Modeling Drift Loss Cone Effects on the Trapping of an Artificial Radiation Belt
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
We summarize the scientific problem and work plan for the LANL LDRD-funded project to use a test particle code to study the sudden de-trapping of inner belt protons and possible cross-L transport of debris ions after a high altitude nuclear explosion (HANE). We also discuss future application of the code for other HANE-related problems.
Los Alamos National Laboratory has developed an end-to-end model that quantifies the total ionizing dose that a shielded component on a space asset will accrue due to interactions with trapped beta-decay electrons produced after a high-altitude nuclear explosion. The model consists of three major components: initial trapping, spatio-temporal evolution of the trapped population, and interaction of the evolving trapped population with a space asset to produce total ionizing dose. The initial trapping module calculates the fraction of betas produced by radioactive decay of nuclear fission products that will be trapped in the magnetic field surrounding Earth for at least one drift around Earth. Previously, the initial trapping calculation assumed a centered dipole magnetic field model whereas we know that Earth’s magnetic field is offset from its geographic center and has higher-order non-dipole terms. Both the offset and the higher-order terms are captured in the International Geomagnetic Reference Field (IGRF) internal field model. In a centered dipole, the electrons that are trapped on a magnetic field line at one longitude will be trapped at all other longitudes as they drift around Earth due to azimuthal symmetry of the field, but the offset and higher-order terms of the IGRF field affects the drift of the trapped electrons and causes some that are trapped at one longitude to be lost at other longitudes. These electrons are called "quasi-trapped" and are said to be in the drift loss cone since they will be lost during their first drift around Earth. In this paper we report on the effect of incorporating the drift of electrons around Earth using the IGRF field on the trapping fraction as compared to using a centered dipole. Here, we find that the new, more accurate, methodology produces higher trapping fractions for bursts above the South Atlantic Anomaly, a region of low magnetic field strength, and lower trapping fractions for bursts in regions with higher magnetic field strength than expected from a centered dipole.
One consequence of a high altitude nuclear explosion (HANE) is the creation of an artificial radiation belt that can have severe consequences for space-based infrastructure in low Earth orbit (LEO). A HANE-generated radiation belt is produced when radioactive debris ions beta decay to produce an intense population of magnetically-trapped, high-energy electrons that can affect satellites through increased total dose rates and/or internal charging. Recent results from NASA's Van Allen Probes mission has shown how electromagnetic waves can scatter radiation belt electrons decreasing their intensity and effects. Radiation Belt Remediation (RBR) seeks to exploit those processes to rapidly deplete the intensity of either natural or HANE-produced radiation belts by artificially injecting waves to enhance electron scattering and loss rates. One promising option for producing the required waves is to use modulated medium energy electron beams as a type of 'wireless transmitter'. (author)
Single-photon detectors operating on satellites for use in a quantum communications network can incur large dark-count-rate increases from the natural radiation environment of space. Displacement damage to the material lattice of a detector from the ionizing radiation can result in a permanent dark-count increase in the detector. In this work, we analyze the radiation-induced dark-count rate of a silicon single-photon avalanche diode onboard a satellite at different orbiting altitudes, as well as, the additional radiation from a nuclear-disturbed environment caused by a high-altitude nuclear explosion. For detectors on low Earth orbit satellites, protons are the biggest source of radiation damage and are best mitigated by choosing an orbit that minimizes exposure when passing through the South Atlantic Anomaly and Polar Cusps. Detectors on medium Earth orbit and geostationary orbit satellites, if shielded by more than 10 mm of aluminum, provide the best platform in terms of the least amount of radiation damage to the detectors. In the event of a high-altitude nuclear explosion, the artificial radiation belts produced by the explosion will cause too much damage to silicon single-photon detectors on low Earth orbit satellites and render them unfit for quantum communications in less than a day. Higher orbit satellites will only suffer minor dark-count-rate increases from the artificial radiation belts.
In this presentation we briefly review some of the published data regarding the artificial radiation belts produced by the Starfish and R2 high altitude nuclear explosions in 1962. The data showed slow temporal variations of the belts in altitude (L) and pitch angle ({alpha}) that could be modeled as a diffusion process. That early work formed the basis for more complex radiation belt diffusion models that are in use at present.
In the early years of this century, there was renewed interest at DTRA in artificial radiation belts, the dynamics of high altitude nuclear explosions that produced them, the development of large-scale kinetic plasma computer models at LLNL and LANL (particularly in the form of “hybrid” {i.e., particle ions, massless fluid electrons} algorithms), and the building of a laser facility at UCLA, under the direction of Prof. Niemann, which was connected to the Large Plasma Device (LAPD), a DOE user facility. These advances sparked the idea for a new laser experimental program to examine early-time HANE issues, reviving the concept from a former program at NRL in the 90’s. The basic motivation for this new effort can be traced back to the first DTRA artificial radiation belt workshop at Stanford in 2009. Subsequent discussions then led to a formal proposal from UCLA that was submitted to DTRA (Grant Jones) in 2010, vigorously reviewed, and finally approved in 2011, with funding begun in 2012. An historical perspective of this development process was presented at a DTRA review last year. In this document we review and summarize the major achievements of the DTRA-sponsored UCLA HANE-laser experiment over the past eight years. Our purpose is to briefly describe the major achievements of this program, as documented in the included extensive list of journal publications [which does not include all the publications nor any of the many invited and contributed presentations of the UCLA group], the role of the national laboratories in this effort, and how this work has impacted (and will continue to improve) our understanding of high altitude nuclear events.
