The Combined Detection of Morphological and Molecular Biomarkers: Implications for Astrobiology
Experience gathered by previous researchers during their hunt for evidence of early Earth life has shown the complexity in interpreting observations of possible microfossils and to establish the evidence to be positive. Similarly, the stillsimmering controversy on the nature of the nano-structures in Martian meteorite ALH84001 described by McKay et al. (1996) emphasizes the difficulties of conclusively identifying those structures as (a) fossilized bacterial cells and (b) establish their indigeneity. A better understanding of biological signatures in rocks is needed in order to identify traces of microbial life, which include morphological, mineralogical and chemical traces. It is thus considered crucial to tackle the problems emerging in the search for evidence of early life on Earth and in exopaleontological research with a multidisciplinary approach. With this is mind we applied surface sensitive Time of Flight-Secondary Ion Mass Spectroscopy (ToF-SIMS) to a previously described 25 m.y. old fossil bacterial biofilm. This technique allows in situ analysis with high mass resolution as well as molecular imaging of micron sized structures. As no extraction or derivatisation of the sample is required for ToF-SIMS analysis, electron microscopical investigation of the same samples subsequent to analysis is possible, thus allowing the combination of molecular and morphological biomarkers. The analysed fossil bacterial biofilms were associated with macrofossils from volcanoclastic lacustrine sediments from the Upper Oligocene Enspel formation (Germany). Preliminary scanning electron microscopy (SEM) studies have shown that a fossil structure interpreted as a coprolite purely consisted of fossilized bacterial biofilm. For ToF-SIMS investigation small particles were taken from the fossil biofilm and mounted onto Au-coated In-foil and analysed in a Phi Evans T-2000 TRIFT system. The ToF-SIMS analysed samples were Au/Pd-sputter coated and imaged using a Philips XL40 Field Emission Gun SEM (FEG-SEM). ToF-SIMS analysis of the organic rich fossil biofilm (TOC 29%) in the 0-100 Dalton (Da) range showed significant amounts of inorganic species, confirming the results obtained previously by EDX analysis, clearly showing the bacterial fossils to be mineralised. ToF-SIMS furthermore revealed the presence of a variety of low- and high-mass organic molecules and fragments thereof. These include peaks indicative of alkenes and alkanes, aromatic organic species and the polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon naphthalene. More tentatively, peaks indicative of alkyl pyrroles and pyridyl-CH2 were identified. Other peaks of interest include peaks indicative of C(n)H(2n)O2 and C(n)H(2n-2)O2, which according to their general formula would suggest the presence of both saturated and unsaturated fatty acids although further in situ derivatisation experiments and GC-MS (Gas Chromatography MS) need to be applied to verify this beyond doubt. Furthermore, peaks at m/z 370, 384, 398, 412, 426, 440, 454 and 468 were identified, which indicate the potential presence of bacterial hopanes, a class of biomarkers indicative of bacteria. The main diagnostic peak for this group of chemicals is the fragment at m/z 191.18. Our studies conducted on purified hopane standards have shown that in the high-mass resolution mode differentiation of this diagnostic hopane peak and polyethylene at m/z 191.05 is possible. However, the spectra discussed here were collected in the lower resolution mapping mode, therefore this differentiation was not possible. The centroids of the possible hopane peaks obtained on the fossil biofilms are well within the range associated with bacterial hopanes. There is a strong possibility therefore that hopanoids may be associated with the fossil bacterial cells. Due to the non-destructive nature of ToF-SIMS, analysed samples can be studied using SEM, thus allowing the combination of morphological and molecular biomarkers. Subsequent SEM analysis of the ToF-SIMS analysed samples confirmed that the analysed material purely consists of fossil bacterial cells. This is thus the first successful effort to demonstrate the combination of spectral and morphological biomarkers. The advantages of highly sensitive non-destructive in situ analysis techniques for biomarker detection are invaluable, particularly with respect to envisaged Mars sample return missions, as it may allow us to identify remains and traces of former microbial life in both ancient terrestrial and extraterrestrial materials. This technique may prove particularly useful in the quest for extraterrestrial life with respect to precious extraterrestrial materials, as minute quantities are sufficient to conduct analysis.