Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “catalytic activity”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 163 records · Page 9

Computational Investigation of the Role of Active Site Heterogeneity for aSupported Organovanadium(III) Hydrogenation Catalyst

A crucial consideration for supported heterogeneous catalysts is the nonuniformity of the active sites, particularly for supported organometallic catalysts. Standard spectroscopic techniques, such as X-ray absorption spectroscopy, reflect the nature of the most populated sites, which are often intrinsically structurally distinct from the most active catalytic sites. Additionally, with computational models, often, only a few representative structures are used to depict catalytic active sites on a surface, even though there are numerous observable factors of surface heterogeneity that contribute to the kinetically favorable active species. A previously reported study on the mechanism of a surface organovanadium-(III) catalyst [(SiO 2 )V III (Mes)(THF)] for styrene hydrogenation yielded two possible mechanisms: heterolytic cleavage and redox cycling. These two mechanistic scenarios are challenging to differentiate experimentally since the kinetic readouts of the catalyst are identical. To showcase the importance of modeling surface heterogeneity and its effect on catalytic activity, density functional theory (DFT) computational models of a series of potential active sites of [(SiO 2 )V III (Mes)(THF)] for the reaction pathways are applied in combination with kinetic Monte Carlo (kMC) simulations. Computed results were then compared to the previously reported experimental kinetic study: (1) DFT free-energy reaction pathways indicated the likely active site and pathway for styrene hydrogenation, a heterolytic cleavage pathway requiring a bare tripodal vanadium site. (2) From the kMC simulations, a mixture of different bond lengths from the support oxygen to the metal center was required to qualitatively describe the experimentally observed kinetic aspects of a supported organovanadium(III) catalyst for olefin hydrogenation. This work underscores the importance of modeling surface heterogeneity in computational catalysis.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Photoinduced Electron and Energy Transfer Pathways and Photocatalytic Mechanisms in Hybrid Plasmonic Photocatalysis

Hybrid plasmonic nanostructures are built on plasmonic metalnanostructures surrounded by catalytic metals or metal oxides. We report that recent studies have shown that hybrid plasmonic nanocatalysts can concurrently utilize thermal energy and photon stimuli and exhibit high catalytic activity, selectivity, and stability that are not attainable in conventional purely thermally activated catalytic processes. The hybrid plasmonic photocatalytic approach has recently emerged as an attractive concept for the conversion of solar energy into chemical energy, the distributed synthesis of valuable chemicals such as ammonia with little to no requirement of external heating, and the development of coke-resistant and selective catalytic processes. The field of hybrid plasmonic photocatalysis has grown tremendously in the last decade. In this review article, the advantages of visible-light-augmented hybrid plasmonic photocatalysis over conventional pure thermally activated heterogeneous catalysis are discussed. Fundamental insights are provided into photocatalytic mechanisms by which the photoexcited charge carriers (electrons and holes) are formed and transferred to adsorbates triggering chemical transformations on the surface of hybrid plasmonic nanocatalysts. Computational modeling used for predicting and understanding the photocatalytic activity and selectivity on hybrid plasmonic nanostructures is also reviewed. The review closes with a discussion of the current challenges, new opportunities, and future outlook for hybrid plasmonic photocatalysis.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Catalytic Water Electrolysis by Co–Cu–W Mixed Metal Oxides: Insights from X-ray Absorption Spectroelectrochemistry

