SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Blown Powder Directed Energy Deposition”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

SourceResearch connectionFrom yearThrough year

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records

All sources NASA NTRS DOE OSTI

DOE OSTI2022

Impact of Nozzle Condition on Powder Catchment Efficiency for Coaxial Powder Direct Energy Deposition

Blown powder directed energy deposition is well-designed for fine resolution additive manufacturing processing. Coaxial powder deposition heads use an outer layer of shielding gas directed by an outer nozzle to prevent oxidation occurring during the powder melting process. Powder blown feedstock catchment efficiency can be as low as 50-80% whereas wire deposition systems are closer to 98% efficient. The present study evaluates the impact of directed energy deposition nozzle condition on catchment efficiency. Changes in the overall outer shielding gas nozzle length has been found to increase material usage efficiency by 10% through convergence of the powder flow. The results of this experiment show that for coaxial powder deposition head design, if the standoff distance can safely be decreased, powder catchment efficiency can be increased as the outer shielding gas nozzle is increased in length, or the standoff distance is decreased.

Heinrich, Lauren↗

DOE OSTI2022

Impact of Nozzle Condition on Powder Catchment Efficiency for Coaxial Powder Direct Energy Deposition

Heinrich, Lauren↗

DOE OSTI2023

Effect of Blown Powder Directed Energy Deposition Angle On Overspray Contamination

Abstract Blown powder directed energy deposition (DED) hybrid machine tools are particularly beneficial when the net shape of a component is to be manufactured in an additive and machined interleaved fashion. This investigation seeks to analyze the effect of the additive head lean angle relative to the part on blown powder DED surface contamination due to overspray. These hybrid DED platforms are commonly installed on multi-axis machining systems where the lean of the deposition head relative to the component surface can be controlled by tilting the component. The blown powder DED process has a 10–50% lower catchment efficiency as compared to wire fed DED systems. This excess powder is still fed towards the deposition location where the particles are heated by the laser and rebound off the melt pool. Some of these heated particles impact the previously machined thin-wall surface. While the deposition process and tool path planning process has been evaluated, the effect of the overspray due to lean angle of the deposition head on the previously thin-wall machined surface is not yet fully understood. This investigation found that minimum lean angle coincides with minimal overspray effect with nearly no contamination. If a lean angle is required, the maximum lean angle possible should be implemented for the smallest effected overspray area on the machined surface which was found to decrease the affect zone by half compared to intermediate lean angles. A diameter divergence was also noticed as the deposition angle was increased. In this study, a thorough analysis of the surface and geometric effects when depositing thin-walled components at varying angles is completed. It has been shown that part quality can be significantly affected by lean angle and thus must be incorporated as an additional design consideration in the manufacturing process.

Heinrich, Lauren↗

DOE OSTI2024

Spatiotemporally Registered In-Situ and Ex-Situ Datasets for Laser-based Blown Powder Directed Energy Deposition

This dataset is comprised of in situ sensing data collected during laser-based, blown powder directed energy deposition (DED) of Inconel 718 representing eight different printing conditions: (1) nominal, (2) +15% scan speed, (3) +12% laser power, (4) +42% powder feed rate, (5) +100% jerk limit, (6) +10% layer height, (7) +20% hatch spacing, (8) +20% carrier gas flow. All eight DED builds constructed an identical test coupon geometry consisting of geometric features representative of industrial print requirements (e.g., bulk deposition, thin walls, overhangs). In situ data consists of xyz-coordinates (100 Hz) and on-axis melt pool camera video (60 Hz), both of which have been temporally synchronized to spatially map the melt pool camera data. In addition, post-build X-ray computed tomography (XCT) data for each of the eight test geometries have been spatially registered to the recorded xyz-coordinates, allowing for comparisons between melt pool camera data and flaws identified in the XCT data.

additive manufacturing↗

DOE OSTI2024

The 650 °C Tensile Deformation of Graded IN718-René41 Superalloy Fabricated by Laser Blown-Powder Directed Energy Deposition

The microstructure and 650 °C tensile properties of a compositionally graded IN718-René41 (718-R41) superalloy fabricated by laser blown-powder directed energy deposition (DED-LB/M) are investigated to understand structure–property relationships and baseline tensile properties. Digital Image Correlation (DIC), in situ neutron diffraction, and conventional characterization techniques are performed to study the as-built and heat-treated states. The applied heat treatment generates static recrystallization and equiaxed grains in 718-rich compositions, while R41-rich compositions remain partially or un-recrystallized possibly influenced by a higher MC carbide fraction (>0.5%). The yield strengths of the 718 and R41 sections in the heat-treated state are comparable to wrought forms but the graded compositions show weakness due to unoptimized heat treatment. Diffraction elastic constants first decrease and then increase along the 718-R41 composition gradient, while a small difference is observed between the as-built and heat-treated states and γ, γ′ phases. Overall, the compositionally graded region shows a smooth transition in the elastic properties. Grain-level load transfer from the (220) to (200) grains shows compositional dependence, and qualitatively agrees with DIC-measured macroscopic yield strength. Within the (200) grains, the γ/γ′ phases deform elastically until the γ phase yields and afterwards, the γ′ phase takes load from the γ phase.

