Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “microstructure characterization”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,603 records · Page 89

Mesoscopic-scale complexity in macroscopically-uniform plastic flow of an Al 0.3 CoCrFeNi high-entropy alloy

The concept of a smooth and homogeneous plastic flow of solids is nowadays constantly challenged by various observations of the self-organization of crystal defects on mesoscopic scales pertaining, e.g., to acoustic emission or the evolution of the local strain field. Such investigations would be of particular interest for High-Entropy Alloys (HEAs) characterized by extremely complex microstructures. However, the complexity of their deformation has been only studied in relation to the jerky flow. The present work explores a mesoscale complexity of the macroscopically-smooth plastic flow of an Al 0.3 CoCrFeNi alloy. Here, an inclusive approach involving various experimental methods and complementary nonlinear analyses allowed to reveal transitions between distinct dynamical regimes, which may be assimilated with noises of different colors, in particular the blue noise that is rarely observed in complex systems, and various kinds of reddened behavior. Such findings provide significant new insights into the micro/macro transition in the deformation behavior of HEAs.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Role of scan strategies and heat treatment on grain structure evolution in Fe-Si soft magnetic alloys made by laser-powder bed fusion

A major goal in printing soft magnetic Fe-Si steels using additive manufacturing is to take advantage of the potential for complex geometric designs and site-specific grain control. One major step in the processing of these alloys is understanding how processing parameters might impact how the as-built microstructure responds to annealing (i.e. the annealing response). The impact of scan strategy on the annealing response for thin wall geometries is specifically explored. Two scan strategies were explored for a thin wall geometry that produced a strongly columnar grain structure and equiaxed grain structure. Additionally, samples from both scan strategies annealed at 1200 °C showed a marked difference in annealing response with the more equiaxed sample seeing full recrystallization and grain growth, while the more columnar grain structure saw little change in microstructure. After analysis through characterization techniques and thermal-mechanical simulations Differences in internal energy within the grains were ruled out because calculated GND density values were similar for both samples. The formation of secondary particles was ruled out as a contributing factor due to the type of oxide formations and their size. It was concluded that the contributing factor to the difference in the annealing response were a difference in the resulting grain size and the density of high angle grain boundaries. These two differences were largely attributed to differences in the thermal gradient conditions due to grains preferentially growing in the direction of the steepest thermal gradient.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Improving fatigue performance of additively manufactured Ti-6Al-4V using sulfur-based self-terminating etching processes

The adoption of Additively Manufactured (AM) Ti-6Al-4V (Ti64) is continually increasing in the industry due to its benefits over the conventional manufacturing techniques. However, AM Ti64 parts are prone to poor surface finish, which significantly affects their fatigue performance. Therefore, AM Ti64 parts need post-processing to enhance surface finish and fatigue performance. Prior work with a sulfur-based self-terminating etching process for AM Ti64 demonstrated support removal and surface roughness reduction. To further this work, this manuscript details the impact of this sulfur-based post-processing technique on the mechanical properties and the fatigue life of AM Ti64 by characterizing the surface roughness, microstructural evolution, and fracture surfaces. Finally, this post-processing technique decreased the surface roughness parameter - S v by 55 % from 84 ± 11 µm to 38 ± 19 µm and increased the average fatigue life by 340 % from about 7000 cycles to 30,000 cycles.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Mesoscopic modeling of transport resistances in a polymer-electrolyte fuel-cell catalyst layer: Analysis of hydrogen limiting currents

