Roadmap for the Application of Ion Beam Technologies to Challenges for the Advancement and Implementation of Nuclear Energy Technologies
The use of ion beams in interrogating materials performance for nuclear energy applications is advancing at a rapid rate. Ion irradiations have been proven to produce radiation effects data that are of direct relevance for understanding neutron-induced displacement damage. This development reflects significant and continued investment in infrastructure by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) as well as support of science and engineering research at universities and national laboratories. Application of ion beam irradiation methods to enhance the deployment of materials in reactors is in the spirit of the Gateway for Accelerated Innovation in Nuclear (GAIN) initiative sponsored by DOE to accelerate the deployment of innovation in the U.S. nuclear industry. Ion beam irradiation shows considerable promise for assisting in down selecting candidate materials for use in both current and advanced nuclear energy systems. Ion beams allow rapid achievement of materials damage levels not accessible by neutron irradiation in test reactors due to cost and time constraints. Ion beam studies provide data on the effects of irradiation under very specific conditions of temperature, radiation dose, and radiation dose rate that are difficult or impossible to achieve via reactor irradiation experiments. This data can be used to develop and validate detailed predictive radiation effects models for use in reactor materials research and development. Despite the current high state of the art and the maturity of quality assurance, there are still challenges to the deployment of ion beam data in support of reactor materials qualification. For the most part, these challenges arise from the lack of a detailed mechanistic understanding of potential difference between ion induced and neutron induced materials damage, which is exacerbated by difficulties in obtaining bulk physical and mechanical properties data from the micron-scale heavy ion irradiation depths. In particular, improved understanding of dose rate effects, as a function of temperature, are needed. This document offers a roadmap for the development and enhancement of current U.S. ion beam irradiation technologies within university and national laboratory settings, and especially for the deployment of new highly controlled in situ interrogation of materials during irradiation to provide dynamic and mechanistic data for model development. The status and capabilities of relevant U.S. ion beam facilities are summarized and recommended “best practices” for performing ion irradiations are described. The potential role of ion beam irradiations to assist the development and deployment of reactor materials is outlined. Key principles include developing methods for rapid and cost-effective materials selection and development, characterizing fundamental material response under irradiation, and developing a robust mechanistic understanding of microstructure evolution under irradiation (including development and validation of reliable predictive models for microstructure evolution).