Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “tungsten”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 163 records · Page 9

Design and physics basis for the upcoming DIII-D SAS-VW campaign to quantify tungsten leakage and transport in a new slot divertor geometry

A set of experiments are planned to exploit the high SOL collisionality enabled by a tightly baffled slot divertor geometry to suppress tungsten leakage in DIII-D. A toroidal row of graphite tiles from the Small Angle Slot (SAS) divertor is being coated with 10–15 μ m of tungsten. New spectroscopic viewing chords with in-vacuo optics will measure the W gross erosion source from the divertor surface with high spatial and temporal resolution. In parallel, the bottom of the SAS divertor is changed from a flat to a ‘V’ shape. New SOLPS-ITER/DIVIMP simulations conducted with drifts using the planned ‘V’ shape predict a substantial reduction in W sourcing and SOL accumulation in either B × ∇B direction relative to either the old SAS divertor shape or the open, lower divertor. Dedicated studies are planned to carefully characterize the level of W sourcing, leakage, and scrape-off-layer (SOL) accumulation in DIII-D over a wide range of plasma scenarios. Various actuators will be assessed for their efficacy in further reducing high-Z impurity sources and leakage from the slot divertor geometry. Finally, this coupled code-experiment validation effort will be used to stress-test physics models and build confidence in extrapolations to advanced, high-Z divertor geometries for next-step devices.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Interstitial hydrogen enhances the mobility of some grain boundaries in tungsten

Segregation of interstitials at a grain boundary (GB) is known to generally lower its mobility. This phenomenon, called 'solute-drag', has important ramifications on the process of recrystallization and microstructural evolution. Here, we present predictions from molecular dynamics (MD) simulations which demonstrate that interstitial hydrogen in tungsten can in fact increase the mobility of some GBs which exhibit shear coupling. Assuming a disconnection-based mechanism, activation energies and pre-factors for disconnection nucleation are predicted from simulations of shear-coupled motion. In GBs where enhanced mobility is predicted, interstitial H reduces both the activation energy and the pre-factor for disconnection nucleation, thus effectively increasing the mobility. For GBs with diminished mobility, MD predicts that presence of interstitial H reduces the pre-factor and, in some cases, increases the activation energy. The reduction in the activation energy inferred from MD simulations are confirmed by nudged elastic band calculations. Temperature-dependent structural transitions are observed for some GBs, and the effect of interstitial H is found to change with the changes in structure. The effect of interstitial H is predicted to be complex and highly variable, providing some plausible explanations for experimental observations on the recrystallization of tungsten in presence of H-loaded plasma.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Effects of surface vacancy-adatom pair formation on PFC tungsten surface morphological response

Abstract We report a simulation study of the effect of He-irradiation-induced surface vacancy-adatom pair formation on the surface morphological evolution of plasma-facing component (PFC) tungsten and examine a number of factors that impact such evolution. Our analysis is based on self-consistent dynamical simulations according to an atomistically-informed, continuum-scale surface evolution model that has been developed following a hierarchical multiscale modeling strategy and can access the spatiotemporal scales of relevance to fuzz formation. The model accounts for the flux of surface adatoms generated as a result of the surface vacancy-adatom pair formation effect upon He implantation, which contributes to the anisotropic growth of surface nanostructural features due to the different rates of adatom diffusion along and across step edges of islands on the tungsten surface. We have carried out atomic-scale computations of optimal diffusion pathways along and across island step edges on the W(110) surface and calculated Ehrlich–Schwoebel (ES) barriers in adatom diffusion along and across such step edges. This aspect of surface adatom diffusion contributes to anisotropic surface atomic fluxes, terrace and step diffusive currents, and has been incorporated into our PFC surface evolution model, which predicts the formation of preferentially aligned nanoridge stripe patterns on the PFC surface. We establish that these anisotropic diffusive currents accelerate nanotendril growth on the PFC surface and the onset of surface nanostructure pattern formation. We also explore systematically the dependence of the PFC surface morphological response on the surface temperature and He ion incident flux, characterize in detail the resulting surface topographies and growth kinetics, and compare the predicted surface morphologies with experimental observations. Our simulation predictions for the emerging surface nanostructure patterns under certain plasma exposure conditions are consistent with experimental findings in the literature.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

