Phase I Final Technical Report: Functionally Graded Composite Plate for Plasma Facing Components
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Various helium (He)-cooled solid-tungsten (W) divertor concepts have been proposed for long-pulse magnetic fusion energy reactors. Among these concepts, the He-cooled flat plate divertor (HCFP) modules have the largest plasma-facing surface area of ~0.2 m 2 . Simulations have shown that the most recent version of the design can withstand heat fluxes as great as 8 MW/m 2 . Earlier experimental studies of a single shortened HCFP cooling unit with a slot length of 7.6 cm used air at ambient temperature and pressures below 0.6 MPa. Here, we present initial experimental studies of a copper alloy and steel test section modeling a shortened HCFP cooling unit using He at prototypical pressure of 10 MPa, inlet temperatures T i ≤ 200 °C and steady-state incident heat fluxes q" ≤ 1.2 MW/m 2 . Results for Nusselt number Nu as a function of Reynolds number Re were obtained for Re = 1.2×10 4 –3.4×10 4 , and used to develop a Nu(Re) correlation and validate numerical models of the test section using commercial computational fluid dynamics (CFD) software. Simulations with this model are performed to evaluate the effect of the shortened slot. Furthermore, these analyses are used to estimate the thermal-fluids performance of the HCFP under prototypical conditions.
The performance demands on plasma-facing components (PFCs) in future fusion power plants are beyond the capability of current materials. In defining the plasma-surface interaction (PSI), it is evident that three coupled spatial regions influence PFC materials evolution and performance. These regions consist of (1) the edge and scrape-off layer region of the plasma, (2) the near-surface material response to extreme thermal and particle fluxes under the influence of, and feedback to, the plasma sheath, and (3) the structural material’s response to an intense, 14 MeV peaked neutron spectrum, which produces very high concentrations of transmuted elements through (n,p) and (n,α) reactions and structural material property degradation. The objective of this project is to develop and deploy validated, high-performance simulation tools capable of predicting the performance of tungsten-based plasma-facing components (PFCs) in a burning fusion plasma environment, which includes modeling surface morphology evolution in either erosion or re-deposition regimes, and the recycling of hydrogen species. This requires the development of a leadership-scale computational code to predict PFC behavior that is well integrated to a suite of multiscale modeling techniques to bridge the scales needed to address complex physical and computational issues at the plasma surface interface and the transition region below the surface where neutron damage processes in the bulk dominate material behavior. Successful completion of this project will provide PFC simulation tools to evaluate steady-state performance of tungsten-based PFC and divertor components in burning plasma environments. This will enable the identification of critical experiments to confirm whether practical PFC solutions exist for magnetic fusion energy beyond ITER. More specifically, the research activities within this project focus on two broadly defined research thrusts: 1) Developing a new simulation code, Xolotl-PSI to predict PFC operating lifetime and performance, that is specifically designed to take advantage of leadership class computing facilities; and 2) Integrating and applying discrete particle-based, as well as continuum-based, multiscale modeling techniques to provide scientific discovery of the mechanisms controlling PFC and bulk materials evolution under fusion plasma and 14-MeV neutron exposure; in this thrust, the challenge of scale-bridging between atomistic/microstructural modeling and the continuum-scale of PFC device performance is achieved through multiscale modeling techniques. Throughout the grant period, research at UMass Amherst focused on the atomic-scale analysis of the dynamics and kinetics (transport and reactions) of small mobile helium clusters near surfaces and grain boundaries in plasma-exposed tungsten, as well as the proper parameterization and incorporation of these processes into our SciDAC team’s continuum-level cluster dynamics code (Xolotl). Our work also included characterization of large-scale molecular-dynamics (MD) simulation results of helium implantation into tungsten based on the findings of our analysis and comparisons of Xolotl simulation predictions with the large-scale MD simulation results for Xolotl validation purposes; emphasis was placed on the impact of helium cluster dynamics/kinetics on tungsten surface morphology, near-surface tungsten structure, and helium retention. Furthermore, our work included initiation of a research program on evaluating the impact of structural defects in tungsten due to plasma exposure (such as helium nanobubbles) on tungsten’s thermophysical properties, focusing on lattice thermal conductivity. Our studies contributed to a fundamental understanding of the effects of plasma-surface interactions on the dynamical response of plasma-facing materials in nuclear fusion devices and the development of predictive hierarchical multiscale computational tools for the quantitative description of the material’s dynamical response to plasma exposure.
