Implications of shock effects in iron meteorites.
Shock loading history effect on solid state response of iron meteorites to annealing at moderate temperatures permits deductions about thermal history
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Shock loading history effect on solid state response of iron meteorites to annealing at moderate temperatures permits deductions about thermal history
Electron microprobe determinations of Si concentrations in metal of iron meteorites, showing weak evidence for Si presence in earth core
New data on high Ni-pallasites and IIIAB irons show a large variation in the PGE contents. Samples from different classes of iron meteorites and pallasites lie on a single isochron.
Recent Mo isotopic studies of meteorites reported evidence for differences in isotopic compositions for whole rocks of some primitive and differentiated meteorites relative to terrestrial materials. Enrichments of r- and p-process isotopes of up to 3-4 units (e unit = parts in 10(exp 4) over s-process dominated isotopes are the most prominent features. Certain types of presolar grains show large enrichments in s-process isotopes, however, it was concluded on grounds of mass balance that incomplete digestion of such grains cannot explain the enrichments of r- and p-process isotopes in whole rocks of primitive chondrites. If the reported variability in r- and p-process isotope enrichments reflects the true isotopic characteristics of the whole rocks, the implications are quite profound. It would suggest the presence of large scale Mo isotopic heterogeneity within the solar accretion disk with likely collateral effects for other elements. However, such effects were not found for Ru isotopes, nor for Zr isotopes. Another recent Mo isotopic study by multi collector ICP-MS could not confirm the reported deviations in Allende, Murchison or iron meteorites. Here, we present new results for the Mo isotopic composition of iron meteorites, chondrites and CAIs obtained by negative thermal ionization mass spectrometry (NTIMS). We discuss analytical aspects and the homogeneity of Mo isotopic compositions in solar system materials.
Sb concentrations determined by radiochemical neutron activation analysis in 60 iron meteorites range from 0.2 ng/g to 36 microg/g. The meteorites with the highest Sb concentrations are those of the nonmagmatic groups IAB and IIICD, while meteorites with the lowest Sb concentrations are found in groups IVA and IVB. In all groups Sb is positively correlated with Ni; slopes on log Sb vs log Ni plots decrease with increasing Ni. This decrease may reflect an increasing tendency to avoid schreibersite during the analysis of high-Ni meteorites because Sb partitions strongly into schreibersite. It is found that schreibersite from New Westville is enriched in Cr, Ni, Ge, As, Sb, and Au and depleted in Fe, Co, Ir; the Sb content in schreibersite is 540 times higher than the bulk metal value.
Experimental procedures for measuring trace element partitioning among metal and sulfide and silicate phases are described, and solid metal/liquid metal partition coefficients for minor and trace elements in the Fe-Ni system at 5 to 14% Ni are reported. The bulk compositions desired are homogenized at superliquidus temperature for 15-24 hours, held at a temperature in the solid/liquid two phase region for about 24 hours, and quenched to freeze in the equilibrium compositions. Run products are analyzed by electron microprobe. With the exception of Cr, all preliminary partition coefficients obtained are in the same sense as values derived from iron meteorites. The partition coefficients for Cr in solid metal/liquid metal and metal/troilite systems suggest that IIIAB and main group pallasites equilibrated with 9-22% troilite. A second method which makes it possible to place upper and lower limits on the partition coefficient by holding part of the sample at subliquidus and part at superliquidus temperatures, yielded significantly different results for the two metals tested (Au and Pt) from those obtained by the first method, demonstrating the importance of a close approach to equilibrium before using experimentally-determined partition coefficients to test empirical differentiation models for iron meteorites.
The partitioning of Ir, Ge, Ga, W, Cr, Au, P, and Ni between solid metal and metallic liquid is investigated as a function of temperature and the S-concentration of the metallic liquid. The partition coefficients for siderophile elements, such as Ir, W, Ga, and Ge, are found to increase by factors of 10-100 as the S-concentration of the metallic liquid increases from 0-30 wt percent. Partition coefficients for other siderophile elements, such as Ni, Au, and P, increase by factors of only 2-3. In contrast, a decrease is seen in the partition coefficients for the more chalcophile element Cr. These experimentally determined coefficients are used in conjunction with a fractional crystallization model to reproduce the geochemical behavior of Ni, P, Au, and Ir during the magmatic evolution of groups IIAB, IIIAB, IVA and IVB iron meteorites. The mean S-concentration for each group increases in the order IVB, IVA, IIIAB, IIAB, which is in accordance with cosmochemical prediction. However, the geochemical behavior of Ge, Ga, W, and Cr cannot be reproduced in an internally consistent way. It is concluded that the magmatic histories of these iron meteorite groups are more complex than has been generally assumed.
Parallels between the abundance patterns of moderately volatile elements in iron meteorites and ordinary chondrites are pointed out and discussed in relation to condensation processes in the solar nebula. The discussion is centered around a graph in which As, Cu, Ga, Ge to Ni ratios, normalized to CI chondrites, are compared for IVB, IVA, IVB, and IIIAB irons and H-group ordinary chondrites. The patterns suggest that the same volatile loss mechanism was at work for both IVB irons and ordinary chondrites, but was more efficient in the IVB process. A picture for the process at the IVB location is proposed, according to which condensation occurred when temperature decreased rapidly and trace metals condensed as a fine aerosol that was later blown away by a T-Tauri solar storm. Condensation at the H-group location was more complete because of a less rapid temperature decrease, allowing trace metals to diffuse deeper into Fe-Ni grains. Possible ways in which IVA conditions may have differed from IIIAB or H conditions are also proposed and discussed.