ELM sputter erosion modeling of a tungsten coated small angle slot divertor in DIII-D

We modeled plasma edge localized mode (ELM) sputter erosion for a Small Angle Slot divertor with a tungsten coated region (SAS-VW), designed for experiments in the DIII-D tokamak, and proposed for use in future advanced tokamaks. The simulations use a free-streaming, 1000 eV, C +6 and D +1 ELM impingement model, with SOLPS-ITER, ITMC-DYN, and REDEP/WBC code packages for background plasma, material response, and erosion/redeposition respectively. The results show ELM'ing plasma gross and net tungsten erosion fluxes of the mixed-material C/W surface peaking at the slot entrance region, and an order of magnitude higher than for non-ELMs. The per-pulse erosion, however, remains low, of order 0.5 nm, due to expected moderate ELM frequencies and duration in DIII-D. Here, the ELMs result in a ~25x higher peak sputtered W current leaving the divertor slot region, towards the core plasma, compared to the ELM-free plasma case. The time-integrated escape current, however, may not significantly affect core plasma high-Z contamination concerns, for a 1% ELM duty factor, but may be an issue for higher frequency ELMs. In general, the modeling results appear favorable for effective testing of the SAS-VW divertor in DIII-D, and extrapolation to innovative divertor designs in future ITER-like and DEMO fusion devices.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

First tungsten radiation studies in DIII-D’s ITER baseline demonstration discharges

Abstract ITER Baseline Scenario plasmas were studied in DIII-D using krypton and xenon gases as a proxy for the tungsten that will be present in ITER. These impurities were chosen for having the same radiative loss rate Lz as tungsten would exhibit in the hotter ITER core. Results show that the scenario with these core radiators spans the range of impurity concentration and W radiated fraction expected for ITER, and up to 50% higher values, explored at zero injected torque, as well as 1 Nm and full co-torque injection with T ∼ 3 Nm. Stationary discharges with duration >2–4 τ R are achieved with f rad ⩾ 30% leading to a reduction in confinement of ∼10%, and a comparison with real metal radiators in the same range of f rad shows that the higher Lz at the lower temperatures in these plasmas yields too pessimistic results on the survivability and performance of this scenario in ITER. Simulations of ITER power balance including W radiation show that with concentration up to three times higher than in the DIII-D plasmas the scenario can be stationary, remaining at acceptable core radiated fraction values.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Uniaxial tensile mechanical properties from a scratch on ultra-fine grained tungsten

We demonstrate that surface-based mechanical testing can be used to quantify a wide range of mechanical properties determined using traditional uniaxial tension experiments. These include mapping of dynamic stress–strain behaviour, which can be used as a screening tool for uniaxial tensile ductility (uniform elongation), fracture toughness (K C ), which is shown to be in good agreement with reported plane-strain K IC , as well work-hardening exponents (n), activation volumes (V) energies (Q) and strain-rate sensitivity (m) exponents as a function of temperature. Advantages of the surface-based approach are the ability to work with significantly smaller volumes and accommodate processing defects like pores, voids and cracks. These methods are applied to ultra-fine grained tungsten (average grain size of 650 nm), as it is an ideal candidate for alloy development efforts in advanced energy systems. Tungsten is a useful baseline as it exhibits a near-ambient temperature (approx. 200°C) ductile-to-brittle transition temperature (DBTT), enabling validation efforts for the proposed methods, and extraordinary material properties, including the highest melting temperature of any metal and complex temperature and strain-rate dependencies linked to transitions in dislocation mechanisms.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Study of the Design and Characteristics of a Modified Pulsed Plasma Thruster with Graphite and Tungsten Trigger Electrodes