Plasma Material Interactions in future fusion reactors have been identified as a knowledge gap to be dealt with before any next step device past ITER can be built. The challenges are manifold. They are related to power dissipation so that the heat fluxes to the plasma facing components can be kept at technologically feasible levels; maximization of the lifetime of divertor plasma facing components that allow for steady-state operation in a reactor to reach the neutron fluences required; the tritium inventory (storage) in the plasma facing components, which can lead to potential safety concerns and reduction in the fuel efficiency; and it is related to the technology of the plasma facing components itself, which should demonstrate structural integrity under the high temperatures and neutron fluence. This contribution will give an overview and summary of those challenges together with some discussion of potential solutions. New linear plasma devices are needed to investigate the PMI under fusion reactor conditions and test novel plasma facing components. The Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment MPEX will be introduced and a status of the current R&D towards MPEX will be summarized.
A shielded residual gas analyzer (RGA) system on Tore Supra can function during plasma operation and is set up to monitor the composition of the neutral gas in one of the pumping ducts of the toroidal pumped limited. This ''diagnostic RGA'' has been used in long-pulse (up to 6 min) discharges for continuous monitoring of up to 15 masses simultaneously. Comparison of the RGA-measured evolution of the H{sub 2}/D{sub 2} isotopic ratio in the exhaust gas to that measured by an energetic neutral particle analyzer in the plasma core provides a way to monitor the evolution of particle balance. RGA monitoring of corrective H{sub 2} injection to maintain proper minority heating is providing a database for improved ion cyclotron resonance heating, potentially with RGA-base feedback control. In very long pulses (>4 min) absence of significant changes in the RGA-monitored, hydrocarbon particle pressures is an indication of proper operation of the actively cooled, carbon-based plasma facing components. Also H{sub 2} could increase due to thermodesorption of overheated plasma facing components.
There are currently few viable diagnostic techniques for in situ measurement of plasma facing component erosion. Digital holography is intended to fill this gap. Progress on the development of single and dual CO 2 laser digital holography diagnostics for in situ plasma facing component erosion is discussed. The dual laser mode’s synthetic wavelength allows the measurable range to be expanded by a factor of ~400 compared to single laser digital holography. This allows the diagnostic to measure surface height changes of up to 4.5 μm in single laser mode and up to 2 mm in dual laser mode. Results include ex situ measurements of plasma eroded targets and also dynamic measurements of nm and μm scale motion of a target mounted on a precision translation stage. Dynamic measurements have successfully been made with the system operating in both single and dual laser modes, from ~50 nm to ~4 μm in single laser mode and up to ~400 μm in dual laser mode (limited only by the stage speed and camera acquisition duration). These results demonstrate the feasibility of using digital holography to characterize plasma facing component erosion dynamically, i.e., during plasma exposure. Results of proof-of-principle in situ digital holographic measurements of targets exposed to an electrothermal arc plasma source are presented.
Plasma-material interactions in future fusion reactors have been identified as a knowledge gap to be dealt with before any next step device past ITER can be built. The challenges are manifold. They are related to power dissipation so that the heat fluxes to the plasma-facing components can be kept at technologically feasible levels; maximization of the lifetime of divertor plasma-facing components that allow for steadystate operation in a reactor to reach the neutron fluence required; the tritium inventory (storage) in the plasma-facing components, which can lead to potential safety concerns and reduction in the fuel efficiency; and it is related to the technology of the plasma-facing components itself, which should demonstrate structural integrity under the high temperatures and high neutron fluence. While the dissipation of power exhaust can and should be addressed in high power toroidal devices, the interaction of the plasma with the materials can be best addressed in dedicated linear devices due to their cost effectiveness and ability to address urgent research and development gaps more timely. However, new linear plasma devices are needed to investigate the PMI under fusion reactor conditions and test novel plasma-facing components. Existing linear devices are limited either in their flux, their reactor-relevant plasma transport regimes in front of the target, their fluence, or their ability to test material samples a priori exposed to high neutron fluence. The proposed Material Plasma Exposure eXperiment (MPEX) is meant to address those deficiencies and will be designed to fulfill the fusion reactor-relevant plasma parameters as well as the ability to expose a priori neutron activated materials to plasmas.
