Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Process Efficiency”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,351 records · Page 75

Applications of MP-1 anion exchange resin and Eichrom LN resin in berkelium-249 purification

Purification of berkelium-249 ( 249 Bk) at Oak Ridge National Laboratory requires a multi-step process with Bk Finishing as the final step. The current multi-process takes 6–7 months, including ~ 3 months spent on Bk Finishing. Recent trials of using columns of either LN resin or MP-1 anion exchange resin adsorbing the tetravalent 249 Bk4+ in 8M HNO 3 -0.5M NaBrO 3 , followed by eluting impurities (e.g. Ce 4+ , Cf 3+ ) and stripping 249 Bk resulted in a new dual column method of selectively separating 249 Bk from other trans-curium elements and fission product impurities, which is proposed to replace the current Bk Finishing with higher Bk purification efficiency and shorter processing period. This paper displays the experimental results and describes the dual column method with relevant chemistry issues.

Du, Miting (ORCID:0000000336741567)↗

Energy Saving Melting and Revert Reduction Technology (E-SMARRT): Mechanical Performance of Dies

As a net shape process, die casting is intrinsically efficient and improvements in energy efficiency are strongly dependent on design and process improvements that reduce scrap rates so that more of the total consumed energy goes into acceptable, usable castings. A casting that is distorted and fails to meet specified dimensional requirements is typically remelted but this still results in a decrease in process yield, lost productivity, and increased energy consumption. This work focuses on developing, and expanding the use of, computer modeling methods that can be used to improve the dimensional accuracy of die castings and produce die designs and machine/die setups that reduce rejection rates due to dimensional issues. A major factor contributing to the dimensional inaccuracy of the casting is the elastic deformations of the die cavity caused by the thermo mechanical loads the dies are subjected to during normal operation. Although thermal and die cavity filling simulation are widely used in the industry, structural modeling of the die, particularly for managing part distortion, is not yet widely practiced. This may be due in part to the need to have a thorough understanding of the physical phenomenon involved in die distortion and the mathematical theory employed in the numerical models to efficiently model the die distortion phenomenon. Therefore, two of the goals of this work are to assist in efforts to expand the use of structural modeling and related technologies in the die casting industry by 1) providing a detailed modeling guideline and tutorial for those interested in developing the necessary skills and capability and 2) by developing simple meta-models that capture the results and experience gained from several years of die distortion research and can be used to predict key distortion phenomena of relevance to a die caster with a minimum of background and without the need for simulations. These objectives were met. A detailed modeling tutorial was provided to NADCA for distribution to the industry. Power law based meta-models for predicting machine tie bar loading and for predicting maximum parting surface separation were successfully developed and tested against simulation results for a wide range of machines and experimental data. The models proved to be remarkably accurate, certainly well within the requirements for practical application. In addition to making die structural modeling more accessible, the work advanced the state-of-the-art by developing improved modeling of cavity pressure effects, which is typically modeled as a hydrostatic boundary condition, and performing a systematic analysis of the influence of ejector die design variables on die deflection and parting plane separation. This cavity pressure modeling objective met with less than complete success due to the limits of current finite element based fluid structure interaction analysis methods, but an improved representation of the casting/die interface was accomplished using a combination of solid and shell elements in the finite element model. This approximation enabled good prediction of final part distortion verified with a comprehensive evaluation of the dimensions of test castings produced with a design experiment. An extra deliverable of the experimental work was development of high temperature mechanical properties for the A380 die casting alloy. The ejector side design objective was met and the results were incorporated into the metamodels described above. This new technology was predicted to result in an average energy savings of 2.03 trillion BTU's/year over a 10 year period. Current (2011) annual energy saving estimates over a ten year period, based on commercial introduction in 2009, a market penetration of 70% by 2014 is 4.26 trillion BTU's/year by 2019. Along with these energy savings, reduction of scrap and improvement in casting yield will result in a reduction of the environmental emissions associated with the melting and pouring of the metal which will be saved as a result of this technology. The average annual estimate of CO2 reduction per year through 2020 is 0.085 Million Metric Tons of Carbon Equivalent (MM TCE).

