Search NASASearch

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Feature selection”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 163 records · Page 9

Long-term measurements of ice nucleating particles at Atmospheric Radiation Measurement (ARM) sites worldwide

Ice nucleating particles (INPs) play a critical role in cloud microphysics and precipitation formation, yet long-term, spatially extensive observational datasets remain limited. Here, we present one of the most comprehensive publicly available datasets of immersion-mode INP concentrations using a single analytical method, generated through the U.S. Department of Energy's (DOE) Atmospheric Radiation Measurement (ARM) user facility. INP filter samples have been collected across a broad range of environments – including agricultural plains, Arctic coastlines, high-elevation mountain sites, marine regions, and urban areas – via fixed observatories, mobile facility deployments, and vertically-resolved tethered balloon system operations. We describe the standardized processing and quality assurance pipeline, from filter collection and processing using the Ice Nucleation Spectrometer to final data products archived on the ARM Data Discovery portal. The dataset includes both total INP concentrations and selectively treated samples, allowing for classification of biological, organic, and inorganic INP types. It features a continuous 5-year record of INP measurements from a central U.S. site, with data collection still ongoing. Seasonal and site-specific differences in INP concentrations are illustrated through intercomparisons at −10 and −20 °C, revealing distinct regional sources and atmospheric drivers. We also outline mechanisms for researchers to access existing data, request additional sample analyses, and propose future field campaigns involving ARM INP measurements. This dataset supports a wide range of scientific applications, from observational and mechanistic studies to model development, and provides critical constraints on aerosol-cloud interactions across diverse atmospheric regimes (Creamean et al., 2024, 2020b; https://doi.org/10.5439/1770816).

Creamean, Jessie M. [Colorado State Univ., Fort Co

Fluorinated ionic liquids as gas chromatographic stationary phases for the separation of volatile per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances

Background Here, the production of fluorinated organic compounds in the manufacturing, semiconductor, and pharmaceutical industries has increased exponentially over the past decade. This rapid growth has created an urgent need for efficient chromatographic platforms capable of selectively separating these compounds from complex mixtures, not only to support industrial quality control and waste management practices, but also to enable reliable environmental monitoring of volatile fluorinated contaminants. Conventional GC stationary phases lack the fluorophilic interactions needed for highly fluorinated analytes. Consequently, there is a clear demand for specialized stationary phases designed to improve chromatographic retention and selectivity for these compounds. Results Three stationary phases composed of fluorinated ionic liquids (ILs) with varied extent of fluorination were prepared to study fluorophilic interactions with fluorinated/non-fluorinated probe molecules by gas chromatography (GC). IL stationary phases featuring linear and branched perfluoroalkyl moieties, as well as a branched alkyl moiety, were systematically investigated. Chromatographic performance was examined using fluorinated compounds and their hydrocarbon analogs, including CF 3 -substituted aromatics, aliphatic alcohols, fluorotelomer alcohols (FTOHs), and perfluoroalkenes. Measurements on 5 m and 20 m columns revealed that the IL possessing branched alkyl provided stronger dispersive and hydrogen bonding interactions toward non-fluorinated aromatic and long-chain alcohols, whereas the fluorinated ILs enhanced retention of highly fluorinated FTOHs and perfluorodecene. Comprehensive two-dimensional GC (GC × GC), using a nonpolar primary column coupled with secondary columns featuring cross-bonded poly(trifluoropropylmethyl siloxane) (Rtx-200 ms), the branched fluorinated IL, or the branched non-fluorinated IL, highlighted complementary selectivity with the branched fluorinated IL providing the strongest interactions with fluorinated analytes. Significance These results demonstrate that fluorinated IL stationary phases are promising alternatives to conventional polysiloxane stationary phases for improving the separation of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances and related fluorinated compounds. By correlating IL structure with fluorophilic interactions, this work establishes design principles for GC stationary phases that enable enhanced selectivity for highly fluorinated analytes while maintaining complementary interactions with non-fluorinated compounds.