The plasma-facing components (PFCs) of future fusion reactors will have intricate structures and require multiple materials because no one material can simultaneously satisfy all the requirements of the component. The dissimilar material joints in PFCs must withstand extreme thermal and stress gradients under neutron irradiation. The Fusion Research Oriented to Neutron Irradiation and Tritium Behavior at Material Interfaces (FRONTIER) U.S.-Japan collaboration seeks to explore and explain the behavior of internal solid interfaces in PFCs under neutron irradiation. The first step of the collaboration was to identify the leading PFCs that should be studied further and prepare them for the next step, which will include neutron irradiation. Different strategies for material development are being pursued worldwide to produce robust PFCs. Here, in this work, an overview is presented of some of the most promising materials in the areas of copper alloys, tungsten-copper composites, tungsten-steel composites, additively manufactured tungsten, particle-reinforced tungsten, and tungsten and SiC fiber composites. Each material’s fabrication and benefits are described, and some discussion of remaining questions is given.
Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) results are presented that provide depth-resolved identification of He implanted in polycrystalline tungsten (PC-W) targets by a 200 keV He+ ion beam, with a surface temperature of approximately 900 °C and a peak fluence of 10 23 m –2 . He retention, and the influence of He on deuterium and tritium recycling, permeation, and retention in PC-W plasma facing components are important questions for the divertor and plasma facing components in a fusion reactor, yet are difficult to quantify. The purpose of this work is to demonstrate the ability of LIBS to identify helium in tungsten; to investigate the sensitivity of laser parameters including, laser energy and gate delay, that directly influence the sensitivity and depth resolution of LIBS; and to perform a proof-of-principle experiment using LIBS to measure relative He intensities as a function of depth. In conclusion, the results presented demonstrate the potential not only to identify helium but also to develop a methodology to quantify gaseous impurity concentration in PC-W as a function of depth.
Lithium plasma facing components reduce the flux of "recycled" particles en- tering the plasma edge from the plasma facing components. This results in increased external fueling requirements and provides the opportunity to control the magnitude and distribution of the incoming particle flux. It has been pre- dicted that the plasma density profile will then be determined by the deposition profile of the external fueling, rather than dominated by the recycled particle flux. A series of experiments on the Lithium Tokamak Experiment demonstrate that lithium wall coatings facilitate control of the neutral and plasma particle in- ventories. With fresh lithium coatings and careful gas injection programming, over 90% of the injected particle inventory can be absorbed in the lithium wall during a discharge. Furthermore, dramatic changes in the fueling requirements and plasma parameters were observed when lithium coatings were applied. This is largely due to the elimination of water as an impurity on the plasma facing components. A Molecular Cluster Injector (MCI) was developed for the fueling of LTX plas- mas. The MCI uses a supersonic nozzle, cooled to liquid nitrogen temperatures, to create the conditions necessary for molecular cluster formation. It has been predicted that molecular clusters will penetrate deeper into plasmas than gas- phase molecules via a reduced ionization cross-section and by improving the collimation of the neutral jet. Using an electron beam diagnostic, the densities of the cryogenic MCI are measured to be an order of magnitude higher than in the room-temperature jets formed with the same valve pressure. This indi- cates increased collimation relative to what would be expected from ideal gas dynamics alone. A systematic study of the fueling efficiencies achieved with the LTX fueling systems is presented. The fueling efficiency of the Supersonic Gas Injector (SGI) is demonstrated to be strongly dependent on the distance between the nozzle and plasma edge. The fueling efficiency of the gas puffer was improved by the addition of a guide tube to keep the gas flow collimated and directed towards the plasma edge. Contrary to results reported on other devices, the MCI yields fueling efficiencies that are at best equal to the SGI. This suggests that any enhanced penetration from cluster formation is nullified by the reduced velocity of the cryogenic gas. Furthermore, at very high neutral fluxes, the fueling efficiency of the MCI dropped off dramatically, suggesting that the build-up of pressure in the scrape-off-layer is producing a self-shielding effect. All of these results are consistent with the idea that the best gas-based fueling source is one that brings highly directed neutrals to the plasma edge, without being scattered or ionized in the scrape-off-layer. The density profiles of LTX plasmas are measured during external fueling with the gas puffer, SGI, and cryogenic MCI. While the density profile amplitude increases with higher fueling rates, the shape of the profile remains constant. This suggests that particle transport is such that differences in the neutral deposition cannot be discerned. The density profiles are consistently hollow, suggesting a region of reduced particle transport in the core of LTX plasmas.
