Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “code verification”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 145 records · Page 8

Verification of Advective Bar Elements Implemented in the Sierra/Aria Thermal Response Code

A thorough code verification effort has been performed on a reduced order, finite element model for 1D fluid flow convectively coupled with a 3D solid, referred to as the 'advective bar' model. The purpose of this effort was to provide confidence in the proper implementation of this model within the SIERRA/Aria thermal response code at Sandia National Laboratories. The method of manufactured solutions is applied so that the order of convergence in error norms for successively refined meshes and timesteps is investigated. Potential pitfalls that can lead to a premature evaluation of the model's implementation are described for this verification approach when applied to this unique model. As a result, through observation of the expected order of convergence, these verification tests provide evidence of proper implementation of the model within the codebase.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Proposed Semi-Analytic Benchmark for Coupled Neutronics/Thermal-Hydraulics Feedback in Multiphysics Simulations

The past decade has seen considerable advancements in multiscale and multiphysics simulations that account for nonlinear effects of feedback between different physical processes within a single calculation. One area of particular interest has been multiphysics simulations that include both neutronics and thermal-hydraulics effects to accurately model the thermal feedback effects present in nuclear reactors. During this time, many groups have successfully modeled thermal feedback effects by coupling a variety of different types of neutron transport and thermal-hydraulic solvers together. However, formal verification and validation of these coupled code systems has proven challenging due to a lack of benchmark problems with well-characterized reference solutions. One approach is to confirm gross energy balance using bulk coolant properties (outlet temperature/enthalpy) for code verification purposes. Alternatively, code-to-code comparisons of results for a predefined reference/challenge problem have been used to establish reasonability of local results (neutron flux, heating, enthalpy rise) for various implementations, for example the VERA Core Physics Progression Problems. While community solutions are valuable for assessing the relative performance and fidelity of different implementations, they are not guaranteed to provide a measure of the absolute accuracy of a given implementation. In fact, these code-to-code comparisons can give a false sense of confidence by masking the effects of errors or approximations that are common to all of the solution methods tested. This is a particular concern when many methods derive from a common approach, such as Picard iteration. To this end, an analytical benchmark would be very valuable for verifying individual coupled physics implementations, as well as for providing a formal assessment of algorithm accuracy and sensitivity to model approximations such as mesh size and number of convergence iterations. However, creation of an analytical benchmark is difficult due to the complex nature of the eigenvalue form of the neutron transport equation (which does not permit a simple analytical solution for non-trivial cases) as well as the variety of different empirical closure relationships used in thermal-hydraulic modeling. In this paper we propose a benchmark for coupled neutronics/thermal-hydraulics simulations. The proposed benchmark overcomes the challenges associated with a multiphysics benchmark problem by using a fixed-source (rather than eigenvalue) formulation of the neutron transport equation and limiting fluid properties to the single-phase regime where the density and temperature of the coolant are related to enthalpy by a known relationship, while still preserving significant nuclear/thermal feedback effects within the simplified problem. The new benchmark is easy to simulate using existing coupled physics implementations, and allows for a direct comparison with a reference solution, as provided in this summary.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Offshore Code Comparison Collaboration, Continuation within IEA Wind Task 30: Phase II Results Regarding a Floating Semisubmersible Wind System: Preprint

Offshore wind turbines are designed and analyzed using comprehensive simulation tools (or codes) that account for the coupled dynamics of the wind inflow, aerodynamics, elasticity, and controls of the turbine, along with the incident waves, sea current, hydrodynamics, and foundation dynamics of the support structure. This paper describes the latest findings of the code-to-code verification activities of the Offshore Code Comparison Collaboration, Continuation (OC4) project, which operates under the International Energy Agency (IEA) Wind Task 30. In the latest phase of the project, participants used an assortment of simulation codes to model the coupled dynamic response of a 5-MW wind turbine installed on a floating semisubmersible in 200 m of water. Code predictions were compared from load-case simulations selected to test different model features. The comparisons have resulted in a greater understanding of offshore floating wind turbine dynamics and modeling techniques, and better knowledge of the validity of various approximations. The lessons learned from this exercise have improved the participants? codes, thus improving the standard of offshore wind turbine modeling.