Comprehensive two-dimensional GC

Unraveling Dimensional Tuning: From 2D to 3D in Covalent Organic Frameworks for Enhanced 2e – Oxygen Reduction Reaction

Covalent organic frameworks (COFs) with a two-dimensional (2D) topology have recently emerged as promising catalyst systems for the electrosynthesis of hydrogen peroxide (H 2 O 2 ) from oxygen (O 2 ). However, designing 2D catalysts to achieve higher H 2 O 2 selectivity presents a significant challenge because of the extensive layer stacking and the aggregated active sites located in the basal planes. It results in lower atom utilization, which requires attention. In this study, we present two functionally similar COFs: one with a 2D rhombus topology (2D@BT_TPA-COF) and another with a three-dimensional (3D) noninterpenetrated pts topology (3D@BT_TPA-COF). Both COFs were utilized for the 2e – oxygen reduction reaction (2e – ORR). Tunning the dimensionality from 2D to 3D resulted in an increase in H 2 O 2 selectivity from approximately ~56% to approximately ~96% (at 0.4 V) and a rise in the turnover frequency (TOF) from 0.05 to 0.08 s –1 at 0.3 V. Nonaggregated active site distribution over 3D topology, featuring higher active site exposure, provides better access to the O 2 /electrolyte and facilitates electron transfer leading to higher 2e – ORR activity and selectivity compared to the 2D counterpart.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH

Tuning the Coordination Environment of Rh Single Atoms on Highly Dispersed Reducible Oxides for Enhanced Reverse Water-Gas Shift Performance

Controlling the dynamic mobility of catalyst surface active sites and their interactions with the surrounding environment is critical in generating active surfaces that directly influence the catalytic activity and selectivity. Here, we report a strategy for tailoring the dispersion and electronic environment of single atom Rh catalysts by decorating the alumina support with highly dispersed (HD) cerium and molybdenum oxides. The resulting catalysts exhibit markedly different behavior in the Reverse Water Gas Shift (RWGS) reaction. In particular, Rh/MoOx(HD)/Al2O3 maintains atomically dispersed Rh even at elevated temperatures (up to 400 °C), achieving CO selectivity of up to 100% and resists sintering via the formation of a newly developed structure featuring Rh single atoms embedded in MoOx clusters. In situ spectroscopy and microscopy analyses confirm the stabilization of Rh and the dynamic evolution of Rh–Mo coordination under reaction conditions. Our findings highlight the power of support modification in steering active site structure and activity, offering a pathway toward enhanced and tunable single atom catalysts for CO2 valorization.

CO selectivity

Distinctive features of structural evolution and thermodynamic response in wide-bandgap semiconductors driven by intense electronic excitation

Radiation-tolerant material selection requires balancing lattice rigidity, defect dynamics, and electronic stability, as shown by covalent SiC outperforming ionic Ga 2 O 3 and GaN under extreme environments. Responding to intense electronic excitation, irradiation-driven phase segregation (β → δ/κ in Ga 2 O 3 ) and core–shell track (disordered structure in GaN), accompanied by elemental redistribution, contrastingly, exceptional radiation tolerance manifested by comparatively minimal lattice distortion (0.17 % strain variation) was demonstrated in SiC. These differential responses are primarily attributed to two fundamental mechanisms: (i) thermodynamic driving forces governing defect migration and phase separation, and (ii) the synergistic effects of robust covalent bonding composition coupled with efficient defect recombination processes. Here, the stronger electron–phonon (e-ph) coupling in Ga 2 O 3 (4.34 × 1018 W m −3 K −1 ) and GaN (3.55 × 10 18 W m −3 K −1 ) enhances lattice energy deposition, triggering thermal spikes (ΔT ≫ T m ) and structural transition behaviors, whereas weaker e-ph coupling in SiC (3.69 × 10 18 W m −3 K −1 ), relatively high thermodynamic parameters and efficient energy dissipation suppress thermal spikes to maintaining lattice integrity. The photoresponse degradation driven by enhanced radiative recombination is dominant in N-doped SiC, while V-doped systems achieve defect-mediated photoconduction optimization characterized by abrupt current transitions, matching fluorescence yield evolutions, and directly connecting defect engineering to optoelectronic performance.

