Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Fuel cladding”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,423 records · Page 79

Post-Irradiation Fracture Toughness Characterization of Generation II FeCrAl Alloys

FeCrAl alloys are promising candidate materials for the accident tolerant fuel (ATF) cladding application due to their exceptional resistance to oxidation in elevated temperature steam environments. Currently, limited fracture toughness data are available for the FeCrAl alloys, including the FeCrAl alloys newly developed at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) under the U.S. Department of Energy’s Advanced Fuels Campaign (AFC) program. In this study, two Generation II candidate FeCrAl alloys, i.e., C06M (81.8Fe-10Cr-6Al-0.03Y-2Mo-0.2Si) and C36M (78.8Fe-13Cr-6Al-0.03Y-2Mo-0.2Si), were irradiated in the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) at ORNL to assess the fracture characteristics of these alloys after neutron irradiation. A total of six rabbit capsules were irradiated in HFIR at target temperatures of 200°C, 330°C, and 500°C up to target damage doses of 8 displacements per atom (dpa) and 16 dpa. Post-irradiation fracture toughness testing was performed following the Master Curve method in the ASTM E1921 standard. The main findings of this study are:1) Both the C06M and C36M alloys exhibited a similar response to irradiation concerning irradiation hardening and embrittlement.2) The irradiation temperature played different roles in terms of irradiation hardening and embrittlement for both C06M and C36M: after irradiation between 166°C and 204°C, both materials exhibited significant irradiation hardening and embrittlement; after irradiation between 315°C and 343°C, both materials showed small irradiation hardening without irradiation embrittlement. After irradiation between 501°C and 507°C, however, the irradiation softening without irradiation embrittlement was observed in both materials.3) Comparing the microhardness and Master Curve reference temperature T0q before and after neutron irradiation, we did not observe a linear correlation between the two parameters for both C06M and C36M steels. This should be mainly due to a flat response of the Master Curve reference temperature T0q to the irradiations at 166–204°C and 315–343°C ranges4) C06M showed a lower T0q, meaning better toughness, than C36M at the unirradiated condition, and such trend was kept even after neutron irradiation except for the 166–204°C irradiation after which both materials had similar T0q.5) In terms of hardening and embrittlement, the irradiation effect on both C06M and C36M appeared to saturate after an irradiation dose of 7 dpa.

Chen, Xiang↗

Nanoscale Mechanical Behavior of Nuclear Materials

One of the primary performance objectives targeted for improved performance of nuclear fuels is fracture toughness. New materials or composite fuel architectures that offer greater resistance to cracking under the extreme environments encountered during nuclear reactor service would provide significant improvements to steady state (e.g. heat transfer, fuel redistribution) and transient (e.g. radionuclide release at elevated temperatures) conditions. Options currently under investigation include 'nontraditional' nuclear fuels designated around high uranium density. These include uranium silicides, uranium borides, and composite fuel materials constructed of these and uranium nitride or uranium dioxide. The increase uranium density compared with uranium dioxide (UO{sub 2}) has made them interesting to a new generation of nuclear fuels research driven by the renewed push for accident-tolerant light water reactor (LWR) fuels. Measurement of the thermophysical and thermodynamic properties of these constituent materials has progressed in recent years, but evaluation of mechanical properties at relevant temperatures is necessary to support further evaluations. While thermophysical properties such as thermal conductivity, heat capacity, and thermal expansion are generally the primary properties of interest, mechanical properties will play an important role in governing the deformation and fracture of the fuel during both normal operation and potential transients. It is therefore necessary to develop techniques capable of measuring these properties to predict the response of a candidate fuel form to anticipated thermal gradients. Nanoindentation techniques provide a demonstrated alternative to traditional mechanical test methods. Much work has also been carried out over the past few years to obtain stress-strain curves using a spherical nanoindentation approach. The techniques are expected to be useful for measurement of the mechanical properties of local structure of various materials. Nanomechanical test techniques have particular value in the area of nuclear materials, where numerous factors motivate limiting the sample volume to the extent possible. However, few attempts at application of nanoindentation to evaluate the mechanical properties of the nuclear fuels and cladding materials are reported in the literature. The effect of a limited set of variables (e.g. porosity, temperature dependence) on the mechanical properties of UO{sub 2} has been explored using early nanomechanical testing techniques. However, nanomechanical evaluation has not been extended to other nuclear fuels. In this work, we demonstrate the effectiveness of using instrumented spherical nanoindentation test techniques to capture the mechanical response of regions within individual grains in ion-irradiated W and Zr over a range of ion-irradiation conditions. As well as the nanomechanical response of U-Si and UO{sub 2} fuel materials Nanoindentation results obtained at room temperature will be used to express nano- and bulk- mechanical properties as a function of material stoichiometry. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