The Dynamic Radiation Environment Assimilation Model (DREAM) is a 3-year effort sponsored by the US Department of Energy to provide global, retrospective, or real-time specification of the natural and potential nuclear radiation environments. The DREAM model uses Kalman filtering techniques that combine the strengths of new physical models of the radiation belts with electron observations from long-term satellite systems such as GPS and geosynchronous systems. DREAM includes a physics model for the production and long-term evolution of artificial radiation belts from high altitude nuclear explosions. DREAM has been validated against satellites in arbitrary orbits and consistently produces more accurate results than existing models. Tools for user-specific applications and graphical displays are in beta testing and a real-time version of DREAM has been in continuous operation since November 2009.
We present a summary of the FY12 activities for DTRA-funded project 'Modeling Relativistic Electrons from Nuclear Explosions in the Magnetosphere'. We briefly review the outstanding scientific questions and discuss the work done in the last year to try to answer these questions. We then discuss the agenda for this Technical Meeting with the DTRA sponsors. In the last year, we have continued our efforts to understand artificial radiation belts from several different perspectives: (1) Continued development of Electron Source Model (ESM) and comparison to HANE test data; (2) Continued studies of relativistic electron scattering by waves in the natural radiation belts; (3) Began study of self-generated waves from the HANE electrons; and (4) Began modeling for the UCLA laser experiment.
Between 1958 and 1962 the United States and the Soviet Union performed several nuclear detonation tests in the atmosphere, including the Starfish Prime event which involved a 1.4 Mt explosion at 400 km altitude over Johnston island on July 9, 1962 (Gombosi et al., 2017). These tests can be considered as the beginning of active experiments in space (i.e., experiments that deliberately perturb the local environment). They demonstrated the potential destructive power of high-altitude nuclear explosions, both in terms of the resulting electromagnetic pulse as well as for the creation of a potentially long-lasting artificial radiation belt from the radioactive fission debris. For instance,one of the unintended consequences of Starfish Prime was to cripple at least seven spacecraft in low-Earth orbit (LEO), about a third of the LEO spacecraft of the time (Gombosi et al., 2017).
Abstract not provided.
This presentation describes particle motion, initial trapping, and evolution. There is also a demo of the end-to-end model and a description of some recent results.
In the presence of drift-shell splitting intrinsic to the IGRF magnetic field model, pitch-angle scattering from Coulomb collisions experienced by radiation-belt electrons in the upper atmosphere and ionosphere produces extra radial diffusion, a form of neoclassical diffusion. The strength of the neoclassical radial diffusion at L < 1.2 exceeds that expected there from radial-diffusion mechanisms traditionally considered, and decreases with increasing L-shell. In this study we construct a numerical model for this coupled (radial and pitch-angle) collisional diffusion process and apply it to simulate raw count-rate data observed aboard the Gemini spacecraft for several years after the 1962 Starfish nuclear detonation. The data show apparent lifetimes 10-100 times as long as would have been expected from collisional pitch-angle diffusion and Coulomb drag alone. Our model reproduces apparent lifetimes for >0.5-MeV electrons in the region 1.14 < L < 1.26 to within a factor of two (comparable to the uncertainty quoted for the observations). We conclude that neoclassical radial diffusion (resulting from drift-shell splitting intrinsic to IGRF's azimuthal asymmetries) mitigates the decay expected from collisional pitch-angle diffusion and inelastic energy loss alone and thus contributes importantly to the long apparent lifetimes observed at these low L-shells.
