Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Defect modelling”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 163 records · Page 9
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2025

Defect Thermodynamics and Transport Properties of Proton Conducting Perovskite Electrode and Electrolyte Materials Evaluated Based on Density Functional Theory Modeling

Both electron-rich and electron-poor perovskite oxides have been used in solid oxide cell applications as electrode and electrolyte materials. The rich oxygen defect chemistry and its coupling to temperature, hydrogen-steam or oxygen-steam gas pressure, or to the applied potentials creates enormous complexities for modeling performance and degradation of the materials. Herein, density functional theory-based thermodynamic modeling was carried out to describe the defect chemistry and transport properties of the proton-conducting electrolyte BaZr1-xYxO3-δ (x≤0.1) and of the triple-conducting perovskite (La,Ba)(Fe,M)O3-δ (M=Y and Zr). The defect thermodynamics of intrinsic point defects and the hydrogen-related defect reactions were solved in integrated defect models and further used to predict the Brouwer diagram and the transport properties of the functional perovskites. For the electron-poor electrolytes BaZr0.9Y0.1O3-δ, the developed model has been used to describe the experimental transport properties in the SOC operating conditions. Specifically, the roles played by the acceptor-bound holes and the intrinsic and hydrogen point defects upon the conductivities of holes, protons, and oxygen vacancies under the hydrogen-rich and oxygen-rich conditions at various humidity levels were demonstrated. A defect modeling tool was also developed for the triple-conducting perovskite (La,Ba)(Fe,M)O3-δ (M=Y and Zr) to examine magnetic effects and hydride defects in defect equilibria.

defect thermodynamics↗
DOE OSTI2022

Pulsed Thermal Tomography Nondestructive Examination of Additively Manufactured Reactor Materials and Components (Final Technical Report)

Metal Additive Manufacturing (AM) is a promising method for cost-efficient fabrication of complex shape structures for applications in harsh environment, such as in a nuclear reactor. However, internal defects (pores) occur in high-strength AM alloys, which are manufactured with Laser Powder Bed Fusion (LPBF) AM method. Pulsed Infrared Thermography (PIT) is an efficient nondestructive evaluation (NDE) method to examine actual structures, because this method offers one-sided non-contact measurements, and fast processing of large sample areas. However, imaging of material defects, particularly defects with sizes at microscopic level, is challenging. In this report, we benchmark the performance of several Unsupervised Learning (UL) algorithms designed to enhance imaging of microscopic defects in metals with PIT. UL aims to learn the latent principal patterns (dictionaries) in PIT data to detect defects with minimal human supervision. Performance of Independent Component Analysis (ICA), Sparse Coding (SC), Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA) was compared using F-score, UL model training time and defects reconstruction time. We obtained the average F-score of 0.75, and a highest F-score of 0.89 for the EFA algorithm. Overall, EFA outperforms other UL algorithms considered in this study. In another approach, we investigate Thermal Tomography (TT), which is a computational method for reconstruction of depth profile of internal material defects from PIT nondestructive evaluation (NDE). TT algorithm obtains depth reconstructions of thermal effusivity, which has been shown to provide visualization of subsurface internals defects in metals. In many applications, one needs to determine the defect shape and orientation from reconstructed effusivity images. Interpretation of TT images is non-trivial because of blurring, which increases with depth due to heat diffusion-based nature of image formation. We have developed a deep learning convolutional neural network (CNN) to classify size and orientation of subsurface material defects in TT images. CNN was trained with TT images produced with computer simulations of 2D metallic structures (thin plates) containing elliptical subsurface voids. Performance of CNN was investigated using test TT images developed with computer simulations of plates containing elliptical defects, and defects with shape imported from scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images. CNN demonstrated the ability to classify radii and angular orientation of elliptical defects in previously unseen test TT images. We have also demonstrated that CNN trained on TT images of elliptical defects is capable of classifying shape and orientation of irregular defects. Training the CNN on irregular defect shapes instead of on elliptical shapes would make the resulting classifications more descriptive of actual defect shapes. However, this requires a much higher volume of SEM images of material defects, which are difficult to obtain because of random occurrence of defects in LPBF. To address this challenge, we developed a generative adversarial network (GAN) to augment the existing dataset of SEM defect images. The GAN model is demonstrated to create novel yet realistic defect shapes that can be used as input for simulated PTT images to train CNN. We also investigate several approaches based on Gaussian Random Circle and Bezier Curves for constructing parametric models of irregular-shape defects.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2026

