dehydration process can be premixed with intake air to condition the cylinder via. homogeneous charge compression ignition (HCCI) for subsequent DI methanol. In this preliminary work, various catalyst or reactor conversion efficiencies were simulated (using bottles) at constant DME and water flow at low load on a single-cylinder marine-variant of a CAT® C18 18 L engine with a 145 mm bore. To substantiate the experimental findings, a zero-dimensional engine model was developed in Cantera using a DME mechanism with 79 species and 658 reactions. Results presented include experimental and simulation heat release rate comparisons, species evolution information, and constant volume ignition delay (ID) for DI methanol with and without background species from HCCI of the premixed products from different reactor efficiencies. The results suggest that thermal effects dominate the DI methanol ignition process, and this work provides a chemical kinetic foundation or guideline for developing future control schemes.

Tyrewala, Daanish [ORNL] (ORCID:0000000208599324)↗
DOE OSTI2024

Hybrid bilayered vanadium oxide electrodes with large and tunable interlayer distances in lithium-ion batteries

The interlayer distances in layered electrode materials, influenced by the chemical composition of the confined interlayer regions, have a significant impact on their electrochemical performance. Chemical preintercalation of inorganic metal ions affects the interlayer spacing, yet expansion is limited by the hydrated ion radii. Herein, we demonstrate that using varying concentrations of decyltrimethylammonium (DTA + ) and cetyltrimethylammonium (CTA + ) cations in chemical preintercalation synthesis followed by hydrothermal treatment, the interlayer distance of hybrid bilayered vanadium oxides (BVOs) can be tuned between 11.1 Å and 35.6 Å. Our analyses reveal that these variations in interlayer spacing are due to different amounts of structural water and alkylammonium cations confined within the interlayer regions. Increased concentrations of alkylammonium cations not only expand the interlayer spacing but also induce local bending and disordering of the V-O bilayers. Electrochemical cycling of hybrid BVO electrodes in non-aqueous lithium-ion cells show that specific capacities decrease as interlayer regions expand, suggesting that the densely packed alkylammonium cations obstruct intercalation sites and hinder Li + ion transport. Furthermore, we found that greater layer separation facilitates the dissolution of active material into the electrolyte, resulting in rapid capacity decay during extended cycling. In conclusion, this study emphasizes that layered electrode materials require both spacious interlayer regions as well as high structural and chemical stabilities, providing guidelines for structural engineering of organic–inorganic hybrids.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Using stable isotopes to inform water resource management in forested and agricultural ecosystems

Present and future climatic trends are expected to markedly alter water fluxes and stores in the hydrologic cycle. In addition, water demand continues to grow due to increased human use and a growing population. Sustainably managing water resources requires a thorough understanding of water storage and flow in natural, agricultural, and urban ecosystems. Measurements of stable isotopes of water (hydrogen and oxygen) in the water cycle (atmosphere, soils, plants, surface water, and groundwater) can provide information on the transport pathways, sourcing, dynamics, ages, and storage pools of water that is difficult to obtain with other techniques. However, the potential of these techniques for practical questions has not been fully exploited yet. Here, we outline the benefits and limitations of potential applications of stable isotope methods useful to water managers, farmers, and other stakeholders. We also describe several case studies demonstrating how stable isotopes of water can support water management decision-making. Finally, we propose a workflow that guides users through a sequence of decisions required to apply stable isotope methods to examples of water management issues. We call for ongoing dialogue and a stronger connection between water management stakeholders and water stable isotope practitioners to identify the most pressing issues and develop best-practice guidelines to apply these techniques.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2025

Improving the prediction of daily reservoir releases over the CONUS using conditioned LSTM