17 WIND ENERGY↗

INL Results for Phases I and III of the OECD/NEA MHTGR-350 Benchmark

The Idaho National Laboratory (INL) Very High Temperature Reactor (VHTR) Technology Development Office (TDO) Methods Core Simulation group led the construction of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) Modular High Temperature Reactor (MHTGR) 350 MW benchmark for comparing and evaluating prismatic VHTR analysis codes. The benchmark is sponsored by the OECD's Nuclear Energy Agency (NEA), and the project will yield a set of reference steady-state, transient, and lattice depletion problems that can be used by the Department of Energy (DOE), the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), and vendors to assess their code suits. The Methods group is responsible for defining the benchmark specifications, leading the data collection and comparison activities, and chairing the annual technical workshops. This report summarizes the latest INL results for Phase I (steady state) and Phase III (lattice depletion) of the benchmark. The INSTANT, Pronghorn and RattleSnake codes were used for the standalone core neutronics modeling of Exercise 1, and the results obtained from these codes are compared in Section 4. Exercise 2 of Phase I requires the standalone steady-state thermal fluids modeling of the MHTGR-350 design, and the results for the systems code RELAP5-3D are discussed in Section 5. The coupled neutronics and thermal fluids steady-state solution for Exercise 3 are reported in Section 6, utilizing the newly developed Parallel and Highly Innovative Simulation for INL Code System (PHISICS)/RELAP5-3D code suit. Finally, the lattice depletion models and results obtained for Phase III are compared in Section 7. The MHTGR-350 benchmark proved to be a challenging simulation set of problems to model accurately, and even with the simplifications introduced in the benchmark specification this activity is an important step in the code-to-code verification of modern prismatic VHTR codes. A final OECD/NEA comparison report will compare the Phase I and III results of all other international participants in 2014, while the remaining Phase II transient case results will be reported in 2015.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Modeling resonance interference by 0-D slowing-down solution with embedded self-shielding method

The resonance integral table based methods employing conventional multigroup structure for the resonance self-shielding calculation have a common difficulty on treating the resonance interference. The problem arises due to the lack of sufficient energy dependence of the resonance cross sections when the calculation is performed in the multigroup structure. To address this, a resonance interference factor model has been proposed to account for the interference effect by comparing the interfered and non-interfered effective cross sections obtained from 0-D homogeneous slowing-down solutions by continuous-energy cross sections. A rigorous homogeneous slowing-down solver is developed with two important features for reducing the calculation time and memory requirement for practical applications. The embedded self-shielding method (ESSM) is chosen as the multigroup resonance self-shielding solver as an integral component of the interference method. The interference method is implemented in the DeCART transport code. Verification results show that the code system provides more accurate effective cross sections and multiplication factors than the conventional interference method for UO{sub 2} and MOX fuel cases. The additional computing time and memory for the interference correction is acceptable for the test problems including a depletion case with 87 isotopes in the fuel region. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

A TWO-DIMENSIONAL METHOD OF MANUFACTURED SOLUTIONS BENCHMARK SUITE BASED ON VARIATIONS OF LARSEN'S BENCHMARK WITH ESCALATING ORDER OF SMOOTHNESS OF THE EXACT SOLUTION

The quantification of the discretization error associated with the spatial discretization of the Discrete Ordinate(DO) equations in multidimensional Cartesian geometries is the central problem in error estimation of spatial discretization schemes for transport theory as well as computer code verification. Traditionally fine mesh solutions are employed as reference, because analytical solutions only exist in the absence of scattering. This approach, however, is inadequate when the discretization error associated with the reference solution is not small compared to the discretization error associated with the mesh under scrutiny. Typically this situation occurs if the mesh of interest is only a couple of refinement levels away from the reference solution or if the order of accuracy of the numerical method (and hence the reference as well) is lower than expected. In this work we present a Method of Manufactured Solutions (MMS) benchmark suite with variable order of smoothness of the underlying exact solution for two-dimensional Cartesian geometries which provides analytical solutions aver- aged over arbitrary orthogonal meshes for scattering and non-scattering media. It should be emphasized that the developed MMS benchmark suite first eliminates the aforementioned limitation of fine mesh reference solutions since it secures knowledge of the underlying true solution and second that it allows for an arbitrary order of smoothness of the underlying ex- act solution. The latter is of importance because even for smooth parameters and boundary conditions the DO equations can feature exact solution with limited smoothness. Moreover, the degree of smoothness is crucial for both the order of accuracy and the magnitude of the discretization error for any spatial discretization scheme.