Chirality reversal at finite magnetic impurity strength and local signatures of a topological phase transition

Here, we study the honeycomb lattice with a single magnetic impurity modeled by adding imaginary next-nearest-neighbor hopping 𝑖⁢ℎ on a single hexagon. This Haldane defect gives a topological mass term to the gapless Dirac cones and generates chirality. For a small density of defects, Neehus et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 126604 (2025)] found that the system's chirality reverses at a critical ℎ 𝑐 ≈ 0.95 associated with an unexpected tricritical point of Dirac fermions at zero defect density. We investigate this zero-density limit by analyzing a single defect and computing two experimentally relevant measures of chirality: (1) orbital magnetization via local Chern marker, a bulk probe of all occupied states; and (2) electronic currents of low-energy states. Both probes show a chirality reversal at a critical ℎ 𝑐 ≈ 0.9–1.0. Motivated by this consistency, we propose a defect-scale toy model whose low-energy states reverse their chirality at ℎ$^{'}_{c}$ ≈ 0.87. Remarkably, the same pair of zero-energy bound states also generates the critical point ℎ 𝑐 in the full impurity projected T-matrix. Our results show how the chirality reversal produced by an impurity can be observed either in local probes or in the global topology, and suggest a possible role of the microscopic defect structure at the critical point.

Chern insulators↗
DOE OSTI2026

The critical role of intrinsic defects and many-body interactions on the stability of MnBi2Te4

Intrinsic antisite defects pose a major challenge to understanding and predicting the exotic properties of the layered topological magnetic insulator MnBi2Te4 (MBT). In this work, we study the origin of the abundance of intrinsic defects in MBT, including many-body defect–defect interactions and many-body electronic correlations. Until now, ab initio methods have struggled to explain thermodynamic stability and properties influenced by defect behavior in MBT. We model native Mn–Bi antisite defects in MBT at finite temperatures using a cluster expansion that includes defect–defect interactions. To overcome the limitations of conventional density functional theory (DFT), we introduce a hybrid approach that incorporates high-accuracy quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) calculations, introducing missing correlations. This strategy allows for accurate estimation of defect energetics and finite-temperature properties. We compute the configurational free energy, defect concentration, and configurational heat capacity, revealing a second-order order–disorder phase transition near the experimental synthesis temperature. Our study provides the first theoretical insight into the thermodynamics of intrinsic defects in MBT. The negative free energy relative to pristine MBT at synthesis temperatures indicates that Mn–Bi antisite formation is thermodynamically spontaneous. We also present a broadly applicable general framework for correcting low-level theoretical theories using highly accurate many-body corrections from QMC.

Ghaffar, Abdul [ORNL] (ORCID:0000000241190168)↗
DOE OSTI2020

Point defect evolution under irradiation: Finite size effects and spatio-temporal correlations

The evolution of point defect concentrations under irradiation is controlled by their diffusion properties, and by their formation and elimination mechanisms. The latter includes the mutual recombination of vacancies and interstitials, and the elimination of point defects at sinks. Two models are traditionally used to predict the defect concentration evolution, the standard rate theory (SRT) and the atomistic kinetic Monte Carlo (AKMC). We show in this work a large discrepancy in the defect concentrations between both methods when the average number of defects in the AKMC simulation box is close or lower than one. The reason is that AKMC naturally captures strong space and time correlations between vacancies and interstitials generated by the finite size of the periodic simulation box. These correlations strongly affect the recombination rate and the point defect concentrations. SRT fails to predict such correlations, and the corresponding solution deviates from the more accurate solution given by the AKMC simulation under similar conditions. These finite size correlation effects are strong when the elimination of point defects occurs by recombination only, but can still be significant in the presence of sinks. In order to account for the spacio-temporal correlation in a continuum framework, we introduce a Correlated Pair Theory (CPT). This theory fully takes into account the correlations between vacancy and interstitial pairs and predicts point defect concentrations in good agreement with AKMC simulations. Inversely, if the goal is for the AKMC to reproduce defect concentrations in bulk using small simulation boxes, the naturally occurring correlations need to be corrected. We show here that the CPT can be used to modify the elimination rates in the AKMC simulations, so as to yield point defect concentrations in agreement with SRT.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗
DOE OSTI2021