The objective of this project is to develop, and integrate, high-performance simulation tools capable of predicting plasma-facing component (PFC) operating lifetime and the impact of the evolving surface morphology of tungsten-based PFCs on plasma contamination, including the dynamic recycling of fuel species and tritium retention, in future magnetic fusion devices. Establishing a fundamental physical understanding and developing predictive capabilities of plasma-surface interactions (PSI) requires simultaneously addressing complex and diverse physics occurring over a wide range of length (Angstroms to meters) and time (femtoseconds to years) scales, as well as integrating extensive physical processes across the plasma–surface interface. This requires development of not only detailed physics models and computational strategies at each scale, but also algorithms and methods to couple them effectively in a way that can be robustly validated. Deploying these tools requires the continued development and coupling of leadership-scale computational codes to describe the boundary plasma and the evolving PFC surface, as well as a host of simulations that bridge disparate scales to address complex physical and computational issues at the plasma–surface interface in multi-component materials systems for magnetic fusion energy development beyond ITER.
A radiative divertor technique is planned for the NSTX-U tokamak to prevent excessive erosion and thermal damage of divertor plasma-facing components in H-mode plasma discharges with auxiliary heating up to 12 MW. In the radiative (partially detached) divertor, extrinsically seeded deuterium or impurity gases are used to increase plasma volumetric power and momentum losses. A real-time feedback control of the gas seeding rate is planned for discharges of up to 5 s duration. The outer divertor leg plasma electron temperature T{sub e} estimated spectroscopically in real time will be used as a control parameter. A vacuum ultraviolet spectrometer McPherson Model 251 with a fast charged-coupled device detector is developed for temperature monitoring between 5 and 30 eV, based on the Δn = 0, 1 line intensity ratios of carbon, nitrogen, or neon ion lines in the spectral range 300–1600 Å. A collisional-radiative model-based line intensity ratio will be used for relative calibration. A real-time T{sub e}-dependent signal within a characteristic divertor detachment equilibration time of ∼10–15 ms is expected.
Magnetic confinement fusion devices require effective heat and particle exhaust solutions on the divertor plates to operate sustainably, especially under reactor-relevant conditions. Liquid lithium divertors have been proposed to address two major challenges: control of excessive heat flux to plasma-facing components through vapor shielding and minimization of core plasma contamination from impurities. The National Spherical Torus Experiment-Upgrade (NSTX-U) will explore lithium as a divertor material due to its potential to meet both objectives. We present a self-consistent coupling framework between the plasma boundary transport code UEDGE and the lithium wall transport code Wall–Li to evaluate the feasibility and operational limits of lithium-based divertors. The model aims to optimize lithium sourcing levels to prevent core plasma contamination via fuel dilution while ensuring divertor protection through vapor shielding. This integrated framework, applicable to any tokamak with lithium sources, dynamically adjusts lithium sourcing based on local plasma conditions and surface temperature. The coupled model is tested using NSTX-like geometry and plasma conditions to assess its performance and reliability. Wall–Li calculates lithium fluxes from plasma-facing components, incorporating physical sputtering, thermally enhanced sputtering, and evaporation driven by surface temperature and ion flux. These fluxes are reintroduced into UEDGE as neutral lithium atoms, enabling simulation of their transport and distribution within the plasma. UEDGE computes plasma and neutral transport, surface heat flux, and iteratively feeds this information back to Wall–Li. A small time step is employed to ensure numerical stability and convergence, enabling accurate simulations over typical tokamak discharge durations. This integrated modeling approach provides a robust tool for identifying operational regimes that balance effective lithium sourcing with minimal core plasma contamination, offering critical insights for optimizing lithium-based divertor systems in current and future fusion devices.