SPENT FUEL MANAGEMENT AT THE SAVANNAH RIVER SITE

Spent nuclear fuels are received from reactor sites around the world and are being stored in the L-Basin at the Savannah River Site (SRS) in Aiken, South Carolina. The predominant fuel types are research reactor fuel with aluminum-alloy cladding and aluminum-based fuel. Other fuel materials include stainless steel and Zircaloy cladding with uranium oxide fuel. Chemistry control and corrosion surveillance programs have been established and upgraded since the early 1990's to minimize corrosion degradation of the aluminum cladding materials, so as to maintain fuel integrity and minimize personnel exposure from radioactivity in the basin water. Recent activities have been initiated to support additional decades of wet storage which include fuel inspection and corrosion testing to evaluate the effects of specific water impurity species on corrosion attack.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Thermal evaluation of uranium silicide miniplates irradiated at high heat flux

The Gas Test Loop (GTL)-1 irradiation experiment was conducted in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) to assess corrosion performance of proposed booster fuel at heat flux levels ~30% above the design operating condition. Sixteen miniplates fabricated from 25% enriched, high-density (4.8 g U/cm3) U3Si2/Al dispersion fuel with 6061 aluminum cladding were subjected to peak beginning of cycle (BOC) heat fluxes ranging from 411 to 593 W/cm2. No adverse impacts to the miniplates were observed at these high heat flux levels. A detailed finite element model was constructed to calculate temperatures and heat flux for an as-run cycle average effective ATR south lobe power of 25.4 MW(t). Miniplate heat flux levels and fuel, cladding, hydroxide, and coolant–hydroxide interface temperatures were calculated using the average hydroxide thickness on each miniplate measured during post-irradiation examination. The purpose of this study was to obtain a best estimate of the as-run experiment temperatures to aid in establishing acceptable heat flux levels and designing fuel qualification experiments for this fuel type.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Characterization of oxide films on aluminum materials following reactor exposure and wet storage in the SRS L-Basin

This report describes the characterization of oxide films on one cropped piece of 6061, one 6063, and one cropped piece that could have been either 6061 or 6063 aluminum-based alloy, stored wet for up to approximately 40 years in L-Basin on the Savannah River Site (SRS). One 6061 cropping was from a Missouri University Research Reactor (MURR) fuel element. The 6063 piece was from a cropping from a Universal Sleeve Housing (USH). The Mark-16B fuel assembly could have been either 6061 or 6063 based on design drawings. Both the Mark-16B and USH were used in SRS Production Reactors. Characterization of the as-received oxides includes the oxide morphology, thickness, structure, and chemical composition. The aim is to characterize the oxide layer on aluminum cladding and fuel components that have reactor service and long-term basin storage service.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Methodology of Experiment Design for Improving Transient Critical Heat Flux Model Development