Intense electronic excitation

Iodine solid sorbent design: a literature review of the critical criteria for consideration

Designing sorbents for iodine capture in different conditions requires selection and optimization of a large and diverse range of variables. These variables fall into general categories (or features) of sorbent activity, sorbent stability, and the fate of the loaded material in terms of the disposal (waste form) options available. To illustrate, silver-loaded, high-porosity sorbents make for maximized iodine capture and less pressure drop in a column-based sorption system approach, however, this high porosity can lead to less mechanically stable sorbents. Additionally, waste forms containing silver must also be compliant with additional criteria for hazardous waste disposal. Thus, all these aspects must be considered simultaneously when selecting a sorbent for utilization under specific conditions. Information is given for different types of sorbent design considerations for different operating conditions and some emphasis is also given on promising alternatives for silver as the active (chemisorption-based) getter metal. Discussion is given around demonstrated options for waste forms for different metal-iodide compounds.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Ultra-low thermal resistance and pressure drop copper and copper-tungsten diamond-shaped pin fin cold plates for liquid cooling of electronics

Modern and future data centers face increasing cooling challenges due to increasing chip thermal design power and die size, along with the need to reduce energy consumption used for cooling. High performance cooling solutions that maintain a low chip junction temperature are needed to ensure electronics reliability. This work develops an ultra-low thermal resistance and low pressure drop 75 mm × 75 mm cold plate, intended for next-generation electronics cooling. The cold plate features an array of diamond-shaped pin fins and integrated copper tungsten heat spreader, selected for its low coefficient of thermal expansion which reduces thermomechanical deformation and allows for closer integration of the cold plate with silicon dies. Starting with 300 candidate designs, three-dimensional computational fluid dynamics simulations predict the thermal-hydraulic performance of cold plate subsections. The highest performing geometries are evaluated with high fidelity simulations. Four cold plates are manufactured for experiments: three with diamond-shaped pin fins and one with straights fins for comparison purposes. The cold plates are fabricated from copper-tungsten (CuW), copper (Cu), or aluminum-silicon-magnesium alloy (AlSi10Mg). The diamond-shaped pin fins achieve a roughly 15 % lower thermal resistance compared to the conventional straight fin microchannel. The highest performing design achieves a chip-to-coolant (including thermal interface material) thermal resistance of 9.0 K/kW in CuW and 6.9 K/kW in Cu under a 1 kW heat load with an inlet-to-outlet pressure drop of 9.0 kPa and water as the working fluid. This work demonstrates ultra-low thermal resistance and pressure drop cold plates for large die, high heat load applications, and shows that CuW is an attractive cold plate material for improved reliability in next generation data center cooling.

Coefficient of thermal expansion

Metal–Organic Frameworks as Catalysts for (De)Hydrogenation: Progress, Challenges, and Perspectives

Storing hydrogen through chemical bonding in liquid-organic hydrogen carriers (LOHCs) offers a safer and more practical approach for hydrogen transportation compared to physical liquefaction, which is limited by low volumetric efficiency and gas release. The efficiency of LOHC systems is highly dependent on effective catalysts, which are typically composed of transition metals supported on metal oxides. However, these materials often rely upon costly noble metals, and their nonuniform nature limits mechanistic insights and structure–function relationships that could improve catalyst design. Metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) are promising alternatives to existing catalysts due to their crystalline, tunable, and porous nature. However, their use as catalysts for (de)hydrogenation reactions remains largely underexplored. Related to this, we identify two general classes of MOFs reported as catalysts for (de)hydrogenation reactions: MOFs as scaffolds for catalytically active species and MOFs that function as reactive materials themselves. MOF composites anchor reactive nanoparticles or homogeneous species, imparting reactivity to the framework. The confinement effects experienced by the affixed species, combined with favorable substrate adsorption interactions or acid sites provided by the MOF, enhance the stability, selectivity, and activity of these catalysts for (de)hydrogenation reactions. Additionally, catalytically active MOFs often feature open metal sites at the node or undergo postsynthetic modification at either node or linker to impart reactivity. Here, taking inspiration from these materials, we outline the current state and key challenges of utilizing MOFs as (de)hydrogenation catalysts and propose research pathways to advance materials in this field for energy applications.

