Bayesian performance evaluation of evapotranspiration models based on eddy covariance systems in an arid region
Abstract. Evapotranspiration (ET) is a major component of the land surface processinvolved in energy fluxes and energy balance, especially in the hydrologicalcycle of agricultural ecosystems. While many models have been developed aspowerful tools to simulate ET, there is no agreement on which model bestdescribes the loss of water to the atmosphere. This study focuses on twoaspects, evaluating the performance of four widely used ET models andidentifying parameters, and the physical mechanisms that havesignificant impacts on the model performance. The four tested models arethe Shuttleworth–Wallace (SW) model, Penman–Monteith (PM) model,Priestley–Taylor and Flint–Childs (PT–FC) model, and advection–aridity (AA)model. By incorporating the mathematically rigorous thermodynamicintegration algorithm, the Bayesian model evidence (BME) approach is adoptedto select the optimal model with half-hourly ET observations obtained at aspring maize field in an arid region. Our results reveal that the SW model has thebest performance, and the extinction coefficient is not merely partitioningthe total available energy into the canopy and surface but also includingthe energy imbalance correction. The extinction coefficient is wellconstrained in the SW model and poorly constrained in the PM model but notconsidered in PT–FC and AA models. This is one of the main reasons that theSW model outperforms the other models. Meanwhile, the good fitting of SWmodel to observations can counterbalance its higher complexity. In addition,the detailed analysis of the discrepancies between observations and modelsimulations during the crop growth season indicate that explicit treatmentof energy imbalance and energy interaction will be the primary way offurther improving ET model performance.