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Combined Impact of Heterogeneous Lifetime and Gettering on Solar Cell Performance

We couple numerical process and device simulations to provide a framework for understanding the combined effects of as-grown wafer impurity distribution, processing parameters, and solar cell architecture. For this study, we added the Impurity-to-Efficiency simulator to Synopsys’ Sentaurus Process software using the Alagator Scripting Language. Our results quantify how advanced processing can eliminate differences in efficiency due to different as-grown impurity concentrations and due to different area fractions of defective wafer regions. We identify combinations of as-grown impurity distributions and process parameters that produce solar cells limited by point defects and those that are limited by precipitated impurities. Gettering targeted at either point defect or precipitate reduction can then be designed and applied to increase cell efficiency. We also visualize the post-processing iron and total recombination distributions in 2D maps of the wafer cross-section. PV researchers and companies can input their initial iron distributions and processing parameters into our software and couple the resulting process simulation results with a solar cell device design of interest to conduct their own analyses. The Alagator scripts we developed are freely available online at http://pv.mit.edu/impurity-to-efficiency-i2e-simulator-for-sentaurus-tcad/.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

Scalable slot-die coating of high performance perovskite solar cells

Perovskite based photovoltaic devices hold the promise to greatly reduce the cost of solar energy production; however, this potential depends greatly on the ability to deposit perovskite active layers using large scale deposition methods such as slot-die coating without sacrificing efficiency. Using a perovskite precursor ink with long wet-film processing window, we demonstrate efficient perovskite solar cells based on slot-die coated perovskite layer. We found almost no difference in the photophysical and structural details of perovskite films that were deposited by spin coating to films deposited by slot-die coating. Furthermore, we explored various slot-die coating parameters to determine their effect on the performance of the device metrics. In addition to slot-die coating, we demonstrate the versatility of this wide wet-film processing window by fabricating perovskite solar cells with active layers deposited by spin coating, blade coating, and spray coating that all exhibited similar performance.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

ORNL Design Engineering Library: Validated Thermoelectric Digital Twins

Radioisotope thermoelectric generators (RTGs) serve a crucial role in supplying thermal and electrical energy for reliable and long-duration power in remote and extreme environments. The thermal energy is provided by the decay of radioisotopes and is converted into electrical energy using the steady-state thermoelectric process by exploiting the Seebeck effect. Maintaining a thermal gradient through the material is necessary to drive current production. Modern predictive multi-physics tools are able to effectively describe the complex and strongly coupled phenomena needed for accurate model-based system engineering efforts needed to develop higher performing RTGs. Experimental validation of model simulations is essential to confirm the accuracy, reliability, and applicability of predictive multiphysics tools. Validation fosters confidence among users, helps meet regulatory requirements, and contributes to the ongoing improvement of simulation techniques, ultimately leading to better, safer, and more efficient designs and processes. Validated models can then be used as digital twins and can be interrogated to understand and quantify the performance gaps between theoretical and physical systems. These insights can be used to build higher performing systems.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

A Principle for Highly Active Metal Oxide Catalysts via NaCl-Based Solid Solution

Toward the preparation of industrial metal oxide catalysts, sacrificial organic templates, excessive solvents, complex impregnation, and drying steps are generally required. Here, we report a versatile rule for the simple synthesis of highly porous metal oxides with well-dispersed noble metal species. Porous metal oxides (Co 3 O 4 , Fe x O y , and Cr 2 O 3 ) are obtained with some surface areas (e.g., Cr 2 O3: 224 m 2 ·g -1 ) beyond the record value. Surprisingly, small noble metal nanoparticles (e.g., Pd: 3.1 and Pt: 3.2 nm) could be incorporated by this solid-state process simultaneously. Corresponding Rh-Co 3 O 4 , Pd-Fe x O y , and Pt-Cr 2 O 3 exhibit excellent performance: CH 4 combustion (T90 = ~360°C and thermal stability: >100 h at 680°C), hydrogenation of nitrobenzene and derivatives (turnover number [TON] = 2.49 × 104, 300 mmol per run), and reversed water gas shift (RWGS) reaction (44% CO 2 conversion with ~98% CO selectivity and thermal stability: >100 h at 500°C), respectively. Therefore, current principle via a NaCl-based solid solution could provide a solid-state, fast, and efficient route for processing metal oxide catalysts.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Parallel beamlet dose calculation via beamlet contexts in a distributed multi‐GPU framework