Catalysts

The Marchantia polymorpha pangenome reveals ancient mechanisms of plant adaptation to the environment

Plant adaptation to terrestrial life started 450 million years ago and has played a major role in the evolution of life on Earth. The genetic mechanisms allowing this adaptation to a diversity of terrestrial constraints have been mostly studied by focusing on flowering plants. Here, we gathered a collection of 133 accessions of the model bryophyte Marchantia polymorpha and studied its intraspecific diversity using selection signature analyses, a genome-environment association study and a pangenome. We identified adaptive features, such as peroxidases or nucleotide-binding and leucine-rich repeats (NLRs), also observed in flowering plants, likely inherited from the first land plants. The M. polymorpha pangenome also harbors lineage-specific accessory genes absent from seed plants. We conclude that different land plant lineages still share many elements from the genetic toolkit evolved by their most recent common ancestor to adapt to the terrestrial habitat, refined by lineage-specific polymorphisms and gene family evolution.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES

Tokamak Energy’s pre-concept design for a fusion power plant: an overview of ST-E1

Climate change and rapidly rising energy demand, driven in part by artificial intelligence and data-centre growth, create an urgent need for stable, low-carbon, and abundant power. Fusion is a promising long-term solution, yet its commercialisation faces a fundamental paradox in today’s investment environment: pilot plants are essential to de-risk physics, engineering, and operations, but their limited lifetime energy output and high upfront costs make them difficult to finance. This paper presents Tokamak Energy’s response: ST-E1, a pre-concept design for a low-aspect-ratio tokamak power plant engineered specifically to overcome this challenge. ST-E1 is designed from the outset for phased operation—pilot and commercial phases, with an upgrade phase in between—with emphasis on commercial viability, maintainability, nuclear engineering, modularity, and upgradability. A key design principle is the deliberate separation of long-lived assets, such as the magnet cage and vacuum vessel, from replaceable in-vessel systems. This provides an attractive and credible investment approach to generate operational data and de-risk key technologies while preserving most capital-intensive assets for later commercial phases. The architecture supports continuous optimisation toward high net electric power (targeting 800–1000 MW net electric), a normalised capital expenditure of $\$$ 12–14k/kW of net electric power, and high availability (targeting > 80%). A tokamak core with a 5 m major radius, aspect ratio of 2.3, and on-plasma axis toroidal field of 5.25 T was selected to meet these objectives. This paper summarises the ST-E1 design philosophy, principal features, and development methodology. It introduces a Focus Collection of 11 papers detailing the pre-concept design of the entire tokamak and corresponding plant.

ST-E1

Development of a High-Intensity Heat Flux Gauge and Characterization Facility (Final Report)

Sandia National Laboratories (SNL) and Hukseflux Thermal Sensors (HTS) collaborated to advance the design and calibration of high-intensity heat flux gauges capable of measuring 2500 kW/m². An industry trade study was first conducted and highlighted the need for enhanced gauge designs and calibration methodology & services suited for high-intensities and broadband flux. We then developed, tested, and evaluated three prototype gauge designs along with four distinct coating types, each designed to extend the measurable flux range of existing HTS products to higher intensity levels. Following a down selection process, the project team refined the focus to a final product design, incorporating updated features to enhance its robustness during high flux exposure.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND

Bipolar Blobs as Evidence of Hidden AGN Activities in the Low-mass Galaxies

Abstract We report evidence of a hidden black hole (BH) in a low-mass galaxy, MaNGA 9885-9102, and provide a new method to identify active BHs in low-mass galaxies. This galaxy is originally selected from the MaNGA survey with distinctive bipolar Hαblobs at the minor axis. The bipolar feature can be associated with active galactic nuclei (AGN) activity, while the two blobs are classified as the Hiiregions on the BPT diagram, making the origins confusing. The Swift UV continuum shows that the two blobs do not have UV counterparts, suggesting that the source of ionization is out of the blobs. Consistent with this, the detailed photoionization models prefer AGN rather than the star-forming origin with a significance of 5.8σ. The estimated BH mass isM BH ∼ 7.2 × 10 5 M ⊙ from theM BH –σ * relationship. This work introduces a novel method for detecting the light echo of BHs, potentially extending to intermediate mass, in low-metallicity environments where the traditional BPT diagram fails.