One phenomenon that contributes to nuclear fuel and clad failure mechanisms is the departure from nucleate boiling (DNB). Accident scenarios such as reactivity-initiated accidents (RIAs) provide conditions where the frequency of boiling crisis is much more likely to occur and on much shorter time scales than loss of coolant (LOCA) or loss of flow (LOFA) accidents. Here, boiling crisis in the form of DNB is attributed to transient-induced heat flux values that exceed the critical heat flux (CHF). The resulting effects, such as bubble crowding and eventual dryout, can affect flow boiling heat transfer and compromise the structural integrity of nuclear reactor materials. The focus of the work proposed here lies in developing a rigorous process using out-of-pile testing, under simulated RIA conditions, to determine the transient critical heat flux of cladding materials, without contributions from aforementioned radiation-induced effects that have been observed during in-pile experiments. This study provides a road-map for developing and performing experiments that simulate the power profile and energy deposition aspects of transient events, specific to RIAs, on the laboratory scale. The goal of our project is to observe and measure DNB in an annular flow channel around a single heater rod that is operating and nominal thermal hydraulic conditions of a PWR. It is also an aim of these experiments to determine how to quantify the gap between SS and transient CHF cases, based on state-dependent properties of the cladding material type that is being interrogated. Traditionally, CHF is determined as a combination of four factors: hydraulic diameter, system pressure, mass flow, fluid quality. The authors propose that an additional measureable quantity, which is dependent on the structural properties of the cladding material itself, is partly reasonable for the difference between measured and model-developed CHF values. Using a carefully metered approach will allow for several key concepts to be realized: compensation for transient-based effects to current models for CHF; adaptation of current models for different cladding material types, including Gen-IV concept materials; and implementation of a correction factor to account for both power transient-based and radiation-induced effects on the CHF that have not yet been accounted for.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Annealing induced interfacial layers in niobium-clad stainless steel developed as a bipolar plate material for polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell stacks

Niobium (Nb)-clad 304L stainless steel (SS) manufactured by cold rolling is currently under consideration for use as a bipolar plate material in polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) stacks. To make the fabrication of bipolar plates using the Nb-clad SS feasible, annealing may be necessary for the Nb-clad SS to reduce the springback induced by cold rolling. However, the annealing can develop an interfacial layer between the Nb cladding and the SS core and the interfacial layer plays a key role in the failure of the Nb-clad SS as reported earlier [JPS our work]. In this investigation, the Nb-clad SS specimens in as-rolled condition were annealed at different combinations of temperature and time. Based on the results of scanning electron microscope (SEM) analysis, an annealing process map for the Nb-clad SS was obtained. The results of SEM analysis and Transmission Electron Microscope (TEM) analysis also suggest that different interfacial layers occurred based on the given annealing conditions.

annealing↗

Steam Oxidation Testing in the Severe Accident Test Station

After the March 2011 accident at Fukushima Daiichi, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) began conducting high temperature steam oxidation testing of candidate materials for accident tolerant fuel (ATF) cladding in August 2011 [1-11]. The ATF concept is to enhance safety margins in light water reactors (LWR) during severe accident scenarios by identifying materials with 100× slower steam oxidation rates compared to current Zr-based alloys. In 2012, the ORNL laboratory equipment was expanded and made available to the entire ATF community as the Severe Accident Test Station (SATS) [4,12]. Compared to the current UO2/Zr-based alloy fuel system, an ATF alternative would significantly reduce the rate of heat and hydrogen generation in the core during a coolant-limited severe accident [13-14]. The steam oxidation behavior of candidate materials is a key metric in the evaluation of ATF concepts and also an important input into models [15-17]. However, initial modeling work of FeCrAl cladding has used incomplete information on the physical properties of FeCrAl. Also, the steam oxidation data being collected at 1200°-1700°C is unique as no prior work has considered steam oxidation of alloys at such high temperatures. Also, because many accident scenarios include steadily increasing temperatures, the required data are not traditional isothermal exposures but exposures with varying “ramp” rates. In some cases, the steam oxidation behavior has been surprising and difficult to interpret. Thus, more fundamental information continues to be collected. In addition, more work continues to focus on commercially-manufactured tube material. This report summarizes recent work to characterize the behavior of candidate alloys exposed to high temperature steam, evaluate steam oxidation behavior in various ramp scenarios and continue to collect integral data on FeCrAl compared to conventional Zr-based cladding.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Carbon cladded composite flow field plate, bipolar plate and fuel cell

