Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Multilayers”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,351 records · Page 75
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2019

A Tunable Optimized Low-Temperature Sensor Based on the Hybrid Photonic Crystals (F{sub 4}/Bg{sub 5}/F{sub 4}) and (Bg{sub 5}/F{sub 4}/Bg{sub 5})

In this paper, we present a novel type of low-temperature sensor based precisely on the symmetrical hybrid photonic crystals. Thanks to the two-fluid model and the transfer matrix method, we study the temperature sensitivity of the hybrid multilayers (F{sub 4}/Bg{sub 5}/F{sub 4}) and (Bg{sub 5}/F{sub 4}/Bg{sub 5}) where F{sub 4} represents the fourth iteration of the quasi-periodic Fibonacci sequence and Bg5 designates the multilayer Bragg mirror (HLS){sub 5}. We assume that the layers H, L, and S indicate precisely the dielectric materials of Bi{sub 4}Ge{sub 3}O{sub 12}, SiO{sub 2}, and YaBO{sub 2}CuO{sub 7} superconductor one. The analysis of the transmittance spectra shows that the hybrid photonic crystal is more sensitive to the temperature than the periodic one. A higher sensibility value is reached due to the possible combination of the periodic and quasi-periodic sequences. Our investigation reveals that the photonic crystal (F{sub 4}/Bg{sub 5}/F{sub 4}) is more sensitive to low temperature compared to (Bg{sub 5}/F{sub 4}/Bg{sub 5}). The sensitivity is significantly affected by the position of quasi-periodic sequences. The sensitivity of such photonic crystals can be adequately controlled by applying a symmetrical chirping. The designed structures pave the way toward the achievement of a potential low-temperature sensor.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2018

Characterization of core–shell nanostructure consisting Si–Au–SiO{sub 2} based on manipulation of optical properties

In this article, we investigated some physical characteristics of core–shell nanostructure in optical regime and perturbation has been also introduced as an effective method in shaping of optical properties. The proposed nanostructures are composed of the selected materials as: Silicon, Silicon Dioxide and Gold. At first, the extinction cross section spectra are calculated for multilayer core–shell nanostructures in optical range and the configuration effect of the constructed materials in a multilayer nanostructure are investigated for determination of Plasmon range. Then, the new structures of core–shell nanoparticles (gold–silicon) are presented, which have an amount of impurity particle in their shells as perturbation and also their extinction cross section spectra are calculated. The obtained results in this article give a proper approach about perturbation effect in broadening, sharpening and shifting of optical response which are decisive factors especially nano-network systems. Indeed, it has been proposed that the impurity particles in the shells can be a mechanism for tuning of optical characteristics of the presented nanoparticles in practical fields and also creation of local oscillations as plasmonic resonances in a considered optical range. Besides, redshift in extinction cross section can be also created by particle perturbation. At the end, the effective permittivity of the perturbed core-shells are extracted. The optional frequency range is selected between 300 and 900 (THz).

77 NANOSCIENCE AND NANOTECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2018

Microstructural Analysis and Transport Properties of Thermally Sprayed Multiple-Layer Ceramic Coatings

In this paper, multilayer, graded ceramic/metal coatings were prepared by an air plasma spray method on Ti-6Al-4V, 4140 steel and graphite substrates. The coatings were designed to provide thermal barriers for diesel engine pistons to operate at higher temperatures with improved thermal efficiency and cleaner emissions. A systematic, progressive variation in the mixture of yttria-stabilized zirconia and bondcoat alloys (NiCoCrAlYHfSi) was designed to provide better thermal expansion match with the substrate and to improve thermal shock resistance and cycle life. Heat transfer through the layers was evaluated by a flash diffusivity technique based on a model of one-dimensional heat flow. The aging effect of the as-sprayed coatings was captured during diffusivity measurements, which included one heating and cooling cycle. The hysteresis of thermal diffusivity due to aging was not observed after 100-h annealing at 800 °C. The measurements of coatings on substrate and freestanding coatings allowed the influence of interface resistance to be evaluated. Finally, the microstructure of the multilayer coating was examined using scanning electron microscope and electron probe microanalysis.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2019