Purpose Dose calculation is one of the most computationally intensive, yet essential tasks in the treatment planning process. With the recent interest in automatic beam orientation and arc trajectory optimization techniques, there is a great need for more efficient model‐based dose calculation algorithms that can accommodate hundreds to thousands of beam candidates at once. Foundational work has shown the translation of dose calculation algorithms to graphical processing units ( GPU s), lending to remarkable gains in processing efficiency. But these methods provide parallelization of dose for only a single beamlet, serializing the calculation of multiple beamlets and under‐utilizing the potential of modern GPU s. In this paper, the authors propose a framework enabling parallel computation of many beamlet doses using a novel beamlet context transformation and further embed this approach in a scalable network of multi‐ GPU computational nodes. Methods The proposed context‐based transformation separates beamlet‐local density and TERMA into distinct beamlet contexts that independently provide sufficient data for beamlet dose calculation. Beamlet contexts are arranged in a composite context array with dosimetric isolation, and the context array is subjected to a GPU collapsed‐cone convolution superposition procedure, producing the set of beamlet‐specific dose distributions in a single pass. Dose from each context is converted to a sparse representation for efficient storage and retrieval during treatment plan optimization. The context radius is a new parameter permitting flexibility between the speed and fidelity of the dose calculation process. A distributed manager‐worker architecture is constructed around the context‐based GPU dose calculation approach supporting an arbitrary number of worker nodes and resident GPU s. Phantom experiments were executed to verify the accuracy of the context‐based approach compared to Monte Carlo and a reference CPU ‐ CCCS implementation for single beamlets and broad beams composed by addition of beamlets. Dose for representative 4 π beam sets was calculated in lung and prostate cases to compare its efficiency with that of an existing beamlet‐sequential GPU ‐ CCCS implementation. Code profiling was also performed to evaluate the scalability of the framework across many networked GPU s. Results The dosimetric accuracy of the context‐based method displays <1.35% and 2.35% average error from the existing serialized CPU ‐ CCCS algorithm and Monte Carlo simulation for beamlet‐specific PDD s in water and slab phantoms, respectively. The context‐based method demonstrates substantial speedup of up to two orders of magnitude over the beamlet‐sequential GPU ‐ CCCS method in the tested configurations. The context‐based framework demonstrates near linear scaling in the number of distributed compute nodes and GPU s employed, indicating that it is flexible enough to meet the performance requirements of most users by simply increasing the hardware utilization. Conclusions The context‐based approach demonstrates a new expectation of performance for beamlet‐based dose calculation methods. This approach has been successful in accelerating the dose calculation process for very large‐scale treatment planning problems ‐ such as automatic 4 π IMRT beam orientation and VMAT arc trajectory selection, with hundreds of thousands of beamlets ‐ in clinically feasible timeframes. The flexibility of this framework makes it as a strong candidate for use in a variety of other very large‐scale treatment planning tasks and clinical workflows.

Neph, Ryan↗

A dynamic control approach for energy-efficient production scheduling on a single machine under time-varying electricity pricing

This paper proposes a dynamic control algorithm to enable an energy-aware single machine scheduling under the time-varying electricity pricing policy, in which price rates remain fixed day-to-day over the season. The key issue is to assign a set of jobs to available time periods where different electricity prices are assigned, while considering requested due dates of jobs so as to minimize total penalty costs for earliness and tardiness of jobs and total energy consumption costs, simultaneously. As the first contribution of this study, we develop a new mixed integer nonlinear programming (MINLP) model that aims at determining job arrival times and resulting earliness and tardiness of jobs and energy consumption costs for machine idle and normal processing. Second, an efficient heuristic approach based on continuous-time variable control models and algorithm is developed. The proposed heuristic adaptively changes job arrival times and due dates, which finally determine production sequence over the time periods of different electricity prices, machine turn-off, and machine idle with minimum energy consumption costs and just-in-time (JIT) penalty. Energy and JIT performance of the proposed approach is examined using real energy and machining parameters of a HAAS machine and compared to those of the metaheuristic approach. For relatively large size data groups, the proposed approach incurs about higher energy consumption costs on average, which are offset by up to lower JIT costs, resulting in lower total costs on average compared to the metaheuristic approach. Further, the proposed time-scaled heuristic algorithm yields extremely short computational time, which enables production managers to flexibly select proper production strategies and to implement them for different production environments.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Facilitating hydrogen atom migration via a dense phase on palladium islands to a surrounding silver surface