The paper presents experimental results for a modified pulsed plasma thruster (PPT) with solid propellant, using a coaxial anode–cathode design. Graphite from pencil leads served as propellant, and a tungsten trigger electrode was tested to reduce carbonization effects. Experiments were performed in a vacuum chamber at 0.001 Pa, employing diagnostics such as discharge current/voltage recording, power measurement, ballistic pendulum, time-of-flight (TOF) method, and a Faraday cup. Current and voltage waveforms matched an oscillatory RLC circuit with variable plasma channel resistance. Key discharge parameters were measured, including current pulse duration/amplitude and plasma channel formation/decay dynamics. Impulse bit values, obtained with a ballistic pendulum, reached up to 8.5 μN·s. Increasing trigger capacitor capacitance reduced thrust due to unstable “pre-plasma” formation and partial pre-discharge energy loss. Using TOF and Faraday cup diagnostics, plasma front velocity, ion current amplitude, current density, and ion concentration were determined. Tungsten electrodes produced lower charged particle concentrations than graphite but offered better adhesion resistance, minimal carbonization, and stable long-term performance. The findings support optimizing trigger electrode materials and PPT operating modes to extend lifetime and stabilize thrust output.

Faraday cup↗

Improving the Fracture Toughness and Ductility of Liquid-Phase Sintered WNiFe Tungsten Heavy Alloys by High-Temperature Annealing

Tungsten heavy alloys (WHAs) are candidates for use in fusion reactor divertors. Here, we characterize liquid-phase sintered WHAs with 90, 92.5, 95, and 97 (wt.%) tungsten (W), with a balance of a 0.7Ni–0.3Fe ductile phase. These WHAs show remarkable room temperature (RT) fracture toughness at the maximum load, K Jm , ranging from ≈ 38 to 107 MPa√m, compared to a monolithic W toughness of ≈ 8 MPa√m. In most cases, the fracture of WHAs occurs through stable crack tearing. However, the 97W WHA has the lowest toughness and fracture elastically in all but the smallest specimens. As lower Ni contents are desirable for fusion application, we explore the potential for improving the ductility and K Jm of WHAs using vacuum annealing at 1300 °C for 24 h. The microstructural observations reveal negligible changes in the WHA microstructure and constituent compositions. While annealing reduces the Vickers microhardness (HV), it does not significantly change the RT yield (σ y ) and ultimate (σ u ) strengths but results in beneficial increases in total elongation in the 95 and 97W WHAs by a factor of 2. RT tests on the precracked three-point-bend (3PB) bars show that annealing increases the K Jm of these WHAs, and in the case of the 97W WHA, the increase is from 42 to 92%, depending on the size of the specimen. Toughening is due to enhanced crack tip process zone microcracking and dilatation.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Evaluation of Tungsten—Steel Solid-State Bonding: Options and the Role of CALPHAD to Screen Diffusion Bonding Interlayers

Critical aspects of innovative design in engineering disciplines like infrastructure, transportation, and medical applications require the joining of dissimilar materials. This study investigates the literature on solid-state bonding techniques, with a particular focus on diffusion bonding, as an effective method for establishing engineering bonds. Welding and brazing, while widely used, may pose challenges when joining materials with large differences in melting temperature and can lead to mechanical property degradation. In contrast, diffusion bonding offers a lower temperature process that relies on solid-state interactions to develop bond strength. The joining of tungsten and steel, especially for fusion reactors, presents a unique challenge due to the significant disparity in melting temperatures and the propensity to form brittle intermetallics. Here, diffusion characteristics of tungsten–steel interfaces are examined and the influence of bonding parameters on mechanical properties are investigated. Additionally, CALPHAD modeling is employed to explore joining parameters, thermal stability, and diffusion kinetics. The insights from this research can be extended to join numerous dissimilar materials for specific applications such as aerospace, automobile industry, power plants, etc., enabling advanced and robust design with high efficiency.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Enhancement of Photovoltaic Current through Dark States in Donor–Acceptor Pairs of Tungsten–Based Transition Metal Di–Chalcogenides