ToF-SIMS Depth Profiling of Organic Delta Layers with Low-Energy Cesium Ions: Depth Resolution Assessment

The advent of cluster ion beams has paved the way to the routine 3D analysis of organic heterojunctions. Alternatively, organic thin layers have also been successfully depth profiled with a low-energy cesium ion beam (Cs{sup +}), to exploit the high chemical reactivity of cesium atoms, acting as free-radical scavengers. Despite of this, little is known about the depth resolution associated with low-energy Cs{sup +} sputtering on organic multilayers. In this work, amino acids multilayers, consisting of phenylalanine delta layers alternated with tyrosine spacers, were used as model systems to assess the depth resolution associated with 500 eV Cs{sup +} depth profiles. High yields were obtained for quasi-molecular ions from both amino acids, and no significant chemical alteration was noticed under the monoatomic bombardment. A depth resolution as low as 4 nm is demonstrated without sensible degradation on a rather long profile depth (300 nm). Limited depth resolution (> 10 nm) along with high molecular degradation was previously reported on similar systems by combining low-energy Cs{sup +} with Ga{sup +} analysis beam. The use of the Bi{sub 3}{sup +} analysis beam results in a dramatic improvement of both the characteristic molecular signal intensities and the depth resolution. Even though the analysis beam fluence is very low compared to the sputtering beam fluence, data suggest that further reducing the analysis Bi{sub 3}{sup +} fluence could improve the depth resolution by ~ 1 nm. .

74 ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS↗
DOE OSTI2017

Mixing and trapping of dissolved CO 2 in deep geologic formations with shale layers

For dissolution trapping, the spatial variability of the geologic properties of naturally complex storage formations can significantly impact flow patterns and storage mechanisms of dissolved CO 2 . The significance of diffusive mixing that occurs in low permeability layers embedded between relatively higher permeability materials was highlighted by Agartan et al. (2015) using a highly controlled laboratory experimental study on trapping of dissolved CO 2 in multilayered systems. In this paper, we present a numerical modeling study on the impacts of low permeability layers on flow and storage of dissolved CO 2 in realistic field-scale settings. The simulator of variable-density flow used in this study was first verified using the experimental data in Agartan et al. (2015) to capture the observed processes. The simulator was then applied to a synthetic, field-scale multilayered system, with 19 sensitivity cases having variable permeability and thickness of the shale layers as well as the source strength and geometry of the source zone of dissolved CO 2 . Simulation results showed that the presence of continuous shale layers in the storage system disrupts the convective mixing by enhancing lateral spreading of dissolved CO 2 in sandstone layers and retarding the vertical mixing of dissolved CO 2 . The effectiveness of trapping of dissolved CO 2 depends on the physical properties of the shale layers and configurations of the source zone. The comparison to homogeneous cases with effective vertical permeability shows that it is important to capture these continuous thin shale layers in a storage formation and include them in the models to enhance dissolution trapping.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2021

Learning-based CO 2 concentration prediction: Application to indoor air quality control using demand-controlled ventilation

There have been increasing concerns over the air quality inside buildings as high levels of bio-effluents can cause nausea, dizziness, headaches, and fatigue to the people working in those spaces. First published in 2004 as Standard 62.1, ASHRAE Standard 62.2-2019 requires highly occupied spaces to implement heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) that can dilute contaminants produced by occupants. In this regard, occupant-centric ventilation control has been regarded as an effective practice to maintain a satisfactory indoor air quality (IAQ) when dealing with highly variable occupancy environments. However, few established models in current literature and practice consider dynamic occupancy behavior and adaptive IAQ control. To address this gap, a dynamic indoor CO2 model is constructed using machine learning algorithms to forecast CO2concentrations across a range of forecasting horizons. Herein, we tuned and compared six state-of-the-algorithms—including Support Vector Machine, Ada Boost, Random Forest, Gradient Boosting, Logistic Regression, and Multilayer Perceptron. The algorithms’ performances are validated using CO 2 and historical meteorological data collected from a campus classroom with a variable occupancy rate. Simulation results showed that Multilayer Perceptron can strongly predict the volatile CO 2 behavior and also outperforms other algorithms in terms of accuracy. Furthermore, a control strategy capable of modeling and detecting dynamic patterns of CO 2 level is utilized to modulate the ventilation rate in real-time and also reduce the energy consumption. The proposed controller reduced the HVAC fan’s energy consumption by 51.4% and provide ventilation as needed per the ASHRAE standards.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗
DOE OSTI2017