Huang, Shenyan (ORCID:0000000196528114)↗

DOE OSTI2022

High-throughput, in situ imaging of multi-layer powder-blown directed energy deposition with angled nozzle

Laser metal additive manufacturing (AM) has become an increasingly popular technology due to its flexibility in geometry and materials. As one of the commercialized additive processes, powder-blown directed energy deposition (DED) has been used in multiple industries such as aerospace, automotive, medical device, etc. However, a lack of fundamental understanding remains for this process, and many opportunities for alloy development and implementation can be identified. A high-throughput, in situ DED system capable of multi-layer builds that can address these issues is presented here. In this work, implications of layer heights and energy density are investigated through an extensive process parameter sweep, showcasing the power of a high-throughput setup while also discussing multi-layer interactions.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗

DOE OSTI2025

Unit cell manufacture by blown powder directed energy deposition

Lattice structures manufactured by additive manufacturing show unique promise to alter existing components to improve the thermo-mechanical properties of the base structure. Here, in the present study, the manufacture of a self-supporting lattice structure by blown powder directed energy deposition was explored. Converging struts were manufactured using multiple lean angles to facilitate the self-supporting structure and to avoid machine-part collisions. The struts showed near uniform straightness relative to a fitted line with a maximum deviation of 1mm at a lean angle of 10°. Micro–hardness and porosity evaluation results showed no significant variation along the struts.

Additive manufacturing↗

NASA NTRS2023

Additive Manufacturing Process Development DOE for NASA HR-1 using Laser Blown Powder Directed Energy Deposition

NASA HR-1 is a Fe-Ni-Cr alloy that is used for high pressure hydrogen applications such as rocket engines, energy, and oil and gas. This investigation was focused on conducting a design of experiment program aimed at mapping the parameter process window for NASA HR-1 using the laser blown powder directed energy deposition (LP-DED) process. A two phased design of experiments (DOE), the first phase of the experiment was focused on optimizing single bead tracks while the second phase of the experiment was focused on optimizing bead overlap hatching in a multi pass bead build up. During the first phase of the deposition parameters, namely laser power, travel speed, and powder feed rate were varied. A down selection from the single bead parameter set was made and hatching experiments were conducted that focused on the overlap distance. In this paper the approach for conducting the DOE and results are discussed. The results focused on measurement of bead geometry, the as-built microstructural evolution, and porosity within the samples. The team at MSFC saw a variety of results across the process map created during the first phase of experimentation and were able to down select a parameter that created an optimal bead shape with a minimal amount of build porosity. It was determined that laser power and robot travel speed were the most sensitive parameters. The results from this investigation will inform future laser powder directed energy deposition parameter developments.

Parker Shake↗

DOE OSTI2024

A Simulated Evaluation of Powder Flowability Through a Partially Obstructed Consumable in Blown Powder Directed Energy Deposition Systems