Reservoirs play a vital role in regulating streamflow timing and variability for hydroelectricity, flood control, water supply, irrigation, and recreation. Despite their importance, many reservoirs lack comprehensive operational guidelines, making their management complex due to conflicting operational objectives. Hence traditional policy-based reservoir models often fail to capture real-world conditions accurately and they depend on perfect streamflow predictions, which are not always available. In contrast, data-driven models like Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) networks offer a robust alternative. This study introduces an approach that integrates reservoir characteristics—such as main use, climate, and maximum capacity—into the LSTM model to enhance reservoir release predictions. Using data from nearly 200 reservoirs in the contiguous United States (CONUS), our conditioned LSTM model (LSTM_cond) was compared with both the vanila LSTM and a traditional policy-based approach. Furthermore, our results show that while both LSTM_cond and LSTM perfoms better than the policy-based approach, LSTM_cond consistently outperforms LSTM for hydroelectric, water supply, irrigation, and recreation reservoirs. The KGE median values for LSTM_cond for out-sample reservoirs are 0.764, 0.565, 0.821, and 0.779, respectively, for the aforementioned reservoir types, which are consistently higher that the corresponding KGE values of 0.737, 0.413, 0.775, and 0.713 of LSTM, demonstrating its advantages in improving generalizability.

CONUS↗
DOE OSTI2026

Solar cell efficiency tables: Version 68

Consolidated tables showing an extensive listing of the highest independently confirmed efficiencies for photovoltaic solar cells and modules are presented. Guidelines for inclusion of results into these tables are outlined, and new entries since January 2026 are reviewed.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2025

Impact of organic acids on extraction of rare earth elements: Mechanisms and optimization

Organic acids are increasingly recognized as an environmentally friendly and efficient selective leaching agent of critical minerals. However, their impact on subsequent extraction processes remains unclear. This study investigates the extraction behavior of rare earth elements (REEs), representative of critical minerals, in the presence of various organic acids, including citric acid, maleic acid, malonic acid, DL-malic acid, L(+)-tartaric acid, and L-ascorbic acid. The results show that organic acids slightly reduce the extraction of REEs but greatly increase the extraction of aluminum (Al³⁺), making it harder to separate REEs from other elements. To avoid this, it is best to keep organic acid concentrations as low as possible in practical applications. However, by optimizing extraction conditions, these negative effects can be minimized. Specifically, adjusting the contact time between solutions allows for efficient REE extraction while limiting unwanted aluminum extraction. Among the acids tested, malonic acid and L(+)-tartaric acid were found to be the most effective for selectively extracting REEs. Mechanistically, organic acids are likely to form complexes with REEs and D2EHPA during extraction, except for Y (III), offering practical guidelines for optimizing REE recovery. Beyond extraction, this study also highlights a way to recover organic acids by precipitating REEs from stripping solutions using oxalic acid, which adds both environmental and economic benefits. Furthermore, these findings provide useful insights for optimizing REE recovery and offer a reference for extracting other critical minerals from solutions containing organic acids.

D2EHPA↗
DOE OSTI2026

Optimization of well design and CO 2 injection strategy for risk reduction in Class VI geological carbon sequestration wells

The safety and durability of Class VI wells are critical for geological carbon sequestration (GCS). However, current GCS operations face unique challenges: unlike traditional Class II wells, Class VI CO 2 injection wells operate at rates up to 100 times higher, dramatically increasing the risk of wellbore leakage and structural compromise due to severe temperature drops and associated mechanical stresses. Despite existing guidelines on material selection, there remains a substantial gap in understanding how rapid CO 2 injection rates, low surface temperatures, and variable reservoir conditions interact to threaten long-term well integrity. This study presents a comprehensive, original workflow integrating advanced analytical and numerical models for both well flow and well integrity analysis. By systematically simulating a wide range of field-relevant scenarios—including variations in injection rate, CO 2 temperature, and reservoir pressure—this work provides the first cross-validated assessment of cooling effects on wellbore. The results reveal that extreme temperature drops, up to 60 °C, can occur under high injection rates, particularly in depleted reservoirs, significantly increasing the risk of cement failure. Building on these insights, the study proposes innovative, practical well design and operational strategies, including ductile cement formulations, pre-stressing techniques, advanced insulation coatings, and proactive management of injection rates. The safety of Class VI well extends beyond simply using CO 2 resistant materials. Cement materials should possess optimal thermo-hydraulic-mechanical-chemical properties for effective performance. This work provides a scientific basis for optimizing Class VI well designs, with direct benefits for minimizing environmental risk, lowering operational costs, and enhancing the long-term reliability of GCS.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Origin of enhanced performance when Mn-rich rocksalt cathodes transform to δ -DRX

