Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Stack Design”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,747 records · Page 97

TREAT neutronics analysis and design support, Part I: Multi-SERTTA

Experiment vehicle design is necessary in preparation for Transient Reactor Test (TREAT) facility restart and the resumption of transient testing to support Accident Tolerant Fuel (ATF) characterization and other future fuels testing requirements. Currently the most mature vehicle design is the Multi-SERTTA (Static Environments Rodlet Transient Test Apparatuses), which can accommodate up to four concurrent rodlet-sized specimens under separate environmental conditions. Robust test vehicle design requires neutronics analyses to support design development, optimization of the power coupling factor (PCF) to efficiently maximize energy generation in the test fuel rodlets, and experiment safety analyses. Calculations were performed to support analysis of a near-final design of the Multi-SERTTA vehicle, the design process for future TREAT test vehicles, and establish analytical practices for upcoming transient test experiments. Models of the Multi-SERTTA vehicle containing typical PWR-fuel rodlets were prepared and neutronics calculations were performed using MCNP6.1 with ENDF/B-VII.1 nuclear data libraries. Calculation of the PCF for reference conditions of a PWR fuel rodlet in clean water at operational temperature and pressure provided results between 1.10 and 1.73 W/g-MW depending on the location of the four Multi-SERTTA units with the stack. Basic changes to the Multi-SERTTA secondary vessel containment and support have minimal impact on PCF; using materials with less neutron absorption can improve expected PCF values, especially in the primary containment. An optimized balance is needed between structural integrity, experiment safety, and energy deposition in the experiment. Type of medium and environmental conditions within the primary vessel surrounding the fuel rodlet can also have a significant impact on resultant PCF values. The estimated reactivity insertion worth into the TREAT core is impacted more by the primary and secondary Multi-SERTTA vehicle structure with the experiment content and contained environment having a near negligible impact on overall system reactivity. Additional calculations were performed to evaluate the peak-to-average assembly powers throughout the TREAT core, as well as the nuclear heat generation for the various structural components of the Multi-SERTTA assembly. Future efforts include the evaluation of flux collars to shape the PCF for individual Multi-SERTTA units during an experiment such as to achieve uniformity in test unit environmental conditions impacted by the non-uniform axial flux/power profile of TREAT. Upon resumption of transient testing, experimental results from both the Multi-SERTTA and Multi-SERTTA-CAL will be compared against calculational results and methods for further optimization and design strategies. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Structure and properties of α-NaFeO{sub 2}-type ternary sodium iridates

