A Test of ASTM Methods E1245-03 and E562-11 in Calculating the Volume Fraction of Carbides in a U-10Mo Foil
Volume fraction measurements of carbides in DU-10Mo castings and foils were performed as part of a round robin study aimed at ensuring characterization efforts by multiple laboratories were yielding consistent results. Three of the four labs employed an automatic image analysis method to determine volume fraction of carbides in the metal and reported results around 2%. The other laboratory used a grid intercept count method and reported a fraction percentage of above 5%, about 3% higher than the other labs. At LANL, the method ASTM E1245-03, Determining the Inclusion or Second-Phase Constituent Content of Metals by Automatic Image Analysis was employed with a result of 2.02 ± .26%. There was a need to resolve the large discrepancy in volume fraction measurements reported from the round robin participant that used the grid intercept method. To do this, the grid intercept method outlined in ASTM E562-11, Determining Volume Fraction by Systematic Manual Point Count was also performed on the exact set of micrographs already analyzed by image analysis software at LANL. Calculations carried out following the manual point count method reported a percentage of 2.2 ± .6% similar to the result yielded by the automated image analysis method. Explanations for discrepancies in the results of the two methods are proposed.