Understanding transport resistances in a polymer-electrolyte fuel cell (PEFC) catalyst layer (CL) is essential to mitigate the unexpected voltage loss when using low loadings of precious metals. In this paper, we explore through mesoscopic modeling the quantification analyses of the transport resistances in CL as derived using hydrogen-pump limiting current. Numerical treatments on the conjugated interfacial conditions at interfaces of ionomer/pore and Pt/ionomer are proposed to describe the mesoscopic transport processes of hydrogen and proton. Characterizations of the reconstructed microstructure of CL are performed. Parameter analyses on the influences of the critical transport properties such as the permeation coefficient and the dissolution and adsorption reaction rates at the surfaces of ionomer/pore and Pt/ionomer on the local transport resistance are presented. It is found that the local transport resistance is mainly originated from the diffusion resistance of the ionomer thin-film, which is more resistive than its bulk analogue with its permeation coefficient fitted to be 5.9% of the bulk one. The interfacial transport resistances and the diffusion resistance are coupled. The local transport resistance increases with I/C ratio due to thicker ionomer coated on the particles. Higher Pt/C ratio and bare carbon fraction lead to higher local transport resistance since the ionomer loading relative to Pt roughness factor decreases. The local transport resistance decreases with the porosity. Furthermore, the contribution of pores to the CL resistance, which decreases with the porosity, is comparatively small at low loadings.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Reactive flash sintering of TiZrN and TiAlN ternary metal nitrides

Here, this study demonstrated the reactive flash sintering (RFS) for two powder mixtures: TiN-ZrN (both conducting) and AlN-TiN (TiN conducting but AlN insulating), targeting ternary metal nitrides (TMN) of Ti 0.5 Zr 0.5 N and Ti 0.5 Al 0.5 N, respectively. A constant volage and pressure (e.g., 8 V DC, ∼15 MPa) at room temperature triggered the flash (current density up to 27 A/mm 2 ) without pre-heating, and the entire RFS process finished in a few minutes. For TiZrN, the flash was instantaneous whereas for TiAlN, there was a long incubation before the flash followed by a quick and dramatic flash. Both conventional ex situ XRD and in situ synchrotron study had been carried out. They showed a uniform Ti 0.57 Zr 0.43 N solution formed in RFS and persisted upon cooling, while (Ti, Al) N solid solution formed at high temperature was not stable and likely went through a very quick phase separation in the cooling process. The final products from RFS had been characterized using SEM/EDS for microstructure. Both TiZrN and TiAlN were dense. Distribution of Ti, Zr, and N was uniform for TiZrN; for TiAlN, Ti and N distribution was uniform, while association of Al with oxygen was observed. TGA-DSC revealed the onset oxidation temperature for TiZrN was comparable to TiN and ZrN, while it was higher by ∼200 °C for TiAlN, likely due to the formation of Al 2 O 3 . In terms of mechanical properties such as hardness or fracture toughness, forming a single-phase solid solution (like TiZrN) does not offer obvious benefits. while large grain size from RFS seemed to be unfavorable. Future optimization of RFS condition and in-depth study by both experiments and simulation are needed to fully understand the composition-processing-structure-property relationships for such TMN from the reactive flash sintering process.

Flash Sintering↗

High pressure effects on EBC systems in high temperature environments

Environmental barrier coatings (EBCs) are designed to protect SiCfiber/SiCmatrix ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) in turbine engines by mitigating wear in high-temperature water vapor environments. The failure of EBCs is frequently attributed to the accelerated oxidation of the silicon bond coating layer when exposed to high-temperature steam, leading to the formation of a thickened thermally grown oxide (TGO). TGO growth increases interfacial stress, weakens adhesion, and results in coating spallation. Understanding the impact of high-temperature oxidation of EBC systems is essential for developing accurate lifespan models for turbine components, although pressurized oxidation testing is extremely sparse in the open literature. In this work, oxidation tests were performed on rare earth silicate EBCs coated onto SiC substrates under increased pressure conditions. The coated specimens were tested at 1100°C, 1200°C, and 1300°C at both 1 atm and 10 atm total pressure in steam environments. Subsequent characterization focused on the microstructural evolution of the EBC/Si/SiC system. The experimental findings indicated that TGO behavior is dependent on high-pressure conditions, with elevated pressure leading to an increase in oxide scale thickness and modifications in its morphology.