The present invention provides a carbon-cladded composite composition for use as a fuel cell flow field plate or bipolar plate. In one preferred embodiment, the composition comprises a core composite layer sandwiched between two clad layers, wherein (a) the clad layer comprises a conductive carbon or graphite material (e.g., carbon nano-tubes, nano-scaled graphene plates, graphitic nano-fibers, and fine graphite particles); (b) the core composite layer comprises a matrix resin and a conductive filler present in a sufficient quantity to render the composite layer electrically conductive with an electrical conductivity no less than 1 S/cm (preferably no less than 100 S/cm); and (c) the composition has a planar outer surface on each clad side having formed therein a fluid flow channel.

30 DIRECT ENERGY CONVERSION↗

TREAT Neutronics Analysis of Water-Loop Concept Accommodating LWR 9-rod Bundle

Abstract. Simulation of a variety of transient conditions has been successfully achieved in the Transient Reactor Test (TREAT) facility during operation between 1959 and 1994 to support characterization and safety analysis of nuclear fuels and materials. A majority of previously conducted tests were focused on supporting sodium-cooled fast reactor (SFR) designs. Experiments evolved in complexity. Simulation of thermal-hydraulic conditions expected to be encountered by fuels and materials in a reactor environment was realized in the development of TREAT sodium loop experiment vehicles. These loops accommodated up to 7-pin fuel bundles and served to simulate more closely the reactor environment while safely delivering large quantities of energy into the test specimen. Some of the immediate TREAT restart operations will be focused on testing light water reactor (LWR) accident tolerant fuels (ATF). Similar to the sodium loop objectives, a water loop concept, developed and analyzed in the 1990’s, aimed at achieving thermal-hydraulic conditions encountered in commercial power reactors. The historic water loop concept has been analyzed in the context of a reactivity insertion accident (RIA) simulation for high burnup LWR 2-pin and 3-pin fuel bundles. Findings showed sufficient energy could be deposited into the specimens for evaluation. Similar results of experimental feasibility for the water loop concept (past and present) have recently been obtained using MCNP6.1 with ENDF/B-VII.1 nuclear data libraries. The old water loop concept required only two central TREAT core grid spaces. Preparation for future experiments has resulted in a modified water loop conceptual design designated the TREAT water environment recirculating loop (TWERL). The current TWERL design requires nine TREAT core grid spaces in order to place the water recirculating pump under the TREAT core. Due to the effectiveness of water moderation, neutronics analysis shows that removal of seven additional TREAT fuel elements to facilitate the experiment will not inhibit the ability to successfully simulate a RIA for the 2-pin or 3-pin bundle. This new water loop design leaves room for accommodating a larger fuel pin bundle than previously analyzed. The 7-pin fuel bundle in a hexagonal array with similar spacing of fuel pins in a SFR fuel assembly was considered the minimum needed for one central fuel pin to encounter the most correct thermal conditions. The 9-rod fuel bundle in a square array similar in spacing to pins in a LWR fuel assembly would be considered the LWR equivalent. MCNP analysis conducted on a preliminary LWR 9-rod bundle design shows that sufficient energy deposition into the central pin can be achieved well within range to investigate fuel and cladding performance in a simulated RIA. This is achieved by surrounding the flow channel with an additional annulus of water. Findings also show that a highly significant increase in TREAT to specimen power coupling factor (PCF) within the central pin can be achieved by surrounding the experiment with one to two rings of TREAT upgrade fuel assemblies. The experiment design holds promise for the performance evaluation of PWR fuel at extremely high burnup under similar reactor environment conditions.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Highlights from the Postirradiation Examination of AFC-3A and AFC-3B