The Hybrid Illinois Device for Research and Applications (HIDRA) at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign is a toroidal plasma device that enables fusion plasma-material interaction testing with both stellarator and tokamak plasmas. HIDRA’s long-pulse steady state stellarator plasmas provide a testbed for plasma facing component (PFC) plasma exposures. The HIDRA Material Analysis Test-stand (HIDRA-MAT) is a material characterization module attached to HIDRA that is being designed and fabricated to include thermal desorption spectroscopy and laser induced breakdown spectroscopy systems for in-vacuo PFC characterization. A specialized rotatable sample holder positions the sample for liquid metal droplet application from a liquid metal droplet injector on HIDRA-MAT. Early experiments look to investigate the effect liquid lithium has on porous tungsten samples’ retention of H, D, and He after plasma exposure. Preliminary results from a dual residual gas analyzer system show the ability to differentiate D2 and He in HIDRA-MAT. Finally, this work aims to advance the understanding of liquid metal PFCs and further the design and development of new fusion PFCs and technologies.
Not Available
The use of lithium-coated plasma facing components for plasma density control is studied in the National Spherical Torus Experiment (NSTX). A recently installed liquid lithium divertor (LLD) module has a porous molybdenum surface, separated by a stainless steel liner from a heated copper substrate. Lithium is deposited on the LLD from two evaporators. Two new spectroscopic diagnostics are installed to study the plasma surface interactions on the LLD: (1) A 20-element absolute extreme ultraviolet (AXUV) diode array with a 6 nm bandpass filter centered at 121.6 nm (the Lyman-{alpha} transition) for spatially resolved divertor recycling rate measurements in the highly reflective LLD environment, and (2) an ultraviolet-visible-near infrared R=0.67 m imaging Czerny-Turner spectrometer for spatially resolved divertor D I, Li I-II, C I-IV, Mo I, D{sub 2}, LiD, CD emission and ion temperature on and around the LLD module. The use of photometrically calibrated measurements together with atomic physics factors enables studies of recycling and impurity particle fluxes as functions of LLD temperature, ion flux, and divertor geometry.
Tungsten is planned to be the plasma-facing material for the main chamber and divertor in future devices like ITER, SPARC, and DTT. To address risks associated with tungsten, R&D is being carried out on various toroidal confinement devices. One particular research question is related to the optimum heating mix for ITER. To investigate the influence of the heating scheme on the release and transport of tungsten, a comparison of neutral beam injection (NBI) and ion cyclotron resonance frequency (ICRF) heating was carried out in TEXTOR tungsten test limiter experiments. The experiments were performed under standard L-mode conditions and in radiative improved-mode operation with neon seeding and boronized walls covering the graphite plasma-facing components. The plasma was heated with hydrogen or deuterium NBI alone or with deuterium NBI in combination with H-minority, ion cyclotron resonance heating. A movable solid tungsten limiter was inserted through a limiter lock system into the edge plasma. The impurity release from this limiter was evaluated from visible spectroscopy. The tungsten concentrations in the plasma core were determined by extreme ultraviolet spectroscopy and bolometry. With deuterium NBI alone, strong central radiation and accumulation of W was observed. This can, however, be avoided by adding ICRF heating.