Ardrey, Kristyn [ORNL] (ORCID:0000000184407796)↗

Hybrid additive manufacturing of AISI 316L via asynchronous powder and hot-wire laser directed energy deposition

Hybrid Additive Manufacturing (AM) offers a way to leverage the advantages of different AM technologies, enabling the efficient production of sizeable parts without compromising material properties or geometric complexity capabilities. This study presents an asynchronous hybrid Directed Energy Deposition (DED) strategy employing laser powder DED and laser hot-wire DED. AISI 316L parts comprising multiple powder and wire segments were fabricated with optional machining on AISI 316L substrates to investigate how quality is impacted by (i) alternative process sequences (laser powder DED followed by laser hot-wire DED and vice versa), (ii) machined vs. as-printed interfacial conditions, and (iii) material deposition on top vs. alongside previously built segments. Optical microscopy, X-ray computed tomography, and Vickers hardness were used to characterize the morphology and microstructure of the parts, localized porosity and lack of fusion defects, bulk density, and mechanical properties. Interfacial machining was necessary for dimensional control but promoted lack of fusion voids, resulting in a 99.71 ± 0.01% dense part. As-printed interfaces resulted in a denser part (99.82 ± 0.02%) at the expense of dimensional accuracy. The hardness of the parts with as-printed and machined interfaces was 196 ± 0.37 HV and 192 ± 0.40 HV, respectively, compared to 156 ± 1.4 HV for the substrate. Depositing powder alongside or on top of wire sections resulted in interfaces with a hardness of 217 ± 2.2 HV, compared to 185 ± 3.4 HV for the wire-powder interfaces.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

U 3 Si 2 behavior in H 2 O environments: Part II, pressurized water with controlled redox chemistry

Recent interest in U 3 Si 2 as an advanced light water reactor fuel has driven assessment of numerous properties, but characterization of its response to H 2 O environments is sparse in available literature. The behavior of U 3 Si 2 in H 2 O containing atmospheres is investigated and presented in a two-part series of articles. This work examines the behavior of U 3 Si 2 following exposure to pressurized H 2 O at temperatures from 300 to 350 °C. Testing was performed using two autoclave configurations and multiple redox conditions. Use of solid state buffers to attain a controlled water chemistry is also presented as a means to test actinide-bearing systems. Buffers were used to vary the hydrogen concentration between 1 and 30 parts per million H 2 . Testing included UN, U 3 Si 5 , and UO 2 . Both UN and U 3 Si 5 were found to rapidly pulverize in less than 5 h at 300 °C. Uranium dioxide was included as a control for the autoclave system, and was found to be minimally impacted by exposure to pressurized water at the conditions tested for extended time periods. Testing of U 3 Si 2 at 300 °C found reasonable stability through 30 days in 1–5 ppm H 2 . However, pulverization was observed following 35 days. The redox condition of testing strongly affected pulverization. Characterization of the resulting microstructures suggests that the mechanism responsible for pulverization under more strongly reducing conditions differs from that previously identified. Hydride formation is hypothesized to drive this transition. In conclusion, testing performed at 350 °C resulted in rapid pulverization of U 3 Si 2 in under 50 h.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Production and characterization of TRISO fuel particles with multilayered SiC

Three distinct composite architectures of silicon carbide (SiC) and pyrocarbon (PyC) were incorporated into the SiC coating layer of tristructural-isotropic (TRISO) nuclear fuel particles. The composite architectures are meant to increase the resistance of SiC coating layer to cracking and fission product attack during operation and accident scenarios. All composite layers were produced using the existing fluidized bed chemical vapor deposition apparatus that is used for production of TRISO fuel particles without modifications. Detailed characterization of the composite microstructure was carried out via optical and electron microscopy. Nano-indentation examination confirms that mechanical properties of the SiC phase was not affected in the composite architectures, however, the resistance to crack propagation in this coating layer was greatly increased in all cases when compared to the reference monolithic coating layer. The stress required to debond the SiC-inner PyC interface in the reference TRISO particles was determined to be ~1 GPa using micropillar compression technique. The high strength may explain the ease of crack propagation from the inner PyC to SiC in the reference design. In the composite architectures, the means of crack deflection were effectively incorporated at this interface. Lastly, finite element analysis of stress evolution in the fuel particles during normal operation with the reference and composite SiC coating layer architectures did not show any significant differences between the variants.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Atom Probe Tomography Characterization of High-Dose Ion Irradiated MA957

