Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “3D printed thermoset resins”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

17 records
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2021

Compositional effects on cure kinetics, mechanical properties and printability of dual-cure epoxy/acrylate resins for DIW additive manufacturing

Interest in 3D printing of thermoset resins has increased significantly in recent years. One approach to additive manufacturing of thermoset resins is printing dual-cure resins with direct ink write (DIW). Dual-cure resins are multi-component resins which employ an in situ curable constituent to enable net-shape fabrication while a second constituent and cure mechanism contribute to the final mechanical properties of the printed materials. In this work, the cure kinetics, green strength, printability, and print fidelity of dual-cure epoxy/acrylate thermoset resins are investigated. Resin properties are evaluated as a function of acrylate concentration and in situ UV exposure conditions. The acrylate cure kinetics are probed using photo-differential scanning calorimetry and the impacts of resin composition and UV cure profile on the acrylate extent of conversion are presented. Continuous and pulsed UV cure profiles are shown to affect total conversion due to variances in radical efficiency at different UV intensities and acrylate concentrations. The effects of acrylate concentration on the kinetics of the epoxy thermal cure and the final mechanical properties are also investigated using dynamic mechanical analysis and three-point bend measurements. The glass transition temperature is dependent on formulation, with increasing acrylate content decreasing the T g . However, the room temperature shear moduli, flexural moduli, strength, strain-to-failure, and toughness values are relatively independent of resin composition. The similarity of the final properties allows for greater flexibility in resin formulation and in situ cure parameters, which can enable the printing of complex parts that require high green strength. We found that the in situ UV print intensities and exposure profiles that are necessary to achieve the best print quality are not, in most cases, the conditions that maximize conversion of the acrylate network. Lastly, this highlights the importance of developing optimized resin compositions which enable complete cure of the acrylate network by promoting acrylate dark cure or thermal cure.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Structural Dynamics in UV Curable Resins Resolved by In Situ 3D Printing X-ray Photon Correlation Spectroscopy

Additive manufacturing (AM) is a promising technique to rapidly produce polymeric materials into complex 3-dimensional (3D) geometries. While AM is widespread and relevant for a range of applications, implementation in industry has outpaced our fundamental understanding of polymer dynamics and structure development during the printing process. Characterization and quantification of such dynamics is necessary to optimize final material properties and design future materials and processes for 3D printing. Here, we utilize X-ray photon correlation spectroscopy (XPCS) to measure spatial and time-resolved, out-of-equilibrium dynamics during direct ink write (DIW) 3D printing. Specifically, we investigate the progression of structural dynamics in a dual cure (UV/thermal) nanocomposite during and directly after printing. As the filament is printed and cured in situ, the relaxation processes of the cross-linking network are measured through the dynamics of inorganic filler particles. The characteristic relaxation time of the dynamics is calculated through the intensity–intensity autocorrelation function g 2 and directly correlated to the printing process parameters, such as printhead velocity and UV light intensity. The time-resolved evolution of nanoscale dynamics follows a power-law dependence as the filament is cured. Additionally, bulk rheological characterizations reveal the macroscopic solidification of the resin, providing correlation of material properties across a wide range of length and time scales. Overall, the measurement of multiscale, out-of-equilibrium dynamics provides insight into the development of structure in polymer nanocomposite filaments during 3D printing and is used to further understand the influence of such parameters on the AM process.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Selective Laser Sintering of High-Temperature Thermoset Polymer

Thermoplastic materials such as PA12 and PA6 have been extensively employed in Selective Laser Sintering (SLS) 3D printing applications due to their printability, processability, and crystalline structure. However, thermoplastic-based materials lack polymer inter-chain bonding, resulting in inferior mechanical and thermal properties and relatively low fatigue behavior. Therefore, 3D printing of high-performance crosslinked thermosets using SLS technology is paramount to pursue as an alternative to thermoplastics. In this work, a thermoset resin was successfully 3D printed using SLS, and its thermal stability of printed parts after a multi-step post-curing process was investigated. Dimensionally stable and high glass transition temperature (Tg: ~300 °C) thermoset parts were fabricated using SLS. The polymer crosslinking mechanism during the printing and curing process was investigated through FTIR spectra, while the mechanical stability of the SLS 3D-printed thermoset was characterized through compression tests. It is found that 100% crosslinked thermoset can be 3D printed with 900% higher compressive strength than printed green parts.