As several photovoltaic materials experimentally approach the Shockley– Queisser limit, there has been a growing interest in unconventional materials and approaches with the potential to cross this efficiency barrier. One such candidate is dark state protection induced by the dipole–dipole interaction between molecular excited states. This phenomenon has been shown to significantly reduce carrier recombination rate and enhance photon-to-current conversion, in elementary models consisting of few interacting chromophore centers. Atomically thin 2D transition metal di-chalcogenides (TMDCs) have shown great potential for use as ultrathin photovoltaic materials in solar cells due to their favorable photon absorption and electronic transport properties. TMDC alloys exhibit tunable direct bandgaps and significant dipole moments. In this work, the dark state protection mechanism has been introduced to a TMDC based photovoltaic system with pure tungsten diselenide (WSe 2 ) as the acceptor material and the TMDC alloy tungsten sulfo-selenide (WSeS) as the donor material. Furthermore, our numerical model demonstrates the first application of the dark state protection mechanism to a photovoltaic material with a photon current enhancement of up to 35% and an ideal photon-to-current efficiency exceeding the Shockley–Queisser limit.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

High‐Pressure Synthesis of Ultra‐Incompressible, Hard and Superconducting Tungsten Nitrides

Abstract Transition metal nitrides, particularly those of 5 d metals, are known for their outstanding properties, often relevant for industrial applications. Among these metal elements, tungsten is especially attractive given its low cost. In this high‐pressure investigation of the W–N system, two novel ultra‐incompressible tungsten nitride superconductors, namely W 2 N 3 and W 3 N 5 , are successfully synthesized at 35 and 56 GPa, respectively, through a direct reaction between N 2 and W in laser‐heated diamond anvil cells. Their crystal structure is determined using synchrotron single‐crystal X‐ray diffraction. While the W 2 N 3 solid's sole constituting nitrogen species are N 3‐ units, W 3 N 5 features both discrete N 3‐ as well as N 2 4‐ pernitride anions. The bulk modulus of W 2 N 3 and W 3 N 5 is experimentally determined to be 380(3) and 406(7) GPa, and their ultra‐incompressible behavior is rationalized by their constituting WN 7 polyhedra and their linkages. Importantly, both W 2 N 3 and W 3 N 5 are recoverable to ambient conditions and stable in air. Density functional theory calculations reveal W 2 N 3 and W 3 N 5 to have a Vickers hardness of 30 and 34 GPa, and superconducting transition temperatures at ambient pressure (50 GPa) of 11.6 K (9.8 K) and 9.4 K (7.2 K), respectively. Additionally, transport measurements performed at 50 GPa on W 2 N 3 corroborate with the calculations.

Chemistry↗

Multimodal Defect Imaging of Pure Tungsten Components Fabricated via Electron Beam Powder Bed Fusion

The utilization of additive manufacturing (AM) techniques for refractory materials in high-temperature environments has significantly expanded because of the ability to fabricate geometrically complex components. Electron beam powder bed fusion (EB-PBF), which provides lower residual stress, a cleaner vacuum environment, and better efficiency for high melting point, is one of the best-suited AM methods to produce advanced refractory components. However, the property variation attributed to the heterogeneous microstructure and process-induced defects has hindered the widespread adoption of EB-PBF-produced material like tungsten. While numerous in-situ monitoring and defect detection methods have been demonstrated for EB-PBF, a workflow that compares and evaluates process-induced abnormalities from different imaging perspectives is still limited. This study examines a feature-embedded tungsten component manufactured via the EB-PBF process to demonstrate the defect detection capabilities of a multimodal defect imaging workflow. The predefined and process-induced defects are evaluated by harnessing various imaging techniques, including in-situ electron imaging, layerwise near-infrared (NIR) imaging, post-build high-energy x-ray computed tomography (CT), and conventional destructive metallography. The results highlight the strengths and limitations of distinctive defect imaging techniques concerning specific defect types, sizes, and conditions. It was found that electron imaging can provide more abnormal detection capabilities while maintaining a higher measuring accuracy, against the conventional metallography in this case study, compared with NIR and CT imaging techniques.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

High surface area mesoporous tungsten oxide for fast, green oxidation of organosulfur compounds in crude oil

Mesoporous, multi-valent tungsten oxide with high surface area (209 m 2 /g) is synthesized via a novel metal dissolution coupled with reverse micelle formation approach. Mesoporous tungsten oxide with highest surface area reported is obtained by this method. The material is used as an excellent heterogeneous catalyst for the oxidation of organosulfur compounds present in crude oil. The complete oxidation of dibenzothiophene was observed with excellent yield (>99%) within 15 min at room temperature (20 °C). The catalyst is reusable up to 5 reaction cycles without losing significant activity. A green oxidant, H 2 O 2 is used and the reaction mechanism involves the activation of peroxo species by W 6+ . The oxidation activity decreases in the order of DBT > 4,6-DMDBT > 1-BT due to the changes in the electronic environment of sulfur and steric effects.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Decoupling indentation size and strain rate effects during nanoindentation: A case study in tungsten