This paper presents a comprehensive characterization study of the microstructural responses to ion irradiation of the oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) ferritic alloy MA957 using atom probe tomography (APT). The MA957 specimens were irradiated by 1.8 MeV Cr3+ ions to doses and temperatures relevant to advanced fast reactors (100 and 500 dpa at 400-500 °C). The average sizes of the YTiO particles decreased slightly after irradiation at all temperatures, with the most pronounced change at 400 °C. The particle number densities for 400 and 500 °C were slightly below number densities for the unirradiated condition, while the values were slightly higher at 420 and 450 °C. This behavior is consistent with the Nelson-Hudson-Mazey rate theory model that considers the competing effects between recombination and dissolution. An increase in the Y/Ti ratio of the YTiO particles was observed at the two lower temperatures. The formation of Cr-rich precipitates (a') was observed in specimens irradiated at temperatures up to 450 °C. Irradiation-induced segregation on grain boundaries was also investigated. Grain boundary element concentration profiles and ion maps demonstrate differences among the irradiation temperatures, with most datasets differing from the unirradiated condition. A key focus of this ion irradiation study is the high-dose response, and this quantitative assessment revealed relatively small but distinct effects of irradiation on microstructure evolution. Overall, these results showing minor second phase evolution suggest that MA957 should retain mechanical performance generally well up to 500 dpa for the irradiation temperatures studied.

Wang, Jing↗

Fabrication and thermophysical properties of UO 2 -UB 2 and UO 2 -UB 4 composites sintered via spark plasma sintering

Uranium dioxide (UO 2 ) composites with uranium diboride (UB 2 ) and uranium tetraboride (UB 4 ) have been proposed as advanced fuel candidates due to their high thermal conductivity, high melting point, high fissile density and their ability to incorporate a built-in burnable poison by tailoring the targeted 10 B/ 11 B ratio. As such, it is important to assess the fabrication, and thermal and micromechanical properties of such composites. In this work, UO 2 -UB 2 and UO 2 -UB 4 samples with boride phase fractions of 5, 15 and 30 wt% were fabricated to high densities (above 95 % theoretical density) via spark plasma sintering (SPS). This enabled sintering at relatively low temperatures and short timescales. SPS also aided in maintaining the target phase fractions of the samples as reactions between the constituent phases were suppressed due to the short timescales and reducing environment during sintering. Here, thermal diffusivity measurements from 299 to 1273 K were conducted through laser flash analysis (LFA). The diffusivity increased as a function of boride weight fraction, and UB 2 additions increased the thermal diffusivity of the composites more than UB 4 additions. Assessment of the LFA results indicated in-situ reactions between the UO 2 and boride phases that suppress the thermal diffusivity occur above 800 K for all samples. Oxidation of the boride phase was proposed as the underlying reaction. This was supported by thermodynamic assessments from the literature, as well as microstructural, crystallographic, and nanoindentation characterization performed on these samples.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Corrosion behavior of ferritic FeCrAl alloys in simulated BWR normal water chemistry

Ferritic iron-chromium-aluminum (FeCrAl) alloys with varying Cr content were subjected to in-situ irradiation-corrosion with energetic protons or electron beams in pure water with various oxygen concentrations. Oxide microstructure and composition were characterized to compare the corrosion under irradiation with the thermal corrosion in the same water conditions. The dominant effect seems to be the production of H 2 O 2 at the surface by the intense proton and electron beams. The corrosion potential of FeCrAl under BWR-NWC condition is somewhat above the Cr 2 O 3 /CrO 4 2- phase boundary, oxidizing the Cr(III) to Cr(VI) in the outer part of the film, but with some Cr(III) remaining in the interior of the oxide. The beam increases the corrosion potential, significantly reducing Cr(III) content throughout the oxide. Finally, the crystallites on the surface, which form by re-precipitation from solution, do not contain Cr because at low potential Cr(III) is not soluble, and at high potential Cr(VI) is quite soluble.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Depth-resolved thermal conductivity and damage in swift heavy ion irradiated metal oxides