Hassan, Md Sahid (ORCID:0000000304665395)↗
NASA NTRS2019

Laser Sintering of Thermoset Polyimide Composites

Selective Laser Sintering (SLS) is an additive manufacturing technique that builds 3D models layer by layer using a laser to selectively melt cross sections in powdered polymeric materials, following sequential slices of the CAD model. SLS generally uses thermoplastic polymeric powders, such as polyamides (i.e. Nylon), and the resultant 3D objects are often weaker in their strength compared to traditionally processed materials, due to the lack of polymer inter-chain connection in the z-direction. Our previous effort showed the challenges of printing a melt-processable RTM370 imide resin powder terminated with reactive 4-phenylethynylphthalic anhydride by LS, due to its inherently low viscosity of these oligomers. This paper presented the first successful 3D printing of high temperature carbon fiber filled thermoset polyimide composites, followed by post cure cycles to promote additional crosslinking for achieving higher temperature (Tg = 370 °C) capability. The processes to build tensile specimens and a component by LS, and the characterization of RTM370 imide resin by DSC and rheology as well as evaluation of the LS printed polyimide composite specimens by SEM and mechanical tests will be discussed.

Polyimide Composites↗
DOE OSTI2025

Real-time process monitoring and automated control for direct ink write 3D printing of frontally polymerizing thermosets

Additive manufacturing (AM) enables the fabrication of complex geometries, yet its application to thermosets remains limited by post-processing requirements. Frontal ring-opening metathesis polymerization (FROMP) offers a promising alternative, enabling energy-efficient, in situ curing of freestanding thermoset structures. This study presents a real-time process monitoring and automated control system for direct ink writing (DIW) of FROMP thermosets. By integrating thermochromic leuco dyes and computer vision, we enable real-time polymerization front tracking, allowing autonomous printing parameter adjustments for consistent geometries across resin formulations. The system’s accuracy was validated against manual tracking, demonstrating precise front velocity detection. Its adaptability was confirmed by printing freestanding mechanical springs with different resins, achieving consistent geometries and mechanical properties despite front velocity variations. These findings highlight the potential of automated DIW control for scalable, repeatable, and material-agnostic 3D printing of thermosets.

Mejia, Edgar Brian [Sandia National Laboratories (↗
DOE OSTI2024

3D printable polymeric lightning strike protection system for fiber reinforced composites

The current embodiments include all-polymeric protective material for mitigating lightning strike damage. The protective material includes a hybrid matrix comprising PANI and MXene dispersed within a thermosetting epoxy resin. This hybrid matrix can be painted, printed, or applied as a conductive polymeric layer to a FRCP structure, for example an aircraft fuselage, wing, empennage, control surface (aileron, flap, slats, rudder, elevator) or a wind turbine blade. The protective material not only withstands lightning strikes, but also functions as shielding against electromagnetic interference and is corrosion-resistant and lightweight.

Kumar, Vipin↗
DOE OSTI2020

Linking thermoset ink rheology to the stability of 3D-printed structures

Thermoset polymer composites show promise for additive manufacturing (AM) applications to address some of the limitations of the more widely used thermoplastic feedstock materials. Thermosets offer attractive mechanical properties while providing excellent interlayer bonding, high thermal and chemical stability, and reduced energy consumption as a result of deposition at room temperature. However, since thermoset resins rely on a crosslinking reaction to solidify, rather than quickly cooling like thermoplastics, viscoelastic properties must be relied upon to maintain deposited shape after deposition until crosslinking can occur. This fact has not impeded development and characterization of new thermoset feedstocks on the small scale, but recent efforts to increase scale of thermoset printing have highlighted issues with structural stability under self-weight. This study addresses issues of self-weight by investigating the mechanisms that cause collapse of tall, thin printed walls. Using nanoclay- and fumed silica-filled epoxy feedstocks, this work compares the collapse height for printed walls to stability models based on yielding and buckling mechanics. Inputs for these models – shear yield stress and storage modulus – were taken directly from parallel plate rheometry measurements. Model predictions were found to be in good agreement with experimental results, where both yielding and buckling behavior were observed, provided the rheological properties after a shear excursion were used as inputs. This work establishes a direct link between basic rheological properties of the feedstock, geometry of the printed object, and achievable height. Overall, the results presented highlight the importance of understanding recovery behavior in thermoset feedstocks and provide valuable guidance on the development of more effective direct-ink writing feedstock materials.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
NASA NTRS2019