The synthesis, structure, and elementary magnetic and electronic properties are reported for layered compounds of the type Na{sub 3−x}MIr{sub 2}O{sub 6} and Na{sub 3−x}M{sub 2}IrO{sub 6}, where M is a transition metal from the 3d series (M=Zn, Cu, Ni, Co, Fe and Mn). The rhombohedral structures, in space group R−3m, were determined by refinement of neutron and synchrotron powder diffraction data. No clear evidence for long range 2:1 or 1:2 honeycomb-like M/Ir ordering was found in the neutron powder diffraction patterns except in the case of M=Zn, and thus in general the compounds are best designated as sodium deficient α-NaFeO{sub 2}-type phases with formulas Na{sub 1−x}M{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2} or Na{sub 1−x}M{sub 2/3}Ir{sub 1/3}O{sub 2}. Synchrotron powder diffraction patterns indicate that several of the compounds likely have honeycomb in-plane metal–iridium ordering with disordered stacking of the layers. All the compounds are sodium deficient under our synthetic conditions and are black and insulating. Weiss constants derived from magnetic susceptibility measurements indicate that Na{sub 0.62}Mn{sub 0.61}Ir{sub 0.39}O{sub 2}, Na{sub 0.80}Fe{sub 2/3}Ir{sub 1/3}O{sub 2}, Na{sub 0.92}Ni{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2}, Na{sub 0.86}Cu{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2}, and Na{sub 0.89}Zn{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2} display dominant antiferromagnetic interactions. For Na{sub 0.90}Co{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2} the dominant magnetic interactions at low temperature are ferromagnetic while at high temperatures they are antiferromagnetic; there is also a change in the effective moment. Low temperature specific heat measurements (to 2 K) on Na{sub 0.92}Ni{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2} indicate the presence of a broad magnetic ordering transition. X-ray absorption spectroscopy shows that iridium is at or close to the 4+ oxidation state in all compounds. {sup 23}Na nuclear magnetic resonance measurements comparing Na{sub 2}IrO{sub 3} to Na{sub 0.92}Ni{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2} and Na{sub 0.89}Zn{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2} provide strong indications that the electron spins are short-range ordered in the latter two materials. Na{sub 0.62}Mn{sub 0.61}Ir{sub 0.39}O{sub 2}, Na{sub 0.80}Fe{sub 2/3}Ir{sub 1/3}O{sub 2}, Na{sub 0.90}Co{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2}, Na{sub 0.92}Ni{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2}, Na{sub 0.86}Cu{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2} and Na{sub 0.89}Zn{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2} are spin glasses. (CSD-numbers: Na{sub 0.62}Mn{sub 0.61}Ir{sub 0.39}O{sub 2}: 426657, Na{sub 0.80}Fe{sub 2/3}Ir{sub 1/3}O{sub 2}: 426659, Na{sub 0.90}Co{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2}: 426658, Na{sub 0.92}Ni{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2}: 426656, Na{sub 0.86}Cu{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2}: 426655, and Na{sub 2.8}ZnIr{sub 2}O{sub 6}: 426660.) - Graphical abstract: Diffraction patterns of Na{sub 0.92}Ni{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2}, Na{sub 0.86}Cu{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2} and Na{sub 0.89}Zn{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2}: neutron diffraction patterns in the main panel and synchrotron diffraction in the insets. The patterns show a small amount of ordering in the transition metal iridium layer. Display Omitted - Highlights: • We report six ternary sodium iridates with the α-NaFeO{sub 2} structure. • Compounds Na{sub 1−x}M{sub 1/3}Ir{sub 2/3}O{sub 2}, M=Co, Ni, Cu, Zn and Na{sub 1−x}M{sub 2/3}Ir{sub 1/3}O{sub 2}, M=Mn, Fe. • Rietveld refinement of powder neutron diffraction data. • All compounds are spin glasses. • NMR comparison to Na{sub 2}IrO{sub 3}.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Molecular docking sites designed for the generation of highly crystalline covalent organic frameworks

Covalent organic frameworks (COFs) formed by connecting multidentate organic building blocks through covalent bonds provide a platform for designing multifunctional porous materials with atomic precision. As they are promising materials for applications in optoelectronics, they would benefit from a maximum degree of long-range order within the framework, which has remained a major challenge. We have developed a synthetic concept to allow consecutive COF sheets to lock in position during crystal growth, and thus minimize the occurrence of stacking faults and dislocations. Hereby, the three-dimensional conformation of propeller-shaped molecular building units was used to generate well-defined periodic docking sites, which guided the attachment of successive building blocks that, in turn, promoted long-range order during COF formation. This approach enables us to achieve a very high crystallinity for a series of COFs that comprise tri- and tetradentate central building blocks. We expect this strategy to be transferable to a broad range of customized COFs.

construction↗

Manganese ion-assisted assembly of superparamagnetic graphene oxide microbowls

A facile manganese ion Mn(II)-assisted assembly has been designed to fabricate microbowls by using graphene oxide nanosheets as basic building blocks, which were exfoliated ultrasonically from the oxidized soot powders in deionized water. From the morphology evolution observations of transmission electron microscope and scanning electron microscope, a coordinating-tiling-collapsing manner is proposed to interpret the assembly mechanism based on attractive Van der Waals forces, π-π stacking, and capillary action. It is interesting to note that the as-prepared microbowls present a room temperature superparamagnetic behavior.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

1 kV, 10-kW SiC-Based Quadruple Active Bridge DCX Stage in a DC to Three-Phase AC Module for Medium-Voltage Grid Integration

Interfacing low voltage dc to medium voltage three-phase ac grid is often based on series-stackable modular converter architectures. To minimize energy storage requirements, it is advantageous to employ a quadruple active bridge (QAB) stage operating as a "dc transformer" in each stackable module. The QAB stage offers three isolated dc link voltages, which then allow for flexible stacking of three single-phase dc-to-ac inverter stages. Each of the module phases processes a pulsating power having a component at twice the line frequency. This presents a challenge in maintaining zero voltage switching (ZVS) on the secondary sides of the QAB during low-power portions of the line cycle. This article is focused on the design of the QAB stage. A detailed analysis of ZVS switching waveforms is presented, including effects of nonlinear device capacitances. It is shown how ZVS can be achieved at all times using a relatively small circulating current provided by the magnetizing inductance of the high-frequency transformer. Analytical expressions are given for the optimal values of the magnetizing inductance and the dead times of the QAB primary and secondary bridges. This approach is verified by experimental results on a 1 kV, 10-kW SiC-based prototype, demonstrating a relatively flat efficiency curve with a peak efficiency of 97.1% at 75% load.

