Replacement correction factors for cylindrical ion chambers in electron beams
Purpose: In the TG-21 dosimetry protocol, for cylindrical chambers in electron beams the replacement correction factor P{sub repl} (or the product p{sub dis}p{sub cav} in the IAEA's notation), was conceptually separated into two components: the gradient correction (P{sub gr}) accounting for the effective point of measurement and the fluence correction (P{sub fl}) dealing with the change in the electron fluence spectrum. At the depth of maximum dose (d{sub max}), P{sub gr} is taken as 1. There are experimental data available at d{sub max} for the values of P{sub fl} (or P{sub repl}). In the TG-51 dosimetry protocol, the calibration is at the reference depth d{sub ref}=0.6R{sub 50}-0.1 (cm) where P{sub gr} is required for cylindrical chambers and P{sub fl} is unknown and so the measured values at d{sub max} are used with the corresponding mean electron energy at d{sub ref}. Monte Carlo simulations are employed in this study to investigate the replacement correction factors for cylindrical chambers in electron beams. Methods: Using previously established Monte Carlo calculation methods, the values of P{sub repl} and P{sub fl} are calculated with high statistical precision (<0.1%) for cylindrical cavities of a variety of diameters and lengths in a water phantom irradiated by various electron beams. The values of P{sub gr} as defined in the TG-51 dosimetry protocol are also calculated. Results: The calculated values of the fluence correction factors P{sub fl} are in good agreement with the measured values when the wall correction factors are taken into account for the plane-parallel chambers used in the measurements. An empirical formula for P{sub fl} for cylindrical chambers at d{sub ref} in electron beams is derived as a function of the chamber radius and the beam quality specifier R{sub 50}. Conclusions: The mean electron energy at depth is a good beam quality specifier for P{sub fl}. Thus TG-51's adoption of P{sub fl} at d{sub max} with the same mean electron energy for use at d{sub ref} is proven to be accurate. The values of P{sub gr} for a Farmer-type chamber as defined in the TG-51 dosimetry protocol may be wrong by 0.3% for high-energy electron beams and by more than 1% for low-energy electron beams.