Manufacturing of Thermoset Polyimide Composites by Laser Sintering

Selective Laser Sintering (SLS) is an additive manufacturing technique that builds 3D models layer by layer using a laser to selectively melt cross sections in powdered polymeric materials, following sequential slices of the computer-aided design (CAD) model. SLS generally uses thermoplastic polymeric powders such as polyamides. The resultant 3D-printed objects are often weaker in their strength compared to traditionally processed materials, due to their higher porosity. This paper described the process development of using melt-processable imide oligomers terminated with reactive 4-phenylethynylphthalic anhydride (4-PEPA) to conduct laser sintering (LS). The first successful 3D-printing of high temperature RTM370 thermoset polyimide carbon fiber composites were further post-cured to promote additional crosslinking for achieving higher temperature (T g = 370°C) capability. Another novel imide oligomer, RTM385-SLS, formulated with a complex melt viscosity [ƞ*] of ~104-105 poise is also suitable for LS. RTM385-SLS resin powder was mixed with 20-25% of hexagonal boron nitride (h-BN) and subjected to LS to print out “Green” specimens which could be further post-cured to afford a thermally conductive but electrically insulating composites with high T g of 385 °C. The cured composite specimens were then subjected to mechanical testing, thermal conductivity and porosity measurements as well as SEM characterization.

additive Manufacturing↗
DOE OSTI2020

4D Printing via an Unconventional Fused Deposition Modeling Route to High-Performance Thermosets

An unprecedented four-dimensional (4D) printing process allowing high-performance and shape memory thermoset to be printed, for the first time, by fused deposition modeling (FDM) with isotropic properties has been achieved. Here, bisphenol A-based epoxy and benzoxazine were formulated to a low-temperature thermoplastic and high-temperature thermoset resin, which is melt-extrudable and can be postcured into covalently cross-linked material. Carbon nanotube (CNT) was added in the resin to work as both mechanical enhancement filler and rheology modifier to prevent shape deformation during postcuring process. The cross-layer reaction fuses individual layers into an integrity, thus eliminating layer delamination induced by FDM, offering isotropic mechanical properties regardless of the printing orientations. The highly cross-linked network provides outstanding mechanical strength and superb thermal stability. The excellent shape memory performance with fast recovery rate and large recovery degree is also obtained in the three-dimensional (3D) printed composites.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2026

The Structure-Properties Relationship of Alternative Bismaleimide Variants for Candidacy for Additive Manufacturing

Modernizing the manufacturing of high-performance polymer foams such as amino-poly(oxadiazole) bismaleimide (APO-BMI), a bismaleimide resin with superior thermal and compressive strength that incorporates additive manufacturing (AM) techniques, is crucial for its applications, but the parameters for AM can be challenging based on the physical properties of the associated monomer. For our applications, selective laser sintering (SLS) is typically used. SLS is a 3D printing technique that allows for complex shapes and geometries without structural supports while also providing high resolution material. However, printing thermosets like APO-BMI with SLS is challenging due to the complex melting and curing considerations required when selecting parameters. Additionally, the temperature difference between melting and curing of APO-BMI is over a hundred º C, which makes selecting a sintering window especially difficult. This work explores structural modifications of APO-BMI that may be more amenable for selective laser sintering. The effects of how different structural changes such as substitution pattern, heteroatom identity in the bridge, and bridge length affect the thermal properties of the material were also compared. All APO variants were found to have a smaller temperature window between the melting and curing peaks based on differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) which is advantageous for SLS. Small structural changes significantly altered the melting and curing properties of APO. Additionally, DSC revealed significant polymorphisms in APO-BMI and other APO variants which could be attributed to differences in thermal history and would need to be considered when adapting for SLS.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
NASA NTRS2016