99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS↗

Additional Model Datasets and Results to Accelerate the Verification and Validation of RELAP-7

The RELAP-7 code verification and validation activities are ongoing under the code assessment plan proposed in the previous document (INL-EXT-16-40015). Among the list of V&V test problems in the ‘RELAP-7 code V&V RTM (Requirements Traceability Matrix)’, the RELAP-7 7-equation model has been tested with additional demonstration problems and the results of these tests are reported in this document. In this report, we describe the testing process, the test cases that were conducted, and the results of the evaluation.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

The “2T” ion-electron semi-analytic shock solution for code-comparison with xRAGE: A report for FY16

This report documents an effort to generate the semi-analytic "2T" ion-electron shock solution developed in the paper by Masser, Wohlbier, and Lowrie, and the initial attempts to understand how to use this solution as a code-verification tool for one of LANL's ASC codes, xRAGE. Most of the work so far has gone into generating the semi-analytic solution. Considerable effort will go into understanding how to write the xRAGE input deck that both matches the boundary conditions imposed by the solution, and also what physics models must be implemented within the semi-analytic solution itself to match the model assumptions inherit within xRAGE. Therefore, most of this report focuses on deriving the equations for the semi-analytic 1D-planar time-independent "2T" ion-electron shock solution, and is written in a style that is intended to provide clear guidance for anyone writing their own solver.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Physics Verification Overview

The purpose of the verification project is to establish, through rigorous convergence analysis, that each ASC computational physics code correctly implements a set of physics models and algorithms (code verification); Evaluate and analyze the uncertainties of code outputs associated with the choice of temporal and spatial discretization (solution or calculation verification); and Develop and maintain the capability to expand and update these analyses on demand. This presentation describes project milestones.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Improvements to PHISICS/RELAP5-3D{sup C} Capabilities for Simulating HTGRs

Accurate, high-resolution full core simulations of prismatic high temperature reactors for burnup and transient analysis remain a challenge. The cores are geometrically large, but some features are quite small (tri-structural isotropic (TRISO) particles, burnable poison pellets). The treatment of both neutron scattering in graphite and resonance capture are complex and not adequately captured using the methods traditionally used in High Temperature Gas-cooled Reactors (HTGR) and commonly used in Light Water Reactors (LWR). For transient analysis, temperature feedback is a function of the TRISO fuel form, but full core models cannot resolve phenomena at this scale without averaging over space and energy. For burnup calculations, a second level of heterogeneity must be resolved to capture the local effects of fuel and burnable poisons, while accurately propagating their effects through and between blocks. The HTGR Methods and Simulation group has been utilizing the INL-developed PHISICS/RELAP5-3D{sup C} (P/R), code suite for participation in the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) Modular High Temperature Gas Cooled Reactor (MHTGR) Benchmark, funded by the US Department of Energy (DOE) under the Advanced Reactor Technologies (ART) program. The MHTGR-350 benchmark consists of several lattice, steady-state and transient exercises, and the P/R code has been successfully applied to most of the cases defined. In addition to this code-to-code verification activity, it is planned that P/R will be validated using data from several Loss of Forced Cooling (LOFC) tests performed at the High Temperature Test Reactor (HTTR) in a joint effort with Japan Atomic Energy Agency (JAEA) under the Civil Nuclear Energy Working Group (CNWG) project. These verification and validation simulations will identify code and model discrepancies, sensitivities, and establish the current state-of-the-art in HTGR simulation. The Department of Astronautical, Electrical and Energy Engineering (DIAEE), 'Sapienza' University has been involved in the development of P/R since 2014 through various graduate and PhD student projects. In the framework of this collaboration the P/R optimization for application on the OECD MHTGR-350 and HTTR models will be carried out.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