Mixed metal oxides (MMOs) are a promising class of electrocatalysts for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) and hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Despite their importance for sustainable energy schemes, our understanding of relevant reaction pathways, catalytically active sites, and synergistic effects is rather limited. Here, we applied synchrotron-based X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) to explore the evolution of the amorphous Co–Cu–W MMO electrocatalyst, shown previously to be an efficient bifunctional OER and HER catalyst for water splitting. Ex situ XAS measurements provided structural environments and the oxidation state of the metals involved, revealing Co 2+ (octahedral), Cu + / 2+ (tetrahedral/square-planar), and W 6+ (octahedral) centers. Operando XAS investigations, including X-ray absorption near-edge structure (XANES) and extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS), elucidated the dynamic structural transformations of Co, Cu, and W metal centers during the OER and HER. The experimental results indicate that Co 3+ and Cu 0 are the active catalytic sites involved in the OER and HER, respectively, while Cu 2+ and W 6+ play crucial roles as structure stabilizers, suggesting strong synergistic interactions within the Co–Cu–W MMO system. In conclusion, these results, combined with the Tafel slope analysis, revealed that the bottleneck intermediate during the OER is Co 3+ hydroperoxide, whose formation is accompanied by changes in the Cu–O bond lengths, pointing to a possible synergistic effect between Co and Cu ions. Our study reveals important structural effects taking place during MMO-driven OER/HER electrocatalysis and provides essential experimental insights into the complex catalytic mechanism of emerging noble-metal-free MMO electrocatalysts for full water splitting.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Intercalation-type catalyst for non-aqueous room temperature sodium-sulfur batteries

Abstract Ambient-temperature sodium-sulfur (Na-S) batteries are potential attractive alternatives to lithium-ion batteries owing to their high theoretical specific energy of 1,274 Wh kg −1 based on the mass of Na 2 S and abundant sulfur resources. However, their practical viability is impeded by sodium polysulfide shuttling. Here, we report an intercalation-conversion hybrid positive electrode material by coupling the intercalation-type catalyst, MoTe 2 , with the conversion-type active material, sulfur. In addition, MoTe 2 nanosheets vertically grown on graphene flakes offer abundant active catalytic sites, further boosting the catalytic activity for sulfur redox. When used as a composite positive electrode and assembled in a coin cell with excess Na, a discharge capacity of 1,081 mA h g s −1 based on the mass of S with a capacity fade rate of 0.05% per cycle over 350 cycles at 0.1 C rate in a voltage range of 0.8 to 2.8 V is realized under a high sulfur loading of 3.5 mg cm −2 and a lean electrolyte condition with an electrolyte-to-sulfur ratio of 7 μL mg −1 . A fundamental understanding of the electrocatalysis of MoTe 2 is further revealed by in-situ synchrotron-based operando X-ray diffraction and ex-situ time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Depositing nanometer-sized particles of metals onto carbon allotropes

A process for depositing nanometer-sized metal particles onto a substrate in the absence of aqueous solvents, organic solvents, and reducing agents, and without any required pre-treatment of the substrate, includes preparing an admixture of a metal compound and a substrate by dry mixing a chosen amount of the metal compound with a chosen amount of the substrate; and supplying energy to the admixture in an amount sufficient to deposit zero valance metal particles onto the substrate. This process gives rise to a number of deposited metallic particle sizes which may be controlled. The compositions prepared by this process are used to produce polymer composites by combining them with readily available commodity and engineering plastics. The polymer composites are used as coatings, or they are used to fabricate articles, such as free-standing films, fibers, fabrics, foams, molded and laminated articles, tubes, adhesives, and fiber reinforced articles. These articles are well-suited for many applications requiring thermal conductivity, electrical conductivity, antibacterial activity, catalytic activity, and combinations thereof.

Watson, Kent A.↗

A characterization of recombinant Arabidopsis FRIABLE1 (FRB1) reveals robust rhamnogalacturonan-I rhamnosyltransferase activity and critical catalytic residues

Plant cell walls are glycan-rich extracellular matrices that fundamentally impact essential cellular processes, such as growth, adhesion, and cell shape acquisition. Understanding plant cell wall glycans requires the identification and characterization of the biosynthetic enzymes that produce these polymers. Most successful in vitro protein expression studies of plant cell wall glycosyltransferases have relied on insect, fungal/yeast, or human cell expression systems, whereas prokaryotic expression systems have been generally unsuccessful. Here, we show that Arabidopsis FRIABLE1 (FRB1)/rhamnogalacturonan-I rhamnosyltransferase 8 (RRT8) can be produced in Escherichia coli RosettaGami2 cells as N-terminal maltose-binding protein fusion proteins containing C-terminal 6X-His-tags. We also report the catalytic constants of FRB1/RRT8 with apparent K M and K cat values of 226 μM and 33 min -1 for UDP-Rhamnose and 117 μM and 28.7 min -1 for rhamnogalacturonan-I (RG-I), respectively. We examine the catalytic activities of mutated FRB1/RRT8 proteins based on an AlphaFold 3-generated FRB1/RRT8 protein structural model with a virtually docked UDP-Rha donor. Enzymatic characterization of the mutated and wildtype FRB1/RRT8 protein confirmed that mutation of predicted catalytic site amino acid residues resulted in a 20-fold reduction in RRT activity. FRB1 also robustly polymerizes RG-I in combination with RG-I galacturonosyltransferase 1. These results show how a robust E. coli expression system combined with artificial intelligence tools can be used to increase understanding of plant cell wall glycosyltransferase structure and function.