24 POWER TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION↗

A stoichiometrically conserved homologous series with infinite structural diversity

Here, we describe a compositionally guided structural evolution within a stoichiometrically conserved framework, BaSbQ 3 (Q = Te 1−x S x ), where each value of x gives rise to a distinct phase. The fundamental building blocks, A 1 (BaSbSTe 2 ) and B n (Ba n Sb n S n−1 Te 2n+1 ), were composed of modular double rocksalt slabs stacked with functional polytelluride zigzag chains, with each phase differing only in the size and assembly of these blocks. Ten compounds were synthesized that maintained a coherent chemical identity that arose from this isovalent, isoelectronic substitution of Te and S. We envision that the phase formation at a molecular level unfolds in stages of extension, termination, and assembly and propose a design concept of “anionic disparity,” where phase homologies and polytelluride hierarchical networks can be controlled by leveraging differences in anion electron affinity and sizes.

Zhao, Hengdi [Argonne National Laboratory (ANL), A↗

Conduction Heat Transfer through Solid in Porous Materials: A Comparative Study by Finite-Element Simulations and Effective Medium Approximations

The development of insulation materials with low effective thermal conductivity is essential for energy savings in various applications, including buildings, food services, pipe insulation, and refrigeration. Such materials can be developed by using micro- or nanoporous structures, as well as low-thermal conductivity gases and/or reduced pressure. A variety of effective medium approximation (EMA) models have been developed to study thermal transport through solid in porous structures. However, in many cases, the impacts of porosity on solid conduction are not well predicted by EMA models because of the assumptions made for simplification. Furthermore, the results can vary by a factor of up to 1.5, depending on the morphology of the pores. Hence, proper guidance is needed to choose the appropriate EMA model for a given morphology. This work presents a finite element method study using COMSOL Multiphysics software for various geometries, including hollow cubes, overlapping hollow spheres (normally stacked and tightly packed), and Voronoi structures, and compares the results to those obtained from various EMA models. Simulation results for the hollow cubes and Voronoi structures matched well with the Maxwell-Eucken and Russell model. The results for hollow spheres closely matched the Bauer model and the Glicksman model with fitting parameters. This work provides guidance on analyzing and designing insulation materials for energy savings in the future.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Plated wire memory subsystem

The design, construction, and test history of a 4096 word by 18 bit random access NDRO Plated Wire Memory for use in conjunction with a spacecraft input/output and central processing unit is reported. A technical and functional description is given along with diagrams illustrating layout and systems operation. Test data is shown on the procedures and results of system level and memory stack testing, and hybrid circuit screening. A comparison of the most significant physical and performance characteristics of the memory unit versus the specified requirements is also included.

Carpenter, K. H.↗

TEXCAD: Textile Composite Analysis for Design. Version 1.0: User's manual

The Textile Composite Analysis for Design (TEXCAD) code provides the materials/design engineer with a user-friendly desktop computer (IBM PC compatible or Apple Macintosh) tool for the analysis of a wide variety of fabric reinforced woven and braided composites. It can be used to calculate overall thermal and mechanical properties along with engineering estimates of damage progression and strength. TEXCAD also calculates laminate properties for stacked, oriented fabric constructions. It discretely models the yarn centerline paths within the textile repeating unit cell (RUC) by assuming sinusoidal undulations at yarn cross-over points and uses a yarn discretization scheme (which subdivides each yarn not smaller, piecewise straight yarn slices) together with a 3-D stress averaging procedure to compute overall stiffness properties. In the calculations for strength, it uses a curved beam-on-elastic foundation model for yarn undulating regions together with an incremental approach in which stiffness properties for the failed yarn slices are reduced based on the predicted yarn slice failure mode. Nonlinear shear effects and nonlinear geometric effects can be simulated. Input to TEXCAD consists of: (1) materials parameters like impregnated yarn and resin properties such moduli, Poisson's ratios, coefficients of thermal expansion, nonlinear parameters, axial failure strains and in-plane failure stresses; and (2) fabric parameters like yarn sizes, braid angle, yarn packing density, filament diameter and overall fiber volume fraction. Output consists of overall thermoelastic constants, yarn slice strains/stresses, yarn slice failure history, in-plane stress-strain response and ultimate failure strength. Strength can be computed under the combined action of thermal and mechanical loading (tension, compression and shear).