We investigated thermal transport in swift heavy ion (SHI) irradiated insulating single crystalline oxide materials: yttrium aluminum garnet- Y 3 Al 5 O 12 (YAG), sapphire (Al 2 O 3 ), zinc oxide (ZnO) and magnesium oxide (MgO) irradiated by 167 MeV Xe ions at 10 12 – 10 14 ions/cm 2 fluences. Depth profiling of the thermal transport on nano- and micro- meter scales was assessed by time-domain thermoreflectance (TDTR) and modulated thermoreflectance (MTR) methods, respectively. This combination allowed us to isolate the conductivities of different sub-surface damage-regions characterized by their distinct microstructure evolution regimes. Thermal conductivity degradation in SHI irradiated YAG and Al 2 O 3 is attributed to formation of ion tracks and subsequent amorphization, while in ZnO and MgO it is mostly due to point defects. Additionally, notably lower conductivity when probed by very low penetrating thermal waves is consistent with surface hillock formation. An analytical model based on Klemens-Callaway method for thermal conductivity coupled with a simplified microstructure evolution capturing saturation in defect concentration was used to obtain depth dependent damage across the ion impacted region. The studies showed that YAG has the highest damage profile resulting in the less dependence of thermal conductivity with the depth, while MgO on the contrary has the strongest dependence. The presented work sheds new light on how SHI induced defects affect thermal transport degradation and recovery of oxide ceramics as promising candidates for next generation nuclear reactor applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Defect-specific strength factors and superposition model for predicting strengthening of ion irradiated Fe18Cr alloy

Here, a high-purity binary alloy Fe18Cr was subjected to heavy-ion irradiation in order to provide improved understanding of the irradiation effect on radiation hardening associated with dislocation loop and network formation, α’ precipitation. The specimens were irradiated with 8 MeV Fe ions (~2 μm ion range) to midrange doses of 0.37 and 3.7 dpa at 300, 350 and 450 °C using dose rates of ~10 –5 –10 –3 dpa/s. Nanoindentation testing was performed to extract the bulk equivalent hardness at low depth from these ion irradiated specimens. High-quality transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images were acquired by utilizing a flash electropolishing method on the Focused Ion Beam (FIB) prepared liftouts. An accurate calculation of the strength factor was provided based on detailed TEM characterization of the irradiated microstructures. A newly refined hardening superposition method was applied to combine the strengthening components from each microstructure. The good agreement between microstructure predicted strength and measured strength further demonstrated the fidelity to use hardening model to quantify the mechanical properties of ion irradiated materials.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Formation of uranium nitride nanoparticles via mechanical alloying of uranium-molybdenum alloy fuels in gaseous nitrogen

Uranium-molybdenum (U-Mo) alloys show promise as a nuclear fuel system due to their high thermal conductivity and fuel loading capability. However, U-Mo systems are susceptible to irradiation induced swelling ultimately affecting the cladding via mechanical and chemical interactions. To address these shortcomings, this research investigated the formation of uranium mononitride (UN) nanoparticles within a 90 wt% U/10 wt% Mo (U-10Mo) matrix to act as a prospective defect sink for fission products at nanometric hetero-interfaces. To promote the formation of UN, U-10Mo powders were mechanically alloyed under a high purity nitrogen atmosphere. Variations of the milling process investigated included media size, duration of milling, and number of times the milling jar was re-aerated with nitrogen gas. Characterization of the fuel microstructure was completed using light element analysis, X-ray diffraction, scanning and transmission-electron microscopy, electron energy loss spectroscopy, and atom probe tomography. UN nanoparticles measuring 1–5 nm in radius were observed in the U-Mo matrix as early as 1 h into the mechanical alloying process. Milling time in excess of 10 h was found to lead to deleterious effects induced by the stainless-steel milling media.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Post-irradiation examination of AGR-3/4 TRISO fuel compacts using three-dimensional X-ray computed tomography