Materials indented at small scales may simultaneously exhibit indentation size and strain rate effects which complicate the identification of the mechanisms that control deformation and strength. Here, in this work, we explore the possibility that indentation size and rate effects in some materials can be decoupled in a simple way. Nanoindentation tests with various load-time histories were carried out to measure the hardness of a tungsten single crystal over a wide range of indentation depths (~500–3600 nm) and indentation strain rates (~5 ×10 –5 –2 ×10 –1 s –1 ). Under these conditions, this material exhibits significant indentation size and rate effects, but the size effect is, to a good approximation, independent of strain rate. It is shown that this behavior can be understood by the Nix-Gao model for the indentation size effect modified to include the effects of a strain rate dependent friction stress. As a consequence, the size and rate dependencies of the hardness can be expressed as the sum of two independent terms: H($\dot{ε}$ i , h c )=H f ($\dot{ε}$ i ) + (H 0 – H f ) $\sqrt{1+ \frac{h^*}{h_c}}$, where H($\dot{ε}$ i , h c ) is the hardness at given indentation strain rate ($\dot{ε}$ i ) and contact depth (h c ), H f ($\dot{ε}$ i ) is the hardness contributed by the rate dependent friction stress, and (H 0 – H f ) and h* are size and rate independent constants that follow from the Nix-Gao analysis. This formula, together with an expression for the rate dependence of H f , was successfully applied to decouple the indentation size and rate effects observed in tungsten. In addition, the physics underlying the rate independence of indentation size effect is discussed, which provides guidance for application of the proposed approach to other materials.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Insights into elevated temperature tensile deformation mechanisms and kink banding in additively manufactured tungsten

Additive manufacturing (AM) potentially enables fabrication and repair of plasma facing components (PFCs) of tungsten. However, deformation mechanisms in AM-fabricated tungsten under service-relevant thermomechanical conditions remain unknown majorly due to challenges in achieving crack-free W. This study reveals the deformation mechanisms operative under tension at 800 °C and 1200 °C in the electron beam melting powder bed fusion (EBM-PBF) fabricated W. Textured columnar grains with mixed <001 >/<111 >|| build-direction were observed. Strong anisotropy in tensile properties persisted across test temperatures, and all specimens exhibited extensive deformation-induced banding phenomena. Grain boundary character analysis of the deformed specimens indicated that these deformation bands were kink bands with tilt grain boundaries prominently present at the band-matrix interface. Interestingly, the material within the kink bands rotated toward higher resolved shear stress, providing insights into the origins of kink band formation in body-centered cubic refractory metals. Intragranular misorientation axis analysis revealed that plasticity was dominated by {110} <111 > slip at 800 °C, whereas additional (213)[11⁢̄1] and (112)[11⁢̄1] slip systems activated at 1200 °C. A dense low-angle boundary networks observed near fractured surface indicated the onset of dynamic recrystallization. Results reveal plasticity governing mechanisms in AM-fabricated W under power plant-relevant conditions, and provide insights into kink band attributes in refractory metals.

Mayes, Riley [ORNL] (ORCID:000900089307010X)↗

Tailoring ductile-phase toughened tungsten hierarchical microstructures for plasma-facing materials