Highlights from the postirradiation examination of the AFC-3A and AFC-3B irradiation test are presented. Baseline non-destructive and destructive examinations of these tests have been completed at this time. Results from visual examination, neutron radiography, gamma spectrometry, dimensional inspection, fission gas release, chemical burnup analysis, and optical microscopy have been collected. All the rodlets from these irradiations appear to have performed well during irradiation. Baseline PIE has been completed on rodlets from AFC- 3A, and AFC-3B. This includes visual exams, neutron radiography, gamma spectrometry. dimensional inspection, fission gas release evaluation, optical microscopy. microhardness evaluation. and chemical analysis. The results compiled here are a sampling of the full results. Baseline PIE provides an engineering or macroscopic scale evaluation of fuel performance and prepares samples for a more detailed phenomenological study of observed performance. Advanced PIE techniques are desired to obtain microscopic elemental and structural information both in the fuel, in the cladding, and in the interface where the composition of the FCCI layer is of great interest. The AFC-3 tests do appear to have performed roughly as designed during the irradiation. The FCCI behavior of Mo alloy metallic fuel versus Zr alloy metallic fuel has been confirmed. Results from this irradiation such as the FCCI observed in AFC-3A R1 and AFC-3A R2 can be used to eliminate Mo alloys as a choice in future irradiations where ultra-high burnup is a stated goal. Annular fuels are a preferred method for many high burnup core designs. The redistribution behavior of the annular U-Zr alloys should be studied further to better understand how this might impact high burnup annular fuel performance. The thermal bonding between annular fuel and cladding should also be studied further as there appear to be localized areas of FCCI forming in both AFC-3A R4 and AFC-3B R2, while no FCCI was observed in the Zr-based Na-bonded or Mo-based low smear density Na-bonded fuel. The performance of the low smear density. solid fuels is less clear. The neutron radiography and optical microscopy cross sections suggest the fuel is not forming a radially symmetric structure which may be causing undesirable localized temperature variations. Further study both by electron microscopy and by simulation to evaluate the implications of the non-symmetric fuel form are needed to better understand whether this fuel form merits further study under irradiation. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Postirradiation examination of recently irradiated metallic fuel concepts

In fast neutron spectrum nuclear reactors, metallic uranium alloys have often been chosen because of their high uranium density, high thermal conductivity, and several reactor kinetic safety benefits. Metallic uranium is often alloyed to raise the melting temperature or to modify the microstructure which improves irradiation performance. Recent irradiations have explored additional alloys and geometric forms beyond what has historically been irradiated (U-10 weight % Zr, 75% smeared density, sodium bonded fuel). Postirradiation examination results and how these results can be incorporated into modelling and simulation will be presented. The evaluated fuels fall into four categories alternative alloying metals, additives, sodium bond removal, and alternative smear densities. For alternative alloys, Zr has been substituted for 10% Mo or 5% Mo, 4.3%Ti, 0.7%Zr to stabilize the cubic phase of U and prevent constituent redistribution seen in U-Zr alloys. Unfortunately these alloys have significant, undesirable interactions with cladding during irradiation. Additives, such as Pd, have been suggested to bind lanthanide fission products, which interact with cladding limiting fuel performance, into high temperature intermetallic compounds. Irradiation results indicate there may be targeted applications such as high burnup fuel or recycled fuel with lanthanide carry-over where additives are useful. Sodium bonding is considered undesirable at the back end of the fuel cycle where sodium bonded fuel must be treated to remove sodium prior to geological disposition. Helium bonded metallic fuel of several alloys has been irradiated to better understand the implications of removing sodium bonding. Current results show that with proper dimensional tolerances on the final fuel slug, helium bonding is feasible. Low smear density fuel is necessary to enable high (30 atom %) burnup. Both solid and annular low smear density fuels have also been examined, and their performance is also discussed.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