Thermal conductivity of α -U with point defects

Here, we develop a theoretical model for thermal conductivity of α-U that combines density functional theory calculations and the coupled electron–phonon Boltzmann transport equation. The model incorporates both electron and phonon contributions to thermal conductivity and achieves good agreement with experimental data over a wide temperature range. The dominant scattering mechanism governing thermal transport in α-U at different temperatures is examined. By including phonon–defect and electron–defect scatterings in the model, we study the effect of point defects including U-vacancy, U-interstitial, and Zr-substitution on the thermal conductivity of α-U. The degradation of anisotropic thermal conductivity due to point defects as a function of defect concentration, defect type, and temperature is reported. This model provides insights into the impact of defects on both phonon and electron thermal transport. It will promote the fundamental understanding of thermal transport in α-U and provide a ground for investigation of coupled electron–phonon transport in metallic materials.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2024

Electrochemical grand potential-based phase-field simulation of electric field-assisted sintering

Here, an electrochemical grand potential functional was proposed to describe the sintering of an ionic ceramic green body. The resultant phase-field description enables simulation of the consolidation of an arbitrary number of granular particles and their interactions with the surrounding void phase. The model includes the effects of charged vacancies and the associated interactions between internal and applied electric fields. Defect segregation to grain boundaries is also accounted for, as well as enhanced interfacial defect mobilities. The model was parameterized for Y 2 O 3 . Simulations of two-particle systems showed that the applied electric field had an increasingly important impact on neck growth as particle size increased. A sudden rapid increase in temperature occurred for larger field strengths, which has been reported to be correlated to the onset of a flash event in flash sintering. Simulations of many particles showed that internal heat generation by Joule heating was localized at particle–particle contacts (grain boundaries), even though their conductivities were lower than nearby internal particle-void interfaces. A percolative path for ionic charge across the green body and the ceramic sintered solid was thus defined, accelerating the Joule heating process as the porosity of the green body is removed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

An all optical approach for comprehensive in-operando analysis of radiative and nonradiative recombination processes in GaAs double heterostructures

We demonstrate an all optical approach that can surprisingly offer the possibility of yielding much more information than one would expect, pertinent to the carrier recombination dynamics via both radiative and nonradiative processes when only one dominant deep defect level is present in a semiconductor material. By applying a band-defect state coupling model that explicitly treats the inter-band radiative recombination and Shockley–Read–Hall (SRH) recombination via the deep defect states on an equal footing for any defect center occupation fraction, and analyzing photoluminescence (PL) as a function of excitation density over a wide range of the excitation density (e.g., 5–6 orders in magnitude), in conjunction with Raman measurements of the LO-phonon plasmon (LOPP) coupled mode, nearly all of the key parameters relevant to the recombination processes can be obtained. They include internal quantum efficiency (IQE), minority and majority carrier density, inter-band radiative recombination rate (W r ), minority carrier nonradiative recombination rate (W nr ), defect center occupation fraction (f), defect center density (N t ), and minority and majority carrier capture cross-sections (σ t and σ tM ). While some of this information is thought to be obtainable optically, such as IQE and the W r /W nr ratio, most of the other parameters are generally considered to be attainable only through electrical techniques, such as current-voltage (I-V) characteristics and deep level transient spectroscopy (DLTS). Following a procedure developed herein, this approach has been successfully applied to three GaAs double-heterostructures that exhibit two distinctly different nonradiative recombination characteristics. The method greatly enhances the usefulness of the simple PL technique to an unprecedented level, facilitating comprehensive material and device characterization without the need for any device processing.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2024