Challenges in Laser Sintering of Melt-Processable Thermoset Imide Resin

Polymer Laser Sintering (LS) is an additive manufacturing technique that builds 3D models layer by layer using a laser to selectively melt cross sections in powdered polymeric materials, following sequential slices of the CAD model. LS generally uses thermoplastic polymeric powders, such as polyamides (i.e. Nylon), and the resultant 3D objects are often weaker in their strength compared to traditionally processed materials, due to the lack of polymer inter-chain connection in the z-direction. The objective of this project is to investigate the possibility of printing a melt-processable RTM370 imide resin powder terminated with reactive phenylethynyl groups by LS, followed by a postcure in order to promote additional crosslinking to achieve higher temperature (250-300 C) capability. A preliminary study to build tensile specimens by LS and the corresponding DSC and rheology study of RTM370 during LS process is presented.

Additive Manufacturing↗
NASA NTRS2016

Challenges in Laser Sintering of Thermoset Imide Resin

Polymer Laser Sintering (LS) is an additive manufacturing technique that builds 3D models layer by layer using a laser to selectively melt cross sections in powdered polymeric materials, following sequential slices of the CAD model. LS generally uses thermoplastic polymeric powders, such as polyamides (i.e. Nylon), and the resultant 3D objects are often weaker in their strength compared to traditionally processed materials, due to the lack of polymer inter-chain connection in the z-direction. The objective of this project is to investigate the possibility of printing a melt-processable RTM370 imide resin powder terminated with reactive phenylethynyl groups by LS, followed by a postcure in order to promote additional crosslinking to achieve higher temperature (250-300 C) capability. A preliminary study to build tensile specimens by LS and the corresponding DSC and rheology study of RTM370 during LS process is presented.

Additive Manufacturing↗
DOE OSTI2023

Photo-Curing 3D Printing of Thermosetting Sacrificial Tooling for Fabricating Fiber-Reinforced Hollow Composites

Carbon fiber-reinforced hollow composites play a vital role in lightweighting modern cars and aircrafts. Fabrication of such hollow composites with seamless internal finish requires sacrificial tooling that can be used under pressure and high temperature. For the very first time, high performance sacrificial tooling that can be used to fabricate fiber-reinforced hollow composites is produced using photocuring 3D printing technology. This is achieved by developing UV-curable resins containing highly soluble yet hydrolysable acetal acrylate cross-linker and hydrophilic 4-acryloylmorpholine monomer. It is found that the cross-linker content greatly affects the printing speed. Further, the widely adopted UV post-curing method is found to have negligible impact on improving the thermal-mechanical properties of printed structures. Additionally, after thermal post-treatment, printed sacrificial tooling exhibits a heat deflection temperature of 112 °C at 0.455 MPa and an average coefficient of linear thermal expansion of 59 ppm °C -1 between 30 and 100 °C. As a result, printed tooling enables fabrication of carbon fiber-reinforced hollow composites with complex geometry, which shows a tensile strength of 802 MPa and an elastic modulus of 50.2 GPa.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Unraveling Reactivity Differences: Room-Temperature Ring-Opening Metathesis Polymerization (ROMP) versus Frontal ROMP

Here, in this study, we explore the distinct reactivity patterns between frontal ring-opening metathesis polymerization (FROMP) and room-temperature solventless ring-opening metathesis polymerization (ROMP). Despite their shared mechanism, we find that FROMP is less sensitive to inhibitor concentration than room-temperature ROMP. By increasing the initiator-to-monomer ratio for a fixed inhibitor/initiator quantity, we find reduction in the ROMP background reactivity at room temperature (i.e., increased resin pot life). At elevated temperatures where inhibitor dissociation prevails, accelerated frontal polymerization rates are observed because of the concentrated presence of the initiator. Surprisingly, the strategy of employing higher initiator loading enhances both pot life and front speeds, which leads to FROMP rates exceeding prior reported values by over 5 times. This counterintuitive behavior is attributed to an increase in the proximity of the inhibitor to the initiator within the bulk resin and to whether the temperature favors coordination or dissociation of the inhibitor. A rapid method was developed for assessing resin pot life, and a straightforward model for active initiator behavior was established. Modified resin systems enabled direct ink writing of robust thermoset structures at rates much faster than previously possible.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2023