The escape of high explosive products: An exact-solution problem for verification of hydrodynamics codes

This paper documents the escape of high explosive (HE) products problem. The problem, first presented by Fickett & Rivard, tests the implementation and numerical behavior of a high explosive detonation and energy release model and its interaction with an associated compressible hydrodynamics simulation code. The problem simulates the detonation of a finite-length, one-dimensional piece of HE that is driven by a piston from one end and adjacent to a void at the other end. The HE equation of state is modeled as a polytropic ideal gas. The HE detonation is assumed to be instantaneous with an infinitesimal reaction zone. Via judicious selection of the material specific heat ratio, the problem has an exact solution with linear characteristics, enabling a straightforward calculation of the physical variables as a function of time and space. Lastly, implementation of the exact solution in the Python code ExactPack is discussed, as are verification cases for the exact solution code.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Investigation, Development, and Evaluation of Performance Proving for Fault-tolerant Computers

A number of methodologies for verifying systems and computer based tools that assist users in verifying their systems were developed. These tools were applied to verify in part the SIFT ultrareliable aircraft computer. Topics covered included: STP theorem prover; design verification of SIFT; high level language code verification; assembly language level verification; numerical algorithm verification; verification of flight control programs; and verification of hardware logic.

Levitt, K. N.↗

COMPUTATION FLUID DYNAMICS ANALYSIS FOR GENERIC SMALL MODULAR REACTOR CONTAINMENT SEPARATE EFFECTS TEST

It is desirable for fourth-generation Small Modular Reactors to be passively cooled in standard and accident operations. Passive Containment Cooling Systems can reject heat from the containment structure, without using pumps or blowers. The targeted design containment structure is a large, domed, stainless steel, cylindrical vessel. In a postulated Design Basis Accident, steam will flash inside containment. Steam condensation occurs on the inner containment wall and transfers heat through the steel containment into a large body of water known as the annular reservoir (AR) surrounding the vessel serving as the ultimate heat sink. Natural circulation drives the flow in the AR and heat will be released to the environment by evaporation of water. Unique containment geometry requires a separate effects test (SET) facility for the verification and validation of the computer code and evaluation model development and assessment for reactor licensing efforts. In this study, STAR-CCM+, a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) code was used to inform the decision-making process on the design of the SET. The CFD simulation modeled, a two-phase turbulent flow with fluid film development and heat transfer for different containment geometries. The Reactor Excursion and Leak Analysis Program will also be used in a code-to-code verification against the CFD results.

21 - SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLAN↗

A verification regime for the spatial discretization of the SN transport equations

The order-of-accuracy test in conjunction with the method of manufactured solutions is the current state of the art in computer code verification. In this work we investigate the application of a verification procedure including the order-of-accuracy test on a generic SN transport solver that implements the AHOTN spatial discretization. Different types of semantic errors, e.g. removal of a line of code or changing a single character, are introduced randomly into the previously verified S{sub N} code and the proposed verification procedure is used to identify the coding mistakes (if possible) and classify them. Itemized by error type we record the stage of the verification procedure where the error is detected and report the frequency with which the errors are correctly identified at various stages of the verification. Errors that remain undetected by the verification procedure are further scrutinized to determine the reason why the introduced coding mistake eluded the verification procedure. The result of this work is that the verification procedure based on an order-of-accuracy test finds almost all detectable coding mistakes but rarely, 1.44% of the time, and under certain circumstances can fail. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

The General Atomics Center for Magnetohydrodynamic Modeling (CEMM) Final Report

The Center for Extended Magnetohydrodynamic Modeling (CEMM) is built around the further development, verification, validation, and other application of two major extended magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) codes NIMROD and M3D-C1. The General Atomics (GA) CEMM Program focuses on three main research areas: extension of the M3D-C1 MHD code plasma response calculations to new regimes, coupling of the DK4D drift kinetic equation solver to a temperature evolution equation, and simulations of disruption mitigation for unstable plasmas with pre-existing magnetic islands using massive gas injection (MGI) with the NIMROD MHD code. A systematic scan of the zero-crossing of the rotation profile in a DIII-D ITER-similar shape equilibrium using linear, time-independent modeling with M3D-C1 was performed. A new Python utility, autoC1, has been developed to automate the running of M3D-C1 for linear simulations. A number of ELM suppression experiments were analyzed including a validation and cross-code verification with the MARS-F MHD code of magnetic signal phase shifts across ELM-suppression bifurcations. A linearized, time-dependent temperature equation was tightly coupled to the electron and ion drift-kinetic equations (DKEs) in the DK4D drift-kinetic equation solver. Various explicit and implicit implementations were attempted, but all methods proved numerically unstable, even with the addition of numerical dissipation. Several simulations were completed investigating the effects of pre-existing islands on disruption mitigation by MGI in DIII-D using NIMROD.