An Analytical Tool to Evaluate Defect Thermodynamics of (La,Ba)Fe1-xMxO3-δ Perovskites for Solid-Oxide Cell Applications

A modeling tool of the defect thermodynamics of (La,Ba)Fe1-xMxO3-δ perovskites which includes energetic information about oxygen vacancy formation, hydration, hydride formation, and charge disproportionation reactions has been developed1. This tool incorporates defect energies and entropies expressed as sixth order polynomial functions to allow refinements of the defect reaction equilibrium constants in the thermodynamic analysis. Calculation of (La,Ba)Fe1-xMxO3-δ Brouwer diagrams as a function of pO2/pH2O and pH2/H2O in a range of temperatures of interest is facilitated by this modeling tool. The results obtained can provide direct guidance how the electronic and ionic defect concentrations of the triple conducting perovskite materials can be used to optimize performance of solid oxide cells for energy applications. The impact of magnetic and electronic structures of the perovskites on the defect reaction energies and entropies as obtained from density function theory modeling and the role played by hydride defect species will also be discussed.

Lee, Yueh-Lin↗
DOE OSTI2025

Diffusion Quantum Monte Carlo Benchmarking of Magnetic Moments in MnBi 2 Te 4

The intrinsically antiferromagnetic topological insulator, MnBi 2 Te 4 (MBT), has garnered significant attention recently due to its potential to host numerous exotic topological quantum states. Unfortunately, their consistent realization has been hindered by intrinsic antisite defects among the Mn and Bi sublattices. In this work, we establish Mn magnetization of pristine MBT through high level diffusion Monte Carlo calculations, which can serve as a precise starting point for various models to estimate antisite defect concentrations in actual MBT samples. The benchmark quality of DMC calculations is further identified from out model estimating antisite defect concentrations, which combines the benchmarked Mn magnetization with data from magnetic susceptibility and intermediate field magnetization measurements. This reproduces well Bi Mn and Mn Bi concentrations measured in the experiments. Here, we anticipate these theoretically based magnetic purity measures may be used as minimization targets in cycles of refinement to synthesize MBT with low antisite defect concentrations and more reproducible topological properties.

Defects↗
DOE OSTI2021

Multiscale Concurrent Atomistic-Continuum (CAC) modeling of multicomponent alloys

We report strengthening in complex multicomponent systems such as solid solution alloys is controlled primarily by the dynamic interactions between dislocation lines and heterogeneously distributed solute species. Modeling of extended defect length scales in such multicomponent systems becomes prohibitively expensive, motivating the development of reduced order approaches. This work explores the application of the Concurrent Atomistic-Continuum (CAC) method to model dislocation mobility in random alloys at extended length scales. By employing recently developed average-atom interatomic potentials, the average “bulk” material response in coarse-grained regions interacts with true random solute species in the atomistic-scale domain. We demonstrate that spurious stresses in domain resolution transition regions are eliminated entirely due to the CAC formulation. Simultaneously, the key details of local stress fluctuation due to randomness in the dislocation core region are captured, and fluctuating stress smoothly decays to the long-range dislocation stress field response. Dislocation mobility calculations, for line lengths over 400 nm, are computed as a function of alloy composition in the model FeNiCr system and compared to full molecular dynamics (MD). The results capture the composition-dependent trends, while reducing degrees of freedom by nearly 40%. This approach can be readily extended to any system described by an EAM potential and facilitates the study of large-scale defect dynamics in complex solute environments to support computational alloy design.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Complexions at the iron-magnetite interface