glycosyltransferase↗

Carbidic Mo is the sole kinetically-relevant active site for catalytic methane dehydroaromatization on Mo/H-ZSM-5

Systematic variation of Mo/Al = {0.10, 0.25, 0.35} in Mo/H-ZSM-5 catalysts effects ~20× change of Mo-to-H + ratio during methane dehydroaromatization (DHA) reactions at steady state and on deactivating catalysts. Mo and Brønsted-acid site count, respectively enumerated by ethane hydrogenolysis probe reaction and dimethyl ether chemical titration, evolve disparately during DHA catalysis, indicating the two sites reduce in number by distinct mechanisms. Here, the deactivation of Mo/H-ZSM-5 catalytic activity is uniquely attributed to the loss of active, or accessible, Mo sites, evinced by (i) the non-selective nature of deactivation (i.e. that deactivation occurs without modification of residual active sites), (ii) invariance in product distribution from Mo/H + = 0.10–2.1, and (iii) linear correspondence between Mo-catalyzed ethane hydrogenolysis rate and active site count during DHA on deactivating samples. DHA forward rate – the intrinsic kinetic descriptor of catalyst activity – normalizes by Mo content at steady state and on deactivating catalysts with Mo/Al = 0.10–0.35 for Mo-based contact times in the range τ Mo = 0.79–44 mol Mo s mol –1 C , unequivocally establishing Mo aggregates as the sole kinetically-relevant active site on Mo/H-ZSM-5. Brønsted-acid site content over a ~40× range in τ H+ = 1.4–54 mol H+ s mol –1 C has no discernable correlation with or effect on DHA rate, methane conversion, or product distribution – demonstrating H + does not catalyze any rate- or selectivity-determining steps in the benzene formation pathway and suggesting that the benefits of zeolitic acid sites are only to disperse Mo during catalyst synthesis and, conceivably, to catalyze equilibrated reaction steps.

02 PETROLEUM↗

Tracking the dynamics of catalytic Pt/CeO2 active sites during water-gas-shift reaction

Abstract Understanding the atomistic structure of the active site during catalytic reactions is of paramount importance in both fundamental studies and practical applications, but such studies are challenging due to the complexity of heterogeneous systems. Here, we use Pt/CeO 2 as an example to study the dynamic nature of active sites during the water-gas-shift reaction (WGSR) by combining multiple in situ characterization tools. We show that the different concentrations of interfacial Pt δ+ – O – Ce 4+ moieties at Pt/CeO 2 interfaces are responsible for the rank of catalytic performance of Pt/CeO 2 catalysts: Pt/CeO 2 -rod > Pt/CeO 2 -cube > Pt/CeO 2 -oct. For all the catalysts, metallic Pt is formed during the WGSR, leading to the transformation of the active sites to Pt 0 – O v – Ce 3+ and interface reconstruction. These findings shed light on the nature of the active site for the WGSR on Pt/CeO 2 and highlight the importance of combining complementary in situ techniques for establishing structure-performance relationships.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

