On the role of joint probability distributions of incompatible observables in Bell and Kochen–Specker Theorems
Highlights: •Bell and Kochen–Specker theorems rule out local or noncontextual realist models. •Still, they assume a joint probability distribution for incompatible observables. •Those joint probability distributions do not exist in quantum mechanics. •Realist models without joint distributions for incompatible observables are given. •A reformulation of Bell and Kochen–Specker arguments is provided to rule them out. -- Abstract: We analyze the validity of Bell and Kochen–Specker theorems under local (or noncontextual) realism but avoiding an assumption of the existence of a joint probability distribution for incompatible observables. We formulate a realist model which complies with this requirement. This is obtained by employing divergent sequences that nevertheless have marginals which are convergent. We find that under standard reasonable assumptions this possibility does not lead to a loophole of those theorems, by deriving a short of CHSH inequality valid for any finite size ensemble. Moreover, we analyze a Hardy’s paradox setting where noncontextual realism imposes the existence of joint probabilities for incompatible observables.