The AGR-3/4 irradiation tests combined the third and fourth planned irradiation experiments in the US Department of Energy’s Advanced Gas Reactor (AGR) testing campaign of tri-structural isotropic (TRISO) fuel compacts. In this article, we present post-irradiation examination (PIE) using X-ray computed tomography (XCT) of two unirradiated and two irradiated compacts from the AGR-3/4 irradiation tests. The irradiated compacts studied (compact 7–1 and compact 12–4) represent the upper and lower limit of burnup within the AGR-3/4 irradiation experiment. This article presents a detailed quantitative analysis on the post-irradiation structure of TRISO fuel compacts. Various quantitative parameters including shape, size, and packing of kernels, and their spatial distribution, were utilized to gain insights into the structural changes caused by irradiation. The equivalent diameter and sphericity were found to increase and decrease, respectively, in irradiated compact 7–1 due to its higher burnup. Nearest neighbor distance between fuel kernels decreased after irradiation, suggesting irradiation-induced shrinkage of graphitic matrix. Furthermore, each compact in AGR-3/4 irradiation tests contained 20 designed-to-fail (DTF) fuel particles that were meant to act as a source of fission product release to the experiment test train. Furthermore, in the present work, all DTF fuel particles in the four compacts studied were identified, and it was found that they exhibited larger kernel swelling in compact 12–4 and smaller kernel swelling in compact 7–1, compared to the driver particles.

11 - NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Archaeometallurgical investigation of the iron anchor from the Tantura F shipwreck

The Tantura F shipwreck was a coaster or a fishing vessel about 15.7 m long, discovered in the Dor/Tantura lagoon, Israel in 1995. It was dated to between the mid-7th and the end of the 8th centuries CE. Among the finds excavated were two T-shaped type iron anchors. Of the two anchors, one (anchor A) was thoroughly studied by archaeometallurgical methods in order to identify forge-welding lines, to determine the welding quality and to understand the manufacturing technology. The examinations included X-ray radiography, XRF analysis, optical microscopy, SEM/EDS observation and analysis, OES analysis and microhardness tests. The investigation included characterization of the composition, microstructure, thermal treatments, forge-welding junctions and slag analysis. The results revealed a heterogeneous microstructure, rich in glassy, fayalite and wüstite slag. Iron based phases included ferrite, pearlite, cementite and Widmanstätten plates, all typical to wrought iron. The forge-welds of Anchor A were located. Each arm was made of one piece, weighing about 2.5–3 kg and the shank was made of a few 1.5–2 kg pieces. The second anchor (anchor B) was only briefly examined visually and with a few radiographs, which support the results from anchor A. The research results revealed significant information about T-shaped anchors and their manufacturing process, including hot-working processes without any additional heat treatments, and folding techniques. The microstructure was similar to other ancient simple tools such as saws, sickles, axes and mortise chisels, and though the technology to make complicated structures and objects, such as swords, existed at that time, the anchors did not require this sophistication; thus simpler techniques were used, presumably because they were more cost-effective. - Highlights: ► Tantura F was a coaster dated to mid-7th–end-8th centuries. ► Two iron anchors were discovered at the Tantura F shipwreck-site. ► Anchor A was manufactured from heterogeneous wrought iron blooms. ► Forge-welding lines were detected using archaeometallurgical methods.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Characterization of a 12-pdr wrought-iron cannonball from the Akko 1 shipwreck

The Akko 1 shipwreck, discovered in Akko harbor, Israel, is the remains of an eastern Mediterranean brig built at the beginning of the 19th century. Among other finds, eleven cannonballs were found in the shipwreck and three of them were retrieved. Two of the cannonballs, the 9- and 24-pdrs, have been studied previously. The present study of the 12-pdr cannonball included γ-rays radiographic testing, XRF analysis, density measurements, optical microscopy and SEM-EDS observation, OES analysis and microhardness tests. The investigation included characterization of the composition, microstructure and slag analysis. The results revealed a quite homogenous microstructure of α-ferrite phase, with glassy, wüstite and fayalite slags, as typical for a wrought-iron—annealed product, a more complicated and an earlier technology, compared to the 9- and 24-pdr that were made of cast-iron. Ferritic cannonballs are extremely rare, especially in the 19th century, when cannonballs were manufactured of cast iron by the sand casting process. The different manufacturing methods may indicate a different place of fabrication, and an apparently earlier production date for the 12-pdr, which might have even been used as ballast. - Highlights: • Three cannonballs were retrieved from the 19th century Akko 1 shipwreck. • The 12-pdr differs from the 9- and 24-pdr cannonballs previously studied. • The 12-pdr was made of high quality annealed wrought-iron, not of cast-iron. • The technology used indicates a date earlier than the middle of the 19th century. • Perhaps the 12-pdr belonged to another navy than the other two or used as ballast.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