The Central Role of Oxo Clusters in Zirconium‐Based Esterification Catalysis

Oxo clusters are a unique link between oxide nanocrystals and Metal‐Organic Frameworks (MOFs), representing the limit of downscaling each of the respective crystals. Herein, the superior catalytic activity of clusters, compared to zirconium MOF UiO‐66 and nanocrystals is shown. Focus is on esterification reactions given their general importance in consumer products and the challenge of converting large substrates. Oxo clusters have a higher surface‐to‐volume ratio than nanocrystals, rendering them more active. For large substrates, for example, oleic acid, MOF UiO‐66 has negligible catalytic activity while clusters provide almost quantitative conversion, a fact we ascribe to limited diffusion of large substrates through the MOF pores. Clusters do not suffer from limited mass transfer and we also obtain high conversion in solvent‐free reactions with sterically hindered alcohols (hexanol, 2‐ethyl hexanol, benzyl alcohol, and neopentyl alcohol). The cluster catalyst can be recovered and shows identical activity when reused. The structural integrity of the cluster is confirmed using X‐ray total scattering and pair distribution function analysis. Moreover, when homogeneous zirconium alkoxides are used as catalysts, the same oxo cluster is retrieved, showing that oxo clusters are the active catalytic species, even in previously assumed homogeneously catalyzed reactions.

Pulparayil Mathew, Jikson↗

A Positive Charge in the Outer Coordination Sphere of an Artificial Enzyme Increases CO 2 Hydrogenation

The protein scaffold around the active site of enzymes is known to influence catalytic activity, but specific scaffold features responsible for favorable influences are often not known. This study focuses on using an artificial metalloenzyme to probe one specific feature of the scaffold, the position of a positive charge in the outer coordination sphere around the active site. Previous work showed that a small molecular complex, [Rh(P Et 2 N glycine P Et 2 )2 ] – , immobilized covalently within a protein scaffold was activated for CO 2 hydrogenation. In this work, using an iterative design where the effect of arginine, histidine, or lysine residues placed in the outer coordination sphere of the catalytic active site were evaluated, we tested the hypothesis that positively charged groups facilitate CO 2 hydrogenation with seven unique constructs. Single-, double-, and triple-point mutations were introduced to directly compare catalytic activity, as monitored by turnover frequencies (TOFs) measured in real time with 1 H NMR spectroscopy, and evaluate related structural and electronic properties. Two of the seven constructs showed a 2- and 3-fold increase relative to the wild type, with overall rates ranging from 0.2 to 0.7 h –1 , and a crystal structure of the fastest of these shows the positive charge positioned next to the active site. A crystal structure of the arginine-containing complex shows that the arginines are positioned near the metal. Molecular dynamics (MD) studies also suggest that the positive charge is oriented next to the active site in the two constructs with faster rates but not in the others and that the positive charge near the active site holds the CO 2 near the metal, all consistent with a positive charge appropriately positioned in the scaffold benefiting catalysis. The MD studies also suggest that changes in the water distribution around the active site may contribute to catalytic activity, while modest structural changes and movement of the complex within the scaffold do not.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

CeO2 Nanoparticle Doping as a Probe of Active Site Speciation in the Catalytic Hydrolysis of Organophosphates

Organophosphate hydrolysis is important for degrading environmentally harmful compounds and recovering phosphate ions in biological molecules. CeO2 nanocrystals have been well-studied for dephosphorylation via hydrolysis owing to the accessible and tunable distribution of Ce3+ and Ce4+ ions. However, there remains uncertainty in the literature regarding which surface defect properties direct catalytic activity, such as the Ce3+/Ce4+ distribution, oxygen vacancies, faceting, and dopants, and to what degree they contribute to efficient hydrolysis. Trivalent (M3+) dopants serve as a tool for manipulating defects, including the concentration of Ce3+ and oxygen vacancies, thereby influencing the hydrolytic activity of CeO2. Herein, trivalent metal ions (M = Y3+, Cr3+, In3+, and Gd3+) were employed to modulate the active sites on the CeO2 nanocrystal surface, and the effects of each metal dopant on the cerium oxide active sites for organophosphate hydrolysis were investigated. M-doped CeO2 nanoparticles were synthesized via hydrothermal methods, followed by annealing to remove ligands and prime the nanocrystal surface for catalysis. Catalytic performance was evaluated using dimethyl-p¬-nitrophenyl phosphate (DMNP) as a model organophosphate substrate, with degradation monitored over time using UV-visible absorption spectroscopy. Powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), and Raman spectroscopy revealed successful doping of CeO2 in all cases, albeit with distinctive characteristics demonstrating how M3+ dopants affect catalysis. We show that CeO2 exhibits high sensitivity to dopants that generate lattice strain, Ce3+ ions, and oxygen vacancy defects. Consequently, achieving high catalytic efficiency within CeO2 requires a balanced active site ensemble, wherein defects are maintained at optimal concentrations and distributions on the nanocrystal surface.