VTR Casting Furnace Conceptual Design

This TEV describes the development of a conceptual design for a fuel casting system to be used in the development and demonstration of fuel designs for the new Versatile Test Reactor (VTR). This system will be installed in the Fuel Manufacturing Facility (FMF). The system will be in a shielded glovebox and will be used to melt fuel materials and injection cast these materials into fuel slugs, which will further be used to fabricate fuel elements for the VTR. This TEV covers only the injection casting system itself. Operations such as removing the castings from the injection molds, trimming of the castings, and installation of the castings into fuel element cladding are beyond the scope of the TEV. The conceptual design herein is principally concerned with the mechanical portion of the casting system and does not include details of the control or power supply systems.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Measurement of thermal gap conductance using the laser flash method

Thermal gap conductance refers to overall heat conductance through a gas-filled gap as interface thermal resistance between the gas and surface has to be considered. The analysis of new ATR (Advanced Test Reactor) fuel experiments requires experimental data and models for the gap conductance of the cladding/fuel capsule gap, which typically varies from 5 μm to 50 μm and is filled with He at 1-3 atm. Although past research has studied the gap conductance between UO{sub 2} fuel and Zircaloy cladding, new experiments are needed to provide the gap conductance data between HT9 and stainless steel 316, and between advanced fuels and advanced cladding in the Accident Tolerant Fuels program. In this paper, the laser flash method is modified to measure the gap conductance. The gap is formed by welding two stainless steel 316 disks with three spacers. The temperature at the rear surface, after exposure to the laser pulse at the front surface, is modeled with 1D heat transfer through three layers. The analytic solution is then fitted with the measured temperature to determine gap conductance. The sensitivity analysis based on the 1D assumption and 3D numerical simulations were performed to assess the sensitivity and uncertainty of the measurement. It is concluded the heat capacity of the gas in the gap has minimal impact on the measurement, which indicates that the thermal property determined by this method is the thermal conductance, instead of the thermal diffusivity. Convective heat loss through sidewalls under the current experimental design has insignificant influences. Heat transfer through spacers may cause up to 10% overestimation of thermal gap conductance, but the effects can be mostly eliminated by the design of grooves on samples. The result established a pathway for gap conductance determination. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Marmot V2

MARMOT is a robust numerical tool for mesoscale modeling of fuel performance developed under the NEAMS Fuels technical area to predict the coevolution of microstructure and properties in fuel and cladding materials. MARMOT accomplishes this using the phase field method coupled with finite strain mechanics and heat conduction. MARMOT is based on the open source Multiphysics Object-Oriented Simulation Environment (MOOSE) and solves the coupled partial differential equations defining the physics using the finite element method. MARMOT is being developed in order to facilitate the development of improved materials models for fuel performance, but it is also being developed as a powerful tool in and of itself for the simulation of mesoscale fuel performance.

Aagesen, LarryK.↗

Specifications of Cladding Diameter Measurements Conducted at AGHCF

Fuel element diameter data was collected on-site at the Alpha-Gamma Hot Cell Facility (AGHCF) before and after out-of-pile furnace transient tests of fuel elements. Available data records have been collected and preserved in the Out-of-Pile Transient Database (OPTD). This data is used to determine the transient-induced changes in fuel element diameter, or cladding strain, for the Whole Pin Furnace (WPF) tests. Fuel element diameter was measured by contact profilometry along the length of the fuel pin at specified rotational orientations and/or by a manually operated micrometer at several discrete axial locations along the pin. The Alpha-Gamma Hot Cell Facility Operations Manual details the way the facility operated, organizational and oversight responsibilities, and procedures for examination of samples. The working version of the manual at the time of the whole pin furnace tests and the test pin examinations is Doc. No. IPS-2-00-00, dated June 1989. This specification was developed using the operations manual and recovered measurement records in consultation with subject matter experts (SMEs). The measurement methods, format of the available post-test examination (PTE) data, and recommended methods for use and interpretation of that data are summarized. Section 2 describes the available diameter measurement data for the WPF tests with guidance for interpretation and usage, and Section 3 describes the instrument measurement procedures and calibration methods.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Irradiation Performance of U-Mo Alloy Based ‘Monolithic’ Plate-Type—Design Selection Update