Significance The energy efficiency of catalytic processes hinges on achieving high selectivity and activity; bimetallic catalysts have potential to increase both by exploiting different chemical properties of the components. Transport of intermediates between the two metals, for example, transport of hydrogen atoms for selective hydrogenation, is required to capitalize on this bifunctionality. A mechanism for the migration of hydrogen atoms to silver from palladium is demonstrated here. Dihydrogen first dissociates on palladium, then forms a dense hydrogen phase on the palladium island. The dense phase includes weakly bound hydrogen atoms that are nearly isoenergetic with hydrogen on silver, rendering migration nearly energy neutral. The efficiency for hydrogen migration across the palladium−silver is maximized for small ensembles of palladium atoms.

O’Connor, Christopher R.↗

Carbon contamination topography analysis of EUV masks

The impact of carbon contamination on extreme ultraviolet (EUV) masks is significant due to throughput loss and potential effects on imaging performance. Current carbon contamination research primarily focuses on the lifetime of the multilayer surfaces, determined by reflectivity loss and reduced throughput in EUV exposure tools. However, contamination on patterned EUV masks can cause additional effects on absorbing features and the printed images, as well as impacting the efficiency of cleaning process. In this work, several different techniques were used to determine possible contamination topography. Lithographic simulations were also performed and the results compared with the experimental data.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Lead halide perovskites for photocatalytic organic synthesis

Abstract Nature is capable of storing solar energy in chemical bonds via photosynthesis through a series of C–C, C–O and C–N bond-forming reactions starting from CO 2 and light. Direct capture of solar energy for organic synthesis is a promising approach. Lead (Pb)-halide perovskite solar cells reach 24.2% power conversion efficiency, rendering perovskite a unique type material for solar energy capture. We argue that photophysical properties of perovskites already proved for photovoltaics, also should be of interest in photoredox organic synthesis. Because the key aspects of these two applications are both relying on charge separation and transfer. Here we demonstrated that perovskites nanocrystals are exceptional candidates as photocatalysts for fundamental organic reactions, for example C–C, C–N and C–O bond-formations. Stability of CsPbBr 3 in organic solvents and ease-of-tuning their bandedges garner perovskite a wider scope of organic substrate activations. Our low-cost, easy-to-process, highly-efficient, air-tolerant and bandedge-tunable perovskites may bring new breakthrough in organic chemistry.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Structural damage response of lanthanum and yttrium aluminate crystals to nuclear collisions and electronic excitation: Threshold assessment of irradiation damage

A comparative analysis is performed on the structural damage response and associated mechanisms in lanthanum aluminate and yttrium aluminate crystals under various irradiation conditions by a combination of experimental and theoretical approaches. Under low-energy Au+ irradiation, the damage accumulation curve shows a higher damage rate for LaAlO 3 crystals than YAlO 3 crystals. The relatively low irradiation tolerance of LaAlO 3 to the action of nuclear collisions is ascribed to the large amorphization cross-section and effective cross-section for defect-stimulated amorphization. Under swift Ar 12+ , Ni 19+ and Kr 17+ irradiation with different ion energies and velocities, the formed highly-disordered/amorphous latent tracks with different morphologies in pristine and predamaged crystals are discussed, and the corresponding electronic energy loss and lattice temperature thresholds are quantitatively determined. Compared to YAlO 3 , LaAlO 3 exhibits lower sensitivity and higher damage tolerance to the electronic energy loss process, attributing to its relatively high recrystallization efficiency during the rapid quenching process. Furthermore, the introduction of lattice defects into LaAlO 3 and YAlO 3 crystals considerably enhances the sensitivity and intensity of thermal spike response to the electronic energy loss, and the induced effective modification of track morphologies demonstrates the synergistic effect between the electronic energy loss and pre-existing defects created by nuclear collisions. In this case, even under the action of electronic energy loss below the threshold, the lattice temperature in the nuclear-collision damaged crystalline system could still meet the criterion for track production. The irradiation energy deposited to atoms and induced lattice temperature evolution discussed in this work provide a deeper insight into the complex processes involved in irradiation-induced latent track behaviors.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Innovative manufacturing technologies for low-cost, high efficiency PERC-based PV modules