Defect-mediated, thermally-activated encapsulation of metals at the surface of graphite

Here, we show that 3 metals – Dy, Ru, and Cu – can form multilayer intercalated (encapsulated) islands at the graphite (0001) surface if 2 specific conditions are met: Defects are introduced on the graphite terraces to act as entry portals, and the metal deposition temperature is well above ambient. Focusing on Dy as a prototype, we show that surface encapsulation is much different than bulk intercalation, because the encapsulated metal takes the form of bulk-like rafts of multilayer Dy, rather than the dilute, single-layer structure known for the bulk compound. Carbon-covered metallic rafts even form for relatively unreactive metals (Ru and Cu) which have no known bulk intercalation compound.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

The structural modification and magnetism of many-layer epitaxial graphene implanted with low-energy light ions

Modifying the properties of graphene has gained wide interest for a plethora of potential applications, including spintronics. One approach has demonstrated that proton irradiation can induce ferromagnetism in graphene as well as in graphite. However, little is known about how the protons interact with graphene, the mechanism that creates the ferromagnetism, or whether the protons remain in the graphene. Here we report an investigation, broadly relevant to graphitic carbon, using low-energy (360–2000 eV) ions of hydrogen, deuterium, and helium implanted into multilayer epitaxial graphene. Complementary x-ray and neutron reflectivity demonstrate that essentially all of the implanted hydrogen remains chemisorbed in graphene. In situ x-ray diffraction reveals significantly different rates of interlayer expansion of the multilayer graphene. Analysis of these data demonstrates that the interlayer expansion arises entirely from the interstitials created by the ions and not from hydrogen that remains in the graphene. The results also establish a quantitative measure of the layer expansion due to carbon interstitials. Magnetometry and x-ray diffraction studies show that the magnetic moment relates to the amount of interstitial carbon rather than the amount of hydrogen, demonstrating that the induced room-temperature ferromagnetism arises directly from the disrupted bonding of the carbon lattice.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Parallel exponential time differencing methods for geophysical flow simulations

Two ocean models are considered for geophysical flow simulations: the multilayer shallow water equations and the multilayer primitive equations. For the former, we investigate the parallel performance of exponential time differencing (ETD) methods, including exponential Rosenbrock–Euler, ETD2wave, and B-ETD2wave. For the latter, we take advantage of the splitting of barotropic and baroclinic modes and propose a new two-level method in which an ETD method is applied to solve the fast barotropic mode. Furthermore, these methods could improve the computational efficiency of numerical simulations because ETD methods allow for much larger time step sizes than traditional explicit time-stepping techniques that are commonly used in existing computational ocean models. Several standard benchmark tests for ocean modeling are performed and comparison of the numerical results demonstrates a great potential of applying the parallel ETD methods for simulating real-world geophysical flows.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2022

Incorporating two-dimensional conduction modeling techniques into an energy simulation program: The EnergyPlus radiant system example

Due to the inherent complexity of multi-dimensional solutions for transient conduction in a multilayered building element, most heat balance-based algorithms assume that conduction occurs only in one dimension—through the building element between the inside and outside environments. Usually, since the length and width of the elements are much greater than the thickness of the element, this is a valid assumption. However, there are some cases such as hydronic radiant slabs where this assumption may not lead to an accurate estimate of the energy consumption of the system. In a hydronic radiant slab, water tubes are embedded in a slab, and hot or chilled water is circulated to meet any heating or cooling loads. The energy consumption of such a system will depend highly on the temperature of the water being sent to the slab (i.e., produced by the boiler or chiller). The temperature of the water that must be sent to the slab will depend on the spacing of the tubes, the multilayer construction of the building element, and the boundary conditions to which the construction is exposed. Thus, to accurately predict the energy consumption of such a system, a transient two-dimensional heat conduction model must be integrated with a heat balance-based simulation. This paper demonstrates the potential loss of accuracy associated with the one-dimensional radiant system models by providing a comparison of one- and two-dimensional solutions using EnergyPlus.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗
DOE OSTI2026