Synthesizing distinct phases and controlling crystalline defects are key concepts in materials design. These approaches are often decoupled, with the former grounded in equilibrium thermodynamics and the latter in nonequilibrium kinetics. By unifying them through defect phase diagrams, we can apply phase equilibrium models to thermodynamically evaluate defects—including dislocations, grain boundaries, and phase boundaries—establishing a theoretical framework linking material imperfections to properties. Using scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) with differential phase contrast (DPC) imaging, we achieve the simultaneous imaging of heavy Fe and light O atoms, precisely mapping the atomic structure and chemical composition at the iron-magnetite (Fe/Fe 3 O 4 ) interface. We identify a well-ordered two-layer interface-stabilized phase state (referred to as complexion) at the Fe[001]/Fe 3 O 4 [001] interface. Using density-functional theory (DFT), we explain the observed complexion and map out various interface-stabilized phases as a function of the O chemical potential. The formation of complexions increases interface adhesion by 20% and alters charge transfer between adjacent materials, impacting transport properties. Our findings highlight the potential of tunable defect-stabilized phase states as a degree of freedom in materials design, enabling optimized corrosion protection, catalysis, and redox-driven phase transitions, with applications in materials sustainability, efficient energy conversion, and green steel production.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Analysis of Defects in Metal Additive Manufacturing with Augmented Data Generation

Laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) is a method of additive manufacturing (AM) that selectively melts and fuses together microscopic metallic powder. LPBF offers the benefit of producing custom structures out of high strength metals that can be difficult to fabricate with conventional methods. The challenge of LPBF is that 3D printed structures often have internal pores due to process flaws. Pulsed thermal tomography (PTT) is a method for reconstructing the depth profile of materials, allowing the visualization internal voids in solids. In prior work, we developed a convolutional neural network (CNN) which, having been trained on simulated 2D PTT images of subsurface elliptical defects, was able to classify the semi-major radii, semi-minor radii, and angular orientation of the best-fit ellipses in previously unseen PTT images. The unseen PTT images contained subsurface irregular defect shapes imported from scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images of metallic LPBF-printed specimens. Training the CNN on irregular defect shapes instead of on elliptical shapes would make the resulting classifications more descriptive of actual defect shapes. However, this requires a much higher volume of SEM images of material defects, which are difficult to obtain because of random occurrence of defects in LPBF. To address this challenge, we developed a generative adversarial network (GAN) to augment the existing dataset of SEM defect images. The GAN model is demonstrated to create novel yet realistic defect shapes that can be used as input for simulated PTT images to train CNN.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Microscopic examination of rf-cavity-quality niobium films through local nonlinear microwave response

The performance of superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) cavities is sometimes limited by local defects. To investigate the rf properties of these local defects, especially those that nucleate rf magnetic vortices, a near-field magnetic microwave microscope is employed. Local third-harmonic response ( P 3 f ) and its temperature dependence and rf power dependence are measured for one Nb / Cu film grown by direct current magnetron sputtering (DCMS) and six Nb / Cu films grown by high-power impulse magnetron sputtering (HiPIMS) with systematic variation of deposition conditions. Five out of the six HiPIMS Nb / Cu films show a strong third-harmonic response that is likely coming from rf vortex nucleation due to a low- T c surface defect with a transition temperature between 6.3 and 6.8 K, suggesting that this defect is a generic feature of air-exposed HiPIMS Nb / Cu films. A phenomenological model of surface-defect grain boundaries hosting a low- T c impurity phase is introduced and studied with time-dependent Ginzburg-Landau (TDGL) simulations of probe-sample interaction to better understand the measured third-harmonic response. The simulation results show that the third-harmonic response of rf vortex nucleation caused by surface defects exhibits the same general features as the data, including peaks in third-harmonic response with temperature, and their shift and broadening with higher microwave amplitude. We find that the parameters of the phenomenological model (the density of surface defects that nucleate rf vortices and the depth an rf vortex travels through these surface defects) vary systematically with film deposition conditions. From the point of view of these two properties, the Nb / Cu film that is most effective at reducing the nucleation of rf vortices associated with surface defects can be identified. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