Astronomy & Astrophysics

Xanthos-Lake Dataset

The Xanthos-Lake v1.0 dataset provides the input data, trained machine-learning models, and simulation outputs needed to characterize lake water balance, snow and ice conditions, and mixing-layer temperature within the Xanthos global hydrological modeling framework. The dataset supports lake representation across a wide range of lake sizes and hydroclimatic conditions by combining xLSIM, a basin-specific machine-learning emulator of lake snow, ice, ice-cover fraction, and mixing-layer temperature, with the Xanthos-Lake water-balance model. The archive contains NetCDF datasets used to train and evaluate xLSIM, trained model weights, processed meteorological and lake-property inputs, and basin- and lake-category-specific simulation outputs. These materials are organized into four primary data groups, described below. Snowice_model_inputs: Contains the NetCDF input data used to train xLSIM. The xLSIM machine-learning framework uses three lake-based datasets. The meteorological forcing dataset provides monthly relative humidity, specific humidity, surface wind speed, maximum and minimum air temperature, downward longwave and shortwave radiation, snowfall, surface air pressure, and total precipitation. Lake surface area is included as an additional static predictor. The target-state dataset provides lake ice thickness, snow depth, snow cover, and lake mixing-layer temperature, while a companion lake-surface dataset provides the lake ice-cover fraction. Before training, ice thickness and snow depth are converted from meters to centimeters, mixing-layer temperature is converted from kelvin to degrees Celsius and constrained to nonnegative values, and ice-cover fraction is converted from a fraction to a percentage. The predictor variables are normalized using statistics calculated across the selected lakes and time steps. Snowice_model_outputs: Contains the NetCDF outputs generated by xLSIM. For each basin, xLSIM produces a file containing observed and predicted lake-state variables for the training, validation, and testing periods. The modeled variables include lake ice thickness, snow depth, snow cover, mixing-layer temperature, and lake ice-cover fraction. For basins without a sufficiently persistent snow-and-ice signal, the emulator predicts only mixing-layer temperature. The outputs also include training and validation loss histories, the selected model configuration, identifiers of the lakes used in training, and SHAP-based feature-importance information at the global, lake, and seasonal-regime levels. The trained machine-learning model weights are provided separately within the dataset archive. Together, these files support model evaluation and subsequent coupling with the Xanthos-Lake water-balance framework. XanthosLAKES: Contains the NetCDF input data used by the Xanthos-Lake framework. Monthly meteorological inputs include relative and specific humidity, downward shortwave and longwave radiation, mean, maximum, and minimum air temperature, wind speed, precipitation, snowfall, and surface air pressure. Static lake-property datasets provide lake identifiers, geographic locations, surface area, volume, mean depth, elevation, drainage area, fetch, outlet-routing information, and associated Xanthos grid-cell attributes. Separate bathymetric datasets provide the coefficients of the area–depth and volume–depth relationships for each aggregated lake unit. GLEV-based records provide observed lake surface area and evaporation data used to initialize lake states, define reference conditions, and calibrate and evaluate the model. Xanthos-Lake Outputs: Contains the basin- and lake-category-specific NetCDF outputs generated by Xanthos-Lake. Monthly variables include lake surface area, storage volume, outlet discharge, evaporation rate, evaporation volume, lake–groundwater exchange, lake inflow, ice thickness, snow depth, snow-cover fraction, ice-cover fraction, and mixing-layer temperature. The files also contain lake-specific calibration and validation statistics, including normalized root-mean-square error, mean absolute error, Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency, Kling–Gupta efficiency, and percent bias. Stored calibrated and derived parameters include the weir discharge coefficient, fractional freeboard, groundwater exchange coefficient, reference water level, corresponding reference surface area and storage volume, weir-width adjustment factor, and the fraction of routed inflow entering the lake. Basin identifiers, lake category, simulation period, calibration and validation periods, and parameter-schema information are retained as NetCDF metadata.

Abeshu, Guta [Pacific Northwest National Laborator

Evaluation of Leak Detection Technologies for Low Global Warming Potential (GWP), Flammable Refrigerants

Current commercial refrigeration systems use refrigerants with global warming potential (GWP) values ranging from 1250 to 4000. The emergence of low GWP alternatives (GWP <150) is expected to significantly reduce direct emissions in this sector, playing a crucial role in the ongoing electrification and decarbonization initiatives. However, many of these low GWP alternatives pose a flammability risk, necessitating robust sensing solutions to ensure the reliable and safe operation of the equipment. This paper examines various sensing mechanisms suitable for potential applications in systems that employ flammable refrigerants, specifically those designated as A2L class. It provides a summary of A2L refrigerants and their properties, followed by a comprehensive review of sensor classes, covering their working principles, features, advantages, and limitations. Additionally, the article delves into key performance characteristics such as accuracy, selectivity, sensitivity, dynamic characteristics, and durability, among other properties. The article discusses areas for improvement and suggests corresponding approaches for potential sensors in facilitating the successful adoption of flammable refrigerants. Finally, this paper presents the latest findings from experimental evaluation of 5 different sensing principles in detecting the composition variation as a result of various operational conditions. Reliability and sensitivity of the sensor in responding to shifts in true composition and the resultant LFL value is also discussed.