Adsorption of hydroxamic acid ligands for improved extraction of rare earth elements from monazite ores

Efficient separation of rare earth element (REE) ores via froth flotation requires the development of novel ligands with enhanced adsorption capacity and selectivity. To realize these advances, understanding the mechanisms underlying interactions between the ligand and mineral surfaces is essential. This study systematically evaluates the adsorption behavior of alkyl- and aromatic alkyl-substituted hydroxamic acid ligands on monazite surfaces using complementary spectroscopic techniques, including UV–visible (UV–vis) spectroscopy, Raman spectroscopy, infrared spectroscopy, and vibrational sum frequency generation (SFG) spectroscopy, together with the ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations. Among the studied ligands, octanohydroxamic acid (OHA) and 4-ethoxy-N,2-dihydroxybenzamide (EDHBA) exhibit high adsorption capacity under basic pH (8–10) by forming multilayers on the surface. OHA has a higher equilibrium adsorption capacity compared to EDHBA, but it forms a less stable multilayer susceptible to disruption in the presence of interfering ions. AIMD results show that OHA adopts a single stable chelating geometry, while EDHBA exhibits multiple binding modes involving distinct interactions with La surface atoms and phosphate-bound oxygens, resulting in more complex adsorption kinetics. The variations in surface binding and intermolecular interactions observed between alkyl and aromatic molecules influence the differences in adsorption kinetics, equilibrium adsorption capacities on the mineral surface, and their flotation performance. This work provides valuable insight into the adsorption mechanism of ligands at mineral interfaces, which is crucial for guiding the design of new ligands with enhanced separation performance.

Zhou, Muchu [ORNL] (ORCID:0000000182650215)↗
DOE OSTI2017

Irradiation-induced creep in metallic nanolaminates characterized by In situ TEM pillar nanocompression

Our work reports on irradiation-induced creep (IIC) measured on nanolaminate (Cu-W and Ni-Ag) and nanocrystalline alloys (Cu-W) at room temperature using a combination of heavy ion irradiation and nanopillar compression performed concurrently in situ in a transmission electron microscope. Furthermore, we observed appreciable IIC in multilayers with 50 nm layer thicknesses at high stress, ≈½ the yield strength, but not in multilayers with only 5 nm layer thicknesses.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Thermal stability of oxidized ultrathin Li films on TZM for plasma facing components

For improved understanding of the behavior of Li plasma facing components (PFCs) in the presence of oxygen impurities, we report on the thermal stability of ultrathin (up to 1.0 nm) LiO x films on a titanium-zirconium-molybdenum (TZM) alloy substrate over the temperature range of 310–1400 K. LiO x films were prepared by either post-oxidation of Li films or Li films deposited on an oxygen-precovered TZM surface. Thermal stability of these films was studied using a combination of temperature programmed desorption (TPD), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), and low-energy ion scattering (LEIS). For post-oxidized Li films, TPD showed that no Li desorption occurred until temperatures above 620 K, and then Li desorbed from the surface via at least three desorption peaks. The O 1s XPS spectra on the post-oxidized films at 310 K indicate the formation of lithium oxide (Li2O) and peroxide/hydroxide (Li 2 O 2 /LiOH). The peroxide/hydroxide converts to oxide after heating to 680 K with no desorption of Li or O 2 , and then this film decomposes to liberate Li into the gas phase while leaving oxygen at the TZM surface. Heating the LiO x films to 1070 K led to a solid-state reaction with surface Mo atoms of the substrate to form a condensed binary lithium molybdenum oxide (LixMoOy) phase, which upon further heating decomposed to liberate gas phase binary lithium molybdenum oxide species. Li deposition on an oxygen-precovered TZM surface formed a complex, highly stable, oxygen rich, Li-O-Mo interfacial oxide. Li desorption from multilayer Li films on oxygen-precovered TZM surfaces occurred in a metallic Li multilayer peak and three other oxide-derived peaks. These results support the improved thermal stability of oxidized lithium as compared to metallic Li and have implications for Mo impurity transport into the plasma at high temperatures.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2018