Naik, Rajiv A.↗

Ares I First Stage: Powering Exploration

he mission of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) is not simply to maintain its current position with the International Space Station and other space exploration endeavors, but to build a permanent outpost on the Moon and then travel on to explore ever more distant terrains. The Constellation Program will oversee the development of the crew capsule, launch vehicles, and other systems needed to achieve this mission. From this initiative will come two new launch vehicles: the Ares I and Ares V. The Ares I will be a human-rated vehicle, which will be used for crew transport; the Ares V, a cargo transport vehicle, will be the largest launch vehicle ever built. The Ares Projects team at Marshall Space Flight Center (MSFC) in Huntsville, Alabama is assigned with developing these two new vehicles. The Ares I vehicle will have an in-line, two-stage rocket configuration. The first stage will provide the thrust or propulsion component for the Ares rocket systems through the first two minutes of the mission. The First Stage Team is tasked with developing the propulsion system necessary to liftoff from the Earth and loft the entire Ares vehicle stack toward low-Earth orbit. Building on the legacy of the Space Shuttle and other NASA space exploration initiatives, the propulsion for the Ares I First Stage will be a Shuttle-derived reusable solid rocket motor. Progress to date by the First Stage Team has been robust and on schedule. This presentation provides an overview and update on the design and development of the Ares I First Stage Propulsion system.

Tiller, Bruce K.↗

The Vibration Ring

The vibration ring was conceived as a driveline damping device to prevent structure-borne noise in machines. It has the appearance of a metal ring, and can be installed between any two driveline components like an ordinary mechanical spacer. Damping is achieved using a ring-shaped piezoelectric stack that is poled in the axial direction and connected to an electrical shunt circuit. Surrounding the stack is a metal structure, called the compression cage, which squeezes the stack along its poled axis when excited by radial driveline forces. The stack in turn generates electrical energy, which is either dissipated or harvested using the shunt circuit. Removing energy from the system creates a net damping effect. The vibration ring is much stiffer than traditional damping devices, which allows it to be used in a driveline without disrupting normal operation. In phase 1 of this NASA Seedling Fund project, a combination of design and analysis was used to examine the feasibility of this concept. Several designs were evaluated using solid modeling, finite element analysis, and by creating prototype hardware. Then an analytical model representing the coupled electromechanical response was formulated in closed form. The model was exercised parametrically to examine the stiffness and loss factor spectra of the vibration ring, as well as simulate its damping effect in the context of a simplified driveline model. The results of this work showed that this is a viable mechanism for driveline damping, and provided several lessons for continued development.

Asnani, Vivake M.↗

Embedding sulfur into N-doped carbon nanospheres as enhanced cathode for high-performance lithium-sulfur batteries

Graphical abstract: S has been successfully embedded into N-doped carbon nanospheres as enhanced cathode exhibiting good performance with high specific capacity and cycling stability. - Highlights: • Construct N-doped carbon nanospheres (N-CNSs) are host for sulfur. • N-CNSs/S cathode show high capacity and good cycles. • N doping is favorable for fast ion/electron transfer. - Abstract: Lithium-sulfur (Li-S) batteries are considered as one of the most efficient power candidates owing to high energy density about 7–10 times larger than the commercial cathode materials. However, its practical application is impeded by severe “shuttle effect” and low cycle stability. As a consequence, in this work, we report N-doped carbon nanospheres (N-CNSs) composited with S as cathode for Li-S batteries. The stacked carbon nanosphere structure can not only improve the conductivity of cathode, but also work as barriers to retard diffusion of intermediate polysulfide. Owing to the unique structure, the N-CNSs/S cathode exhibits superior electrochemical performances with high specific capacity (1228 mAh g{sup −1} at 0.1 C), and excellent rate capability as well as good cyclic life. Our smart designed strategy may promote the development of high performance Li-S batteries.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Boosting Photoelectric Conductivity in Porphyrin-Based MOFs Incorporating C 60