Abstract In the interest of continued industrialization of metal additive manufacturing in modern production environments, cost is often referenced as a primary deterrent to new adopters. Conventional economic models for additive systems, processes, and supply chains often focus on specific process applications with little generalizability, or they neglect significant costs associated with production such as machine maintenance and consumable part replacement. Compounding the latter issue are substantial knowledge gaps in consumable part wear characterization for additive and other convergent manufacturing systems. In coaxial blown powder directed energy deposition systems, gas atomized metal powder is wasted during material deposition at a rate that is partly dependent on present wear phenomena in a consumable nozzle housed in the cladding head assembly. The price and lead time required to replace the nozzle incentivizes its reuse even when visibly worn. Often this initiates a process quality decline in the form of underbuilt geometry and internal defects due to losses in powder catchment efficiency. While depositing H13 steel using a hybrid manufacturing machine tool equipped with such a deposition system, a unique partial clog with a bridge-like structure formed at the consumable nozzle exit when supporting argon gas flows failed mid-process. To further understand coaxial multi-phase powder flow in the event of support gas failure, a computational fluid dynamics simulation is tailored to relevant process parameters, H13 powder material profile, and machine operator observations collected after the incident. The resulting differences in powder flow compared to control gas flow parameters is presented and discussed. The powder flowability and performance of the clogged nozzle is then assessed by using an optical profilometer to extract the profile of the clog and recreate the clog geometry within the simulation environment. In past work this simulation has been experimentally validated for a 316L steel powder material profile and used specifically for analyzing powder stream geometry and catchment efficiency. After the initial powder flow characterization, the clog is removed, and the nozzle is reprofiled. After removing the obstructing clog, the newly unobstructed nozzle geometry, the original off the shelf nozzle geometry, and additional nozzle profiles exploring different consumable refurbishment strategies are reevaluated in the simulation. Powder catchment efficiency for all variant nozzle geometries and relevant flow variables are compared and discussed, along with potential mitigation strategies for optimizing powder flowability with worn consumables. This work expands on the known morphology of blown powder obstructions and wear defects present in consumable coaxial nozzles while discussing pragmatic simulation driven responses to unanticipated subsystem failure in hybrid manufacturing machining platforms.

DeWitte, Lisa↗

DOE OSTI2021

In situ X-ray imaging of pore formation mechanisms and dynamics in laser powder-blown directed energy deposition additive manufacturing

Directed energy deposition (DED) additive manufacturing (AM) is receiving growing attention in many applications, such as repair, remanufacturing, and fabrication of functionally graded structures. However, the laser-matter interactions and melt pool dynamics in laser DED with powder flow are still unclear, particularly in how pores form and flow inside the melt pool during the process. Understanding the porosity formation mechanisms is critical in the qualification, certification, and overall properties of a DED AM part. Porosity is a common phenomenon and can significantly hinder the quality of DED fabricated parts, as the pores can act as sites of crack nucleation and propagation. Here in this paper, we reveal four types of pore formation mechanisms through in-situ and operando high-speed high-resolution X-ray imaging in the DED AM process. Our results confirm that porosity within the feedstock powder induces pores in the process. We also observed pore formation mechanisms unique to the laser-based, powder-blown DED process as a result of powder delivery, keyhole dynamics, melt pool dynamics, and shield gas. High-speed X-ray images provide direct evidence for pore formation mechanisms and show that the pores related to the interaction between the delivered powder and melt pool are the largest in size in laser-based powder-blown DED AM. These results will guide porosity mitigation, elimination, and control in DED AM.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

NASA NTRS2019

Additive Manufacturing Development and Hot-Fire Testing of Liquid Rocket Channel Wall Nozzles Using Blown Powder Directed Energy Deposition Inconel 625 and JBK-75 Alloys

Additive manufacturing (AM) is being investigated at NASA and across much of the rocket propulsion industry as an alternate fabrication technique to create complex geometries for liquid engine components that offers schedule and cost saving opportunities. The geometries that can be created using AM offer a significant advantage over traditional techniques. Internal complexities, such as internal coolant channels for combustion chambers and nozzles that would typically require several operations to manufacture traditionally can be fabricated in one process. Additionally, the coolant channels are closed out as a part of the AM build process, eliminating the complexities of a traditional process like brazing or plating. The primary additive manufacturing technique that has been evaluated is powder bed fusion (PBF), or selective laser melting (SLM), but there is a scale limitation for this technique. There are several alternate additive manufacturing techniques that are being investigated for large-scale nozzles and chambers including directed energy deposition (DED) processes. A significant advantage of the DED processes is the ability to adapt to a robotic or gantry CNC system with a localized purge or purge chamber, allowing unlimited build volume. This paper will discuss the development and hot-fire testing of channel-cooled nozzles fabricated utilizing one form of DED called blown powder deposition. This initial development work using blown powder DED is being explored to form the entire channel wall nozzle with integral coolant channels within a single AM build. Much of this development is focused on the design and DED-fabrication of complex and thin-walled features and on characterization of the materials properties produced with this techniques in order to evolve this process. Subscale nozzles were fabricated using this DED technique and hot-fire tested in Liquid Oxygen/Hydrogen (LOX/GH2) and LOX/Kerosene (LOX/RP-1) environments accumulating significant development time and cycles. The initial materials that were evaluated during this testing were high-strength nickel-based Inconel 625 and JBK-75. Further process development is being completed to increase the scale of this technology for large-scale nozzles. This paper will summarize the general design considerations for DED, specific channel-cooled nozzle design, manufacturing process development, property development, initial hot-fire testing and future developments to mature this technology for regeneratively-cooled nozzles. An overview of future development at NASA will also be discussed.