3D MHD Simulation↗

Two-dimensional equations of the surface harmonics method for solving problems of spatial neutron kinetics in square-lattice reactors

Two-dimensional time-dependent finite-difference equations of the surface harmonics method (SHM) for the description of the neutron transport are derived for square-lattice reactors. These equations are implemented in the SUHAM-TD code. Verification of the derived equations and the developed code are performed by the example of known test problems, and the potential and efficiency of the SHM as applied to the solution of the time-dependent neutron transport equation in the diffusion approximation in two-dimensional geometry are demonstrated. These results show the substantial advantage of SHM over direct finite-difference modeling in computational costs.

74 ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS↗

(Doublon) Benchmarking of Different Inverse Point Kinetics Implementations for an Autocorrected Reactimeter Algorithm

In November 2017, the Transient Reactor Test Facility returned to operation. Since that time, many transient test series have been completed, such as the Transient Heatsink Overpower Response capsule (THOR), the Transient Water Irradiation System for TREAT (TWIST), and Sirius. Each has provided valuable data for materials performance and reactor safety that can be applied in future designs. During each experimental series, detector count rates provided important information on the core behavior during transients. However, a limitation of these data is that variations in the neutron distribution during experiments can cause errors when attempting to infer reactivity evolution from detector signals. Neutron physics codes can be used to compute the flux shape variations. However, this is a poor solution when the experimental data is used for code verification, validation and uncertainty quantification. Indeed, if the output of the code is used both as a reference and to correct what the reference is compared to, the circular dependency limits the quality of the verification, validation and uncertainty quantification approach. To overcome this problem, the autocorrected reactimeter algorithm (ACRA) has been developed. This approach infers a time-dependent reactivity evolution by testing different spatial corrections and selecting the one that minimizes reactivity variations when the core is in a frozen configuration (i.e., when there is no variation in parameters affecting reactivity). However, the scope of this method was limited to transients where there were negligible thermal feedback. Indeed, the core is never in a frozen configuration when the fuel temperature varies during the whole transient. This is our motivation for developing an improved version of the ACRA that does not require frozen configurations. To develop this new algorithm, we need a precise and unbiased implementation of the inverse point kinetic equations (IPKEs) as any error in the reactivity evaluation will be propagated into the choice of the optimal spatial correction. Indeed, the previous reactimeter algorithm would use approximations, such as a negligible flux amplitude derivative, to focus on rapidity. For the numerical validation of ACRA, we aim at absolute error under for reactivity derived from signals similar to the one of this study. In this summary, we test eight different IPKE implementations. Each will process a mockup signal built for this study, similar to those that the future ACRA will process. Each reactivity output will be compared to the reference reactivity that has been used to generate the mockup signal. The implementation minimizing the difference with the reference reactivity will be used in the development of a new ACRA formulation.

73 - NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Development of a Trajectory-Centric CFD-RBD Framework for Advanced Multidisciplinary/Multiphysics Simulation

The desire to model increasingly complex unsteady flow phenomena drives coupling of physics-based disciplinary analysis tools, such as coupled aerodynamics-rigid body dynamics simulations. This paper documents the creation of a framework linking the six-degree-of-freedom trajectory propagator POST2 with NASA’s FUN3D computational fluid dynamics flow solver. Cross-code verification between the framework and a CFD-centric 6DOF code is performed using the Army-Navy Finner projectile experiencing unsteady accelerating flow. Free-flight simulations of an entry vehicle ballistic range test are validated against physical and computational experiments.

Zachary J Ernst↗