The goal this project was to accelerate the deployment of innovative solar cell and module technologies that reduce the cost of PERC-based modules to best-in-class. New module integration technology was to be used to reduce the cost and reliance on conventional silver bus bar pastes and enhance cell efficiency. On the cell manufacturing front, the cost of PERC solar cells was to be reduced by introducing advanced metallization approaches to increase cell efficiency. These advancements will be combined with process optimization to target cell efficiencies in the range of 21 to 21.5%. This project will also explore the viability of a bifacial PERC solar cell design to enable cost savings through the use of thin silicon wafers. This project was terminated on 4/30/17 after four months of activity due financial challenges facing the recipient.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

ROSE::FTTransform - A Source-to-Source Translation Framework for Exascale Fault-Tolerance Research

Exascale computing systems will require sufficient resilience to tolerate numerous types of hardware faults while still assuring correct program execution. Such extreme-scale machines are expected to be dominated by processors driven at lower voltages (near the minimum 0.5 volts for current transistors). At these voltage levels, the rate of transient errors increases dramatically due to the sensitivity to transient and geographically localized voltage drops on parts of the processor chip. To achieve power efficiency, these processors are likely to be streamlined and minimal, and thus they cannot be expected to handle transient errors entirely in hardware. Here we present an open, compiler-based framework to automate the armoring of High Performance Computing (HPC) software to protect it from these types of transient processor errors. We develop an open infrastructure to support research work in this area, and we define tools that, in the future, may provide more complete automated and/or semi-automated solutions to support software resiliency on future exascale architectures. Results demonstrate that our approach is feasible, pragmatic in how it can be separated from the software development process, and reasonably efficient (0% to 30% overhead for the Jacobi iteration on common hardware; and 20%, 40%, 26%, and 2% overhead for a randomly selected subset of benchmarks from the Livermore Loops [1]).

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Effects of Particle Size Distribution with Efficient Packing on Powder Flowability and Selective Laser Melting Process

The powder bed-based additive manufacturing (AM) process contains uncertainties in the powder spreading process and powder bed quality, leading to problems in repeatability and quality of the additively manufactured parts. This work focuses on identifying the uncertainty induced by particle size distribution (PSD) on powder flowability and the laser melting process, using Ti6Al4V as a model material. The flowability test results show that the effect of PSDs on flowability is not linear, rather the PSDs near dense packing ratios cause significant reductions in flowability (indicated by the increase in the avalanche angle and break energy of the powders measured by a revolution powder analyzer). The effects of PSDs on the selective laser melting (SLM) process are identified by using in-situ high-speed X-ray imaging to observe the melt pool dynamics during the melting process. The results show that the powder beds made of powders with dense packing ratios exhibit larger build height during laser melting. The effects of PSD with efficient packing on powder flowability and selective laser melting process revealed in this work are important for understanding process uncertainties induced by feedstock powders and for designing mitigation approaches.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Oscilloscope Data Push Program

This paper details the development of a Python program designed to automate the data acquisition and conversion for an oscilloscope for the purposes of a one-off/temporary data acquisition system for users that readily need data, and do not have the option of obtaining a Data Acquisition (DAQ) solution. Creating DAQ systems for analyzing a system requires expensive electronics and a dedicated team of engineers for support. Traditionally, manual data collection and processing are time consuming and prone to error. By automating these processes, the cost, efficiency and accuracy of data handling are improved upon. This project involves the creation of a program that interacts with the oscilloscope. During this interaction, there are various functions being performed such as the acquisition of waveform data via floating points, generating plots with the acquired wave points, and storing of floating points in a CSV file format for future reference and plotting purposes. While the initial aim of the project included continuous logging to a cloud database, this was deferred due to time constraints. The results portrayed an almost-instant rate of data collection with a buffer time, showcasing the potential for further integration and real-time data processing.