Most Mn-rich cathodes are known to undergo phase transformation into structures resembling spinel-like ordering upon electrochemical cycling. Recently, the irreversible transformation of Ti-containing Mn-rich disordered rock-salt cathodes into a phase — named δ — with nanoscale spinel-like domains has been shown to increase energy density, capacity retention, and rate capability. However, the nature of the boundaries between domains and their relationship with composition and electrochemistry are not well understood. In this work, we discuss how the transformation into the multi-domain structure results in eight variants of Spinel domains, which is crucial for explaining the nanoscale domain formation in the δ -phase. We study the energetics of crystallographically unique boundaries and the possibility of Li-percolation across them with a fine-tuned CHGNet machine learning interatomic potential. Energetics of 16 d vacancies reveal a strong affinity to segregate to the boundaries, thereby opening Li-pathways at the boundary to enhance long-range Li-percolation in the δ structure. Defect calculations of the relatively low-mobility Ti show how it can influence the extent of Spinel ordering, domain morphology and size significantly; leading to guidelines for engineering electrochemical performance through changes in composition.

Anand, Shashwat↗
DOE OSTI2026

Mechanistic mass transfer in hollow fiber membrane solvent extraction for bio-based isobutanol

Membrane solvent extraction (MSE) has emerged as a promising method for selectively recovering bioproducts from complex aqueous streams. Bio-isobutanol, a next-generation feedstock for biofuel, remains challenging to recover because of its low concentration and the presence of inhibitory substances. This study explores the potential of hollow fiber (HF) MSE for bio-isobutanol recovery and systematically examines the coupled effects of fiber packing, shell-side flow dynamics, and aqueous chemistry on performance. A resistance-in-series model is applied to understand mass transfer in the HF MSE modules, quantify local resistances, and validate overall performance. The results show that increasing the fiber packing provides a larger interfacial area but induces poor flow distribution and channeling, hindering effective isobutanol transport. Meanwhile, increasing the shell-side velocity improves isobutanol recovery due to reductions in the boundary layer thickness. The presence of salts, added to mimic fermentation broth, increases the partition coefficient through salting-out effects, further improving isobutanol flux. A modified correlation for the shell-side mass transfer coefficient (k s,ϕ+v ), integrating geometric and hydrodynamic effects, was developed and validated. The proposed model achieves highly predictive accuracy (r 2 = 0.9808) across a wide range of conditions, outperforming previous models. The findings provide mechanistic insight into the interaction of geometric packing, hydrodynamics, and chemistry in governing mass transfer in HF MSE. Overall, this work demonstrates the potential of HF MSE for efficient bio-isobutanol recovery and also provides practical guidelines on critical factors (packing fraction, partition coefficient, and shell-side velocity), aiding in the design and scaling of MSE systems for resource recovery.

Aqueous chemistry↗
DOE OSTI2025

PHASE: Personalized Head-based Automatic Simulation for Electromagnetic properties in 7T MRI

Accurate and individualized human head models are becoming increasingly important for electromagnetic (EM) simulations. These simulations depend on precise anatomical representations to realistically model electric and magnetic field distributions, particularly when evaluating Specific Absorption Rate (SAR) within safety guidelines. State of the art simulations use the Virtual Population due to limited public resources and the impracticality of manually annotating patient data at scale. Here, this paper introduces Personalized Head-based Automatic Simulation for EM properties (PHASE), an automated open-source toolbox that generates high-resolution, patient-specific head models for EM simulations using paired T1-weighted (T1w) magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and computed tomography (CT) scans with 14 tissue labels. To evaluate the performance of PHASE models, we conduct semi-automated segmentation and EM simulations on 15 real human patients, serving as the gold standard reference. The PHASE model achieved comparable global SAR and localized SAR averaged over 10 grams of tissue (SAR-10g), demonstrating its potential as a promising tool for generating large-scale human model datasets in the future. The code and models of PHASE toolbox have been made publicly available: https://github.com/hrlblab/PHASE.