Tungsten concentrations have been determined by instrumental neutron activation in 104 iron meteorites, and range from 0.07 to 5 microg/g. In individual groups, concentrations vary by factors of between 1.5 and 8, but there are negative W-Ni correlations in 8 groups: IAB, IC, IIAB, IID, IIE, IIIAB, IIICD, and IIIF. The lowest W concentrations are found in groups IAB and IIICD, which also have the smallest slopes on a W-Ni plot. Eighteen anomalous irons have W concentrations between 5 microg/g (Butler) and 0.11 microg/g (Rafrueti). The distribution of W in irons shows similarities to that of other refractory sideophilic elements (except Mo), but is closest to the distribution of Ru and Pt. Assuming that chemical trends in group IIIAB were produced by fractional crystallization, a value of 1.6 can be deduced for the distribution coefficient of W between solid and liquid metal, as compared with 0.89 for Mo. Experimental evidence in support of these values is tenuous.
Published analyses of trace and minor elements in iron meteorites have been compiled and the distributions interpreted with the chemical groups defined by Wasson. When each element is plotted against Ni on log scales, groups are often clearly resolved with all the members of a group falling within the limits of sampling and analytical error on a straight line. Two fractionations have occurred, a primary event which established the bulk composition of each group and a secondary event which fractionated the elements within each group. Group I appears to have escaped the secondary fractionation. An examination of possible fractionation mechanisms suggests that the secondary process took place during solidification of iron cores in the parent bodies. The elements Ir, Os, Pt, Ru and Rh would be enriched in the early Ni-poor solid whilst As, Au, Co, Mo, P, Pd and Sb would concentrate in later solid and produce the observed positive correlations with Ni.-
Potassium feldspar phenocrysts in surface of Colomera octahedrite, discussing relationship to iron meteorites origin
Small positive anomalies in Ru-98 and Ru-99 in IIAB iron meteorites relative to a terrestrial standard may reflect Tc-Ru fractionation in the precursor metal of the asteroidal core.
Re-187 - Os-187 and Pt-190 - Os-186 isotope systems are applied to dating evolved iron meteorites. The Re-Os systematics of some evolved irons may indicate late stage system closure. This conclusion appears to be supported by a "young" Pt-Os isochron age.
The contents of nickel, cobalt, phosphorus, and carbon are tabulated for 38 iron meteorites. The samples used in the analyses are splits taken from larger samples made by milling chips from the surface of each meteorite. Individual splits from these larger samples give excellent analytical reproducibility. Previously developed criteria (Moore, Lewis, and Nava, 1969) are used to evaluate the quality of old analyses. The results of the old analyses are also tabulated.
Some of the properties of IAB and IIICD iron meteorites thought to be derived from partially differentiated planetesimals are summarized, and the physical aspects that may have controlled parent body differentiation and affected the composition of the sulfide melt are outlined. The chemical evolution of the parent body is then discussed, and observations supporting the partial differentiation model are examined. Finally, an attempt is made to reinterpret barometric and chronometric data in light of the partial differentiation model, and tentative conclusions are presented.
A neutron-activation study of 49 group-IVA irons shows much lower negative slopes on Ir-Au and Ir-As diagrams than observed in the larger magmatic group IIIAB. This difference seems to reflect the tendency of D(sub Ir), D(sub Au), and D(sub As) to increase with increasing S content. Contents of S and other volatiles are much lower in IVA irons than IIIAB irons. We show that both groups can be fit with Dx values that depend quadratically on S, with initial IVA S contents about 6X lower than those in IIIAB. The IVA scatter fields show a spread in Au or As at constant Ir that appears to reflect variations in the fraction of trapped melt between 0% and 30%. Copper shows an S-shaped trend that may reflect moderate positive and negative changes in D(sub Cu) as the magma evolved or, less likely, sampling variations in a broad band reflecting fractionation and trapping of melt. Gibeon, the largest IVA iron with a mass greater than 30 tons, shows an appreciable range in compositions consistent either with differences in the degree of magma crystallization or with differences in the content of trapped melt. A striking difference between IVA and IIIAB is observed in the Ir/Au ratios in the most Ir-rich irons in the groups; that in IVA is 40% lower than the IIIAB ratio, and lower than those in other iron-meteorite groups, The IVA Ir/Au ratio is about half the ratios in the chondrite groups. We examined three possible explanations of this anomaly: (1) the high-Ir irons contain large amounts of trapped melt: or (2) half of the IVA core (i.e., the first 50% to crystallize) is missing from the terrestrial set of IVA irons; or (3) the IVA magma formed by incomplete melting of the metal in the chondritic precursor material, with the metal that remained in the mantle having high Ir and low Au contents. Plausibility arguments favor the third possibility. The third scenario is the most plausible, but the second cannot be ruled out. We review recent evidence regarding the cooling rates in group IVA. In contrast to recent interpretations, we note several lines of evidence that indicate constant cooling rates independent of composition, as expected if all IVA meteorites were in the same core when cooling between 900 and 650 K occurred.
Fe-Ni-P phase diagram studies applied to schreibersite and rhabdite formation in iron meteorites
An equation is derived which approximates the Goldstein-Short graph for determining iron-meteorite cooling rates from kamacite bandwidths and Ni concentrations. The equation has the form