Inhibitory effect of Ti and La on Fe dissolution in Al–Zn–Si bath by in-situ SXRD, SXRF, TEM and DFT calculation

Highlights: • In-situ synchrotron X-rays diffraction was used to study the solid-liquid reaction. • The addition of Ti and La suppresses the dissolution of Fe in the reaction. • A new quaternary phase was found in the hot-dip coated sheets. • The formation of the quaternary phase needed an enrichment of Si from bath. • The continuous formation of dross probably caused by the initial dissolution - Abstract: During the hot-dipping process, there is always a desire to restrain the mutual diffusion between steel and alloy bath for suppressing the formation of bath dross. However, the dissolution of steel sheets is difficult to quantify by the traditional methods. In this work, in-situ X-ray diffraction was used to investigate the solid-liquid reaction between solid Fe and Al–Zn–Si liquid alloy for quantitatively analyzing the consumption of Fe and the formation of Fe–Al compounds. The results indicated that the addition of trace Ti or La could suppress the mutual diffusion. We also observed the microstructures of the Fe–Al intermetallic multilayers and the distribution of Ti or La in the multilayers. A new quaternary phase was identified. The inhibitory effects of Ti and La were also explained by calculating the diffusion barrier energies with density functional theory.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2018

Controllable nanoporous fibril-like morphology by layer-by- layer self-assembled films of bioelectronics poly(pyrrole-co-formyl pyrrole)/polystyrene sulfonate for biocompatible electrode

Highlights: • Controllable highly degree of nano porous/fibril-like network of P (Py-co-FPy) morphology on top surface film by LBL technique. • Modulation of morphology, charge, conductivity and wettability of film for bioaffinity surface by LBL technique. • Fibril-like structure of P(Py-co-FPy)/PSS layers can influences the BSA and Fgn absorption. • P(Py-co-FPy)/PSS LBL electrode completely reveals non-cytotoxicity. - Abstract: We demonstrate a new class of nanocoating materials for biocompatible electrode based on poly (pyrrole-co-formyl pyrrole) (P(Py-co-Fpy)) multilayered with polystyrene sulfonate (PSS) using layer by layer (LBL) self-assembly technique. By modulating the number layer of deposition, the unique surface properties of P(Py-co-Fpy) are evaluated for bioaffinity. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) demonstrates the controllable morphology of the degree fibril network structure of P(Py-co-Fpy)/PSS surface. The direct adsorption of bovine serum albumin (BSA) onto the top surface of P(Py-co-Fpy)/PSS film by AFM analysis reveals the forming of BSA multilayer at high degree of fibril structure P(Py-co-Fpy). In addition, the adsorbed fibrinogen (Fgn) reveals the reversible conformation change on surface of P(Py-co-Fpy)/PSS. The effect of P(Py-co-Fpy)/PSS morphology on primary mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEF) is investigated. Cell morphology and proliferation on P(Py-co-Fpy)/PSS LBL film at different number of layer deposition are evaluated, demonstrating that P(Py-co-Fpy)/PSS LBL nanocoating surface is non-cytotoxic as morphology-dependent.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2020

High-efficiency, air-stable manganese–iron oxide nanoparticle-pigmented solar selective absorber coatings toward concentrating solar power systems operating at 750 °C