Bona fide upcycling strategy of anhydride cured epoxy and reutilization of decomposed dual monomers into multipurpose applications

Waste epoxy materials become an enormous problem to society and the environment. The advantages of epoxy resins derive from their rigid and chemically stable networks, but these qualities also make them difficult to dispose of or recycle. In this work, we demonstrated an efficient degradation of anhydride cured epoxy resin by aminolysis in aminoethanol without using any catalysts. The epoxy resin was fully decomposed at 160 °C in 4 h, resulting in two distinct high purity monomers (HHPA-OH and BPA-OH). To fully realize this upcycling approach, The BPA-OH was used to synthesize a polyurethane coating with an excellent glass transition temperature (88.9 °C), scratch hardness (8H), gouge hardness (6H), adhesive strength (5B), and strong solvent resistance. The HHPA-OH with two hydroxyl groups was reacted with methacrylic anhydride to form a dimethacrylate monomer which was then used as a viable crosslinker for photo-curable 3D printing thermosetting polymer with tensile strength as high as 64 MPa and impact strength of 4.86 kJ/m 2 . This work demonstrates a feasible pathway to convert anhydride cured epoxy waste to new monomeric recyclates for superior polymer products.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Additive manufacturing of carbon fiber-reinforced thermoset composites via in-situ thermal curing

Fiber-reinforced polymer composites are lightweight structural materials widely used in the transportation and energy industries. Current approaches for the manufacture of composites require expensive tooling and long, energy-intensive processing, resulting in a high cost of manufacturing, limited design complexity, and low fabrication rates. Here, we report rapid, scalable, and energy-efficient additive manufacturing of fiber-reinforced thermoset composites, while eliminating the need for tooling or molds. Use of a thermoresponsive thermoset resin as the matrix of composites and localized, remote heating of carbon fiber reinforcements via photothermal conversion enables rapid, in-situ curing of composites without further post-processing. Rapid curing and phase transformation of the matrix thermoset, from a liquid or viscous resin to a rigid polymer, immediately upon deposition by a robotic platform, allows for the high-fidelity, freeform manufacturing of discontinuous and continuous fiber-reinforced composites without using sacrificial support materials. This method is applicable to a variety of industries and will enable rapid and scalable manufacture of composite parts and tooling as well as on-demand repair of composite structures.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Dielectric Barrier Discharge Electrothermal Heating and Additive Manufacturing of Thermoset Parts

Additive manufacturing of thermosets requires a mechanism for solidifying deposited layers in order to prevent part collapse. To accomplish this, non‐equilibrium plasma is proposed for its ability to target, heat, and cure printed thermosetting resin. Non‐equilibrium plasmas have not been used for the curing of liquid thermoset composites, and so their impact on an uncured resin is unknown. Here this work investigates the mechanism through which dielectric barrier discharge (DBD) heats an epoxy/carbon nanotube (CNT) composite under atmospheric conditions. Plasma applied to resin surfaces is found to cause rapid heating, with heating rate controlled by adjusting the applied power. Heating is localized to within the top 0.5 mm of the sample surface and maximum temperature is found to depend on sample conductivity, indicating the heating reaction occurs through a combination of electron conduction and ion bombardment. Characterization of composites cured using plasma shows oxidation and roughening of the surface. Based on the heating and surface studies, several demonstrative prints are performed using in situ plasma curing. This work shows the potential of DBD plasma to rapidly heat liquid substrates and demonstrates how plasma curing expands the capability of existing direct ink write (DIW) printer technologies.

3D printing↗