The Russian-3 (R3) HANE, a 60 km high-latitude burst with yield estimated at 300 kt, was chosen for the demonstration. This test was selected because it allowed LLNL to leverage existing funding, which was directed at extending LLNL’s capability to simulate HANEs at atmospheric altitudes (<100 km). David Larsen (LLNL) developed a new particle-tracing code that tracks monoenergetic electrons of various energies from a point source as they interact with the atmosphere, losing energy and ‘pitch-angle scattering’ as they are transported. A relatively large fraction of the initial electrons are able to escape the atmosphere and were handed off to LANL for further processing to calculate the effect on space based assets. LANL binned the electrons into a phase-space density as a function of energy and equatorial pitch-angle and showed that all of the electrons would travel along field lines to the conjugate point in the Southern hemisphere, where they would likely be absorbed, because their equatorial pitch-angles were too field-aligned to permit them to ‘mirror’ above the atmosphere and be ‘trapped’. Thus, the initial LLNL output did not produce any trapped electrons to input into LANL’s diffusion code and so no study of the long-term evolution of the trapped population and its effect on space-based assets could be performed. It was recognized that LLNL’s calculation did not properly model the low-probability, large-angle scattering associated with a single Coulomb interaction between a beta-decay electron and the nucleus of the neutral particles in the high atmosphere, which would be the dominant interaction above some altitude (>100 km) and might allow the electrons to be pitch-angle scattered sufficiently to become trapped. A second LLNL calculation that properly included this single interaction probability was conducted and the output processed by LANL. It was shown that a small fraction of the initial population (~0.01%) would be ‘locally trapped’; however, even this small population would likely be absorbed within a few minutes as the electrons drifted around earth and eventually ended up on field lines where they would be absorbed in the atmosphere. The output of the second LLNL calculation was found to produce about 4x fewer backscattered electrons than previous work (Selesnick et al 2012), and so the remainder of the FY13 LANL effort on the project was aimed at trying to resolve this discrepancy. LANL implemented a stochastic differential equation to simulate the backscatter process so that the results could be compared to Larsen and Selesnick. Initial results from this capability have been obtained, but no quantitative comparison to Larsen or Selesnick has been done yet.
Abstract Terrestrial ring current dynamics are a critical part of the near‐space environment, in that they directly drive geomagnetic field variations that control particle drifts, and define geomagnetic storms. The present study aims to specify a global and time‐varying distribution of ring current proton using geomagnetic indices and solar wind parameters with their history as input. We train an artificial neural network (ANN) model to reproduce proton fluxes measured by the Radiation Belt Storm Probes Ion Composition Experiment instrument onboard Van Allen Probes. By choosing optimal feature parameters and their history length, the model results show a high correlation and a small error between model specifications and satellite measurements. The modeled results well capture energy‐dependent proton dynamics in association with geomagnetic storms, including inward radial diffusion, acceleration and decay. Our ANN model produces proton fluxes with their corresponding 3D spatiotemporal variations, capturing the latitudinal distribution and local time asymmetry that are consistent with observations and that can further inform theory.
Naturally occurring whistler mode emissions in the magnetosphere, are important since they are responsible for the acceleration of outer radiation belt electrons to relativistic energies and also for the scattering loss of these electrons into the atmosphere. Recently, we reported on the first laboratory experiment where whistler waves exhibiting fast frequency chirping have been artificially produced [1]. A beam of energetic electrons is launched into a cold plasma and excites both chirping whistler waves and broadband waves. Here we extend our previous analysis by comparing the properties of the broadband waves with linear theory.
We present the recent progress in upgrading a predictive model for megaelectron-volt (MeV) electrons inside the Earth's outer Van Allen belt. This updated model, called PreMevE 2.0, provides improved forecasts, particularly at outer L-shells, by adding upstream solar wind speeds to the model's input parameter list that originally includes precipitating electrons observed at low Earth orbits and MeV electron fluxes in situ measured by a geosynchronous satellite. Furthermore, based on several kinds of linear and artificial neural networks algorithms, a list of models was constructed, trained, validated, and tested with 42-month MeV electron observations from Van Allen Probes. Out-of-sample test results from these models show that, with optimized model hyperparameters and input parameter combinations, the top performer from each category of models has the similar capability of making reliable 1-day (2-day) forecasts of 1-MeV electron flux distributions with performance efficiency values ~0.87 (~0.82) averaged over the L-shell range of 2.8–6.6, significantly outperforming the previous version of PreMevE particularly at L-shells > ~4.5. Interestingly, the linear regression model is often the most successful when compared to other models, which suggests the relationship between dynamics of trapped 1-MeV electrons and precipitating electrons is dominated by linear components. Results also show that PreMevE 2.0 can reasonably well predict the onsets of MeV electron events in 2-day forecasts. PreMevE 2.0 is designed to be driven by observations from longstanding space infrastructure to make high-fidelity forecasts for MeV electrons, thus can be an invaluable space weather forecasting tool for the future.
Cosmic rays propagating in the Galaxy may excite a streaming instability when their motion is super-alfvenic, thereby producing the conditions for their own diffusion. In this paper we present the results of a self-consistent solution of the transport equation where diffusion occurs because of the self-generated turbulence together with a pre-existing turbulence injected, for instance, by supernova explosions and cascading to smaller scales. All chemicals are included in our calculations, so that we are able to show the secondary to primary ratios in addition to the spectra of the individual elements. All predictions appear to be in good agreement with observations. The fact that data are explained with no need for artificial breaks in the injection spectrum and/or in the diffusion coefficient as functions of momentum can be interpreted as a strong indication that the phenomenon proposed here is in fact being observed in Nature. We also show that there is very good agreement between the calculated proton spectrum and the cosmic ray spectrum inferred from observations of the gamma ray emission from clouds in the Gould's belt.