Miura-Stempel, Emily L.↗

Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes with Confined Chalcogens as the Catalysts and Electrodes for Oxygen Reduction Reaction in Fuel Cells

The goal of this project is to synthesize and characterize a new non-metal electro-catalyst for oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) for fuel cell applications. The intended catalyst is a composite material composed of sulfur chains encapsulated in narrow diameter single-walled carbon nanotubes (S@SWNTs). S@SWNTs were successfully synthesized through sulfur vapor infusion method, and validated with Raman spectroscopy. However, the electrochemical analysis on the ORR catalytic activity of S@SWNTs indicated that it had low ORR catalytic activity. Our theoretical study based on density functional theory (DFT) revealed that the poor oxygen adsorption (low binding energy) on the surface of S@SWNTs was the bottleneck of the entire catalytic reaction. The focus of the project was subsequently pivoted to the development of a new non-noble metal ORR catalyst that could provide durability in acidic electrolyte. The hypothesis was to encapsulate small iron (Fe) clusters in SWNTs (Fe@SWNTs) can provide ORR electro-catalytic activity and long durability in acidic environment. DFT-based computational studies were carried out to explore the feasibility of the Fe@SWNTs catalyst. The theoretical study indicated that Fe@SWNTs indeed could catalyze the ORR with lower theoretical overpotential than platinum (Pt). However, its weaker bonding energy with oxygen was the bottleneck of the overall reaction. On the other hand, Fe clusters (composed of 7 Fe atoms) encapsulated in nitrogen-doped SWNTs (Fe 7 @N 4 WSNTs) showed proper oxygen adsorption by the Fe cluster and low theoretical overpotential of ORR. Comparing to the Fe single atom catalyst on N-doped SWNTs (Fe-N 4 SWNTs), which is one the best non-noble metal ORR catalysts reported in the literature, the Fe 7 @N 4 WSNTs showed lower overpotential and better resistance to acidic environment. Fe encapsulated N-doped SWNTs were synthesized with ferrocene as the Fe precursors through vapor infusion method, and experimental validate is underway. This study theoretically demonstrated the feasibility of a new type of non-noble metal electro-catalyst for ORR that could have high catalytic activity and long durability.

08 HYDROGEN↗

Perovskite-Type Solid Solution Nano-Electrocatalysts Enable Simultaneously Enhanced Activity and Stability for Oxygen Evolution

A trade-off between catalytic activity and structural stability generally exists in oxygen evolution electrocatalysis, especially in acidic environment. This dilemma limits the development of higher-performance electrocatalysts that are required by next-generation electrochemical technologies. In this work it is demonstrated that the inverse catalytic activity–structural stability relation can be broken by alloying catalytically inert strontium zirconate with the other catalytically active perovskite, strontium iridate. This strategy results in an alloyed perovskite electrocatalyst with simultaneously improved iridium mass activity and structural stability, by about five times, for the oxygen evolution reaction under acidic conditions. The experimental and theoretical results suggest that the alloying strategy generates multiple positive effects, mainly including the reduction of catalyst size, the decrease of catalyst covalency, and the weakening of surface oxygen-binding ability. The synergistic optimization of bulk and surface properties, as a result, enhances the intrinsic activity and availability of surface iridium sites, whilst significantly inhibiting the surface cation corrosion during electrocatalysis.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Characterization of alternate encounter assemblies of SARS-CoV-2 main protease