Electronic structure calculations show that guest C60 in the porphyrin-containing metal organic frameworks Zn 2 (TCPB)(DA-ZnP) (DA-MOF; H 4 TCPB = 1,2,4,5-tetrakis(4-carboxyphenyl)benzene, DA-ZnP = [5,15-bis[(4-pyridyl)ethynyl]-10,20-diphenylporphinato]zinc(II)) and Zn 2 (TCPB)(F-ZnP) (F-MOF; F-ZnP = [5,15-di(4-pyridyl)-10,20-bis(pentafluorophenyl)porphinato]zinc(II)) engenders high photoelectrical conductivity due to efficient donor–acceptor charge-transfer (CT) interactions. Structural modifications at the meso position of the porphyrin influence the preferred positions of C 60 within the frameworks, giving rise to host–guest interactions with different anisotropic structural, electronic, and optoelectronic properties. A preferred slipped-parallel π-stacked interaction of C 60 that is predicted for NH 2 -substituted DA-MOF and F-MOF fosters strong CT transitions and lowers band gaps by ~1.0 eV compared to the pristine DA-MOF and F-MOF. Hopping rates computed using Marcus theory are found to be anisotropic and accelerated by multiple orders of magnitude across π-stacked interfaces created by C 60 incorporation, a consequence of strong electronic coupling between initial and final diabatic states. Calculations indicate that photoinduced electron transfer, as well as direct CT from porphyrin to C 60 upon irradiation, triggers a charge separation process that leads to the formation of what should be long-lived electron-trapped states at the heterojunctions. Lastly, design principles revealed here for the control of photophysical and electron-transfer processes will be useful for constructing new MOF-derived visible- and infrared-based optoelectronics.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Asymmetric Bipolar Membrane for High Current Density Electrodialysis Operation with Exceptional Stability

Bipolar membranes (BPMs) enable isolated acidic/alkaline regions in electrochemical devices, facilitating optimized environments for electrochemical separations and catalysis. For economic viability, BPMs must attain stable, high current density operation with low overpotentials in a freestanding configuration. We report an asymmetric, graphene oxide (GrOx)-catalyzed BPM capable of freestanding electrodialysis operation at 1 A cm–2 with overpotentials <250 mV. Use of a thin anion-exchange layer improves water transport while maintaining near unity Faradaic efficiency for acid and base generation. Voltage stability exceeding 1100 h with an average drift of 70 μV/h at 80 mA cm–2 and 100 h with an average drift of −300 μV/h at 500 mA cm–2 and implementation in an electrodialysis stack demonstrate real-world applicability. Continuum modeling reveals that water dissociation in GrOx BPMs is both catalyzed and electric-field enhanced, where low pK a moieties on GrOx enhance local electric fields and high pK a moieties serve as active sites for surface-catalyzed water dissociation. These results establish commercially viable BPM electrodialysis and provide fundamental insight to advance design of next-generation devices.

Lucas, Éowyn↗

Systematic evaluation of structure–property relationships in heteroacene – diketopyrrolopyrrole molecular donors for organic solar cells

Improved understanding of fundamental structure–property relationships, particularly the effects of molecular shape and intermolecular packing on film morphology and active layer charge transport characteristics, enables more rational synthesis of new p-type small molecules. Here we investigate a series of small molecules consisting of an acene-based electron-rich core flanked by one or two electron-deficient diketopyrrolopyrrole (DPP) moieties. Through minor changes in the molecule structures, measurable variations in the crystal structure and sizable differences in macroscopic properties are achieved. The molecular symmetry as well as the conformation of the side chains affects the unit cell packing density and strength of the intermolecular electronic coupling in single crystals of all molecules in this series. Here, the addition of a second DPP unit to the benzodithiophene (BDT) core increases molecular planarity leading to decreased reorganization energy, strong cofacial coupling, and moderate hole mobility (2.7 × 10 –4 cm 2 V –1 s –1 ). Increasing the length of the acene core from benzodithiophene to naphthodithiophene (NDT) results in a further reduction in reorganization energy and formation of smaller crystalline domains (~11 nm) when mixed with PCBM. Decreasing the aspect ratio of the core using a “zig-zag” naphthodithiophene (zNDT) isomer results in the highest hole mobility of 1.3 × 10 –3 cm 2 V –1 s –1 due in part to tight lamellar (d = 13.5 Å) and π–π stacking (d = 3.9 Å). The hole mobility is directly correlated with the short-circuit current (11.7 mA cm –2 ) and solar cell efficiency (4.4%) of the highest performing zNDT:PCBM device. For each of these small molecules the calculated π-coupling constant is correlated with the hole mobility as a function of crystal structure and orientation indicating the importance of designing molecules that create extended crystalline networks with maximal π-orbital overlap.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Overcoming the Range Limitation of Medium-Duty Battery Electric Vehicles through the use of Hydrogen Fuel-Cells