Wang, Chung-Yang (ORCID:0000000184299633)↗
DOE OSTI2022

Native and radiation induced point defects in AlN and Sc-doped AlN

Herein, we have performed first-principles calculations to investigate the electronic structure, configurations, formation, and binding energies of native and radiation induced point defects in pristine and Sc-doped wurtzite AlN. For the native defects, the nitrogen vacancy has the lowest formation energy in p-type material while the aluminum vacancy has the lowest formation energy in n-type material which is consistent with the previous studies. Several interstitial defect structures were modeled for Al, N, and Sc atoms. The effects of charge state on their relative stability were investigated. The binding energy of Sc with point defects was calculated and found to be dependent strongly on the defect type and charge state. The results obtained are discussed in light of the possible Sc effects on the radiation damage evolution in AlN. Thus the attraction of Sc atom to N vacancy and both Al and N interstitials reduces their mobility and increases Frenkel pair recombination distance.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Defect control strategies for Al 1- x Gd x N alloys

Tetrahedrally bonded III-N and related alloys are useful for a wide range of applications from optoelectronics to dielectric electromechanics. Heterostructural AlN-based alloys offer unique properties for piezoelectrics, ferroelectrics, and other emerging applications. Atomic-scale point defects and impurities can strongly affect the functional properties of materials, and therefore, it is crucial to understand the nature of these defects and the mechanisms through which their concentrations may be controlled in AlN-based alloys. In this study, we employ density functional theory with alloy modeling and point defect calculations to investigate native point defects and unintentional impurities in Al 1-x Gd x N alloys. Among the native defects that introduce deep midgap states, nitrogen vacancies (V N ⁠) are predicted to be in the highest concentration, especially under N-poor growth conditions. We predict and experimentally demonstrate that V N formation can be suppressed in thin films through growth in N-rich environments. We also find that Al 1-x Gd x N alloys are prone to high levels of unintentional O incorporation, which indirectly leads to even higher concentrations of deep defects. Growth under N-rich/reducing conditions is predicted to minimize and partially alleviate the effects of O incorporation. The results of this study provide valuable insights into the defect behavior in wurtzite nitride-based alloys, which can guide their design and optimization for various applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Towards Ab-Initio Simulations of Crystalline Defects at the Exascale Using Spectral Quadrature Density Functional Theory

Defects in crystalline solids play a crucial role in determining properties of materials at the nano, meso- and macroscales, such as the coalescence of vacancies at the nanoscale to form voids and prismatic dislocation loops or diffusion and segregation of solutes to nucleate precipitates, phase transitions in magnetic materials via disorder and doping. First principles Density Functional Theory (DFT) simulations can provide a detailed understanding of these phenomena. However, the number of atoms needed to correctly simulate these systems is often beyond the reach of many widely used DFT codes. The aim of this article is to discuss recent advances in first principles modeling of crystal defects using the spectral quadrature method. The spectral quadrature method is linear scaling with respect to the number of atoms, permits spatial coarse-graining, and is capable of simulating non-periodic systems embedded in a bulk environment, which allows the application of appropriate boundary conditions for simulations of crystalline defects. In this article, we discuss the state-of-the-art in ab-initio modeling of large metallic systems of the order of several thousand atoms that are suitable for utilizing exascale computing resourses.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Understanding the Mechanism of Secondary Cation Release from the (001) Surface of Li(Ni 1/3 Mn 1/3 Co 1/3 )O 2 : Insights from First-Principles

The transformations of complex metal oxides in aqueous settings must be studied to form a chemical understanding of how technologically relevant nanomaterials impact the environment upon disposal. Owing to the inherent heterogeneity and structural complexity of the ternary intercalation material Li(Ni x Mn y Co 1-x-y )O 2 (NMC), the mechanisms of chemical processes at the solid–water interfac e are challenging to model. Here, density functional theory (DFT) + solvent ion methodology is used to study the energetics of stepwise release of two surface metals following unique pathways. Further, the study spans different combinations of metal removal and also considers unique patterns of defects formed by modeling the NMC surface in supercells. The approach here also considers the equilibration of the surface with the surroundings between successive metal removals. A key finding is that a second metal removal prefers to proceed at a metal lattice site adjacent to the initial defect, and this is attributed in part to how the resulting slab with two metal vacancies maintains the most antiferromagnetic couplings between the remaining Ni/Mn.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