Gradl, Paul R.↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Nanomechanical Characterization of Additive Manufactured GRCop-42 Alloy Developed by Directed Energy Deposition Methods

Propulsion applications such as combustion chambers and nozzles for liquid rocket engines require the use of unique materials with superior mechanical and thermal properties. GRCop-42(Cu-4 wt.% Cr-2 wt.% Nb) is one such candidate material developed by NASA and is now being manufactured using additive manufacturing (AM) techniques. AM offers a unique processing environment different from traditional metal fabrication processes. This study characterized the mechanical and structural properties of as-deposited and heat-treated GRCop-42manufactured with Blown Powder Directed Energy Deposition (BPD)based on preliminary testing. The materials were characterized using several techniques including surface profiling by laser microscopy, mechanical stiffness by instrumented indentation, crystal structure, residual stress measurements using XRD and residual XRD, and chemical composition and microstructural evaluation using SEM with EBSD. The results of the study are compared using the BPD techniques for samples in the as-deposited and heat-treated conditions.

GRCop-42↗

DOE OSTI2025

Impact of lead on an axisymmetric, single bead blown powder DED overhung geometry

Metal additive manufacturing can be utilized for the near net-shape manufacture of components in a layer wise technique. Traditionally, the buildup process is conducted in the direction of gravity or bottom to top in the vertical orientation; however, with the availability of commercial systems with additive heads or fixturing that can index from vertical, and the need to manufacture larger parts without modifying available systems, the limitation of manufacturing from bottom to top is removed enabling the buildup of larger components printed at an angle from vertical. The effect of gravity on the melt pool and as-deposited component quality when printing off vertical is unknown in literature, especially for axisymmetric components. This understanding is critical for the advancement of manufacturing components of increased size in 4 and 5-axis additive systems. This investigation utilizes blown powder directed energy deposition to evaluate the change in as-printed geometry when the start point is altered in relation to gravity while the part rotates to manufacture an axisymmetric component. The objectives of this work are to determine the impact of the deposition location on the geometric variability on axisymmetric components. This investigation tests the hypothesis that differences in layer height exist due to a change in catchment efficiency when the deposition location is moved to a tangent of the round geometry due to a change in the melt pool dynamics. It was found the ideal deposition location when printing at 26.6-degrees from vertical was at −90-degrees from the top center point of the component, along the tangent, where gravity was pushing the melt pool down, but the rotation of the part was pulling the deposited material towards the top center of the component. This work provides an understanding of layer height stability and catchment efficiency to guide print orientation strategy for high-aspect ratio components. It was found the −90-degree lead deposition had the best layer height stability at 0.6 % as compared to the top-center at 6.3 % and +90-degree deposition location at 9.2 % for the nominal programmed layer height. The change in layer height also effected the final diameter the greatest for the top center deposition location where the diameter diverged by 2.5 % during the overbuild condition and converged by 0.6 %. In conclusion, this finding will increase the manufacturing efficiency of axisymmetric components by increasing the passive stability of the printing process for the successful manufacture of parts without the need for perfectly calibrated manufacturing parameters.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Microstructural Analysis Across a Hybrid Inconel 718 Turbopump Inducer Following a Scheduled Heat Treatment Process

Additive Manufacturing (AM) provides a low-cost method to fabricate near net shape complex parts. In this study, a turbopump inducer was fabricated using blown powder direct energy deposition (DED) of Inconel 718 to form the fins on a wrought hub. By utilizing this combination process, more cost-effective methods are possible for complex parts. A series of heat treatments were applied to the assembly per ASTM F330.

Inconel 718↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Investigation of Additive Manufactured GRCop-42 Alloy Developed by Directed Energy Deposition Methods

GRCop is an alloy family constructed of copper, chromium, and niobium and was developed by NASA for high heat flux applications. GRCop-alloys were specifically formulated for the requirements in channel-cooled main combustion chambers allowing for repeat use in high heat flux environments[1]. GRCop-84 was evolved using additive manufacturing techniques under a NASA development program. To further increase thermal conductivity while maintaining material strength characteristics, the percentage of alloying elements were cut in half and GRCop-42 was developed. In recent years, NASA has successfully additively manufactured GRCop-42 with comparable material characteristics to extrudedGRCop-42 using a Laser Powder Bed Fusion (L-PBF) process. Benefits of this process include fabrication of intricate internal cooling channels as well as a decrease in manufacturing time. However, there are some large disadvantages in using this process. The nature of the powder bed process imposes a strict volume constraint as well as an excessive amount of material inventory required. A Directed Energy Deposition (DED) process addresses these limitations while also speeding up the manufacturing process. With little data on how DED performs with GRCop-42, an investigation into the mechanical properties was conducted. More specifically, Blown Powder Directed Energy Deposition (BPD), was used to compare material properties to that of the L-PBF manufactured GRCop-42. The DED manufactured material was found to have less than 0.1% porosity. Tensile tests concluded that the DED manufactured GRCop-42 had lower tensile strengths at room temperature. The results point towards a process capable of producing fully dense parts capable of meeting mechanical strength requirements with some possible refinement of printing parameters.