Battery electric vehicles possess great potential for decreasing lifecycle costs in medium-duty applications, a market segment currently dominated by internal combustion technology. Characterized by frequent repetition of similar routes and daily return to a central depot, medium-duty vocations are well positioned to leverage the low operating costs of battery electric vehicles. Unfortunately, the range limitation of commercially available battery electric vehicles acts as a barrier to widespread adoption. This paper describes the National Renewable Energy Laboratory's collaboration with the U.S. Department of Energy and industry partners to analyze the use of small hydrogen fuel-cell stacks to extend the range of battery electric vehicles as a means of improving utility, and presumably, increasing market adoption. This analysis employs real-world vocational data and near-term economic assumptions to (1) identify optimal component configurations for minimizing lifecycle costs, (2) benchmark economic performance relative to both battery electric and conventional powertrains, and (3) understand how the optimal design and its competitiveness change with respect to duty cycle and economic climate. It is found that small fuel-cell power units provide extended range at significantly lower capital and lifecycle costs than additional battery capacity alone. And while fuel-cell range-extended vehicles are not deemed economically competitive with conventional vehicles given present-day economic conditions, this paper identifies potential future scenarios where cost equivalency is achieved.

08 HYDROGEN↗

Performance Comparison of Wireless Sensor Network Standard Protocols in an Aerospace Environment: ISA100.11a and ZigBee

Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) can provide a substantial benefit in spacecraft systems, reducing launch weight and providing unprecedented flexibility by allowing instrumentation capabilities to grow and change over time. Achieving data transport reliability on par with that of wired systems, however, can prove extremely challenging in practice. Fortunately, much progress has been made in developing standard WSN radio protocols for applications from non-critical home automation to mission-critical industrial process control. The relative performances of candidate protocols must be compared in representative aerospace environments, however, to determine their suitability for spaceflight applications. In this paper, we will present the results of a rigorous laboratory analysis of the performance of two standards-based, low power, low data rate WSN protocols: ZigBee Pro and ISA100.11a. Both are based on IEEE 802.15.4 and augment that standard's specifications to build complete, multi-hop networking stacks. ZigBee Pro targets primarily the home and office automation markets, providing an ad-hoc protocol that is computationally lightweight and easy to implement in inexpensive system-on-a-chip components. As a result of this simplicity, however, ZigBee Pro can be susceptible to radio frequency (RF) interference. ISA100.11a, on the other hand, targets the industrial process control market, providing a robust, centrally-managed protocol capable of tolerating a significant amount of RF interference. To achieve these gains, a coordinated channel hopping mechanism is employed, which entails a greater computational complexity than ZigBee and requires more sophisticated and costly hardware. To guide future aerospace deployments, we must understand how well these standards relatively perform in analog environments under expected operating conditions. Specifically, we are interested in evaluating goodput -- application level throughput -- in a representative crewed environment in the presence of varying levels of 802.11g Wi-Fi traffic. To do so, we use the NASA Johnson Space Center Wireless Habitat Testbed (WHT), a metallic, habitation-sized module designed for co-existence testing of wireless systems. In its quiescent state, the sealed WHT provides an RF-quiet environment to which we can selectively add interfering systems; it also provides a realistic level of multi-path self-interference for systems under investigation. In our test, we deploy two representative five node networks, configured in a star topology with all nodes reporting directly to a WSN gateway. Each ZigBee network WSN node is built using a Texas Instruments (TI) CC2530 system-on-a-chip radio running TI's ZigBee Pro Z-stack. Each ISA100.11a network node is built using a Nivis VersaNode 210 system-on-a-chip radio. In both cases, radios interface with TI MSP430-F5438 microcontroller implementing a common test application. Interference is provided by a D-link 802.11g Wi-Fi router transporting traffic generated using the Iperf network testing tool. For the single-channel ZigBee network, effects of both direct and indirect Wi-Fi interference are evaluated. For the channel-hopping ISA100.11a network, effects of interference from multiple Wi-Fi routers configured in non-overlapping 802.11g channels are evaluated. Our results show that, in general, the more lightweight ZigBee network performs well at low interference levels, but performance degrades as interference increases. Conversely, the more complex and costly ISA100.11a network continues to perform well as Wi-Fi interference levels increase.

Wagner, Raymond S.↗