Solar selective absorber coating with long-term thermal stability at high temperatures ≥750 °C in air is an important component to reduce the levelized cost of energy (LCOE) of concentrating solar power (CSP) systems toward 50% power efficiency and dispatchable solar electricity. Conventionally, solar spectral selectivity requires multilayer-interference coatings implemented by stringently controlled vacuum deposition, and these coatings degrade significantly at >700 °C in air. Herein, we established a quantitative design approach and demonstrated a proof-of-concept air-stable, manganese–iron oxide nanoparticle (NP)-pigmented solar selective coatings with a high solar absorptance of ~93%, a relatively low thermal emittance of ~52%, and an optical-to-thermal energy conversion efficiency >89% under 1,000× solar concentration at 750 °C toward Generation 3 CSP systems. These coatings demonstrate spectral selectivity using cost-effective spray coating approach, a notable improvement over conventional vacuum-deposited, multilayer solar selective coatings for low-cost, high-efficiency solar thermal receivers. In contrast to the thermal degradation of spectrally non-selective benchmark Pyromark 2500 coatings at 750 °C in air, the solar absorptance of the MnFe 2 O 4 -pigmented coatings on stainless steel 310 (SS 310) substrates is increased to ~92.9% and the optical-to-thermal energy conversion efficiency is improved to 89.7% after serving at 750 °C in air for 700 h. X-ray diffraction results reveal that this improvement is due to the transformation of MnFe 2 O 4 NPs into more thermodynamically stable, non-stoichiometric manganese-rich manganese ferrite and iron-rich manganese–iron oxide phases after 500 h aging at 750 °C. For >1,000 h-endurance testing at 750 °C in air and the subsequent 19 day-night thermal cycling between 750 °C (12 h/cycle) and 25 °C (12 h/cycle) on SS 310 substrates, the thermal degradation is mainly due to the CrO x microflake formation from SS 310 substrates rather than the coatings, which can be suppressed by preoxidizing the surface of SS 310. With lower emittance matrix material and further optimization of pigment NP stoichiometry, concentration, and coating thickness, it is promising to achieve an optimized thermal efficiency ≥92.5% with long-term thermal stability at 750 °C for Generation 3 CSP systems.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2020

The effects of nanoscale confinement on the behavior of metal laminates

By reducing the layer thickness, h, in metal multilayers from micrometer- to nanometer-levels, scale-dependent transitions in behavior are observed. The role of interface properties in these transitions has been extensively investigated. However, reducing h to the nanoscale regime also imposes a physical geometric confinement on defect-related processes occurring within the layers, an effect that is relatively less explored. Herein, we present illustrative examples of the influence of nanoconfinement on the strength, structure, and radiation response of multilayers. These examples show that nanoconfinement and interface structure and topology act cooperatively in the nanoscale limit, affecting behaviors that cannot be explained based on either factor alone.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Metal DiSulfide thin films synthesized by pulsed ion beam ablation: Self-assembled structures with improved mechanical properties in humid conditions

Thin films composed of transition metal dichalcogenides such as molybdenum disulfide (MoS 2 ) or tungsten disulfide (WS 2 ) are well known for their solid lubricating behavior in dry environments such as space, but deteriorate rapidly in environments where oxygen is present. There have been many attempts over recent decades to improve MoS 2 lubricating performance in humid environments by addition of metals such as titanium to the film. The additions have come in the form of co-sputtering with the MoS 2 , or formation of nano multilayer coatings. We have previously reported on the synthesis of MoS 2 films by high-power ion beam ablation [Prasad et al, Matls. Lett. 65 (2010) 4–6]. The resulting films are observed to contain spheres of pure Mo of 10–100 nm size evenly dispersed throughout the ~1 μm-thick film, a form of self-assembly not before seen in films produced by sputtering or by pulsed laser deposition (PLD). The remaining Mosingle bondS matrix was observed to crystalize in situ under frictional contact into MoS 2 with the basal planes orienting themselves in the direction of sliding underneath the wear surface. The present study concerns metal additions in the form of alternating layers with MoS 2 deposited in between from an ablation target. The addition of Ti resulted in the extension of good tribological performance to humid air conditions, but the path to good performance appears to be relatively narrow. The same distributed Mo spheres were present in the new film, and similar self-assembled morphologies when V was substituted for the Ti, and when multilayers were formed of WS 2 with Zr additions. Furthermore, it appears that addition of Ti resulted in improvements in mechanical film strength that contributed to the wear ability in humid conditions.

Intense ion beams↗