Deep learning↗
DOE OSTI2024

Co-, Ni- and Fe-rich grain-boundary phases enhance creep resistance in θ'-strengthened Al-Cu alloys

Here, microstructural evolution and creep response were investigated in the cast Al-5.0Cu-0.3Mn-0.2Zr (wt.%) alloy with and without addition of slow-diffusing, intermetallic-forming elements Fe, Ni, or Co. Baseline Al-5.0Cu-0.3Mn-0.2Zr alloy exhibits high creep resistance at 300 °C, up to ~75 MPa, which is attributed to high-aspect-ratio, intragranular θ'-Al 2 Cu precipitates that effectively suppress dislocation climb. However, θ'-Al 2 Cu precipitate-free zones form along grain boundaries upon heat treatment, whose extent is amplified during subsequent creep. Such weak regions experience dislocation creep, leading to strain localization and acceleration of grain-boundary sliding. Adding Ni and Co, individually or in combination, leads to the formation of grain-boundary precipitates (Al 9 Co 2 , Al 3 Ni 2 ) which are resistant to coarsening, thus suppressing the formation of θ'-Al 2 Cu precipitate-free zones. This microstructure provides high creep resistance at stresses up to 75–80 MPa, with strain rates much lower than in unmodified Al-5.0Cu-0.3Mn-0.2Zr. Adding Fe, which results in extensive decoration of grain boundaries with coarsening-resistant Al 7 Cu 2 Fe, and then increasing the Cu content to compensate for the Cu loss to this new phase, leads to a new Al-7.4Cu-1.6Fe-0.3Mn-0.2Zr alloy with creep resistance at 300 °C that surpasses known cast aluminum alloys. Adding Fe to improve the creep resistance of Al-Cu alloys is both cost-effective and sustainable. Our findings offer guidelines applicable to various alloy systems on controlling the evolution of precipitate-free zones and its ensuing effects on creep deformation.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

An atomistic study connecting underlying dislocation behavior with superior mechanical properties of NiCoCr medium entropy alloy

NiCoCr-based medium-entropy alloy (MEA) with a simple face-centered cubic crystal phase exhibits excellent mechanical properties, often attributed to the synergy of multiple deformation mechanisms. However, the atomistic origin of their outstanding mechanical response, including microstructural evolution and dislocation behavior under varying strain-rates and orientation, remains unclear. In this work, we employ large-scale molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to investigate the changes in deformation mechanisms along three distinct orientations ([110], [111], [100]) under varying strain rates (1 ×10 8 /sec, 1 ×10 10 /sec, 1 ×10 12 /sec) in the NiCoCr MEA. The presence of the stair-rod and the Shockley partial dislocations under uniaxial tensile strain are found to play a key role in the formation of deformation twinning and ε-martensite, which positively correlates with strain-rate dependent dislocation analysis. These findings further establish the role of the dislocations in controlling the superior mechanical response and excellent fracture toughness of the NiCoCr MEA. Systematic transmission-electron microscopy tests performed on the [111]-oriented crystals, deformed at different strain levels, at room temperature provide clear evidence of both the extended stacking-fault and the stair rods, confirming the predicted microstructural features. Finally, this study offers key insights into the complex nucleation mechanisms of deformation twinning and ε-martensite, such as twinning – and transformation–induced plasticity (TWIP-TRIP), providing valuable guidelines for studying similar material classes.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