Reshniak, Viktor

Efficiency of ML Anomaly Detection Triggers for Emerging Jets

Novel machine learning-based anomaly detection Level 1 (L1) triggers are currently under development at CMS, namely AXOL1TL and CICADA. The former employs a variational autoencoder, while the latter utilizes a convolutional autoencoder. These triggers aim to balance rate reduction with model independence, enabling the selection of potentially significant events that might be overlooked by traditional triggers relying on basic kinematic variable selections. Consequently, they have the potential to enhance signals indicative of physics beyond the Standard Model, such as those associated with emerging jets. Such signals are predicted by models featuring a composite dark sector where long-lived particles decay into Standard Model jets with displaced tracks and numerous vertices. This study evaluates the efficiency of these anomaly detection triggers in selecting events with emerging jets produced via the s-channel production of two dark quarks.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS

Efficiency of ML Anomaly Detection Triggers for Emerging Jets

Novel machine learning-based anomaly detection Level 1 (L1) triggers are currently under development at CMS, namely AXOL1TL and CICADA. The former employs a variational autoencoder, while the latter utilizes a convolutional autoencoder. These triggers aim to balance rate reduction with model independence, enabling the selection of potentially significant events that might be overlooked by traditional triggers relying on basic kinematic variable selections. Consequently, they have the potential to enhance signals indicative of physics beyond the Standard Model, such as those associated with emerging jets. Such signals are predicted by models featuring a composite dark sector where long-lived particles decay into Standard Model jets with displaced tracks and numerous vertices. This study evaluates the efficiency of these anomaly detection triggers in selecting events with emerging jets produced via the s-channel production of two dark quarks.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS

Efficiency of ML Anomaly Detection Triggers for Emerging Jets

Novel machine learning-based anomaly detection Level 1 (L1) triggers are currently under development at CMS, namely AXOL1TL and CICADA. The former employs a variational autoencoder, while the latter utilizes a convolutional autoencoder. These triggers aim to balance rate reduction with model independence, enabling the selection of potentially significant events that might be overlooked by traditional triggers relying on basic kinematic variable selections. Consequently, they have the potential to enhance signals indicative of physics beyond the Standard Model, such as those associated with emerging jets. Such signals are predicted by models featuring a composite dark sector where long-lived particles decay into Standard Model jets with displaced tracks and numerous vertices. This study evaluates the efficiency of these anomaly detection triggers in selecting events with emerging jets produced via the s-channel production of two dark quarks.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS

Feature review of photovoltaic modeling software utilizing blind performance assessment

While confidence in photovoltaic (PV) modeling software has always been essential, the rapid pace of new PV plant developments makes accuracy and credibility more critical than ever. Independent assessments, particularly through blind modeling comparisons, are therefore necessary to ensure unbiased benchmarking across PV modeling software. Previous studies have been limited by a narrow range of models compared, anonymized results, or system size. This study presents results from the first-ever onymous blind modeling comparison, evaluated using both lab- and utility-scale fixed-tilt, monofacial, south-facing systems at sub-hourly time intervals. Seven commercially used PV software tools were compared: 3E SynaptiQ, PlantPredict, PVsyst, RatedPower, SAM, SolarFarmer, and Solargis Evaluate. Predictions were submitted directly by software representatives, providing unique insights into each software’s implementation and resulting prediction behavior. Notable features, including plane-of-array (POA) transposition model, module temperature model, shading model, and performance model were analyzed and compared. Four summary tables compile these features of the software, serving as a resource to help users understand the methodological differences and select the most suitable software for their applications. The software tools show deviations from mean error in annual yield up to 2.5 % in the lab-scale system, increasing to 6.0 % for the utility-scale system. These differences arise from a combination of user decisions and the inherent behavior of the software, indicating the need for continuous and rigorous validation of modeling methods using these software tools against complex, real-world systems.

14 SOLAR ENERGY