Osei-Tutu, Jason↗

Office of the Chief Financial Officer Annual Report 2010

In March, a review team consisting of CFOs from other national laboratories, industry, and members of the University of California Office of the President (UCOP) convened for three days to conduct a comprehensive peer review of the OCFO. This was the first time in almost a decade that the financial operations of the Laboratory had been reviewed. The Committee relayed their observations on our strengths, and their very thoughtful recommendations for improvement, which we are actively pursuing. These improvements, when implemented, will benefit the entire Laboratory for many years to come. The complete report is available on the OCFO website (www.lbl.gov/Workplace/CFO). In August, the senior management team of the OCFO participated in a strategic planning retreat. The purpose of the two and a half day exercise was, of course, to update our strategic plan, but instead of spending days developing a written document, we enlisted the expertise of a seasoned journalist who also happens to be a very talented graphic artist. He listened carefully to our ideas and committed them to a visual roadmap. All members of the OCFO, Business Managers, and the Laboratory Leadership Team reviewed this draft roadmap. By having a completely visual strategic plan that is posted widely throughout the OCFO, all employees can easily see and identify with the goals that we are all working towards. FY2010 was an extraordinary year. The Laboratory welcomed its seventh Director, Dr. Paul Alivisatos, who wasted no time communicating his vision and priorities for Berkeley Lab. They include five very ambitious initiatives: Carbon Cycle 2.0, The Next Generation Light Source, a Safe and Efficient Lab, Building Community, and Space. In response, the Office of the Chief Financial Officer (OCFO) developed twelve specific initiatives that align completely with these five priorities. We will be very focused on these in the coming fiscal year, but for now, let's review what happened in FY2010. FY2010 was a pivotal year for the Procurement and Property Department. A provision of the management contract that was signed fives years ago required us to achieve cost savings of $30M. I am proud to announce that this last fiscal year we reached that goal, in large part due to the implementation of eBuy, and the negotiation of strategic sourcing contracts. Our last wall-to-wall inventory exceeded all the Department of Energy's (DOE) national targets and DOE approved the LBNL property system unconditionally. Of the total inventory, 92.3% or 25,601 assets were accounted for using barcode scanning that made the inventory process much more efficient. The effective management of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) funds was strengthened by the continued successful partnership that LBNL shares with our DOE Site Office. They provided authority, support and clarity to this very complex task. The Laboratory's ARRA Stimulus Committee played a critical role in assuring internal controls, compliance with DOE regulations and quality financial management. The LBNL Budget Officer led a DOE complex-wide effort to identify and share how various DOE facilities track and report ARRA-funded projects, share best practices, evaluate issues and discuss solutions. LBNL has been recognized as a leader in this process and will continue to share knowledge and best practices with other DOE laboratories. Continuous education of our staff as well as the greater Laboratory population was still a major focus of the OCFO. With the help of many OCFO senior managers and staff that acted as subject-matter experts, the Core Financial Management Program was completely re-engineered and resulted in a revised classroom and web-based curriculum that will be formally rolled out Lab-wide in early FY2011. The Office of Sponsored Projects and Industry Partnerships (OSPIP) led the effort to select and purchase four Click Commerce software modules for the LBNL electronic Scientific Research Administration (eSRA) project. In early FY2010, the implementation of the Institutional Review Board (IRB) module, responsible for the human subjects review process, began and should be completed in early FY2011. OSPIP also began implementation of the grants and contracts module and we expect an early go-live of 'Grants Express' in mid-FY2011 with a full completion date in FY2012. The peer review's most substantial recommendation for improvement involved the Laboratory's central financial systems. To quote: 'financial reporting system is outdated and inadequate. There is an inability to easily extract data; the field has little confidence in data; people spend more time mining data than analyzing data; requires field users to create & rely upon shadow systems; causes proliferation of program administrators and resource analysts. These issues impact the quality & execution of research; and the data warehouse lacks understanding & ownership.'

99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS↗