The assembly of two monomeric constructs spanning segments 1-199 (MPro 1-199 ) and 10-306 (MPro 10-306 ) of SARS-CoV-2 main protease (MPro) was examined to assess the existence of a transient heterodimer intermediate in the N-terminal autoprocessing pathway of MPro model precursor. Together, they form a heterodimer population accompanied by a 13-fold increase in catalytic activity. Addition of inhibitor GC373 to the proteins increases the activity further by ~7-fold with a 1:1 complex and higher order assemblies approaching 1:2 and 2:2 molecules of MPro 1-199 and MPro 10-306 detectable by analytical ultracentrifugation and native mass estimation by light scattering. Assemblies larger than a heterodimer (1:1) are discussed in terms of alternate pathways of domain III association, either through switching the location of helix 201 to 214 onto a second helical domain of MPro 10-306 and vice versa or direct interdomain III contacts like that of the native dimer, based on known structures and AlphaFold 3 prediction, respectively. At a constant concentration of MPro 1-199 with molar excess of GC373, the rate of substrate hydrolysis displays first order dependency on the MPro 10-306 concentration and vice versa. An equimolar composition of the two proteins with excess GC373 exhibits half-maximal activity at ~6 μM MPro 1-199 . Catalytic activity arises primarily from MPro 1-199 and is dependent on the interface interactions involving the N-finger residues 1 to 9 of MPro 1-199 and E290 of MPro 10-306 . Importantly, our results confirm that a single N-finger region with its associated intersubunit contacts is sufficient to form a heterodimeric MPro intermediate with enhanced catalytic activity.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

Graphite Intercalation Compounds Derived by Green Chemistry as Oxygen Reduction Reaction Catalysts

Precious group metal (PGM) catalysts such as Pt supported on carbon supports are expensive catalysts utilized for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) due to their unmatched catalytic activity and durability. As an alternative, PGM-free ORR electrocatalysts that offer respectable catalytic activity are being pursued. Most of the notable PGM-free catalysts are obtained either from a bottom-up approach synthesis utilizing nitrogen-rich polymers as building blocks, or from a top down approach, where nitrogen and metal moieties are incorporated to carbonaceous matrixes. The systematic understanding of the origin of catalytic activity for either case is speculative and currently employed synthesis techniques typically generate large amounts of hazardous waste such as acids, oxidizing agents, and solvents. Herein, for the first time, we investigate the catalytic activity of graphite-based materials obtained via intercalation strategies that minimally perturb the graphitic backbone. Here, our outlined approaches demonstrate initial efforts to not only elucidate the role of each element but also significantly reduce the use of hazardous chemicals, which remains a pressing challenge. Graphite intercalation compounds (GIC) were obtained using fewer steps and solvent-free processes. X-ray diffraction and Raman results confirm the successful intercalation of FeCl 3 between graphite layers. Electrochemical data shows that the ORR performance of FeCl 3 -intercalated GIC displays slight improvement where the onset potential reaches 0.77 V vs RHE in alkaline environments. However, expansion of the graphite and solvent-free incorporation of iron and nitrogen moieties resulted in a significant increase in ORR activity with onset potential to 0.89 V vs RHE, a maximum half-wave of 0.72 V vs RHE, and a limiting current of about 2.5 mA cm –2 . We anticipate that the use of near solvent-free processes that result in a high yield of catalysts along with the fundamental insight into the origin of electrochemical activity will tremendously impact the methodologies for developing next-generation ORR catalysts.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Influence of Intracrystalline Ionic Strength in MFI Zeolites on Aqueous Phase Dehydration of Methylcyclohexanols

Abstract The impact of the concentration of hydrated hydronium ions and in turn of the local ionic strength in MFI zeolites has been investigated for the aqueous phase dehydration of 4‐methylcyclohexanol (E1 mechanism) and cis ‐2‐methylcyclohexanol (E2 mechanism). The E2 pathway with the latter alcohol led to a 2.5‐fold higher activity. The catalytic activity normalized to the hydronium ions (turnover frequency, TOF) passed through a pronounced maximum, which is attributed to the increasing excess chemical potential of the alcohols in the pores, increasing in parallel with the ionic strength and the additional work caused by repulsive interactions and charge separation induced by the bulky alcohols. While the maximum in rate observed is invariant with the mechanism or substitution, the reaction pathway is influencing the activation parameters differently.

Milaković, Lara↗