GRCop-42↗

DOE OSTI2023

Prediction of Substrate Distortion in Powder DED Using Finite Element Model

Abstract Leveraging the capabilities of both additive and subtractive manufacturing to repair tooling and other high value items can result in significant cost and time saving opportunities. However, when dimensional accuracy of the repaired component must be held within a specified tolerance, distortion of the component induced during repair can lead to an out of specification final component. This work presents simulation of a novel method to mitigate part distortion using sacrificial support structures. A blown powder directed energy deposition system was utilized for deposition of sacrificial support structures and clad surface depositions. Sacrificial support structures were deposited on the underside of the substrate with varying geometries prior to clad surface depositions. A finite element model was developed and verified using experimental results. The simulation and experimental control results were found to match within 6%. It has been shown that simulation can be used to predict effects of sacrificial support structures on substrate distortion in a blown powder directed energy deposition process.

Burl, Alan G.↗

DOE OSTI2022

Residual stress and microstructure in IN718-René41 graded superalloy fabricated by laser blown directed energy deposition

Additively printed Ni-based superalloy with a compositionally graded transition from IN718 to René41 was fabricated by laser blown-powder directed energy deposition (DED/LB-M), with the goals of meeting location-specific temperature capability and reducing component cost for hot gas path turbine components. Residual stress distribution in thin wall specimens with three sets of DED build parameters in the as-built and stress-relieved states was measured by neutron diffraction. For calculating residual stress, the calculated d0 method was found to be more appropriate as stress-free reference than using the lattice spacing measured from the stress-relief heat treated specimens. Longer dwell time (lower interpass temperature), higher energy input, smaller layer thickness resulted in a higher magnitude of tensile residual stresses at edges and compressive residual stresses at center of the specimens. The residual stress results did not show a strong dependence on graded compositions, indicating that the residual stress build-up was more geometry and process dependent. Non-destructive neutron imaging based on the attenuation coefficient qualitatively visualized the compositional variation in the bulk and showed good agreement with quantitative Electron Probe Micro-Analysis (EPMA) measurement. Grain structure, texture, and residual plastic strain along the build direction were characterized by Electron Backscatter Diffraction (EBSD). Long columnar grains with (001) preferred grain orientation were dominant along the build direction. Compositional change did not show an obvious effect on the epitaxial growth of dendrites and the continuation of the columnar grains. Residual plastic strain was relatively low in the as-built specimens.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Mechanisms of Interfacial Mixing in the Blown Powder Deposition of Inconel 625 to Copper Alloy for Liquid Rocket Engine Applications

There is an increasing need for functional materials to support high heat flux applications and optimize weight by using bimetallic additive manufacturing (AM). While one promising fabrication technology is the use of blown powder directed energy deposition (DED) AM, challenges remain with bi-metallic combinations. Prominent among these challenges is the need to understand mixing of materials at the bimetallic interface for forming stronger, more durable and reliable joints to extend the versatility of AM into critical applications. One application is the manufacturing of combustion chambers with copper-alloy liners and Superalloy structural jackets. In this application, material combinations are selected for effective heat dissipation, using copper, and retention of strength at high temperatures using Inconel 625. Currently, the dominant problem with this configuration is the highly variable strength of the interface and its correlation with deposition parameters. In this study, samples were fabricated at several vendors with Inconel 625 deposited onto wrought C-18150 (Cu-Cr-Zr) to form a bimetallic interface. Characterization of the interfaces were achieved through optical and electron microscopy, mechanical testing of mini tensile specimens, and electron dispersion spectroscopy to understand diffusion and bulk mixing behaviors at the joint. A theoretical framework was constructed in the context of solidification and mixing mechanisms to explain the resulting differences in the interface. This qualitative approach utilized a fluid dynamics perspective to sum the order of magnitudes of the various acting forces on the weld pool during deposition to predict convection trends based off known parameters. The predicted trends for each vendor are compared to obtain a better understanding of how mixing in the molten pool varied based on deposition parameters.

Additive Manufacturing↗