Based on data available in 2009, a decision was made to focus U–Mo monolithic fuel development and qualification efforts on a single fuel design. This fuel design consists of a U–10Mo (wt.%) monolithic fuel foil, a zirconium barrier layer applied to the faces of the foil, and 6061 aluminum cladding. This document updates the basis for the selection of that fuel system, drawing on additional fuel-performance data available as of May 2013. This update also applies recently developed GTRI (Global Threat Reduction Initiative) requirements for fuel qualification to the selection process. Because of its inherent gamma-phase stability and qualitatively better rolling behavior, U–10Mo was selected as the fuel alloy of choice, exhibiting reasonable uranium density and good irradiation performance. A zirconium barrier layer between the fuel and cladding was chosen to provide a predictable, well-bonded, fuel-cladding interface, greatly reducing fuel-cladding chemical interaction. The fuel plate testing conducted to inform this selection was based on the use of U–10Mo foils fabricated by hot- and cold co-rolling with a Zr foil. The foils were subsequently bonded to the Al–6061 cladding by hot isostatic pressing or friction stir welding. Since the original down-select decision was made, additional information has become available on fuel performance and on the cost of the fuel system. Preliminary cost estimates indicate that U–Mo-Zr waste generated during fabrication is difficult to recycle and adds substantially to the production cost. It is the purpose of this report to review fuel-performance data available as of May 2013, outline data and observations that are significant to informing the down-selection process, review the data against down-select requirements, and update the recommendation on a fuel system suitable for fuel qualification. In addition, this report assesses the potential of a fuel system without a zirconium barrier layer for use in USNRC-licensed research reactors. This revised report is issued as a working draft for discussion by the United States High Performance Research Reactor (USHPRR) program. The document will continue to be revised as additional information becomes available. This may include updates to information about normal and anticipated transient fuel operating conditions as conversion fuel-element designs evolve or additional information on fuel performance gained from U.S. or international testing programs. In particular, information from the RERTR–12 experiment will be included when available.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Evaluation Metrics Applied to Accident Tolerant Fuels

The safe, reliable, and economic operation of the nation’s nuclear power reactor fleet has always been a top priority for the United States’ nuclear industry. Continual improvement of technology, including advanced materials and nuclear fuels, remains central to the industry’s success. Decades of research combined with continual operation have produced steady advancements in technology and have yielded an extensive base of data, experience, and knowledge on light water reactor (LWR) fuel performance under both normal and accident conditions. One of the current missions of the U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) Office of Nuclear Energy (NE) is to develop nuclear fuels and claddings with enhanced accident tolerance for use in the current fleet of commercial LWRs or in reactor concepts with design certifications (GEN-III+). Accident tolerance became a focus within advanced LWR research upon direction from Congress following the 2011 Great East Japan Earthquake, resulting tsunami, and subsequent damage to the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant complex. The overall goal of ATF development is to identify alternative fuel system technologies to further enhance the safety, competitiveness and economics of commercial nuclear power. Enhanced accident tolerant fuels would endure loss of active cooling in the reactor core for a considerably longer period of time than the current fuel system while maintaining or improving performance during normal operations. The U.S. DOE is supporting multiple teams to investigate a number of technologies that may improve fuel system response and behavior in accident conditions, with team leadership provided by DOE national laboratories, universities, and the nuclear industry. Concepts under consideration offer both evolutionary and revolutionary changes to the current nuclear fuel system. Mature concepts will be tested in the Advanced Test Reactor at Idaho National Laboratory beginning in Summer 2014 with additional concepts being readied for insertion in fiscal year 2015. This paper provides a brief summary of the proposed evaluation process that would be used to evaluate and prioritize the candidate accident tolerant fuel concepts currently under development.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