DETERMINING THE TRIBUTARY SEDIMENT CONTRIBUTION TO EXPERIMENTAL FLOOD DEPOSITS ON THE COLORADO RIVER IN MARBLE CANYON, GRAND CANYON, ARIZONA
A multivariate sediment fingerprint was used in a Bayesian mixing model to determine the source contribution to experimental flood deposits along the Colorado River in the Marble Canyon reach of Grand Canyon, AZ. This study provides an independent evaluation, complementary to previous sediment mass balance and morphological studies, of the degree to which sand from the Paria River, the primary source of sand in Marble Canyon, has supplemented total sand storage since upstream dam closure in 1963. Samples of endmember and downstream mixed populations of sand were analyzed using portable XRF to measure the concentration of eleven major and trace elements, from which 55 elemental ratios were calculated. A principal components analysis consolidated those ratios eligible for use in the fingerprint into a multivariate signature used in the mixing model, MixSIAR. Twenty flood deposits from 14 sites in Marble Canyon from the 2013 and 2014 controlled floods were sampled. Six individual mixing models, using sediment fingerprints unique to each of six half-phi grain size fractions returned the percentage of sand, in each size fraction of each deposit, that was sourced from the Paria River. Paria contribution averaged 33.8 ± 4.1% in deposits from the 2013 flood, and 54.7 ± 4.3% in deposits from the 2014 flood. Individual grain size samples ranged 4.9 – 73.1% in 2013 and 9.1 – 90.2% in 2014. In general, iii the four median grain size fractions (90 – 355 μm) in both years have the highest Paria contribution; low Paria contribution in the finest 63 – 90 μm) fraction suggests significant contribution by an unaccounted-for third endmember, likely minor tributaries. The coarsest fraction, 355 – 500 μm, is the only grain size to show a trend in Paria contribution with distance traveled downstream, suggesting a transport-related fractionation effect. Overall scatter in the results speaks to the spatial heterogeneity of intra-rapid storage pools throughout the reach and their capacity, as well as the effects of local hydraulic variability between eddy deposition zones where sandbars form. Mass balance calculations determine that under conditions of constant or decreasing total storage since 1963, approximately 20-30% of the annual Paria flux would need to be retained within Marble Canyon each year to reach the observed concentration of Paria sand. From these results, we conclude that HFEs are conditionally sustainable given frequent enough occurrence to maintain sandbar deposit storage.