Biological materials, such as bones, nacre, etc., have been found to show attractive and unique combinations of stiffness, strength and fracture toughness. Research has been conducted in various engineering areas to mimic the naturally hierarchical microstructures or nanostructures of these materials to produce materials with optimum stiffness, high strength and fracture toughness for their intended structural applications. In the same objective, this work applies a multiscale microstructural approach recently developed to investigate the deformation and fracture behavior of ductile phase toughened tungsten (W) materials such as tungsten-nickel/iron (W-Ni/Fe) composites that possess lamellar-like and hierarchical “brick-and-mortar” (BAM) microstructures. First, the approach is used to simulate tensile loading of W-Ni/Fe specimens cut out from hot-rolled W-Ni/Fe plates which possess lamellar-like microstructures. The finite element model of the gage section of the specimen consists of a W-Ni/Fe dual-phase microstructural domain in which the constitutive behaviors of W and Ni/Fe phases are described by an elastic-plastic damage model. The predicted material stress-strain response and crack pattern development as a function of loading are then compared to the corresponding experimental results to determine the constitutive model parameters for W and Ni/Fe. Subsequently, the model parameters are used to analyze W-Ni/Fe BAM microstructures that are artificially created to investigate the effects of microstructural features and morphologies on the composite stress-strain response, damage, and fracture patterns. The modeling shows that regular BAM microstructures that experience bridging mechanism combined with crack penetration across W-phase regions exhibit significantly higher strengths than the rather random lamellar-like microstructures. More significantly, however adjusting the brick’s length-to-height ratio, the BAM microstructure can be designed to allow a more distributed damage zone which leads to increased strength, ductility and fracture energy.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

A spatially-resolved model of neutron-irradiated tungsten coupling stochastic cluster dynamics and finite deformation plasticity

Structural materials used in nuclear reactors face severe degradation in mechanical properties, such as hardening and embrittlement. At the microscopic scale, this occurs due to creation and accumulation of irradiation-induced defects and their interaction with system dislocations. Although techniques exist which can model evolution of irradiation defects, for instance kinetic transport theory-based models, their interaction with mechanical deformation of the bulk material has not been investigated extensively. In this work, we demonstrate a novel spatially-resolved multiscale coupling between microscopic irradiation defect evolution, modeled using Stochastic Cluster Dynamics (SCD) and macroscopic mechanical deformation modeled using a finite-deformation plasticity model. SCD is used to determine the statistically averaged defect cluster spacing, dependent on operating conditions such as irradiation dose and temperature. This acts as an initial condition that governs the critical resolved shear stress of dislocation glide in the macroscopic plasticity model. This framework is used to predict mechanical behavior in post-mortem test of irradiated Tungsten samples, which has found its importance as structural material used in nuclear reactors. The results obtained using the coupled approach are in good agreement with experimental data of uniaxial tension tests. The model is able to capture the effect of temperature and irradiation dose on the material hardening. Two methods are proposed to estimate hardness – using Tabor's Law relating uniaxial yield stress to hardness and from flat-punch simulations. The results are in reasonable agreement with hardness data from micro-indentation experiments of irradiated Tungsten samples. Finally, the model is also able to reveal microstructural details such as spatial variation in defect density and local stress.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Influence of preheating on tungsten damage under pulsed hydrogen plasma exposure

Preheated tungsten plate behavior under multiple pulsed hydrogen plasma irradiations in the PW-7 plasma accelerator was investigated. The preheating temperature was 973 K, which is above the ductile to brittle transition temperature (DBTT ≈ 673 K). The plate was exposed to three consecutive series of 13 plasma pulses each. Preheating sufficiently suppressed surface cracking at the early irradiation stage: after 13 pulses, cracks were rare, localized, and did not form extensive fractures. During subsequent irradiation series, the area fraction of fine cracks increased by ∼ 2% due to accumulation of dislocations around the pre-existing defects. However, their width remained nearly constant, averaging 0.2–0.3 μm, with rare cracks up to 1 μm in size. Repeated plasma exposure resulted in pronounced surface roughening associated with multiple melting cycles, crater formation and blister rupture, with roughness reaching ∼ 204 nm and a recorded sample mass loss of ∼ 2.8 mg. These results indicate that controlling tungsten preheating well above DBTT effectively reduces damage. However, the surface condition during initial irradiation significantly influences its subsequent morphological evolution. Preheating to 773 K, selected regarding the minimum DBTT value, has previously been demonstrated to be an effective approach for limiting crack growth. A further increase in temperature of approximately ∼ 1000 K did not qualitatively improve results: crack still formed and widths did not decrease. At the same time, the absence of further crack coarsening indicates that the limiting effect of preheating has been reached. Considering the increased energy costs, further increasing the preheating temperature seems unjustified.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